Currencies

Highlights The US saves too much to achieve full employment but not enough to close the current account deficit. According to the “Swan diagram,” a weaker dollar would move the US economy closer to “external” and “internal” balance. Structural forces are unlikely to have much effect on the value of the dollar over the next few years: The neutral rate of interest is higher in the US than in most other developed economies; the US still earns more on its overseas assets than it pays on its liabilities; and there is no meaningful competition to the dollar’s reserve currency status. Cyclical forces, in contrast, will become more dollar-bearish over the coming months: A vaccine would buoy the global economy next year; interest rate differentials have moved sharply against the dollar; and further fiscal stimulus should lift US inflation expectations. Stocks tend to outperform bonds when the dollar is weakening. Investors should remain overweight global equities on a 12-month horizon, favoring non-US stocks and cyclical sectors. A Clash Of Views? Today marked the last day of BCA’s Annual Investment Conference, held virtually this year in light of the pandemic. As in past years, it was a star-studded cavalcade of the who’s who in financial and policymaking circles. I always find it interesting when two of our speakers seemingly disagree on a critical issue. Such was the case with Larry Summers and Stephen Roach. Larry kicked off the proceedings with an update of his secular stagnation thesis. He argued that his thesis had gone from “a hypothesis that needed to be considered” to a “presumptively accurate analysis of the status quo.” In Larry’s mind, the core problem facing the US and most other economies is a surplus of savings. Excess savings results in a chronic shortfall of spending relative to an economy’s productive capacity. Faced with the challenge of maintaining adequate employment, central banks have been forced to cut rates to extraordinarily low levels. Perpetually easy monetary policy has periodically spawned destabilizing asset bubbles. Larry recommends that governments ease fiscal policy in order to take the burden off central banks. Later that morning, we heard from Stephen Roach. Stephen expects the real US trade-weighted dollar to weaken by 35% by the end of next year. What’s behind this bearish forecast? The answer, according to Stephen, is that the US economy suffers from a shortage of savings. Unable to generate enough domestic savings to cover its investment needs, the US has ended up running persistent current account deficits. How can the US be saving too much, as Larry Summers claims, while also saving too little, as Stephen Roach insists? The two views seem utterly unreconcilable. In fact, I think there is a way to reconcile them with something called the Swan diagram. The Swan Diagram True to the reputation of economics as the dismal science, the Swan diagram – named after Australian economist Trevor Swan – depicts four “zones of economic unhappiness” (Chart 1). Each zone represents a different way in which an economy can deviate from “internal balance” (full employment and stable inflation) and “external balance” (a current account balance that is neither in deficit nor in surplus). Chart 1The Swan Diagram And The Four Zones Of Unhappiness Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? The four zones are: 1) high unemployment and a current account deficit; 2) high unemployment and a current account surplus; 3) overheating and a current account deficit; and 4) overheating and a current account surplus. The horizontal axis of the Swan diagram depicts the budget deficit. A rightward movement along the horizontal axis corresponds to an easing of fiscal policy. The vertical axis depicts the real exchange rate. An upward movement along the vertical axis corresponds to a currency appreciation. The external balance schedule is downward sloping because an easing of fiscal policy raises aggregate demand (which boosts imports, resulting in a current account deficit). To restore the current account balance to its original level, the currency must weaken. A weaker currency will spur exports, while curbing imports. The internal balance schedule is upward sloping because an easing in fiscal policy must be offset by a stronger currency in order to keep the economy from overheating. The US presently finds itself in the top quadrant of the Swan diagram: It saves too much to achieve internal balance, but not enough to achieve external balance. From this perspective, both Larry Summers and Stephen Roach are correct. Unlike the US, the euro area, Japan, and China run current account surpluses. Rather than pursuing currency depreciation, the Swan diagram says that all three economies would be better off with more fiscal easing. What It Would Take To Eliminate The US Trade Deficit By how much would the real trade-weighted US dollar need to weaken to achieve external balance? According to the New York Fed, a 10% dollar depreciation raises export volumes by 3.5% after two years, while reducing import volumes by 1.6%.1 Given that exports and imports account for 12% and 15% of GDP, respectively, this implies that a 10% dollar depreciation would improve the trade balance by 0.12*0.035+0.15*0.016=0.7% of GDP. Considering that the trade deficit is around 3% of GDP, the dollar may need to weaken by 30%-to-50% to eliminate the trade deficit, a range which encompasses Stephen Roach’s projection for the dollar’s decline.  Don’t Hold Your Breath In practice, we doubt that the dollar will decline anywhere close to that much. Despite a net international investment position of negative 67% of GDP, the US still generates substantially more income from its overseas assets than it pays to service its liabilities (Chart 2). This reflects the fact that US foreign liabilities are skewed towards low-yielding government bonds, while its assets largely consist of higher-yielding equities and foreign direct investment (Chart 3). Chart 2The US Generates More Income From Its Overseas Assets Than It Pays On Its Liabilities The US Generates More Income From Its Overseas Assets Than It Pays On Its Liabilities The US Generates More Income From Its Overseas Assets Than It Pays On Its Liabilities Chart 3A Breakdown Of US Assets And Liabilities Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Given that the Fed will keep rates on hold at least until end-2023, it is unlikely that US government interest payments will rise substantially in the next few years. Faster Growth Helps Explain America’s Chronic Current Account Deficit The neutral rate of interest is higher in the US than in most other developed economies. Economic theory suggests that global capital will flow towards countries with higher interest rates, producing current account deficits (Chart 4).2 Chart 4Interest Rates And Current Account Balances Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? The higher neutral rate in the US can be partly attributed to faster trend GDP growth. There are three reasons why faster growth will raise investment while lowering savings, thus leading to a current account deficit: Faster-growing economies require more investment spending to maintain an adequate capital stock. For example, if a country wants to maintain a capital stock-to-GDP ratio of 200% and is growing at 3% per year, it would need to invest (after depreciation) 6% of GDP. A country growing at 1% would need to invest only 2% of GDP. Governments may wish to run larger budget deficits in faster-growing economies in the belief that they will be able to outgrow their debt burdens. To the extent that faster growth may reflect productivity gains, households may choose to spend more and save less in anticipation of higher real incomes in the future. While trend growth is just one of several factors influencing the balance of payments, in general, the evidence does suggest that fast-growing developed economies such as the US and Australia have tended to run current account deficits, while