Silver

Highlights The world remains mired in a manufacturing recession. This has historically not been bullish for pro-cyclical currencies. The velocity of money in the euro area will need to rise vis-à-vis the U.S. to confirm a bottom in EUR/USD. Watch the gold/silver ratio in timing this shift. Feature The view on the dollar has hardly ever been more polarized. In the bullish camp are those who believe expected returns are currently highest in the U.S., whether in the bond, equity, or real estate markets. As such, deployment of fresh capital will naturally gravitate towards the U.S. Meanwhile, the bearish side has to contend with the fact that the dollar is expensive, the Federal Reserve is about to expand dollar liquidity, and central banks keep diversifying out of their dollar holdings at a rampant pace. Both camps make quite strong arguments. However, there is little discussion about how these trends will affect relative prices between the U.S. and its trading partners. Exchange rates constantly oscillate to equate prices between any two nations. And the most important of those prices is that of money or interest rates. Forecasting relative interest rates can be an arduous task, but at a minimum, one can observe whether they are in equilibrium or not. In this report, we do it via one lens: the velocity of money, with specific application to the EUR/USD exchange rate.    EUR/USD And The Velocity Of Money The velocity of money (V) is a difficult concept to define, but can be summarized by Irving Fisher’s classical equation MV=PQ, where P is the price level in the economy, Q is output, and M is the money supply. In other words, V=PQ/M. Classical monetarists believe that the velocity of money should exhibit a high degree of stability, allowing central banks to control prices by simply altering the money supply. However, over the past few decades, there has been no correlation between prices and money supply, at least in the U.S., which seems to suggest V has a life of its own.  Chart I-1Money Velocity And Interest Rates There are many debates on how to interpret the velocity of money, but it is generally accepted that it is related to interest rates. If money supply is expanding faster than output, then it must be that interest rates are falling, assuming the latter are the price of money. Ergo, one way to regard V is as the interest rate required by the underlying economy (the neutral rate), since it is measured using economic variables, while long rates are priced in the financial arena. Put another way, once economic agents start to increase the turnover of money in the system, it is an endogenous sign that the economy requires higher rates, similar to the signal from rising inflation. Ever since the European debt crisis, the velocity of money in the euro area has collapsed relative to that in the U.S. In the financial world, relative long bond yields have followed suit in tight correlation (Chart I-1). In a nutshell, the relative demand for holding money, perhaps precautionary demand, has been extremely high in the euro area, such that all the increase in relative money supply has been absorbed by falling relative velocity. Put another way, the neutral rate of interest in the euro area has been falling relative to that in the U.S. The velocity of money is observed ex-post, meaning it is not very useful as a forecasting tool. However, if we accept the premise that it measures the underlying neutral rate of interest in an economy, then observing it offers powerful insight into the underlying fundamental trends for any economy. One conclusion from this could be that outgoing European Central Bank President Mario Draghi might be justified in his delivery of powerful monetary stimulus last month, despite the rising chorus of dissent from the governing council. Chart I-2Structural Slowdown In European Growth Chart I-2 plots the relative growth performance of the euro area versus the U.S. superimposed with the exchange rate. The result is very evident: The collapse in the euro since the financial crisis has been driven by falling growth differentials between the Eurozone and the U.S. There is little the central bank can do about deteriorating demographic trends, but it can do something about falling productivity. One of those things is to lower the cost of capital in the entire Eurozone, such that it makes sense even for the less productive peripheral countries to borrow and invest. Of course, dynamics in the euro area are much more complex than this simple analogy, since rates do little to boost total factor productivity, and the capital stock in the euro area is quite high. But the fact that the biggest increase in investment since the end of the European debt crisis has been in the periphery is non-negligible evidence. A weaker exchange rate also helps. Global trade growth peaked in 2011, which means that since then, one of the few ways for countries to expand their trade pie has been via a “beggar thy neighbor” policy. Both the Germans and the Japanese are automobile geniuses. So, at the margin, the decision for an indifferent buyer comes down to cost. Chart I-3 shows that ever since the European debt crisis, the relative exchange rate between Japan and the euro area has followed the relative balance sheet expansion and contraction of both central banks. Until now, the Bank of Japan’s balance sheet was slated to expand much faster than that of the ECB. This would have been a powerful and unnecessary upward force on the EUR/JPY exchange rate, in the face of a trade war. Ever since the European debt crisis, the relative exchange rate between Japan and the euro area has followed the relative balance sheet expansion and contraction of both central banks. EUR/USD could face some near-term downside, judging from the spread between German bunds and Treasury yields (Chart I-4). Admittedly, hedged yields still favor the Eurozone over the U.S., especially in the periphery, but that advantage is fading rapidly. More importantly, yields across the periphery are converging rapidly towards those in Germany, solving a critical dilemma that has always plagued the Eurozone in general, and the euro in particular. In simple terms, ECB policy has historically always been too easy for some member countries while too stimulative for others. This has traditionally led to internal friction for the currency. However, with 10-year government bond yields in France, Spain, and even Portugal now at -26 basis points, 15 basis points and 14 basis points, respectively, this dilemma is slowly fading. Chart I-3ECB Action May Have Stalled A Euro Overshoot Chart I-4EUR/USD And ##br##Interest Rates The drop in the neutral rate of interest for the Eurozone versus the U.S. might have to do with internal dynamics in the euro area, but part of the reason may also lie in the performance of the manufacturing sector versus the services industry over the past few years. The end of the commodity bull market earlier this decade, the peak in global trade – partly driven by  China’s deliberate efforts to shift its economy more towards services, and the proliferation of “capital-lite” firms has decimated the manufacturing sector around the world. This maybe explains the underperformance of the Eurozone versus the U.S. It is clear that part of this shift is structural, but there has also been a cyclical component. Together with a lot of our leading indicators, one way to time the reversal will be to watch relative money velocity trends – between the U.S., the euro area, and China, for example. This brings us to the ratio of gold prices versus silver. Bottom Line: The world remains mired in a manufacturing recession. This has historically not been bullish for pro-cyclical currencies. The velocity of money in the euro area will need to rise vis-à-vis the U.S. to confirm a bottom in EUR/USD. Gold Versus Silver Chart I-5GSR At A Speculative Extreme The gold/silver ratio (GSR) was in a race towards major overhead resistance at 100 this summer, but finally hit a three-decade high of 93.3 and is now showing tentative signs of a reversal. The history of these reversals is that they tend to be powerful, quick, and extremely volatile (Chart I-5). This not only paves the way for an excellent entry point to short gold versus silver, but provides important information on the battleground between easing financial conditions and a pick-up in economic (or manufacturing) activity. In short, it provides insight on when to buy pro-cyclical currencies. Just like gold, silver benefits from low interest rates, plentiful liquidity, and the incentive for currency wars and fiat money debasement. However, the gold/silver ratio tends to rally ahead of an economic slowdown, but then peaks when growth is still weak but liquidity conditions are plentiful enough to affect the outlook for future global growth. Of course, a key assumption is that the global economy fends off a recession, which could otherwise sustain a high and rising GSR. The ratio of the velocity of money between the U.S. and China has tended to track the gold/silver ratio in a tight embrace. The ratio of the velocity of money between the U.S. and China has tended to track the gold/silver ratio in a tight embrace (Chart I-6). A falling ratio signifies that the number of times money is changing hands in China outpaces the number in the U.S. This also tends to coincide with a pickup in manufacturing activity, for the simple reason that silver has more industrial uses (Chart I-7).  