slower-growing economies such as the euro area and Japan have generally run current account surpluses (Chart 5). Chart 5Fast-Growing Developed Economies Tend To Run Current Account Deficits, While Slower- Growing Economies Tend To Run Surpluses Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? The Dollar’s Reserve Currency Status Is Not In Any Jeopardy Even if many commentators do tend to overstate the importance of having a reserve currency, the dollar’s special status in the global financial system will still provide it with support. The US dollar’s share of global central bank reserves stood at 61.3% in the second quarter of 2020, only modestly lower than where it was a decade ago (Chart 6). While the euro area is not at risk of collapse, it remains an artificial political entity. China’s role in the global economy continues to increase. However, the absence of an open capital account limits the yuan’s appeal. Chart 6The US Dollar’s Share Of Global Central Bank Reserves Has Barely Fallen Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Then there’s the dollar’s first mover advantage. During our conference, Marc Chandler likened the greenback to the QWERTY keyboard: It may not be perfect, but like it or not, it has become the default choice for typing.  I like to equate the dollar’s role with that of the English language. When a Swede has a business meeting with another Swede, they will speak in Swedish. However, when a Swede has a business meeting with an Indonesian, chances are they will speak in English. By the same token, when a Swede wants to purchase Indonesian rupiah, the bank is unlikely to convert krona directly to rupiah since the probability is low that many people will just happen to be looking to exchange rupiah for krona at precisely the same time. Rather, the bank will first convert the krona to US dollars and then convert the dollars to rupiah. The dollar is the hub of the global financial system. Just like the pound remained the global currency long after the sun had set on the British Empire, King Dollar will endure for many years to come. Cyclical Forces Will Drive The Dollar Lower Chart 7The Dollar Is A Countercyclical Currency The Dollar Is A Countercyclical Currency The Dollar Is A Countercyclical Currency The discussion above suggests that structural forces are unlikely to have much effect on the value of the dollar for the foreseeable future. Cyclical forces, in contrast, will become more dollar-bearish over the coming months. The US dollar is a countercyclical currency, meaning that it tends to move in the opposite direction of the global business cycle (Chart 7). According to the Good Judgment Project, there is a 43% chance that a Covid vaccine will be available by the first quarter of 2021, and a 91% chance it will be available by the end of the third quarter (Chart 8). A vaccine would supercharge global growth, causing the dollar to weaken.   Chart 8When Will A Vaccine Become Available? Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Interest rate differentials have moved considerably against the dollar – more so, in fact, than one would have expected based on the fairly modest depreciation that the greenback has experienced thus far (Chart 9). Chart 9A Relatively Muted Decline In The Dollar Given The Move In Real Yield Differentials A Relatively Muted Decline In The Dollar Given The Move In Real Yield Differentials A Relatively Muted Decline In The Dollar Given The Move In Real Yield Differentials Chart 10Stocks Tend To Outperform Bonds When The Dollar Is Weakening... As Do Non-US Stocks Versus US Stocks Tend To Outperform Bonds When The Dollar Is Weakening... As Do Non-US Stocks Versus US Stocks Tend To Outperform Bonds When The Dollar Is Weakening... As Do Non-US Stocks Versus US   An open question is how additional fiscal support will affect the dollar and other financial assets. Equity investors have brushed off the dwindling prospects for a pandemic relief bill before the election on the assumption that a “blue sweep” will allow the Biden administration to enact even more stimulus than was possible under President Trump and a Republican senate. The dollar rallied in the weeks following Donald Trump’s victory. The dollar also surged in the early 1980s after Ronald Reagan lowered taxes and raised military spending. A key difference between now and then is that real interest rates rose during both of those two prior episodes. Today, the Fed is firmly on hold. This implies that real rates are unlikely to rise much, and could even fall if inflation expectations move up in response to easier fiscal policy. Stocks tend to outperform bonds when the dollar is weakening (Chart 10). In particular, stock markets outside the US often do well in a soft-dollar environment. Investors should remain overweight equities on a 12-month horizon, favoring non-US stocks and cyclical sectors.   Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist peterb@bcaresearch.com   Footnotes 1  Mary Amiti, and Tyler Bodine-Smith, “The Effect of the Strong Dollar on U.S. Growth,” Liberty Street Economics, (July 17, 2015). 2 There are many different ways to measure the neutral rate. As depicted in Chart 4, capital flows tend to equalize the neutral rate across countries. This is another way of saying that the neutral rate would be higher in the US were it not for the fact that the US runs a current account deficit.   Global Investment Strategy View Matrix Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Current MacroQuant Model Scores Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? Does The US Save Too Much Or Too Little? ​​​​​​​

  Chart Of The WeekInvestor Consensus Is Bearish On Dollar Investor Consensus Is Bearish On Dollar Investor Consensus Is Bearish On Dollar Today we are releasing another issue from our series Charts That Matter. Going forward, this publication will become a regular monthly deliverable to our clients. This is a charts-only report with minimal wording. It presents the key charts, indicators, and relationships that we monitor at the time of publication. Needless to say, the importance of different indicators and factors varies over time. Thus, each issue of Charts That Matter will present different charts, indicators and relationships. Presently, global assets are experiencing a tug-of-war. On the one hand, equity and credit markets are overbought and have elevated valuations. On the other hand, expectations of a large US fiscal stimulus package are sustaining prospects of continued US and global economic recoveries. We have been expecting a pullback in risk assets before year-end due to a delay in significant US fiscal stimulus, potential volatility around the US elections as well as overbought conditions in risk assets. In addition, since April commodities prices have benefited from China’s growth recovery as well as inventory restocking (see Charts on page 11). Given that the latter is likely to be followed by a destocking phase, we believe resource prices are at a risk of experiencing a setback. This will weigh on commodity-producing emerging markets.   The correction in September has been short circuited. It seems the prospects of an eventual large US fiscal stimulus package, even if it is next year, and the ongoing recovery in China (Charts on pages 8-9) are sustaining a bid under risk assets. Besides, cash on the sidelines has not been fully exhausted (Charts on page 6). Consistently, we illustrate on pages 3 that various US equity indexes are presently trying to break out and that the US equity market breadth has recently been strong. In contrast, EM equity breadth has been very weak (Chart on page 4). The latest rebound in the EM equity index has been again narrow, led by mega-cap new economy stocks in China, Korea and Taiwan. Provided such poor EM equity breadth in both absolute terms and relative to the US, we are reluctant to upgrade EM equities from neutral to overweight in a global equity portfolio. As to absolute performance, the Charts on pages 12-18 illustrate that many market-based indicators are flagging yellow or red lights for EM risk assets. Even though we turned structurally bearish on the US dollar in early July, we currently expect a tactical rebound in the greenback. Investor sentiment on the greenback is very depressed, which is positive for the US dollar from a contrarian perspective (Chart of the Week on page 1). In short, global financial markets are due to reset, which will not be long-lasting but will be meaningful and produce a better entry point. For now, we maintain a neutral allocation to EM stocks and credit markets within global equity and credit portfolios, respectively.  In the currency space, we are short several EM currencies – BRL, CLP, ZAR, TRY, KRW and IDR – versus a basket of the euro, CHF and JPY. As to local rates, we are long duration – receiving 10-year swap rates in several countries – but are reluctant to take on currency risk at the moment. Arthur Budaghyan Chief Emerging Markets Strategist arthurb@bcaresearch.com US Equities Have Been Trading Well Various US equity indexes have broken out to new cyclical highs. This is a sign of a broad-based rally. Chart I-1US Equities Have Been Trading Well US Equities Have Been Trading Well US Equities Have Been Trading Well Chart I-2US Equities Have Been Trading Well US Equities Have Been Trading Well US Equities Have Been Trading Well   Equity Market Breadth Is Strong In The US But Poor In EM The advance-decline line for the US equity market has rebounded from the neutral level of 0.5. On the contrary, the same measure for EM stocks remains below the 0.5 line, signaling poor breadth despite the rebound in the EM equity index. Chart I-3Equity Market Breadth Is Strong In The US But Poor In EM Equity Market Breadth Is Strong In The US But Poor In EM Equity Market Breadth Is Strong In The US But Poor In EM The World Economy And Global Trade Are Reviving Economic data for September continue to register a sequential revival in business activity in most parts of the world. Chart I-4The World Economy And Global Trade Are Reviving The World Economy And Global Trade Are Reviving The World Economy And Global Trade Are Reviving Chart I-5The World Economy And Global Trade Are Reviving The World Economy And Global Trade Are Reviving The World Economy And Global Trade Are Reviving The US: Cash On The Sidelines Has Declined But Is Not Exhausted US institutional and money market funds presently amount to 8.5% of the value of the US equity market cap plus all US-dollar denominated bonds available to investors. The Fed and commercial banks hold $11 trillion of debt securities. This amount of securities has been withdrawn from the market and is not available to non-bank investors. Chart I-6The US: Cash On The Sidelines Has Declined But Is Not Exhausted The US: Cash On The Sidelines Has Declined But Is Not Exhausted The US: Cash On The Sidelines Has Declined But Is Not Exhausted Chart I-7The US: Cash On The Sidelines Has Declined But Is Not Exhausted The US: Cash On The Sidelines Has Declined But Is Not Exhausted The US: Cash On The Sidelines Has Declined But Is Not Exhausted   A Delay In The US Fiscal Stimulus Package Is A Risk to The US Economy US fiscal transfers have produced a surge in household disposable income, which through consumer spending have contributed to the global recovery via a widening trade deficit. In the absence of large fiscal transfers to consumers, the opposite dynamics will prevail. Chart I-8A Delay In The US Fiscal Stimulus Package Is A Risk to The US Economy A Delay In The US Fiscal Stimulus Package Is A Risk to The US Economy A Delay In The US Fiscal Stimulus Package Is A Risk to The US Economy Chart I-9A Delay In The US Fiscal Stimulus Package Is A Risk to The US Economy A Delay In The US Fiscal Stimulus Package Is A Risk to The US Economy A Delay In The US Fiscal Stimulus Package Is A Risk to The US Economy   The Business Cycle In China Is Recovering China’s domestic demand and production are recovering but labor market improvements are still timid. Chart I-10The Business Cycle In China Is Recovering The Business Cycle In China Is Recovering The Business Cycle In China Is Recovering Chart I-11The Business Cycle In China Is Recovering The Business Cycle In China Is Recovering The Business Cycle In China Is Recovering   China: The Stimulus Is Working Its Way Into The Economy In China, the credit and fiscal stimulus leads the business cycle by about nine months. Thereby, China’s recovery will continue until the end of Q2 2021. Chart I-12China: The Stimulus Is Working Its Way Into The Economy China: The Stimulus Is Working Its Way Into The Economy China: The Stimulus Is Working Its Way Into The Economy Chart I-13China: The Stimulus Is Working Its Way Into The Economy China: The Stimulus Is Working Its Way Into The Economy China: The Stimulus Is Working Its Way Into The Economy   China: Liquidity Tightening Has Not Yet Affected Money And Credit Growth The PBoC has withdrawn liquidity, pushing up the policy rate and bond yields. With a time lag, money and credit growth will eventually roll over. But for now, China is enjoying another period of credit splurge and the credit excesses are getting larger. Chart I-14China: Liquidity Tightening Has Not Yet Affected Money And Credit Growth China: Liquidity Tightening Has Not Yet Affected Money And Credit Growth China: Liquidity Tightening Has Not Yet Affected Money And Credit Growth Chart I-15China: Liquidity Tightening Has Not Yet Affected Money And Credit Growth China: Liquidity Tightening Has Not Yet Affected Money And Credit Growth China: Liquidity Tightening Has Not Yet Affected Money And Credit Growth   China: From Commodities Restocking To Destocking? Chinese imports of many commodities have been super strong since April. However, they have substantially outpaced their final demand. This suggests there has been an inventory restocking phase. This will likely soon be followed by a period of destocking when Chinese imports of resources dwindle for several months. Chart I-16China: From Commodities Restocking To Destocking? China: From Commodities Restocking To Destocking? China: From Commodities Restocking To Destocking? Chart I-17China: From Commodities Restocking To Destocking? China: From Commodities Restocking To Destocking? China: From Commodities Restocking To Destocking?   Red Flags For EM Currencies The rollover in platinum prices and pick-up in EM currency volatility (shown inverted on the bottom panel) point to a rebound in the US dollar and a relapse in EM exchange rates. Chart I-18Red Flags For EM Currencies Red Flags For EM Currencies Red Flags For EM Currencies Yellow Flags For EM Equities The new cyclical high in EM share prices has not been confirmed by a new low in EM equity volatility (the latter shown inverted in the top panel). Moreover, our Risk-On/Safe-Haven Currency ratio has been trending lower since June, flagging risks to EM assets. Finally, global ex-TMT stocks are struggling to break above their June highs. Chart I-19Yellow Flags For EM Equities Yellow Flags For EM Equities Yellow Flags For EM Equities EM Sovereign And Corporate Spreads, Currencies, Equities And Commodities Commodities prices and EM currencies drive EM sovereign and corporate spreads while EM corporate bond yields (shown inverted in the bottom panel) correlate with EM share prices. Chart I-20EM Sovereign And Corporate Spreads, Currencies, Equities And Commodities EM Sovereign And Corporate Spreads, Currencies, Equities And Commodities EM Sovereign And Corporate Spreads, Currencies, Equities And Commodities Many Currencies Against The US Dollar Are At Critical Resistances If these currencies break out of these technical resistance levels, they will experience a lasting appreciation versus the US dollar. However, in our view, they will initially weaken before breaking out next year. Chart I-21Many Currencies Against The US Dollar Are At Critical Resistances Many Currencies Against The US Dollar Are At Critical Resistances Many Currencies Against The US Dollar Are At Critical Resistances Chart I-22Many Currencies Against The US Dollar Are At Critical Resistances Many Currencies Against The US Dollar Are At Critical Resistances Many Currencies Against The US Dollar Are At Critical Resistances   Are Global Defensive Equity Sectors On A Cusp Of Outperformance? Many defensive equity sectors have reached or are close to their technical support lines. Their outperformance will likely occur during a risk-off period. Chart I-23Are Global Defensive Equity Sectors On A Cusp Of Outperformance? Are Global Defensive Equity Sectors On A Cusp Of Outperformance? Are Global Defensive Equity Sectors On A Cusp Of Outperformance? Chart I-24Are Global Defensive Equity Sectors On A Cusp Of Outperformance? Are Global Defensive Equity Sectors On A Cusp Of Outperformance? Are Global Defensive Equity Sectors On A Cusp Of Outperformance?   