Chart I-6Falling GSR = Rising Manufacturing Activity Chart I-7No Recession = Buy Silver A falling dollar also tends to benefit silver more than gold, because silver generally rises faster than gold during precious metal bull markets. Part of the reason is that the silver market is thinner and more volatile, with futures open interest that is about one-third that of gold. Put another way, volatility in silver has always been historically higher than gold (Chart I-8), just as manufacturing and exports tend to be the most volatile part of any economy. Chart I-8Silver Is More Volatile Than Gold This brings us to the sweet spot for silver (and procyclical currencies). Even if global growth remains tepid over the next few months, a lot of the bad news is already reflected in a high GSR, meaning the potential for upside will have to be nothing short of a deep recession. Relative speculative positioning hit a high of 36% of open interest and has been rolling over since. Relative sentiment hit a high of 33% and is also rolling over. More often than not, confirmation from both these indicators has led to a selloff in the GSR (Chart I-9). Chart I-9Tentative Signs Of A Top If global growth bottoms, then the rise in silver prices could be explosive. Silver fabrication demand benefits from new industries such as solar and a flourishing “cloud” industry that are capturing the new manufacturing landscape (Chart I-10). Meanwhile, we are entering a window where any pickup in demand could lead to a sizeable increase in the silver physical deficit. The sharp fall in silver scrap supply is an indication that the supply bottleneck is becoming acute (Chart I-11). Chart I-10Silver Fabrication Demand Uptrend Chart I-11Physical Silver Is In Deficit As for speculators, ETF demand for silver has just started to pick up, meaning the prospect for a speculative buying frenzy is significant. Similarly, in Shanghai, turnover in both gold and silver has been muted – fitting evidence that there has been a dearth of Asian physical demand, from Hong Kong to India (Chart I-12). We are following this turnover closely as it could be a good indication of a turnaround. Chart I-12Silver Turnover Is Low In Asia Bottom Line: A falling GSR provides important information about the battleground between easing financial conditions and a pickup in economic activity. We remain bullish on both gold and silver, but a trading opportunity has opened up for a short GSR position. Place a limit sell at 90.   Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.S. have been mostly negative: Average hourly earnings growth fell from 3.2% year-on-year to 2.9% in September. Nonfarm payrolls decreased to 136,000, while the unemployment rate fell to a 50-year low of 3.5%. The trade deficit marginally widened to $54.9 billion in August. The NFIB’s business optimism index fell to 101.8 in September, down from 103.1 in August. Producer prices for final demand fell by 0.3% month-on-month in September. Services decreased by 0.2% while goods fell by 0.4%.  Initial jobless claims fell to 210,000 for the week ended October 4th. Both headline and core inflation were unchanged at 1.7% and 2.4% year-on-year in September. The DXY index increased by 0.1% this week. Fed chair Jerome Powell said in a speech on Tuesday that the Fed will begin increasing its securities holdings to maintain an appropriate level of reserves in order to avoid another cash supply shock. Balance sheet expansion may eventually help weaken the greenback. Report Links: Preserving Capital During Riot Points - September 6, 2019 Has The Currency Landscape Shifted? - August 16, 2019 USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area have continued to disappoint: The Sentix confidence index in the euro area fell further to -16.8 in October.  German factory orders contracted by 6.7% year-on-year in August, while industrial production fell by 4% year-on-year. The trade surplus narrowed by roughly €2 billion to €18 billion in August. In France, the trade deficit widened by €0.5 billion to €5 billion in August. Industrial output fell by 0.9% month-on-month in August.  The EUR/USD increased by 0.4% this week. The incoming data are sending the same old message: that while services and domestic demand are holding up, manufacturing and exports continue to underperform. In an interview this week, European Central Bank Vice President Luis de Guindos stated that the ECB still has further headroom to ease policy.  Report Links: A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 EUR/USD And The Neutral Rate Of Interest - June 14, 2019 Japanese Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been mixed: Both the coincident index and leading index fell to 99.3 and 91.7 in August. Labor cash earnings contracted by 0.2% year-on-year in August. The current account balance also widened to a surplus of ¥2.2 trillion in August. The ECO Watchers Survey shows an improvement of the current situation to 46.7 in September. However, the outlook index fell further to 36.9. Preliminary machine tool orders contracted by 35.5% year-on-year in September. The USD/JPY increased by 0.6% this week. The Bank of Japan is likely to introduce additional stimulus via stronger forward guidance. But the path of least resistance for the yen before then is down. Report Links: A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 Has The Currency Landscape Shifted? - August 16, 2019 Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.K. have been dismal: Halifax house prices contracted by 0.4% month-on-month in September. Retail sales decreased by 1.7% year-on-year in September. Industrial production continued to fall by 1.8% year-on-year in August. Manufacturing production also decreased by 1.7% year-on-year. GDP fell by 0.1% month-on-month in August. The GBP/USD fell by 0.8% this week, weighed by Brexit uncertainties and weaker incoming data. Moreover, the FPC meeting minutes released this Wednesday highlighted the downside risks associated with a disorderly Brexit, including material debt vulnerabilities, structural illiquidity, and reduced space for monetary policy. The pound is extremely cheap, but volatility will persist in the near term. Report Links: A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 United Kingdon: Cyclical Slowdown Or Structural Malaise? - Sept. 20, 2019 Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia have been negative: The NAB’s business conditions index increased to 2 from 1 in September. However, the NAB confidence index fell to zero. The Westpac consumer confidence reading also plunged by 5.5% to 92.8 in October, its lowest since mid-2016.  Home loans grew by 1.8% month-on-month in August, following a monthly increase of 5% in July. The AUD/USD has been flat this week. Our bias remains pro-cyclical and we are constructive on the Aussie dollar from a contrarian perspective, especially against the kiwi. As an export-oriented economy, the Australian dollar is likely to respond well to positive U.S.-China trade talks. Report Links: A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 There is scant data from New Zealand this week: The Inflation gauge was unchanged at 0.3% month-on-month in September. The NZD/USD has been flat this week. As a small, open economy, New Zealand is highly tied to global growth, and heavily weighed down by the U.S.