These Markets Have Not Yet Entered A Bull Market  These markets have rebounded to their technical resistance lines but have so far failed to break out. This gives us comfort to remain neutral on EM by expecting a pullback. Chart I-25These Markets Have Not Yet Entered A Bull Market These Markets Have Not Yet Entered A Bull Market These Markets Have Not Yet Entered A Bull Market Chart I-26These Markets Have Not Yet Entered A Bull Market These Markets Have Not Yet Entered A Bull Market These Markets Have Not Yet Entered A Bull Market   Risk Measures Signal Modest Investor Complacency The SKEW index for the S&P 500 is low, entailing that investors are not hedging tail risks. The put-call ratio is not elevated despite many investors hedging against the US election uncertainty. Critically, the Nasdaq’s volatility is in a bull market. Chart I-27Risk Measures Signal Modest Investor Complacency Risk Measures Signal Modest Investor Complacency Risk Measures Signal Modest Investor Complacency Chart I-28Risk Measures Signal Modest Investor Complacency Risk Measures Signal Modest Investor Complacency Risk Measures Signal Modest Investor Complacency   EM (ex-China, Korea And Taiwan): The Recovery Is Sluggish And Subdued Outside China, Korea and Taiwan, EM domestic demand recovery is very slow and tame. In these economies, the fiscal stimulus has been small, the banking system is unhealthy and the monetary transmission mechanism is broken, i.e. banks are failing to properly transmit monetary easing into the real economy. Chart I-29EM (ex-China, Korea And Taiwan): The Recovery Is Sluggish And Subdued EM (ex-China, Korea And Taiwan): The Recovery Is Sluggish And Subdued EM (ex-China, Korea And Taiwan): The Recovery Is Sluggish And Subdued Chart I-30EM (ex-China, Korea And Taiwan): The Recovery Is Sluggish And Subdued EM (ex-China, Korea And Taiwan): The Recovery Is Sluggish And Subdued EM (ex-China, Korea And Taiwan): The Recovery Is Sluggish And Subdued   Footnotes Equities Recommendations Currencies, Credit And Fixed-Income Recommendations

Highlights Currency markets remain vulnerable to the upcoming US election, Brexit, and a resurgence of Covid-19 infections. Meanwhile, President’s Trump suggested “piecemeal” fiscal deal increases the odds of a correction in the near term. Stay short USD/JPY as a core holding. We eventually expect the passage of a fiscal deal, regardless of who is in the White House. This will favor pro-cyclical trades. CAD/USD is likely to continue strengthening versus the dollar, but underperforming at the crosses. The key reason is that, in the short term, even with an oil price recovery, Canadian crude will remain trapped in Alberta, keeping the WCS-to-WTI discount wide. Meanwhile, domestically, while the Canadian economy has bottomed, a resurgence in new Covid-19 cases puts this recovery at risk. We therefore expect the loonie to touch 80-82 cents but underperform the Australian dollar, Swedish krona, and Norwegian krone. Go short CAD/NOK for a trade. Feature Chart I-1The CAD Has Been A Laggard The CAD Has Been A Laggard The CAD Has Been A Laggard Since the DXY index peaked on March 19, the Canadian dollar has been an underperformer. Among its G10 peers, only the safe-haven currencies such as the Swiss franc and Japanese yen trail behind the loonie. This is remarkable since other commodity currencies such as the Norwegian krone and Australian dollar have posted very handsome returns since the March lows (Chart I-1). The natural question is whether the loonie’s underperformance is a sign of mispricing, or if other fundamental factors are at play? If the latter, then what are the key drivers of this underperformance and what sort of returns can we expect from the loonie over the next six to 12 months? Finally, are there any opportunities at the crosses that investors can capitalize on? The Loonie: Key Drivers The key drivers of the Canadian dollar are what happens to natural resource prices, specifically crude oil, and the Bank of Canada’s monetary policy stance relative to the Federal Reserve. As a major oil-producing nation, it is well known that an important driver of the loonie has been the price of crude oil. This is because rising domestic income from higher oil prices boosts aggregate demand. This comes both from the private sector through increased capital spending, more hiring and increased wages, and from government spending afforded by higher tax revenues and royalty income. As a result, the higher aggregate demand provides room for the BoC to hike interest rates. As a major oil-producing nation, it is well known that an important driver of the loonie has been the price of crude oil. Meanwhile, an increase in oil prices also implies rising terms of trade. This improves balance-of-payment dynamics, allowing the fair value of the exchange rate to rise in the process. As such, the rise in the currency does not necessarily tighten financial conditions. It is quite remarkable that for most of the last two decades, the difference between Canadian and US interest rates can be explained by swings in the oil price. This in turn has been a powerful driver of the Canadian dollar (Chart I-2). Chart I-2Policy Rates Follow The Oil price Policy Rates Follow The Oil price Policy Rates Follow The Oil price Chart I-3A Significant Resource Sector In Canada A Significant Resource Sector In Canada A Significant Resource Sector In Canada This should not come as a surprise. As a share of GDP, resources account for almost 20% of the Canadian economy (Chart I-3). The share of commodity exports is also a quite significant at 23%. While the share of services in the economy has risen, much of this is in the orbit of mining and oil and gas extraction support services. In a nutshell, the Canadian economy remains a resource-based one, making the outlook for resources, specifically crude oil, an important consideration. Where To Next For Canadian Crude? The oil industry has been hit by multiple tectonic shocks, including a sudden stop in economic activity, a fallout from the OPEC cartel, divestment from ESG funds, and falling oil intensity in many economies. Just over a decade ago, the price of crude oil was firmly above $100 per barrel. Fast forward to today and many blends are trading south of $45 per barrel (Chart I-4). Chart I-4Many Blends Are Trading Below Many Blends Are Trading Below $45 Many Blends Are Trading Below $45 Going forward, the path for oil prices will be highly dependent on the interplay between demand and supply. Oil demand tends to follow the ebbs and flows of the business cycle, with over 60% of global petroleum consumed by the transportation sector. As a result, crude oil prices have largely tracked Apple mobility data (Chart I-5). Many countries are now entering renewed restrictions due to the second wave of the pandemic, which is showing up in a slowdown in traffic. However, as we discussed last week, the economic effects should be far less lethal that what we experienced in the first half of this year. The reasons include the potential for a vaccine soon and a substantial drop in mortality rates. Our commodity strategists expect oil prices to average $65 per barrel next year, much more than is currently priced in the futures curve. Crude oil prices have largely tracked Apple mobility trends data.  From a bird’s-eye view, oil prices are more likely to enter a broad trading range, as they did in the ‘80s and ‘90s, than a structural bull market. On the positive side, we have probably seen a bottom in oil prices, in that it is unlikely we will revisit negative price territory. However, history suggests that it takes quite a long time for excesses to clear in the oil market. The bull market of the 1970s was followed by a 20-year bear market, as OPEC production surged (Chart I-6). This time around, US shale production has gained significant market share, and with the electrification of the modern economy, a lot of barrels may need to be taken off the market to induce a genuine bull market. Chart I-5Oil Prices Have Tracked The Recovery In Traffic Oil Prices Have Tracked The Recovery In Traffic Oil Prices Have Tracked The Recovery In Traffic Chart I-6A Secular View On ##br##Oil Prices A Secular View On Oil Prices A Secular View On Oil Prices Canadian players suffer from two additional hiccups: First, the International Maritime Organization has introduced new standards for bunker fuel since January 2020 (IMO 2020). According to the new standards, sulphur content must be cut from 3.5% to 0.5%. Canada’s Western Canadian Select (WCS) blend is one of the world’s heavier crudes with a sulphur content north of 3.5%. This is expected to significantly widen the discount between WCS and light sweet crude. This is bad news for Canadian oil producers. Second, pipeline capacity remains a major hurdle to getting Canadian crude to US refineries. This leads to a transportation discount for Canadian crude oil. The Enbridge Line 3 replacement is facing delays from the state of Minnesota (390K additional barrels). The future of the Keystone XL pipeline, a major release valve for Canadian oil (830K barrels a day in capacity), rests on the US election. Former Vice President Joe Biden has opposed the project, calling Alberta’s oil “tar sands that we don’t need.” The Trans Mountain Expansion project (690K additional barrels), connecting Alberta to the Westridge Marine Terminal and Chevron refinery in Burnaby, is slated to be competed only by the end of 2022. All this could widen the discount between WCS and WTI crude oil, hurting the Canadian dollar in the process (Chart I-7). There are offsetting factors. The drop in Venezuelan oil production has allowed Canadian producers to gain market share in the heavy crude oil market. Production cuts in Alberta have also helped mitigate the oversupply of heavy crude. Canadian oil exports are near record highs, despite the fact that the US is rapidly becoming energy independent (Chart I-8). As a share of imports, Canadian crude represents about half of the US’s intake (Chart I-9). This highlights the importance of heavy crude in oil market dynamics. Specifically, a lot of refining capacity in the US has been fine-tuned to handle the cheaper but heavier blend from Canada. Chart I-7Canadian Oil Discount Could Widen Canadian Oil Discount Could Widen Canadian Oil Discount Could Widen Chart I-8Big US Demand For Canadian Oil Big US Demand For Canadian Oil Big US Demand For Canadian Oil Chart I-9Big US Demand For Canadian Oil Big US Demand For Canadian Oil Big US Demand For Canadian Oil Netting it all out, we will expect crude oil prices to head to $65 per barrel, while the Canadian discount to widens to $20 per barrel before slowly recovering. This should provide modest upside for the Canadian dollar as terms of trade continue to improve. A Regime Shift Chart I-10Oil Production: US Versus Canada Oil Production: US Versus Canada Oil Production: US Versus Canada There has been a paradigm shift in oil production, with US shale producers aggressively grabbing market share from both OPEC and non-OPEC producers. Currently, Canada produces only 5.5% of global crude versus 15% for US production. Admittedly, the Canadian market share has also been rising, but the tectonic shift in US production has severely dampened the positive correlation between crude prices and the loonie (Chart I-10). In statistical terms, petrocurrencies had a near-perfect positive correlation with oil around 2010 when US production was about to take off. Since then, that correlation fell from around 0.9 to about 0.2 (Chart I-11). The loss of shale output during the recent downturn has somewhat re-established a strong correlation between petrocurrencies and the crude oil price (bottom panel). But more importantly, should global demand pick up, US shale output will rise again and redistribute market share away from both OPEC and other non-OPEC members and towards the US. Chart I-11Negative Correlation Between Petrocurrencies And Crude Oil Restored Negative Correlation Between Petrocurrencies And Crude Oil Restored Negative Correlation Between Petrocurrencies And Crude Oil Restored Take the Mexican peso as an example. Since 2013, Mexico has become a net importer of oil, as the US moves towards becoming a net exporter. This explains why the positive correlation between the peso and oil prices has weakened significantly in recent years. Put another way, rising oil prices benefit US domestic income much more than they did in the past, while the benefits for countries like Canada and Mexico are slowly fading. The Canadian crude market share has been rising, but the tectonic shift in US production has severely dampened the positive correlation between crude prices and the loonie.  The second seismic shift in oil markets has been the ESG wave. With awareness towards global warming and climate change gaining mainstream support, divestments from energy assets has picked up steam. Currency markets react to net portfolio flows, and divestments from the energy sector in particular and the commodity sector in general have been behind the huge underperformance of the Canadian dollar since 2011 (Chart I-12). Chart I-12Huge Underperformance Of Canadian Equities Huge Underperformance Of Canadian Equities Huge Underperformance Of Canadian Equities The good news is that a lot has already been priced in. First, global energy stocks have been in a 12-year bear market in relative performance terms. This represents a 70% peak-to-trough decline, with the latest selloff being symptomatic of a capitulation phase. Second, at a price-to-book discount of 64% and a dividend yield of 7%, energy stocks are very cheap (Chart I-13). Chart I-13A Capitulation In Energy Stocks? A Capitulation In Energy Stocks? A Capitulation In Energy Stocks? It is remarkable that long-term portfolio flows into Canadian assets have started picking up, a sign of bargain hunting by international investors (Chart I-14). This should provide a modest tailwind to the Canadian dollar over the next six to 12 months. Chart I-14A Recovery In Canadian Portfolio Inflows A Recovery In Canadian Portfolio Inflows A Recovery In Canadian Portfolio Inflows Improving Domestic Conditions The Canadian domestic economy has been holding up well, despite lower oil prices. This has occurred on the back of massive fiscal stimulus, in addition to the BoC dropping rates to 0.25% and engaging in quantitative easing. During his Throne Speech a fortnight ago, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau vowed to do “whatever it takes” to support people and businesses throughout the crisis. Fitch Ratings estimates that the budget deficit in Canada will remain wide going into 2022 (Chart I-15). Meanwhile, as lockdown measures have eased since April, incoming data has been robust. Chart I-15Lots Of Fiscal Stimulus In Canada The Outlook For The Canadian Dollar The Outlook For The Canadian Dollar Canada continues to create record employment, with 246,000 new jobs added in August. This is leading to the fastest recovery in the unemployment rate on record (Chart I-16). The manufacturing and resources sectors in Quebec, Alberta, and British Columbia, which bore the brunt of the employment declines, are rebounding. Chart