-China trade war. We continue to be long AUD/NZD however as a play on relative valuation. Report Links: USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been relatively strong: Exports and imports both increased in August. However, the trade deficit narrowed to C$0.96 billion in August from C$1.38 billion in July. The Ivey PMI fell to 48.7 in September, down from 60.6 in August. Building permits grew by 6.1% month-on-month in August. New housing prices contracted by 0.3% year-on-year in August. The USD/CAD fell by 0.1% this week, as Canada is gearing up for a federal election on October 21st. The latest opinion polls show the Liberal Party still ahead with 34.2% of votes, followed by the Conservative Party, closely behind. Our colleagues in Commodity & Energy Strategy point out that the most positive outcome for the Canadian energy sector is a Conservative majority. Our baseline scenario remains a second Trudeau term, producing a status quo result that does not materially change our energy sector outlook. Report Links: Preserving Capital During Riot Points - September 6, 2019 Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland have been positive: The unemployment rate came in at 2.3% in September, the lowest over the past 18 years. USD/CHF has been more or less flat this week. As we argued in last week’s report, the Swiss domestic economy is holding up well. However, due to the highly export-driven nature of the Swiss economy, the Swiss National Bank is likely to weaponize its currency to keep tradeable goods prices in a favorable range. We will go long EUR/CHF at 1.06. Stay tuned.   Report Links: Notes On The SNB - October 4, 2019 What To Do About The Swiss Franc? - May 17, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway have been mostly negative: Manufacturing output contracted by 1.1% month-on-month in August. Headline inflation slowed to 1.5% year-on-year in September. Core inflation, however, increased to 2.2% year-on-year. The producer price index increased by 3.6% month-on-month in September. The Norwegian krone continues to trade offside against the U.S. dollar, due to broad dollar resilience and weak oil prices. The USD/NOK increased by 0.2% this week. The EIA posted an increase of 2.9 million barrels in crude oil stocks this week, following an increase of 3.1 million barrels last week, much higher than expected. The increase in oil supply, together with a quick recovery of Saudi oil facilities are viewed as near-term bearish for oil prices. But if demand is able to recover, this will be positive. Remain long petrocurrencies for now. Report Links: A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data in Sweden continue to disappoint: Industrial production grew by 2.5% year-on-year in August, following yearly growth of 3.1% the previous month. Total manufacturing new orders contracted by 1.1% year-on-year on a seasonally-adjusted basis in August. Headline inflation increased to 1.5% year-on-year in September. The Swedish krona has been the worst-performing G-10 currency this week, losing 1.1% against the U.S. dollar. Year-to-date, the USD/SEK has appreciated by a total of 12.3%. Swedish manufacturing new orders, a key indicator we watch in gauging the direction of the global economy, continued to deteriorate this week. Among sub-sectors, the largest decrease was recorded in the mines and quarries sector. We are watching Swedish data closely.  Report Links: Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades

Just as it appeared the slowdown in global industrial activity had run its course, commodity markets face another test of demand resiliency brought on by exogenous political shocks (Chart Of The Week). As luck would have it, these shocks – arriving in the form of an unexpected escalation of Sino-U.S. trade tensions – came on the heels of reports of further weakness in global manufacturing activity, a less-dovish-than-expected Fed, and a breach of the 7.0 level of the RMB/USD cross. The fallout – a global risk-off event – raises the spectre of a deeper trade war damaging EM GDP growth, which would weaken commodity demand. We continue to expect global fiscal and monetary stimulus to revive commodity demand, albeit further out the curve – i.e., later this year, as opposed to earlier in 2H19. Given the trade-war escalation, we are recommending a tactical long position in spot silver to hedge portfolio risk. The metal has been tracking gold’s ups and downs post-GFC – more so than industrial demand for silver – indicating it may have some catching up to do. This will make us strategically long gold, and tactically long silver at tonight’s close. Chart Of The WeekRenewed Trade Tensions Threaten Industrial Commodities' Recovery   Highlights Energy: Overweight. U.S. President Trump informed Congress earlier this week he was imposing a total economic embargo on Venezuela, which freezes assets of the Maduro government and all business dealings with its representatives except for humanitarian aid. Venezuela’s oil production averaged ~ 750k b/d in 2Q19, and was supported by the assistance of Russian technicians, U.S.-based Chevron Corp., and four service companies that were granted 90-day waivers by the U.S. to continue to do business in the country.1 Our long Sept19 Brent vs. short Sept20 Brent position expired with a gain of 101.7%. We remain long 4Q19 Brent vs. short 4Q20 Brent. Base Metals: Neutral. Industrial metals, iron ore and steel came under renewed selling pressure this week, in the wake of heightened trade tensions between the U.S. and China. Precious Metals: Neutral. Safe-haven demand rallied gold 3% over the week ended Tuesday, following the escalation in Sino-U.S. trade tensions. We continue to favor gold as a strategic portfolio hedge, particularly if central banks are compelled to accelerate monetary accommodation as global trade tensions rise, and are adding a tactical long silver position to our recommendations. Ags/Softs: Underweight. China’s Commerce Ministry reported U.S. ag products no longer are being purchased by Chinese companies earlier this week.2 U.S. President Trump’s decision to impose tariffs on Chinese imports to the U.S. were occasioned by his claim China was not living up to an agreement to increase agricultural purchases. This broke the truce in the Sino-U.S. trade war that accompanied the resumption in negotiations last month. Feature A recovery in industrial-commodity demand – particularly for oil and base metals – could be stretched out longer than we expected just a week ago. It’s still too early to tell whether the escalation in Sino-U.S. trade tensions will throw a spanner into the revival of commodity demand we’ve been expecting, but it does give us pause. Prior to the political shocks and other disappointments hitting markets this past week, our commodity demand gauges were indicating the slowdown in demand had – or was close to – run its course, and that EM demand, in particular, was set to revive. EM GDP growth drives commodity demand growth globally, which is why it is so important in our analysis. Our Chart of the Week illustrates this point, showing three relationships we've developed that allow us to track the evolution of EM GDP growth in something close to real time: BCA’s Global Industrial Activity (GIA) index, which is highly sensitive to economic activity in EM generally and China in particular;3  BCA’s Global Commodity Factor (GCF), which condenses the information contained in 28 commodity price series to a common factor using principal components analysis; and BCA’s EM Import Volume model, which generates an expectation of EM import volumes using mainly FX values for countries highly exposed to global trade. To be precise, we find the output of these three models shown in the Chart of the Week and EM GDP growth are deeply entwined.4 As can be seen in the chart, these models appeared to have bottomed and were preparing to hook up. This is supported by current global activity indicators (CAIs), particularly for China and EM, which still is showing positive y/y growth, even if its rate is slowing. (Chart 2), and the recent upturn in EM Financial Conditions we track here at BCA Research (Chart 3).  