I-16Best Job Recovery In Decades Best Job Recovery In Decades Best Job Recovery In Decades Most measures of household confidence are in a V-shaped recovery. Retail sales in Canada have rebounded, reaching above pre-pandemic levels. Mortgage credit has also picked up strongly. Correspondingly, housing starts have overtaken their pre-pandemic peak as well, with new home construction at its highest level since 2007. Working from home has led to a surge in renovation projects. Meanwhile, low rates and rising home prices have encouraged new construction. Residential investment is almost 7% of Canadian GDP, a significant chunk of aggregate demand (Chart I-17). Despite the improvement in domestic conditions, inflationary pressures remain moribund. The output gap measure according to the BoC remains wide at -3.2% of GDP. The latest inflation print shows that domestic prices in Canada still remain anchored below the midpoint of the BoC’s target band. This means that the BoC will be in no rush to normalize policy anytime soon (Chart I-18). Chart I-17Residential Construction Is Important Residential Construction Is Important Residential Construction Is Important Chart I-18Canadian Inflation Is Below Target Canadian Inflation Is Below Target Canadian Inflation Is Below Target Given the government’s commitment to step in as a spender of last resort, real rates in Canada will remain depressed as inflation starts to recover. This will not be as pronounced versus the US, where the Fed is trying to asymmetrically generate inflation, but more so against its commodity peers such as Australia and Norway, where the number of new Covid-19 cases remains under control, giving the governments there less incentive to significantly increase spending. This suggests that while the loonie may have upside against the dollar, it could underperform at the crosses. Investment Implications We expect the CAD/USD to gravitate higher in the next few months. The key catalysts are favorable interest rates versus the US and a gradual recovery in WCS oil prices as global economic activity picks up. From a fundamental perspective, the CAD is still undervalued by 7.3% on a trade-weighted basis (Chart I-19). This puts 80-82 cents within striking distance. Chart I-19The CAD Is Still Cheap The CAD Is Still Cheap The CAD Is Still Cheap Chart I-20Sell CAD/NOK Sell CAD/NOK Sell CAD/NOK Relative to other commodity currencies, transportation bottlenecks in Canada will prove to be a formidable hurdle in closing the current discount between WCS and WTI and/or Brent. While Canadian crude is likely to remain trapped in the oil sands for now, North Sea crude will face fewer transportation bottlenecks in the near term. This suggests that the path of least resistance for the CAD/NOK is down (Chart I-20). Sell CAD/NOK for a trade. An improvement in economic activity in Asia relative to the West will also favor AUD/CAD. Rising oil prices are a terms-of-trade boost for oil exporters but lead to demand destruction for oil importers. In general, a strategy for playing oil upside is to be long a basket of energy producers versus energy consumers. This suggests that the CAD has upside against the euro, the Indian rupee, and the Turkish lira. We are already long a basket of petrocurrencies versus the euro. Finally, we are long CAD/NZD as a play on policy divergences between the Reserve Bank Of New Zealand and the BoC. However, our conviction on this trade is low due to the resurgence of new cases in Canada. We recommend maintaining tight stops on this position.   Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 USD Technicals 1 USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 USD Technicals 2 USD Technicals 2 Recent data from the US have been positive: The unemployment rate fell from 8.4% to 7.9% in September. Nonfarm payrolls increased by 661K. The ISM Non-manufacturing Index increased from 56.9 to 57.8 in September. The Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index jumped from 74.1 to 80.4 in September. The trade deficit widened from $63.4 billion to $67.1 billion in August. Initial jobless claims increased by 840K for the week ending on October 3. The DXY index fell initially but then recouped the loss, ending flat this week. Trump’s tweet on Tuesday about “halting COVID-19 relief talks until after election” largely reduced the likelihood of any imminent fiscal stimulus. While pre-election uncertainties have been dominant recently, we remain dollar bears in the cycle, especially in a post-election and post-vaccine world. Report Links: Tail Risks In FX Markets - October 2, 2020 The Message From Dollar Sentiment And Technical Indicators - Sept. 25, 2020 Addressing Client Questions - September 4, 2020 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 EUR Technicals 1 EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 EUR Technicals 2 EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area have been mixed: Headline inflation declined from -0.2% to -0.3% year-on-year in September. Core inflation also decreased from 0.5% to 0.2%. The Markit Services PMI edged up from 47.6 to 48 in September. The Sentix Investor Confidence Index increased from -9.5 to -8.3 in October. Retail sales grew by 3.7% year-on-year in August. The euro rose by 0.2% against the US dollar this week. The slip in core inflation this week reinforced the concern about deflation. In the recent strategic review, Christine Lagarde kept a dovish tone and reiterated a desire to keep policy accommodative. We believe that the PEPP with a total envelope of €1,350 billion through the end of June 2021 will continue to support euro area economic recovery. Report Links: Addressing Client Questions - September 4, 2020 On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Japanese Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 JPY Technicals 1 JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 JPY Technicals 2 JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been positive: The Jibun Bank Services PMI increased from 45 to 46.9 in September. The current account surplus surged from ¥1.5 trillion to ¥2.1 trillion in August. The Eco Watchers Survey Outlook Index increased from 42.4 to 48.3 in September. The Current Conditions Index also grew from 43.9 to 49.3. The Japanese yen declined by 0.3% against the US dollar this week. Incoming data confirms that the Japanese economy is recovering from pre-pandemic lows. Apart from being a cheap safe-haven hedge, the Japanese yen is also supported by lower COVID infection rates and fewer political uncertainties. Stay short on USD/JPY. Report Links: The Near-Term Bull Case For The Dollar - February 28, 2020 Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 Currency Market Signals From Gold, Equities And Flows - January 31, 2020 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 GBP Technicals 1 GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 GBP Technicals 2 GBP Technicals 2 Recent data from the UK have been positive: The Markit Services PMI increased from 55.1 to 56.1 in September. House prices grew by 2.3% year-on-year in July. Unit labor costs surged by 27.4% year-on-year in Q2. The British pound has been flat against the US dollar this week. Despite ongoing Brexit chaos, the pound managed to remain well above 1.27 in recent months. Our bias is that a Brexit deal will eventually be reached. We favor the British pound relative to the euro since the pound is tremendously undervalued against the euro. Besides, risk reversals also suggest that the pound is deeply oversold. Report Links: Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 AUD Technicals 1 AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 AUD Technicals 2 AUD Technicals 2 Recent data from Australia have been mixed: The Commonwealth Bank Services PMI increased from 50 to 50.8 in September. Exports declined by 4% month-on-month in August while imports expanded by 2%. The trade surplus narrowed from A$4.65 billion to A$2.6 billion.   The NAB Business Confidence Index increased from -8 to -4 in September. The Australian dollar fell by 0.3% against the US dollar this week. On Tuesday, the RBA kept its interest rate steady at 0.25%. Governor Philip Lowe acknowledged the weakness in Australia’s labor market and highlighted that the RBA continues to consider various measures designed to support job growth as the economy opens further. We remain positive on the Australian dollar. Report Links: An Update On The Australian Dollar - September 18, 2020 On AUD And CNY - January 17, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 NZD Technicals 1 NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 NZD Technicals 2 NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand have been positive: The ANZ Business Confidence Index improved from -28.5 to -14.5 in October. The Activity Outlook index also shifted from -5.4 to 3.6 in October. The New Zealand dollar fell by 1.1% against the US dollar this week. While still well below pre-pandemic levels, the ANZ Business Confidence Index has undoubtedly improved in October. Investment and employment intensions both moved higher, lifting profit expectations. That said, the services sector is still under severe pressure resulting from strict lockdown measures. Markets are now pricing in a higher than 50% probability of a further rate cut by early next year, which contributes to the relative weakness in the New Zealand dollar. Report Links: Currencies And The Value-Versus-Growth Debate - July 10, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Place A Limit Sell On DXY At 100 - November 15, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 CAD Technicals 1 CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 CAD Technicals 2 CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been negative: The trade deficit marginally narrowed from C$2.53 billion to C$2.45 billion in August. The Ivey PMI declined from 67.8 to 54.3 in September. Housing starts increased by 209K in September, down from 261.5K in the previous month. The Canadian dollar appreciated by 0.3% against the US dollar this week. As an important oil producer and exporter, the Canadian dollar shifts along with the price of oil. In this week’s report, we discuss the key drivers behind the Canadian dollar and discover why it has underperformed other G10 pro-cyclical currencies. Please refer to our front section for more detailed research. Report Links: Currencies And The Value-Versus-Growth Debate - July 10, 2020 More On Competitive Devaluations, The CAD And The SEK - May 1, 2020 A New Paradigm For Petrocurrencies - April 10, 2020 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 CHF Technicals 1 CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 CHF Technicals 2 CHF Technicals 2 Recent data from Switzerland have been positive: Total sight deposits continue to increase from CHF 704.5 billion to CHF 705.1 billion for the week ending on October 2. The unemployment rate declined from 3.4% to 3.3% in September. The Swiss franc appreciated by 0.2% against the US dollar this week and nearly 6% since January. The unwanted appreciation has been a headache for the SNB, which warrants more intervention against a pricey franc. Interestingly, the franc has been flat against the euro year-to-date. We are looking to buy EUR/CHF on weakness due to the SNB’s intervention and the CHF’s lower beta to growth. Report Links: On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 Currency Market Signals From Gold, Equities And Flows - January 31, 2020 Portfolio Tweaks Before The Chinese New Year - January 24, 2020 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 NOK Technicals 1 NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 NOK Technicals 2 NOK Technicals 2 Recent data from Norway have been positive: The industrial production index increased by 1.1% month-on-month in August.  Manufacturing output increased by 3% month-on-month in August. The Norwegian krone rose by 0.7% against the US dollar this week. Incoming data from Norway is consistent with the recent economic recovery there, especially in the resources sector. Industrial production of mining and quarrying, basic metals, and machinery equipment jumped, respectively, by 10.1%, 8.8% and 15.7% month-on-month in August. We continue to favor the Norwegian krone and are looking to purchase the Nordic basket again at a more favorable price. Report Links: Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 A New Paradigm For Petrocurrencies - April 10, 2020 Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 SEK Technicals 1 SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 SEK Technicals 2 SEK Technicals 2 Recent data from Sweden have been positive: Industrial production increased by 0.2% year-on-year in August, or 7% month-on-month. Manufacturing new orders was unchanged year-on-year in August, but that’s up from a 6.9% contraction in the previous month. The budget balance shifted from a surplus of SEK 19.8 billion to a deficit of SEK 13.1 billion in September. The Swedish krona increased by 0.6% against the US dollar this week. As a bellwether of global growth, Swedish manufacturing activity is one of the indicators we monitor closely in order to gauge where we are in a cycle. Despite recent uncertainties, the Swedish manufacturing sector is showing budding signs of recovery, which is bullish for the Swedish krona. Kelly Zhong Research Analyst Report Links: Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Where To Next For The US Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades

Highlights Long-term investors who can tolerate volatility should buy SEK/USD for a potential 20 percent upside. Short-term investors who cannot tolerate volatility should buy CHF/USD. The dollar’s short-term moves are a perfect mirror-image of the global stock market. US and euro area long-duration bond yields will ultimately converge… …and the euro area’s huge trade surplus with the US will vanish. Fractal trade: Underweight European retailers versus market. Feature Chart of the WeekSEK/USD Is 20 Percent Undervalued Relative To The Sweden/US Bond Yield Differential SEK/USD Is 20 Percent Undervalued Relative To The Sweden/US Bond Yield Differential SEK/USD Is 20 Percent Undervalued Relative To The Sweden/US Bond Yield Differential The demand for a foreign currency serves one of four purposes: To buy goods and services denominated in the foreign currency. To buy long-term investments denominated in the foreign currency, also known as foreign direct investment (FDI). To buy shorter-term financial investments like bonds and equities denominated in the foreign currency, also known as portfolio flows.1 To buy currency reserves denominated in the foreign currency. What Sets The Broad Level Of EUR/USD? Looking at the euro, three of the four components of demand tend to change relatively slowly. The net foreign demand for euro area goods and services is not particularly volatile. Neither is FDI. Demand for euro reserves also tends not to suffer wild gyrations, except at the rare moment that a currency peg starts or ends.  