Chart 2Global CAIs Support EM Growth Expectation Chart 3EM Financial Conditions Move To Easier Setting However, the escalation of Sino-U.S. trade tensions, coming off a somewhat disappointing Fed rate cut of 25bps and weak manufacturing data, was enough to erase 6% and 3% from the GSCI and Bloomberg commodity indices over the week ended Tuesday (Chart 4), and to lift volatility in industrial commodities’ prices sharply (Chart 5).5    Chart 4Policy Shock, Disappointing Rate Cut Hammer Commodity Indices Chart 5Crude Oil, Copper Vol Jump On Policy Shock   A Fraught Situation The Sino-U.S. trade standoff is fraught with risk for both sides. A full-blown trade war could devolve into domestic recessions (there is a non-trivial risk to the global economy, as well). In addition, a kinetic military confrontation between China and its allies and the U.S. and its allies cannot be ruled out, as tensions rise. The case for resolving the trade dispute is strong. Our colleague Peter Berezin notes that while an escalation in the Sino-U.S. trade war “would tip the scales towards recession, the risk of such an outcome remains low.”6 An all-out trade war could push the U.S. economy into a recession next year, just as President Trump faced re-election, which strongly suggests a goodwill gesture or two from the U.S. – e.g., the Commerce Department renewing the licenses allowing U.S. firms to deal with Huawei – could go a long way to getting trade talks back on track.  Our commodity demand gauges were indicating the slowdown in demand had – or was close to – run its course, and that EM demand, in particular, was set to revive. That said, we cannot gainsay the conclusions of our colleague Matt Gertken, who runs our Geopolitical Strategy: “The U.S.-China trade negotiations are falling apart at the moment. … (B)ut with the latest round of tariffs we think it is more likely that we will get a major escalation of strategic tensions and even saber-rattling,” as U.S. and Chinese positions harden, particularly around North Korea, Hong Kong and Taiwan.7 Clearly, the outcome of this latest round of the Sino-U.S. dispute is uncertain, and the risks are elevated. Moving To A Safe Haven: Silver While we continue to expect global fiscal and monetary stimulus will revive commodity demand, the shocks and disappointments visited upon markets could incline firms, households and investors globally to scale back on risky investments and purchases until the dust settles.8  Over the near term – i.e., 3 months or so – seeking refuge in a safe haven is sensible. In particular, we believe silver offers near-term cover, and expect it will continue to follow the evolution of gold prices.9  We expect central banks generally – the Fed in particular – will err on the side of maintaining monetary accommodation while uncertainty over trade and global growth prospects remains elevated. Fed Chairman Jay Powell's description of the central bank's July rate cut of 25 bps as a mid-cycle adjustment – and not the beginning of a lengthy cutting cycle – was perceived as a hawkish surprise, but markets appear to be pricing in additional cuts this year, which will support precious metals until further guidance from the Fed arrives. An escalation of the trade war likely would increase the probability the Fed cuts rates further at its next meeting, which would push down recession fears. The outcome of this latest round of the Sino-U.S. dispute is uncertain, and the risks are elevated.   On the supply side, silver typically is mined as a secondary metal, and usually is found with gold, copper and lead deposits, according to the Silver Institute.10 On the demand side, investment and electronics account for much of the usage. Prior to the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), silver traded like a base metal, owing to the high growth rates in EM economies undergoing rapid industrialization, which led to higher consumption. This resulted in a large supply-deficit in most industrial commodities, including silver (Chart 6). Following the GFC, the evolution of silver’s price more closely tracked gold prices, following the massive injections of money and credit by central banks globally. (Chart 7).11  Chart 6Silver Is Less Industrial, More Precious Now Chart 7Post-GFC, Silver and Gold Are More Closely Aligned We expect this to continue, given our view central banks are likely to either increase or accelerate monetary accommodation to offset Sino-U.S. trade tensions, should they worsen. The U.S. dollar outlook remains important for precious metals. The dollar is a counter-cyclical currency. Thus, the escalation in trade tensions risks delaying the rebound we expect in emerging markets. This could support the USD for longer than we expected. Bottom Line: We expect commodity demand to revive on the back of global fiscal and monetary stimulus. However, exogenous political shocks along the way toward that revival likely will force households, firms and investors to re-think spending and investment decisions. This could potentially lead to reduced aggregate demand, in the event uncertainty around manufacturing, which still accounts for significant employment and output in EM economies, and global trade becomes too high. Until this is sorted, taking refuge in a safe haven is prudent. To hedge against this, we are recommending spot silver as a tactical portfolio hedge. We already are long gold as a strategic portfolio hedge, and this position is up 20% this year.   Robert P. Ryan, Chief Commodity & Energy Strategist rryan@bcaresearch.com Hugo Bélanger, Senior Analyst Commodity & Energy Strategy HugoB@bcaresearch.com   1      Please see U.S. sanctions waiver for Chevron signals Venezuela solution near: opposition ambassador, published by S&P Global Platts July 30, 2019. 2      Please see U.S. farmers suffer 'body blow' as China slams door on farm purchases published by reuters.com August 5, 2019. 3      Please see Expanded Sino – U.S. Trade War Could Be Bullish For Base Metals, published by BCA Research’s Commodity & Energy Strategy May 9, 2019, for a discussion of the GIA index. The index is a weighted average of selected trade, currency, manufacturing PMIs, and Chinese industrial sector variables. The article is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 4      This is to say there is strong two-way Granger causality between EM GDP and the output of the models shown above in the Chart of the Week. Knowing the output of one of the models allows one to forecast EM GDP growth, and vice versa. We will be doing further research into using these models to estimate the change in EM GDP at a higher frequency than the stand-alone EM GDP data are reported – e.g., the World Bank’s most recent actual EM GDP data in constant 2010 USD is reported up to 1Q18, while the models shown in the chart can be updated daily (GCF and the EM Import Volume models); and monthly, as the components of the GIA index become available. 5      For a discussion of global fixed-income markets’ response to the escalation of the Sino-U.S. trade war and the outlook for more aggressive monetary policy accommodation globally, please see Trade War Worries: Once More, With Feeling, published by BCA Research’s Global Fixed Income Strategy August 6, 2019. It is available at gfis.bcaresearch.com. 6      Please see A One-Two Punch, published by BCA Research’s Global Investment Strategy August 2, 2019. It is available at gis.bcaresearch.com. 7      Please see Tariffs ... And The Last Prime Minister Of The United Kingdom?, published by BCA Research’s Geopolitical Strategy, August 2, 2019. It is available at gps.bcaresearch.com.  Almost on cue, China warned the U.S. it would view its deployment of intermediate-range missiles in Asia following Russia’s revival of its intermediate-range missile development as “offensive in nature.” Please see China warns US against deploying missiles on its ‘doorstep’, published by the Financial Times August 6, 2019.  8      Our global macro expectation can be found in Oil Markets Await Lift From Global Stimulus, published by BCA Research’s Commodity & Energy Strategy August 1, 2019. It is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 9      Please see "The Gold Trifecta," published June 27, 2019, by BCA Research's Commodity & Energy Strategy, for our most recent analysis of the gold market and of our long-held bullish gold view. It is available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 10     The Institute’s supply-demand annual supply-demand balances showed a 29.2mm-ounce deficit in 2018. 11     When we model silver returns as a function of gold and base metals’ returns, silver’s elasticity to gold prices more than doubles – from 0.68 over the 1999 - 2010 period, to 1.67 post-GFC (2010 to now). The elasticity to changes in base-metals prices was roughly cut in half over this period, to 0.28 post-GFC.   Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades TRADE RECOMMENDATION PERFORMANCE IN 2019 Q2 Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Trades Closed in 2019 Summary of Closed Trades

Dear Clients, In addition to this Weekly Report, you will also be getting a Special Report authored by some of our top strategists on global growth. The manufacturing recession that began in early 2018 has lasted longer than most expected. The risk is that this is an additional end-of-cycle indicator, with important ramifications for the U.S. dollar. The dollar tends to stage meaningful rallies in recessions. In this week’s publication, we highlight some of the key indicators we are watching for justification on maintaining a pro-cyclical stance, but the internal debate from the Special Report highlights how delicate the balance of forces for this stance are. A fortnight ago we suggested a few portfolio hedges, and recommend maintaining tight stops on all positions until September. Next week, we will be sending you a Special Report on gold, from our colleagues in the Commodity & Energy Strategy team. In the interim, I will be learning from our clients in Latin America about some of the forces currently shaping global FX markets. I will report back with my findings in a few weeks. Kind Regards, Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist Highlights There is very scant evidence that global growth is bottoming. That said, it is usually darkest before dawn. A few key indicators are beginning to flash amber, which we will continue to closely monitor. The deceleration phase this cycle has been as prolonged as others, warning that the rebound could also be V-shaped. The AUD/JPY cross will be a very useful barometer. Stay long a basket of petrocurrencies versus the euro and short USD/JPY. Feature One of the most cyclical developed-market indices is the Japanese Nikkei (Table I-1).1 Almost 60% of all sectors are concentrated in just three: consumer discretionary, information technology and industrials. Boasting a wide spectrum of global robotic, automotive and construction machinery giants, Japanese companies sit at the epicenter of the global manufacturing supply chain. As such, it is very telling when Japanese share prices – which track global bond yields very closely – appear to be making a tentative bottom (Chart I-1). On the currency front, a lower greenback has also tended to be a very useful confirmation signal that we are entering a reflationary window. A slowing global economy on the back of deteriorating trade is positive for the greenback. As a reserve and counter-cyclical currency, the dollar has tended to rise during times of capital flight. On the other hand, a dovish Federal Reserve knocks down U.S. interest rate expectations relative to the rest of the world. This has historically been bearish for the dollar, and positive for global growth (Chart I-2). More importantly, even if the Fed does not proceed to cut rates as much as the market expects, it will be because global growth has bottomed, which will also favor non-U.S. rates. Chart I-1Japanese Share Prices Usually Bottom Before Bond Yields Chart I-2A Dovish Fed Will Be Dollar Bearish The commodity and export channel also helps explain why rising global growth is negative for the dollar. In theory, rising commodity prices (or rising terms of trade) allow for increased government spending in export-driven economies, making room for the resident central bank to tighten monetary policy. This is usually bullish for the currency. Rising terms of trade also further increases the fair value of the exchange rate. Balance-of-payments dynamics also tend to improve when exports are booming. Altogether, these forces combine to be powerful undercurrents for pro-cyclical currencies. Both political and domestic pressure for central banks to ease policy is the highest it has ever been. Chart I-3Both Economic And Political Pressure For Central Banks To Alter Policy Both political and domestic pressure for central banks to ease policy is the highest it has ever been.2 This suggests that either they have already done so or the conditions warranting stimulus have hit climactic pressure. Going forward, such a synchronized move by global central banks is usually accompanied by a synchronized recovery, for the simple reason that central banks are usually behind the curve (Chart I-3). Finally, the starting point for long dollar positions is one of an overcrowded trade, along with U.S. Treasury bonds. The latest downdraft in global manufacturing has nudged U.S. net speculative long positions to a point where they typically experience exhaustion (Chart I-4). This suggests there may be a scarcity in fresh dollar bulls. 2018 was particularly favorable for the dollar, as a liquidity crunch (the Fed’s balance sheet runoff) underpinned a sizeable rally. The big surge in cryptocurrencies this year (and gold) could suggest that the liquidity environment is once again becoming favorable.  Chart I-4Dollar Positioning Is Stretched Chart I-5Carry Trades Are Usually Consistent With Higher Yields   An improving liquidity environment will be especially favorable for carry trades. High-beta currencies such as the RUB/USD, ZAR/USD and BRL/USD have stopped falling and are off their lows of the year. These currencies are usually good at sniffing out a change in the investment landscape. The message so far is that the drop in U.S. bond yields may have been sufficient to make these currencies attractive again (Chart I-5). Bottom Line: There is very scant evidence that global growth is bottoming. That said, it is usually darkest before dawn. A few key indicators are beginning to flash amber, which we will continue to monitor closely. A Few Growth Barometers A key difference from last year is that U.S. growth leadership is set to give way to the rest of the world. The U.S. ISM manufacturing Purchasing Manager’s Index (PMI) peaked last August and has been steadily rolling over relative to its trading partners. Historically, the relative growth differential between the U.S. and elsewhere has had a pretty good track record of dictating trends in the dollar. The message is that the manufacturing PMI should pick up from 47.6 currently to the 50 boom/bust level in the coming months. Meanwhile, there is some evidence that there are tentative signs of a bottom in global growth: Chart I-6Euro Area Might Be Close To A Bottom Europe: The Swedish new orders to inventory ratio has a long and pretty accurate track record of calling bottoms in European growth, and the message is that the manufacturing PMI should pick up from 47.6 currently to the 50 boom/bust level in the coming months. Importantly, the recoveries have tended to be V-shaped pretty much throughout the past two decades. Any further decline in the PMI will pin it at levels consistent with the last European debt crisis (Chart I-6). Japan: Japan is closely impacted by the industrial cycle, especially demand from China. And while overall machinery orders remain weak, machine tool orders from China have bottomed. China: The Chinese credit impulse has bottomed. This suggests the contraction in imports, along with Korean and Taiwanese exports, is near its nadir (Chart I-7). The domestic bond market in China is becoming pretty good at signaling reflationary conditions for domestic demand (Chart I-8). Singapore exports this week were deeply negative, but this could be the bottom if all credit-injection so far in China starts flowing. Shipping indices are already recovering very strongly, and global machinery stocks are re-rating. Chart I-7A Modest Recovery For Exports Chart I-8Chinese Imports Should Bounce A pickup in Chinese growth should begin to benefit commodity currencies, especially the Australian dollar. A lot of the bad news already appears to be priced into the Aussie, which is down 14% from its 2018 peak and 37% from its 2011 peak. This suggests outright short AUD bets are susceptible to either upside surprises in global growth or simply forces of mean reversion. Importantly, the AUD/JPY cross is sitting at an important technical level. Ever since the financial crisis, the 72-74 cent zone has proven to be formidable resistance, with the cross failing to break below both during the euro area debt crisis in 2011-2012 and the China slowdown of 2015-2016. Speculators are now massively short the cross, suggesting that any upward move could be powerful and significant (Chart I-9). A rally in the Swedish krona will be another confirmation that global growth may have bottomed.  A rally in the Swedish krona will be another confirmation that global growth may have bottomed. On a relative basis, the Swedish economy appears to have troughed relative to that of the U.S., making the USD/SEK an attractive way to play USD downside. From a technical perspective, USD/SEK failed to break decisively above 9.60, and is now trading below a major resistance at 9.40 (Chart I-10). Aggressive investors can slowly begin accumulating short positions, while being cognizant of the negative carry. Chart I-9AUD/JPY Near A Critical Zone Chart I-10The Swedish Krona Is Attractive Bottom Line: We are already long the SEK versus NZD, and the thesis remains intact from our June 7th recommendation. The AUD/JPY cross is very close to a bottom.  Hold EUR/CAD For A Trade Chart I-11EUR/CAD Technicals: Limited Downside The EUR/CAD has reached an important technical level, and what will follow is either a major breakdown or a powerful bounce (Chart I-11). With Canadian data firing on all cylinders and the euro area in the depths of a manufacturing recession, the cross has rightly responded to growth divergences. On the downside, the EUR/CAD is at the bottom of the upward trending channel that has existed since 2012, in the vicinity of 1.45-1.46. A bounce here will not meet initial upside resistance until the triple top, a nudge above 1.6. The biggest catalyst for this cross going forward will likely be interest rate differentials, since any improvement in euro area data will continue to reduce the scope by which the European Central Bank stays dovish relative to the Bank of Canada. European rates are further below equilibrium, and the ECB’s dovish shift will help lift the growth potential of the euro area. Meanwhile, the Canadian neutral rate will be heavily weighed down by the large stock of debt in the Canadian private sector, exacerbated by overvaluation in the housing market. Valuations and balance-of-payment dynamics also favor the euro versus the CAD on a long-term basis. Bottom Line: Hold the EUR/CAD for a trade with a stop at 1.45. Chart I-12Gold/Silver Ratio Near Speculative Extreme Trade Idea: Buy Silver, Sell Gold The gold/silver ratio is reaching a speculative extreme. Usually, reflationary cycles benefit silver more than gold, with 100 usually the upper bound of the gold/silver ratio. We are very close to such a tipping point. Stay tuned (Chart I-12). Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com               Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.S. have continued to soften: Headline PPI fell to 1.7% year-on-year in June. Core PPI was unchanged at 2.3% year-on-year in June. NY Empire State manufacturing index increased to 4.3 in July. Retail sales increased by 0.4% month-on-month in June. Import and export prices contracted by 0.9% and 2% year-on-year respectively in June. Building permits contracted by 6.1% month-on-month in June. Housing starts softened by 0.9% month-on-month. Philadelphia Fed manufacturing index rose to 21.8 in July from 0.3 in June. Continuing jobless claims fell to 1.686 million this week, while initial jobless claims increased to 216 thousand. DXY increased by 0.4% this week. On Tuesday, Fed Chair Powell gave a short speech in Paris, regarding the current developments in the U.S. economy, and some post-crisis structural shifts. While U.S. economy has been on the 11th consecutive year of expansion, Powell highlighted concerns towards softer growth this year, in the manufacturing sector in particular, weighed down by weaker consumer spending, sluggish business investment, and trade war uncertainties. Report Links: On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 EUR/USD And The Neutral Rate Of Interest - June 14, 2019 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area have been weak: Industrial production contracted by 0.5% year-on-year in May. Trade balance widened to €20.2 billion in May. Headline and core inflation increased by 1.3% and 1.1% year-on-year respectively in June. EUR/USD fell by 0.36% this week. ZEW data continue to soften in July: The sentiment index in the euro area fell to -20.3, and the sentiment in Germany decreased to -24.5. Moreover, the European Commission’s summer forecast released last week cut the 2020 euro area GDP projection from 1.5% (spring forecast) to 1.4%, and lowered inflation to 1.3% for both this year and next year. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 EUR/USD And The Neutral Rate Of Interest - June 14, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been negative: Industrial production contracted by 2.1% year-on-year in May. Capacity utilization increased by 1.7% in May. Exports contracted by 6.7% year-on-year in June. Imports also fell by 5.2% year-on-year. Total trade balance increased to ¥589.5 billion. USD/JPY fell by 0.2% this week. The weak Q2 data worldwide, driven by a significant slowdown in the manufacturing sector have raised concerns for a possible near-term recession. This has been exacerbated by a trade war, U.S.-Iranian tensions and Brexit uncertainties. We continue to favor the yen as a safe-haven currency. Hold to the short USD/JPY and short XAU/JPY positions. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 Short USD/JPY: Heads I Win, Tails I Don’t Lose Too Much - May 31, 2019 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.K. have been mixed: Rightmove house price index contracted by 0.2% year-on-year in July. On the labor market front, ILO unemployment rate was unchanged at 3.8% in May. Average earnings including bonus increased by 3.4% in May. Headline inflation was unchanged at 2% year-on-year in June. Core inflation increased to 1.8% year-on-year. Retail sales increased by 3.8% year-on-year in June. GBP/USD fell by 0.5% this week, now trading around 1.2486. The Brexit uncertainties still loom over the U.K. Boris Johnson and Jeremy Hunt are fighting to take over from Theresa May as the leader of the Conservative Party and the UK’s next Prime Minister. In addition, the Q2 credit conditions survey released this Thursday indicates that default rates on loans to corporates increased for small and large businesses in Q2. Meanwhile, these are expected to increase for businesses of all sizes in Q3. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia have been mixed: Westpac leading index fell by 0.08% month-on-month in June. On the labor market front, unemployment rate was unchanged at 5.2% in June. Participation rate was steady at 66%. 500 new jobs were created in June, including 21.1 thousand new full-time positions, and a loss of 20.6 thousand part-time positions. AUD/USD increased by 0.3% this week. The RBA minutes released this week reiterated that the central bank is ready to adjust interest rates if required, in order to support sustainable growth and achieve the inflation target overtime. The easing financial conditions and rising terms of trade all underpin the Aussie dollar in the long term. Report Links: A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns- April 19, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand have been mostly positive: House sales keep contracting by 3.8% year-on-year in June. Business manufacturing PMI increased to 51.3 in June. Headline inflation increased to 1.7% year-on-year in Q2. NZD/USD rose by 0.6% this week. Solid incoming data have lifted the New Zealand dollar for the past few weeks. However, the kiwi might lag the Aussie given the RBNZ is behind the RBA. The market is currently pricing in an 84% probability of a rate cut at the beginning of next month, but more cuts could be needed down the road. Hold to our long AUD/NZD and SEK/NZD positions. Report Links: Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been mostly positive: Headline and core inflation both fell to 2% year-on-year in June.  ADP employment shows an increase of 30.4 thousand new jobs in June. USD/CAD increased by 0.3% this week. Just last week, the BoC kept its interest rate on hold. With a more dovish Fed, this might narrow the interest rate differentials between the Fed and the BoC. We favor the loonie in the near-term based on the interest rate differentials, crude oil prices, and relatively more positive data incoming from Canada. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland have been mixed: Producer and import prices contracted by 1.4% year-on-year in June. Exports increased to CHF 20,328 million, while imports fell to CHF 17,131 million in June. This lifted the trade balance up to 3,251 million. USD/CHF increased by 0.35% this week. We continue to favor the Swiss franc in the long term. The rising market volatility has increased the appetite for the Swiss franc. Moreover, the Swiss franc is still cheap compared to its fair value. Report Links: What To Do About The Swiss Franc? - May 17, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway have been negative: Trade balance narrowed to NOK 5.2 billion in June. USD/NOK increased by 0.8% this week. The recent energy price volatility, mostly due to the uncertainties of oil demand has knocked down the Norwegian krone. In the long term, we continue to believe that the OPEC 2.0’s production strategy of reducing global oil inventories, and U.S. – Iran tension will drive oil prices higher, thus bullish for petrocurrencies including the Norwegian krone. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data in Sweden have been positive. Industrial orders increased by 3.2% year-on-year in May. Budget balance came in at SEK -24.8 billion in June. USD/SEK fell by 0.28% this week. Recent data shows that the Swedish government debt is sliding below 35% of GDP. This is triggering political pressure on the government to expand fiscal support. More fiscal expenditure will allow for a more hawkish Risksbank, supporting the Swedish Krona.  Report Links: Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Footnotes 1      The Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) classification does not really apply for euro zone companies, so we used the Industry Classification Benchmark (ICB) for the euro area, the U.S., and Japan. The difference between GICS and ICB is that the new GICS standard (which took effect last year) splits Telecom into an additional Communication Services sector. ICB may also apply this later this year. 2      Carola Binder, “Political Pressure on Central Banks,” SSRN, December 16, 2018. Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades

Highlights As the Fed proceeds with its policy tightening this year, higher real rates and a stronger USD will weigh on silver and platinum prices, and, to a lesser extent, palladium prices. Offsetting these downward pressures, silver, and to a lesser extent platinum, could take their lead from the gold market, and outperform on the back of increased equity volatility and understated geopolitical risks this year.1 Palladium, as always, will march to its own drummer, as this market's defining feature remains chronic physical deficits and depleted inventories, which will prevent prices from reacting too severely to tighter Fed policy this year. Energy: Overweight. Supply-demand fundamentals still are supportive of crude oil prices overall, and continued backwardation in forward curves. Our long Jul/18 WTI vs. short Dec/18 WTI calendar spread, which gains as backwardation becomes more pronounced, is up 47.4% since inception on November 2, 2017. Base Metals: Neutral. Base metals remain well supported by still-strong global growth, estimates of which were revised higher by the IMF in its most recent World Economic Outlook. Precious Metals: Neutral. Fed tightening this year will weigh on silver and platinum, less so palladium (see below). Our long gold portfolio hedge is up 7.9%. Ags/Softs: Underweight. The USDA revised down its forecast of U.S. corn ending stocks in the latest WASDE on the back of an upwards revision to U.S. corn exports. Feature The term "precious metals" is something of a misnomer: Gold, silver, and platinum-group metals (PGMs) - chiefly platinum and palladium - do not constitute a single asset class, and should not be treated as such (Chart of the Week). Nevertheless, as with most commodity markets we cover, the evolution of these markets is highly sensitive to U.S. financial variables, particularly as regards monetary policy. Palladium is something of an outlier: It behaves more like an industrial metal, while silver, and to a lesser extent platinum, are more sensitive to the fundamental drivers of gold prices - i.e., the evolution of the USD's broad trade-weighted index (USD TWIB), and real U.S. interest rates. Palladium's demand is dominated by its use in catalytic converters in gasoline-powered cars, whereas industrial applications form a more limited source of demand for platinum and silver (Chart 2). Chart of the WeekA Schism In Precious Metals Chart 2Industrial Uses Dominate Palladium Gold, silver, and, to a more limited extent platinum are cointegrated in the long run, meaning their prices follow their own random walks, even though they share a long-term trend. Palladium, on the other hand, is more responsive to the physical realities of the automobile market - chiefly, demand for gasoline-powered cars. In our econometric analysis of the behavior of PGMs and silver, we use the CRB Metals Index as a proxy for industrial activity. We find that while all three are sensitive to changes in the CRB Metals Index, palladium prices are significantly more responsive (i.e., elastic) to industrial activity than platinum and silver (Table 1). Table 1Palladium Behaves Like An Industrial Metal Furthermore, while gold prices impact both silver, and, to a lesser extent platinum, they are not significant when it comes to the palladium market. Bullish Fundamentals Tightened Palladium Market Palladium registered a 60% gain in 2017. Its forward curve has been backwardated since June (Chart 3). This backwardation - i.e., spot prices trade higher than deferred prices - is a symptom of a tight market. In fact, according to Thomson Reuters GFMS data, the palladium market has been in a chronic deficit since 2007, with the 2017 deficit the largest since 2000. The culprit in this case has been strong demand and stagnant supply. While supply has been growing ~ 1% year-over-year (yoy) over the past 5 years, demand growth has averaged 1.7% yoy over the same period. Palladium demand over this period has been driven by its growing use in automobile catalytic converters, most notably in China, where sales of gasoline-powered cars exceed those of diesel-powered cars, which typically use platinum in their catalytic converters (Chart 4). Chart 3Tight Fundamentals In##BR##The Palladium Market Chart 4Growing Demand For##BR##Autocatalysts Dominated In The Past... Growth in global demand for palladium-based autocatalysts averaged 4.8% yoy in the past 5 years. The use of palladium for autocatalysts now makes up more than 75% of global palladium demand, up from 56% 10 years ago. Chinese demand for palladium used in autocatalysts grew from 10% of global demand in 2007 to more than a quarter of global demand last year. Given autocatalysts' oversized contribution to demand growth, the palladium market is highly dependent on car sales. Our modelling highlights global car production as a significant explanatory variable when it comes to palladium prices. Most significant are the U.S. and Chinese markets, which are the largest markets for gasoline-powered cars. While vehicle sales in China were strong in 2016, they have slowed considerably and recorded yoy declines in the most recent November and December data (Chart 5). Slowing demand growth for cars in China likely comes on the back of the phasing out of tax cuts on small vehicles. This will limit the upside for palladium prices from China's industrial demand. Growth in car sales in the U.S. has been even more muted, contracting in 2017 for the first time since 2009. However, a more concerted adoption of gasoline-powered cars in Europe - largely in response to efforts by cities to reduce emissions of particulate matter from diesel engines, and the highly publicized emissions-testing scandals involving European carmakers - will, at least partially, mitigate the negative impact of slowing demand from the top two gasoline-powered markets. On the supply side, global mine supply has been relatively stagnant over the past 5 years, expanding an average 1.2% yoy during this period. Russia, South Africa and Canada account for almost 90% of total palladium mine supply. And while Russian and South African supplies have been relatively flat over the years, Canadian palladium has grown to account for ~11% of global supply in 2017, up from 4% in 2010. Global palladium supply has been supported by metal recovered from autocatalyst scrap, which has been averaging 4.8% yoy growth in supply over the past 5 years. In fact, the share of palladium recovered from autocatalyst scrap has almost doubled in the past 10 years, and now makes up almost 20% of total supply. Growth in this source of supply has come down significantly (Chart 6). However, we expect palladium's exorbitant price and elevated steel prices to incentivize an increase in the metal's recovery from scrap. Indeed, GFMS expects recycled palladium to pave record highs this year and to surpass 2 million ounces next year. Chart 5...But Beware Of Slowing Gasoline Car Sales Chart 6Palladium Needs Restocking Strong demand, combined with limited supply growth, has weighed on palladium inventories. Furthermore, ETF holdings of palladium have come down sharply while net speculative long positions have skyrocketed. Given that stocks are so low, we do not expect a severe fall in prices. Bottom Line: Palladium behaves like an industrial metal and is especially sensitive to changes in demand for automobiles. While the stars were aligned for palladium last year - a weak USD, low real interest rates, and bullish fundamentals - car sales in the U.S. and China have been slow recently. Even so, a physical deficit will prevent a crash in the palladium market this year. Platinum Trading At A Discount To Palladium In contrast with palladium's remarkable performance last year, platinum was up a mere 3.4% in 2017. In fact palladium, which usually trades at a discount to platinum, has been more expensive since October (Chart 7). This can be attributed to differences in fundamentals. Palladium's market conditions have been significantly tighter than platinum. Greater demand for the physical metal than supply put the market in deficit last year, which supported platinum prices. As with palladium, catalytic converters are a major demand source for platinum; however, they account for ~ 40% of platinum demand - considerably less than the roughly 80% share of palladium demand accounted for by catalytic converter demand. Europe is the largest market for diesel cars, and, while total vehicle sales in Europe have remained healthy, diesel-powered cars have been losing market share since the Volkswagen emissions-rigging scandal came to light in 2015 (Chart 8). This hit platinum use in autocatalysts particularly hard. In addition, weaker demand from its second use - jewelry - is keeping a lid on platinum prices (Chart 9). In fact, Chinese demand for the white metal, which accounts for more than 50% of global platinum jewelry demand, has been falling. Despite weakening demand, global balances remained in deficit on the back of muted supply. Chart 7Platinum Now Cheaper Than Palladium Chart 8EU Diesel Car Market Losing Momentum Chart 9Platinum Jewelry Losing Its Appeal Platinum's market balance could be at risk if carmakers start using more of it in catalytic converters, now that it trades at a discount to palladium. Platinum is a superior material for autocatalysts, but palladium has been traditionally favored on a cost basis. Platinum's lower price incentivizes carmakers to switch to this metal. According to Johnson Matthey, it will be two years before the impact of such substitution begins to affect the palladium market. Bottom Line: Subdued demand for platinum jewelry combined with the loss of market share for diesel-powered cars in Europe will keep a lid on the platinum market this year. However, platinum follows gold, and this could support prices if equity investors hedge market volatility and future corrections by purchasing the metal. Silver Follows Gold Silver, and, to a lesser extent, platinum are not as exposed to the industrial business cycle as palladium. These metals' prices instead move in line with gold (Chart 10). Our modeling reveals that a 1% increase in gold prices is associated with a 0.76 pp increase in silver prices. Thus gold's spillovers to the silver market are significant. Even so, there are periods when this relationship disconnects. This is because, although industrial uses do not account for as large a share of silver demand as they do for palladium, such fundamentals do account for a significant source of demand. Thus, in addition to the financial factors which drive gold, silver's industrial applications give it some exposure to economic activity. In fact, a 1% increase in the CRB Metals Index is associated with a 0.17pp increase in silver prices. This explains why, in some instances, silver's cointegration with gold weakens. As a practical matter, gold is a superior hedge against equity downfalls than silver (Chart 11). While gold month-on-month (mom) returns outperform S&P 500 mom returns almost 80% of the time in periods of decreasing equity returns, the ratio for silver comes in at a lower 67%. On the other hand, gold mom returns outperform S&P 500 returns less than 30% of the time during periods when equities are increasing, while silver outperforms the stock market almost 40% of the time. Chart 10Silver And Gold##BR##Move In Tandem Chart 11Gold Outperforms Amid Equity Downfalls,##BR##Not During Rising Stocks In addition, although both gold's and silver's correlations with the S&P 500 become large and negative when the S&P 500 decreases in yoy terms, this negative correlation in the case of gold is significantly larger than for silver (Chart 12). In fact, along with silver's relatively weaker negative correlation with the S&P 500 during periods of negative equity returns, silver also exhibits a relatively stronger positive correlation with equities during periods of positive returns. While silver is an effective hedge against geopolitical and economic crises, gold's hedging ability remains superior (Chart 13). Silver and gold post similar returns during geopolitical crises; however, gold returns are significantly higher during economic crisis. Chart 12Negative Correlations More##BR##Pronounced During Equity Downfalls Chart 13Gold Is A##BR##Superior Protection This supports the finding that silver's hedging ability is hampered by its use in industrial applications, which make it more responsive to the business cycle than gold. Bottom Line: Gold and silver prices are cointegrated. However, given silver's industrial applications, it is more sensitive to business activity. This explains the periods of divergence in the two precious metals, and limits silver's ability to hedge against economic crises and falling equities. Roukaya Ibrahim, Associate Editor Commodity & Energy Strategy RoukayaI@bcaresearch.com Hugo Bélanger, Research Analyst HugoB@bcaresearch.com 1 For a discussion of the gold market fundamentals, please see Commodity & Energy Strategy Weekly Report titled "Gold Still Shines Despite Threat Of Higher Rates," dated February 1, 2018. Available at ces.bcaresearch.com. Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Trades Closed in 2018 Summary of Trades Closed in 2017

A Fed rate hike by December could erode the slowly evolving fundamentals favoring base metals.

Clearing the refined-product overhang in the global storage markets is not as straightforward as it used to be: The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA), China, and India all are making concerted efforts to boost refining capacity, which is leaving them with surplus product that ends up being sold in export markets.

Our strategic and tactical trades were up an average 24.6% in 2016Q2, led by strategic energy recommendations. Going forward, we continue to favor energy exposure over base and precious metals, ags and softs.

Increasing uncertainty over the Brexit vote will keep the Fed from raising its overnight policy rate at this week's FOMC meeting, but it may not keep the USD from rallying in the event of a decisive win for Brexit advocates on June 23.

Saudi oil policy, like its defense policy, will be more aggressive and less predictable, following Deputy Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman's apparent nullification of a production "freeze" deal at Doha.