All of which means that the usual driver of demand for euros are portfolio flows (Chart I-2). Chart I-2Euro Area Portfolio Flows Have A High Amplitude Euro Area Portfolio Flows Have A High Amplitude Euro Area Portfolio Flows Have A High Amplitude Portfolio flows are of two main types: fixed income and equity. However, in the euro area, fixed income portfolio flows usually have the much higher amplitude (Chart I-3). The reason is that most savings are invested in fixed income assets. For example, German households hold 80 percent of their assets in fixed income, cash, or close proxies. This explains why the stock of government fixed income securities in the euro area is almost twice as large as the market capitalisation of all the euro area’s stock markets (Chart I-4). Chart I-3Euro Area Fixed Income Portfolio Flows Have A Higher Amplitude Than Equity Flows... Euro Area Fixed Income Portfolio Flows Have A Higher Amplitude Than Equity Flows... Euro Area Fixed Income Portfolio Flows Have A Higher Amplitude Than Equity Flows... Chart I-4...Because Euro Area Fixed Income Is The Dominant Asset-Class ...Because Euro Area Fixed Income Is The Dominant Asset-Class ...Because Euro Area Fixed Income Is The Dominant Asset-Class What causes fixed income flows to flood out of the euro area one moment and back in the next? The answer is the expected change in interest rates. The main issue is not the exact timing of short-term interest rate changes. Instead, it is the so-called terminal rate: the average interest rate over the very long term, proxied by the long-duration bond yield. Fixed income investors gravitate to the bonds with the highest potential returns adjusted for currency hedging costs or likely currency moves. In the euro area, fixed income portfolio flows have a higher amplitude than equity flows. When the expected interest rate in the euro area declines relative to that in the US, it diminishes any further price upside of euro area bonds compared with that of US T-bonds. Hence, fixed income investors shift out of the less attractive euro area bonds into US T-bonds. The outflow continues until it has depressed EUR/USD to a level where the potential upside to the exchange rate becomes symmetrically more attractive. At this new lower level for EUR/USD, the fixed income portfolio outflow stops because a new equilibrium has been established. International fixed income investors have less upside from the euro area bond price, but they now have symmetrically more upside from the cheaper EUR/USD – and the two factors cancel out. Chart I-5 provides powerful evidence of this dynamic. For the past 15 years, the broad territory in which EUR/USD trades has been a close function of the euro area/US long-duration bond yield spread.3 A zero yield spread equates to EUR/USD in the broad territory of 1.35 with every +/-100 bps equal to +/- 15 cents. Hence, the current yield spread of -100 bps equates to EUR/USD trading in the broad territory of 1.20. Chart I-5The Euro Area/US Bond Yield Differential Sets EUR/USD... The Euro Area/US Bond Yield Differential Sets EUR/USD... The Euro Area/US Bond Yield Differential Sets EUR/USD... Interestingly, the euro area/US trade imbalance is also a close function of the bond yield spread. This confirms that the euro area’s massive trade surplus with the US is the direct result of the massive imbalance in relative monetary policy – which depressed EUR/USD and boosted the euro area’s relative competitiveness. Put simply, at a narrower (and more normal) bond yield spread, the euro area’s trade surplus with the US would largely vanish (Chart I-6). Chart I-6...And Thereby It Sets The Euro Area/US Trade Imbalance ...And Thereby It Sets The Euro Area/US Trade Imbalance ...And Thereby It Sets The Euro Area/US Trade Imbalance The Euro Area/US Yield Spread Is Likely To Narrow Further The long-term evolution of EUR/USD – as well as the associated trade imbalance – hinges on the long-term evolution of the euro area/US long-duration bond yield spread. Will this spread widen or narrow? At a narrower bond yield spread, the euro area’s trade surplus with the US would largely vanish. From the euro area side, the answer is easy. The spread cannot widen, it can only narrow. With the ECB policy interest rate already expected to be stuck at its lower bound indefinitely, down is not an option. From the US side, the spread could go either way, at least mathematically. However, it is our high conviction view that in the long term it will narrow. The Federal Reserve’s recent strategic review has made its reaction function blatantly asymmetric. The central bank has told us that it will be thick-skinned to reflationary shocks, but trigger-happy to the slightest further deflationary shock. Hence, when the slightest further deflationary shock comes – and sooner or later it will – US long-duration bond yields will converge with those in the UK and Japan in one of two ways. Either the Fed will follow the Bank of England in a volte-face about adding negative interest rate policy into its toolbox. Or the Fed will follow the Bank of Japan in formally implementing yield curve control (Chart I-7).   Chart I-7The US Bond Yield Will Converge With The Others The US Bond Yield Will Converge With The Others The US Bond Yield Will Converge With The Others Buy SEK/USD For The Long Term, Buy CHF/USD For The Short Term Other European economies also exhibit the same strong link between their exchange rates with the dollar and their bond yield spreads with the US. In the case of Sweden, there is an attractive opportunity. SEK/USD is still about 20 percent undervalued relative to the long-term relationship with the Sweden/US bond yield spread. Hence, the long-term case for owning SEK/USD does not even require the yield spread to narrow from where it stands today. Of course, if the spread did narrow by a further 50 bps, the potential upside would approach 30 percent (Chart of the Week). SEK/USD is still about 20 percent undervalued relative to the long-term relationship with the Sweden/US bond yield spread.  Nevertheless, for short-term investors, there is an important caveat. While fixed income portfolio flows drive the long-term values of European currencies versus the dollar, equity portfolio flows become dominant in periods of market stress. During such dislocations, equity flows tend to flee to perceived haven assets and markets, many of which are denominated in dollars. As a result, the dollar rallies. The compelling proof is that over the past year, the dollar has traded as a perfect mirror-image of the global stock market (Chart I-8). Chart I-8The Dollar In 2020 = A Perfect Mirror-Image Of The Stock Market The Dollar In 2020 = A Perfect Mirror-Image Of The Stock Market The Dollar In 2020 = A Perfect Mirror-Image Of The Stock Market In Europe, the haven currency is the Swiss franc. Hence, while SEK/USD fell by 10 percent during this year’s market turbulence, CHF/USD remained unperturbed. Furthermore, CHF/USD is also undervalued relative to its relationship with the Switzerland/US bond yield spread.4 Albeit, the undervaluation is more modest, at around 6 percent (Chart I-9). Chart I-9CHF/USD Is Modestly Undervalued Relative To The Switzerland/US Bond Yield Differential CHF/USD Is Modestly Undervalued Relative To The Switzerland/US Bond Yield Differential CHF/USD Is Modestly Undervalued Relative To The Switzerland/US Bond Yield Differential The conclusion is that long-term investors who can tolerate volatility should buy SEK/USD for its greater upside. Whereas short-term investors who cannot tolerate volatility should buy CHF/USD for its greater safety. Fractal Trading System* This week we note that the recent strong outperformance of European retailers is vulnerable to a trend reversal, and especially so if the pandemic resurges. Accordingly, the recommended trade is underweight European retailers versus the market (which can be implemented as EXH8 versus Euro Stoxx 600). The profit target and symmetrical stop-loss is set at 4.2 percent. Chart I-10European Retailers Vs. Market European Retailers Vs. Market European Retailers Vs. Market The rolling 1-year win ratio now stands at 56 percent. When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated  December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Footnotes 1 In this discussion, portfolio flows include short-term speculative flows. 2 For example, when the Swiss National Bank broke the franc’s peg with the euro in early 2015, it abruptly stopped buying euro reserves. 3 The euro area bond yield is the issue-weighted average of the euro area’s constituent sovereign bond yields. A good approximation of the euro area’s issue-weighted average is the French bond yield.   Dhaval Joshi Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System   Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart I-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields   Interest Rate Chart I-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations