Market Returns

Highlights Portfolio Strategy Recovering energy related capex and upbeat oil prices are a powerful tonic for the S&P integrated oil & gas index. Augment positions to overweight. A diverging crude/refined product inventory backdrop, narrowing Brent-WTI crude oil spread, and extreme analyst optimism warn that the easy money has been made in refiners. Lock in profits and downgrade to a benchmark allocation. Recent Changes S&P Integrated Oil & Gas - Upgrade to overweight. S&P Oil & Gas Refining & Marketing - Book profits of 9% and downgrade to neutral today. Table 1 Acrophobia Acrophobia Feature Chart 1Vertigo Alert Vertigo Alert Vertigo Alert Equities have been rising at a dizzying speed year-to-date, as investors have extrapolated the tax reform EPS tailwind far into the future in a very short time span. The risk of a tactical, and likely short lived, 5-10% pullback is very high. Putting this potential correction in perspective is in order. A drop in the SPX to near its 50-day moving average would set the market back 6%, to near the 2,700 mark. As a reminder, the S&P 500 crossed 2,700 on January 3, 2018. A 10% drawdown would push the market below 2,600, a level first surpassed on Black Friday (Chart 1). While steep stock price increases are not unprecedented, at the current juncture all of our tactical indicators suggest that caution is warranted (please refer to the January 22 and January 29 Weekly Reports for more details). The way we recommend defending against such exuberance is to book gains in high-beta pair trades, institute trailing stops to the high-conviction list high flyers (see page 19) and make some subsurface changes to intra-sector positioning. From a cyclical perspective we remain constructive on the broad market and given our view of no recession in the coming 9-12 months our investment strategy is to "buy the dip". Chart 2 shows our S&P 500 EPS model using trailing EPS data directly from Standard & Poor's. Calendar 2017 profit growth is on track to hit 17% year-over-year. Chart 3 shows our S&P 500 EPS model using IBES trailing EPS data. We decided to regress the same variables on the IBES trailing EPS dataset since the market trades on the forward EPS from IBES. According to IBES, calendar 2017 EPS growth will hit 12%, so there is a 5% delta between the two datasets. Our understanding of the difference between the two numbers is what each provider considers one time I/S items. Currently, IBES bottom-up forecasts pencil in 18% growth in calendar 2018 and our model suggests that 21% is possible (Chart 3). S&P forecasts call for a 23% calendar 2018 increase and our model is pointing toward 24% (Chart 2). Chart 2No Matter The Data Set... No Matter The Data Set... No Matter The Data Set... Chart 3...EPS Will Shine In 2018 ...EPS Will Shine In 2018 ...EPS Will Shine In 2018 Irrespective of what data one uses the signal is clear: EPS will have a blowout year in 2018. Studying such EPS reacceleration phases is very interesting. Since the mid-1980s there have been four other periods where EPS exhibited breakneck growth (excluding the GFC, Chart 3). Importantly, we analyzed what the prevalent macro conditions were in all four iterations and Charts A1-A4 in the Appendix on page 16 detail the results. In all iterations, the 10-year Treasury yield was rising, the ISM manufacturing survey was well above the 50 boom/bust line, the U.S. dollar was falling, and crude oil prices were increasing. Currently, we believe reaching and even surpassing the 20% EPS growth rate number in 2018 is likely, given the similarities between the current macro backdrop and these four prior periods (Chart 4). However, this does not necessarily mean that there will be no stock market volatility and equites will increase uninterruptedly in a straight line. Chart 5 shows how the S&P 500 performed in these four periods and in all of them short-term tactical pullbacks occurred. We think 2018 will prove no different. This week we update our view on a deep cyclical sector and tweak our intra-sector positioning. Chart 4Favorable Macro Conditions... Favorable Macro Conditions... Favorable Macro Conditions... Chart 5...But Don't Get Carried Away ...But Don't Get Carried Away ...But Don't Get Carried Away Stay Long Energy... We put the S&P energy sector on our high-conviction overweight list in late-November as a key beneficiary of our synchronized global capex theme.1 Since then, the broad energy complex has bested the S&P 500 by over 3%, and our macro indicators suggest that more gains are in store for this deep cyclical sector. The Dallas Fed manufacturing outlook survey is firing on all cylinders and, given the importance of oil to the state of Texas, it serves as an excellent gauge for oil activity. Importantly, the capital expenditures part of the survey hit the highest level in a decade. Similarly, capex intentions in the coming six months are also probing multi-year highs and signaling that the budding recovery in energy capital budgets will likely gain steam (middle panel, Chart 6). Following the late-2015/early-2016 drubbing in oil prices, energy projects ground to a halt and only now are green shoots appearing (bottom panel, Chart 6). Indeed, rising oil prices are providing a much needed assist. Higher crude prices make more global projects economical and coupled with the steadily lower breakeven costs of shale oil suggest that EPS and sales growth normalcy is likely to return to this commodity complex. Moreover, the indiscriminate selling of the U.S. dollar explains part of the oil price rise, but other macro forces are also at play (Chart 7). Chart 6Capex Theme Beneficiary Capex Theme Beneficiary Capex Theme Beneficiary Chart 7Catch Up Phase Looming Catch Up Phase Looming Catch Up Phase Looming Chart 8Levered To Global Growth##BR## And Rising Inflation Levered To Global Growth And Rising Inflation Levered To Global Growth And Rising Inflation Similar to "Dr. Copper", crude oil prices are an excellent global growth barometer. In fact, oil price swings move in lockstep with the ebb and flow of global output growth and the current message is positive (Chart 8). Not only is our proprietary measure of global Industrial Production rising, but the multi-year high in the forward looking global manufacturing PMI survey also suggests that more good news on the global economic front lies ahead. As unemployment gaps close around the world, with more and more countries following in the U.S.'s footsteps toward full employment, inflation is bound to reaccelerate. Recently, the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield has been on a tear driven mostly by rising inflation expectations. Higher interest rates is another key BCA theme for 2018 and energy stocks also stand to benefit from this rising interest rate backdrop. Historically, relative share prices have been positively correlated both with bond yields and inflation expectations and the current message is to expect a catch up phase in the former (bottom panel, Chart 8). Beyond an enticing macro backdrop, favorable industry supply/demand dynamics are a harbinger of sunnier energy days. OECD oil stocks are receding steadily and so are U.S. crude oil inventories. The implication is that relative share prices will remain well bid (oil inventories shown inverted, middle panel, Chart 9). OPEC 2.0 remains in place and will likely balance the oil market by continuing to constrain supply. Our Commodity & Energy Strategy service is still penciling in higher oil prices for 2018. On the demand side, emerging markets/Chinese demand is the key determinant of overall oil demand, and the news on this front is encouraging and consistent with BCA's synchronized global growth theme: following the recent lull, non-OECD demand is growing anew roughly by 1.5mn bbl/day. The upshot is that S&P energy relative revenues will climb out of the recent trough (bottom panel, Chart 9). Our energy profit model does an excellent job capturing all of these different forces and is signaling that energy EPS will easily outpace the SPX and continue to capture a larger share of the broad market's earnings pie (Chart 10). Chart 9Favorable Supply/Demand Backdrop Favorable Supply/Demand Backdrop Favorable Supply/Demand Backdrop Chart 10EPS Model Flashing Green EPS Model Flashing Green EPS Model Flashing Green Bottom Line: We reiterate our high-conviction overweight call in the S&P energy index. ...Boost The Integrated Oil & Gas Index To Overweight, But... Factors are falling into place for the heavyweight S&P integrated oil & gas index to generate outsized returns in the coming year, and we are compelled to lift this beaten-down energy sub-index to an above benchmark allocation. Investment spending and relative performance are one and the same for this capital-outlay-reliant group. The time to buy these capital intensive high-operating leverage stocks is during a capex upcycle when a virtuous EPS cycle takes root. The opposite is also true. Earlier this decade, the energy sector's share of the U.S. stock market reported capex pie got halved to 16% (top panel, Chart 11). While we are not calling for a return to the heyday of triple digit oil, even a modest renormalization of capital spending would go a long way. Recent news that Exxon Mobil would bump domestic capital spending to $50bn over the next five years is a step in the right direction. New projects/investments comprise 70% of this figure. The company cited the new U.S. tax law as a reason behind the announcement, and tax reform has the potential to drive industry capex plans/budgets. Our sense is that more announcements like the Exxon Mobil one may be brewing and could serve as a catalyst to unlock excellent value in the S&P integrated oil & gas index. Meanwhile, higher oil prices will result in a pickup in global energy project outlays. The top panel of Chart 12 shows that the global oil & gas rig count is rebounding from an extremely depressed level. Encouragingly, these investments will likely pay dividends and translate into cash flow growth extending the virtuous upcycle (bottom panel, Chart 12). Chart 11Buy Oil Majors Buy Oil Majors Buy Oil Majors Chart 12Prime Beneficiary Of Rising Capex Prime Beneficiary Of Rising Capex Prime Beneficiary Of Rising Capex As we mentioned earlier in the energy section, BCA still has a sanguine 2018 oil view, and if it pans out, it will continue to underpin not only the broad energy space, but also oil majors. Action in the commodity pits corroborates that the path of least resistance is higher both for the underlying commodity and relative share prices. Crude oil net speculative positions just hit a record high as a percent of open interest (bottom panel, Chart 13). Similarly, consensus on oil just breached the 50 line and is now in bullish territory, signaling that momentum in the relative share price ratio will gain steam in the coming months (middle panel, Chart 13). Adding it up, recovering energy related capex coupled with upbeat oil prices are a powerful tonic for the S&P integrated oil & gas index. Under such a backdrop a valuation rerating phase is looming (Chart 14). Chart 13Encouraging Oil Market Dynamics Encouraging Oil Market Dynamics Encouraging Oil Market Dynamics Chart 14Cheap With A 150bps Dividend Carry Cheap With A 150bps Dividend Carry Cheap With A 150bps Dividend Carry Bottom Line: Boost the S&P integrated oil & gas index to overweight. This index also sports a 150bps positive dividend carry. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: XOM, CVX & OXY. ...Take Profits In Refiners While we recommend upgrading the S&P integrated oil & gas index to overweight, we are booking gains of 9% in the niche S&P oil & gas refining & marketing index and downgrading to a benchmark allocation. We upgraded refiners to overweight in early September, as a way to capitalize on the havoc that hurricane season dealt to refining capacity. Since then, our portfolio has benefited handsomely from the run up in refining stocks, but we do not want to overstay our welcome in this niche space as refinery runs have now returned to normal (Chart 15). Moreover, a number of headwinds signal that the easy gains are already behind this group. First, refining margins are under pressure as the Brent-WTI crude oil spread is steadily narrowing. Historically, refining margins and this oil price spread have been joined at the hip and the current message is negative for margins. A diverging inventory backdrop also points toward margin trouble ahead. Refined product inventories are outpacing crude oil supplies, warning that a further softening in crack spreads is in the cards (bottom panel, Chart 16). In fact, crude oil inventories are whittled down, whereas gasoline and distillate fuel stocks are built up (middle panel, Chart 15). This inventory accumulation represents, at the margin, a challenging pricing outlook for refiners. Chart 15Return To Normalcy... Return To Normalcy... Return To Normalcy... Chart 16...But Cracks Are Forming ...But Cracks Are Forming ...But Cracks Are Forming Worrisomely, sell side analysts have been extrapolating a euphoric EPS backdrop far into the future with five year profit forecasts pushing all-time highs. While tax reform represents a one-time boost to EPS in 2018, we cannot comprehend how this highly cyclical industry with razor thin margins can attain 34% EPS growth for the next 3-5 years, outpacing the overall market by a staggering 20 percentage points (Chart 17). Putting this sky-high long-term EPS growth number in perspective is instructive. Typically, relative share prices hit a wall when such analyst optimism reigns. The tech sector in the late 1990s, biotech stocks twice in 2001 and 2014, and semi equipment stocks late last year all suffered a major setback when long-term profit forecasts catapulted near the 25% mark (Chart 17). (As a reminder chip equipment stocks are a high-conviction underweight and have benefitted our portfolio by 17.2% since the November 27th inception, please see page 19.) Finally, from a technical perspective, a bearish pennant formation with lower highs has formed and is warning that a breakdown is possible in the relative share price ratio in the coming quarters (top panel, Chart 16). Nevertheless, we refrain from turning outright bearish on refiners as there is a sizeable offset. Refined product consumption is as firm as ever. Gasoline demand remains upbeat and this indicator has historically been positively correlated with relative share prices, relative 12-month forward EPS and relative valuations (Chart 18). Chart 17Watch Out Down Below Watch Out Down Below Watch Out Down Below Chart 18Consumption Is A Positive Offset Consumption Is A Positive Offset Consumption Is A Positive Offset Any let-up in demand or a further jump in refined product inventories could prove deflationary for refiners and were that to take place we would not hesitate to further prune exposure to a below benchmark allocation. Bottom Line: Lock in profits of 9% in the S&P oil & gas refining & marketing index and downgrade to neutral. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: PSX, VLO, MPC and ANDV. Anastasios Avgeriou, Vice President U.S. Equity Strategy anastasios@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "High-Conviction Calls," dated November 27, 2017, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. Appendix Chart A1 Chart A1 Chart A1 Chart A2 Chart A2 Chart A2 Chart A3 Chart A3 Chart A3 Chart A4 Chart A4 Chart A4 Current Recommendations Current Trades Size And Style Views Favor value over growth. Stay neutral small over large caps (downgrade alert).

Highlights Global equities are technically overbought, making them highly vulnerable to a correction. The cyclical picture for stocks still looks good, thanks to strong economic growth and rising corporate profits, but the recent spike in bond yields is becoming a headwind. Valuations are highly stretched, particularly in the U.S. This points to subpar long-term returns. On balance, we recommend staying overweight global equities. However, investors should consider buying some insurance against a market selloff. The VIX has probably bottomed for this cycle and high-yield spreads are unlikely to move much lower. This makes long volatility and short credit positions attractive hedges. Going short AUD/JPY is also an appealing hedge, given the yen's defensive characteristics and the Aussie dollar's vulnerability to slower Chinese growth. We were stopped out of our long global industrials versus utilities trade for a gain of 12%. We are also raising our stop on our short fed funds futures trade to 70 bps. Feature A Cloudy Picture As a rule of thumb, technical factors drive stocks over short-term horizons of one-to-three months, business cycle developments and financial conditions drive stocks over horizons of one-to-two years, and valuations drive stocks over ultra long-term horizons of five years and beyond. Occasionally, all three sets of signals line up in the same direction. In March 2009, the combination of bombed-out sentiment, cheap valuations, green shoots in the economy, and the expansion of the Fed's QE program all aligned to mark the beginning of a powerful bull market in stocks. Unfortunately, today the calculus is not so simple. Stocks Are Technically Overbought Technically, the stock market has gotten ahead of itself. The S&P 500 Relative Strength Index hit a record high earlier this week, while our Technical Indicator reached a post-recession high (Chart 1). The S&P has now gone 310 days without a 3% drawdown and 402 days without a 5% drawdown - both records (Chart 2). Chart 1U.S. Equities Are Technically Overbought U.S. Equities Are Technically Overbought U.S. Equities Are Technically Overbought Chart 2It's Been A Long Time Since U.S. Stocks Corrected Take Out Some Insurance Take Out Some Insurance Irrational exuberance is back. Our Composite Sentiment Indicator has jumped to the highest level since right before the 1987 crash (Chart 3). Retail investors are also flooding back into the market. Discount brokers such as E*TRADE and Ameritrade have seen a flurry of activity (Chart 4).The latest monthly survey conducted by the American Association of Individual Investors showed that respondents had the largest allocation to stocks since 2000 (Chart 5). Chart 3Equity Investors Are Mega-Bullish Equity Investors Are Mega-Bullish Equity Investors Are Mega-Bullish Chart 4Retail Investors Have Piled In (Part I) Retail Investors Have Piled In (Part I) Retail Investors Have Piled In (Part I) Chart 5Retail Investors Have Piled In (Part II) Retail Investors Have Piled In (Part II) Retail Investors Have Piled In (Part II) The Economy And Earnings Still Paint A Bullish Backdrop Chart 6Economic Outlook Remains Solid Economic Outlook Remains Solid Economic Outlook Remains Solid In contrast to the ominous technical picture, the cyclical outlook for stocks looks reasonably solid (Chart 6). The Citigroup Economic Surprise Index for major advanced economies has risen to near record-high levels. Goldman's Global Current Activity Indicator stands close to a cycle high of 5%, up from 2.2% at the start of 2016. Our Global Leading Indicator has decelerated somewhat, but is still pointing to above-trend growth this year. Growth in the euro area remains strong. The economy grew by 2.5% in 2017, the fastest pace since 2007. U.S. growth is gathering steam. Real private final demand increased by 4.6% in Q4. The Atlanta Fed's GDPNow model is signaling growth of 5.4% in the first quarter, while the New York Fed Staff Nowcast is pointing to a more plausible growth rate of 3.1%. Reflecting the strong economy, corporate profits are ripping higher. 45% of S&P 500 companies have reported 2017 Q4 results. 80% have beaten consensus EPS projections, above the long-term average of 69%. 82% have beaten revenue projections, which also exceeds the long-term average of 56%. The fact that earnings and revenue have surprised so strongly to the upside is all the more impressive given the sharp increase in EPS estimates over the past few months (Chart 7). Moreover, the improvement in earnings has been broad-based across sectors (Table 1). Chart 7Analysts Scramble To Revise 2018 Earnings Estimates Higher Analysts Scramble To Revise 2018 Earnings Estimates Higher Analysts Scramble To Revise 2018 Earnings Estimates Higher Table 1Estimated Earnings Growth For 2018 Take Out Some Insurance Take Out Some Insurance Financial Conditions Are Supportive, But Rising Bond Yields Are A Risk Financial and monetary conditions remain accommodative, as judged by an assortment of financial conditions indices (Chart 8). The global credit impulse has surged (Chart 9). Chart 8Financial Conditions Have Eased Financial Conditions Have Eased Financial Conditions Have Eased Chart 9Global Credit Impulse Is Positive Global Credit Impulse Is Positive Global Credit Impulse Is Positive The recent rapid ascent in global bond yields complicates matters. So far, much of the increase in yields has been driven by higher inflation expectations. This has kept real yields down. Indeed, real 2-year yields have actually declined in the euro area and Japan over the last several months. In absolute terms, yields are still low by historic standards (Chart 10). As my colleague Doug Peta, who heads our Global ETF Strategy service, has documented, rising bond yields pose a bigger problem for the economy and risk assets when they move into restrictive territory (Table 2). We are not there yet (Chart 11). Stronger global growth and diminished spare capacity have pushed up the pain threshold for when rising bond yields begin to bite. In the U.S., fiscal stimulus and a cheaper dollar have also caused the neutral rate to rise. Chart 10Yields Are Still Low ##br## By Historic Standards Yields Are Still Low By Historic Standards Yields Are Still Low By Historic Standards Table 2Aggregate Real S&P 500 Returns ##br## During Rate Cycle Phases From August 1961 Take Out Some Insurance Take Out Some Insurance Chart 11Rates Not Hurting ... Yet Rates Not Hurting ... Yet Rates Not Hurting ... Yet Nevertheless, equities often struggle to digest rapid increases in bond yields. Although the late 2016 episode stands out as an exception, stocks have typically floundered following an increase in global bond yields of around 50 bps (Table 3). The yield on the JP Morgan Global Government Bond index has risen by 27 bps since last autumn. If yields continue their swift ascent, stocks could come under pressure. Table 3What Happens When Bond Yields Spike? Take Out Some Insurance Take Out Some Insurance Valuation Concerns Chart 12Demanding U.S. Valuations Point To Low Long-Term Returns Demanding U.S. Valuations Point To Low Long-Term Returns Demanding U.S. Valuations Point To Low Long-Term Returns Valuations are not much use for timing the stock market, but they are the most important driver of returns over the long haul. Chart 12 shows the close correlation between the Shiller P/E ratio in the U.S. and the subsequent 10-year total return for stocks. Even though realized earnings growth tends to be higher following periods when the P/E ratio is elevated, this is more than offset by a lower dividend yield and the compression of P/E multiples. Today's Shiller P/E ratio of 34 presages subpar returns over the next decade. The picture is somewhat better outside the U.S. Our composite valuation measure - which combines trailing P/E, price-to-sales, price-to-book, Tobin's Q, and market capitalization-to-GDP - suggests that most stock markets outside the U.S. will see returns in the low-to-mid single-digit range over the next ten years (Appendix 1). Nevertheless, this is still well below the historic average return for these markets. What To Do? Our cyclical overweight in global equities has worked out well, and barring evidence that the global economy is tipping into recession, we intend to maintain this recommendation. Nevertheless, the discussion above suggests that stocks are vulnerable to a near-term correction and that long-term returns are likely to be lackluster at best. As such, it is sensible to take out some insurance against a market selloff. The question, as always, is how to guard against a drop in equity prices without suffering too much of a drag if global bourses continue to grind higher. We noted three weeks ago that today's equity bull market is starting to look increasingly like the one in the late 1990s.1 Back then, rising equity prices were accompanied by both higher volatility and wider credit spreads (Chart 13). History seems to be repeating itself. The VIX bottomed on November 24 at 8.56 and ended last week at 11.08, even as the S&P 500 hit another record high. Investors should consider buying volatility futures on any major dip in the VIX. Junk bonds have also underperformed equities year-to-date, which has benefited our long S&P 500/short high-yield credit recommendation. As we go to press, the Barclays high-yield total return index is flat for the year, while the S&P 500 has gained 5.7%. Given the deterioration in our Corporate Health Monitor, and the likelihood that rising inflation will keep Treasury yields in an uptrend, investors should consider hedging equity risk by shorting junk bonds. Chart 13Volatility Can Increase And Spreads Can Widen As Stock Prices Rise Volatility Can Increase And Spreads Can Widen As Stock Prices Rise Volatility Can Increase And Spreads Can Widen As Stock Prices Rise Chart 14Chinese Growth Is Decelerating Moderately Chinese Growth Is Decelerating Moderately Chinese Growth Is Decelerating Moderately Go Short AUD/JPY Chart 15Iron Ore Stockpiles Are Hitting New Highs In China Iron Ore Stockpiles Are Hitting New Highs In China Iron Ore Stockpiles Are Hitting New Highs In China Going short the Australian dollar versus the Japanese yen is also an appealing hedge against a broad-based retreat from risk assets. The yen is a highly defensive currency. Japan has a healthy current account surplus of 4% of GDP. Its accumulated foreign assets outstrip foreign liabilities by a whopping 65% of GDP. When Japanese investors get nervous about the world and start repatriating funds back home, the yen invariably strengthens. The Aussie dollar is highly levered to the Chinese economy. While we do not expect a steep deceleration in Chinese growth this year, we do think that growth will fall from last year's heady pace. This can already be seen in the deterioration in the Li Keqiang index (Chart 14). The growth rate of railway freight, one of the index's components, has fallen from above 20% in early 2017 to -1%. Crucially for Australia, iron ore stockpiles in Chinese ports are hitting record highs (Chart 15). Meanwhile, the Reserve Bank of Australia's commodity index has rolled over. The year-over-year change in the index has dropped from a high of 47% six months ago to -1%. Domestically, the output gap stands at 2% of GDP. Both core CPI inflation and wage growth remain subdued (Chart 16). The household saving rate has dropped to 3%, while debt levels have reached nosebleed levels (Chart 17). This will limit consumer spending. Business confidence has dipped recently, as has the PMI new orders index (Chart 18). Mining capex has been trending lower, falling from over 6% of GDP in 2012 to 2.1% of GDP in 2017. The Australian government expects mining capex to sink further to 1.3% of GDP in 2018 (Chart 19). All this will limit the RBA's ability to hike rates. Chart 16Australian Core CPI Inflation And Wage Growth Remain Subdued Australian Core CPI Inflation And Wage Growth Remain Subdued Australian Core CPI Inflation And Wage Growth Remain Subdued Chart 17Australian Household Debt At Unsustainable Levels Australian Household Debt At Unsustainable Levels Australian Household Debt At Unsustainable Levels Chart 18Australia: Business Confidence And Orders Have Dipped Australia: Business Confidence And Orders Have Dipped Australia: Business Confidence And Orders Have Dipped Chart 19Mining Capex To Fall Further Mining Capex To Fall Further Mining Capex To Fall Further From a valuation perspective, AUD/JPY currently trades at a 27% premium to its Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate, having traded at a discount of as much as 50% back in 2000 (Chart 20). Speculators are heavily short the yen right now. As my colleague Mathieu Savary has noted, this could supercharge any short covering rally.2 Higher asset market volatility should also weaken the Aussie dollar. Chart 21 shows that AUD/JPY tends to be inversely correlated with the CVIX, an index of currency volatility. Chart 20AUD/JPY Trading At A Premium AUD/JPY Trading At A Premium AUD/JPY Trading At A Premium Chart 21Higher Vol Will Weaken AUD Higher Vol Will Weaken AUD Higher Vol Will Weaken AUD With this in mind, we are opening a new tactical trade recommendation to go short AUD/JPY. As a housekeeping matter, we are closing our long AUD/NZD trade for a loss of 1.8%. We were also stopped out of our long global industrial stocks versus utilities trade for a gain of 12%. Lastly, we are raising our stop on our short fed funds futures trade to 70 bps. Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Global Investment Strategy peterb@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Global Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "Will Bitcoin be Defanged," dated January 12, 2018, available at gis.bcaresearch.com 2 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, "Yen: QQE Is Dead! Long Live YCC!," dated January 12, 2018, available at fes.bcaresearch.com Appendix 1 Chart A1Long-Term Return Prospects Are Slightly Better Outside The U.S. Take Out Some Insurance Take Out Some Insurance Long-Term Return Prospects Are Slightly Better Outside The U.S. Take Out Some Insurance Take Out Some Insurance Long-Term Return Prospects Are Slightly Better Outside The U.S. Take Out Some Insurance Take Out Some Insurance Strategy & Market Trends Tactical Trades Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades

The GAA DM Equity Country Allocation model is updated as of January 31, 2018. The model has made large shifts in country allocations. The U.S. is upgraded to neutral from previously the largest underweight, driven largely by technical conditions. It seems dramatic, but as shown in Chart 2, the model did have similar large shifts in the past as well. Canada also has received a large increase to overweight driven by extremely attractive valuation. To fund these upgrades, the previously largest overweight in Italy is cut in half (mainly driven by liquidity and valuation) and Australia is back to underweight (trading places with Canada). As a result, the model now is overweight the Netherlands, Italy, Germany, Canada and Spain, neutral on the U.S. and underweight Japan, the U.K., France, Australia and Sweden as shown in Table 1. As shown in Table 2 and Chart 1, Chart 2 and Chart 3, the overall model outperformed its benchmark by 99 bps in January, largely driven by the Level 2 model which outperformed by 207 bps, thanks to the underweights in the U.K., Japan and Canada vs. the overweights in Italy, the Netherlands and Germany. Since going live in January 2016, the overall model has outperformed the benchmark by 190 bps, largely from the allocation among the 11 non-U.S. countries, which has outperformed its benchmark by 570 bps. The Level 1 model has performed in line with the MSCI world benchmark. Chart 1GAA DM Model Vs. MSCI World GAA DM Model Vs. MSCI World GAA DM Model Vs. MSCI World Chart 2GAA U.S. Vs. Non U.S. Model (Level1) GAA U.S. Vs. Non U.S. Model (Level1) GAA U.S. Vs. Non U.S. Model (Level1) Chart 3GAA Non U.S. Model (Level 2) GAA Non U.S. Model (Level 2) GAA Non U.S. Model (Level 2) Table 1Model Allocation Vs. Benchmark Weights GAA Quant Model Updates GAA Quant Model Updates Table 2Performance (Total Returns In USD) GAA Quant Model Updates GAA Quant Model Updates Please see also the website http://gaa.bcaresearch.com/trades/allocation_performance. For more details on the models, please see the January 29, 2016 Special Report, "Global Equity Allocation: Introducing the Developed Markets Country Allocation Model." http://gaa.bcaresearch.com/articles/view_report/18850. Please note that the overall country and sector recommendations published in our Monthly Portfolio Update and Quarterly Portfolio Outlook use the results of these quantitative models as one input, but do not stick slavishly to them. We believe that models are a useful check, but structural changes and unquantifiable factors need to be considered too in making overall recommendations. GAA Equity Sector Selection Model The GAA Equity Sector Selection Model (Chart 4) is updated as of January 31, 2018. The model continues to be bullish on global growth as seen by a 10% aggregate overweight in the cyclical sectors. The model continues to hold equal underweights in consumer staples, health care, telecom and utilities stocks. Looking forward, we believe improving global growth dynamics, and rising equity markets will help us maintain an aggregate cyclical pro-growth bias. For more details on the model, please see the Special Report "Introducing The GAA Equity Sector Selection Model," July 27, 2016 available at https://gaa.bcaresearch.com. Chart 4Overall Model Performance Overall Model Performance Overall Model Performance Table 3Allocations GAA Quant Model Updates GAA Quant Model Updates Table 4Performance Since Going Live GAA Quant Model Updates GAA Quant Model Updates Xiaoli Tang, Associate Vice President xiaoli@bcaresearch.com Aditya Kurian, Research Analyst adityak@bcaresearch.com

Highlights Portfolio Strategy A stable China, a depreciating U.S. dollar, rising commodity prices and sustained synchronized global growth signal that the industrials complex, especially the most cyclical part, remains on a solid footing. Deteriorating profit prospects warn that investors should refrain from paying a premium valuation for industrial machinery; take profits and move to the sidelines. Recent Changes S&P Industrial Machinery - Book profits of 4% and downgrade to neutral today. S&P Construction Machinery & Heavy Truck - Stop triggered last week, remove from the high-conviction list for a 10% gain. Small Caps / Large Caps - Downgrade alert in a recent Insight. Table 1 Corporate Pricing Power Update Corporate Pricing Power Update Feature The S&P 500 smashed through the 2,800 mark last week, as corporate profits continued to deliver, the U.S. dollar took a dive and global economic data releases held their own. Stars could not be more aligned for a euphoric blow off phase, with equity bourses the world over already registering annual-like returns in but a few short weeks. While stocks have more room to run, especially versus bonds, on a cyclical time frame, tactically the likelihood of a short-term healthy pullback is increasing. Last week we identified five indicators we are closely monitoring that are signaling an overstretched market.1 This week we update our Complacency-Anxiety Indicator that also catapulted to all-time highs and breached the one standard deviation above the historical mean mark (Chart 1). This confirms that a Q1 setback remains likely, and our strategy since December 18 has been to monetize gains in tactical trades and institute stops to the high flyers in our high-conviction call list. Were a 5-10% correction to materialize, we would "buy the dip" as we do not foresee a recession in the coming 9-12 months. While consumer price inflation is nowhere to be found, corporate selling prices are climbing at a brisk pace. The U.S. dollar debasement and related commodity reflex rebound, especially in oil prices, are the culprits, and the latter will likely assist even the CPI basket and morph into an inflationary impulse as we posited in late-November (please see the bottom two panels of Chart 1B). Already, inflation expectations are headed higher. Chart 2 updates our corporate sector pricing power proxy and our diffusion index. It also updates the business sector's overall wage inflation and associated diffusion index from the latest BLS employment report. The middle panel of Chart 2 shows the Atlanta Fed Wage Growth Tracker and that measure of wage inflation has converged down to the AHE reading, suffering a 100bps drop in the past year. Chart 1Complacency Reigns Complacency Reigns Complacency Reigns Chart 2Margin Expansion Phase Is Intact Margin Expansion Phase Is Intact Margin Expansion Phase Is Intact Corporate pricing power is upbeat at a time when wages are decelerating. Taken together, our margin proxy indicator suggests that the ongoing profit margin expansion phase has more upside (bottom panel, Chart 2). Table 2 shows our updated industry group pricing power gauges, which we calculate from the relevant CPI, PPI, PCE and commodity growth rates for each of the 60 industry groups we track. Table 2 also highlights shorter-term pricing power trends and each industry's spread to overall inflation. Table 2Industry Group Pricing Power Corporate Pricing Power Update Corporate Pricing Power Update 78% of the industries we cover are lifting selling prices, and 45% are doing so at a faster clip than overall inflation. Importantly, inflation rates have increased since our late-September update. The outright deflating sectors dropped by two to 13 since our last update. Encouragingly, only 7 industries are experiencing a downtrend in selling price inflation, or 5 fewer than our most recent report. Impressively, deep cyclicals/commodity-related industries dominate the top ranks, occupying 8 out of the top 10 slots (top panel, Chart 3). A softening greenback and rising global end demand explain the commodity complex's sustained ability to increase prices. In contrast, tech, telecom and consumer discretionary sectors populate the bottom ranks of Table 2. Netting it out, accelerating corporate sector pricing power will continue to bolster top line growth in 2018. Tack on high operating leverage kicking into higher gear at this stage of the cycle and still muted wage inflation and profit margins and EPS growth will remain upbeat. With regard to cyclicals versus defensives, diverging pricing power (Chart 3) and wage growth trends (Chart 4) suggest that cyclicals continue to have the upper hand compared with defensives (Chart 5). Chart 3Deep Cyclicals... Deep Cyclicals... Deep Cyclicals... Chart 4...Have The Upper Hand... ...Have The Upper Hand... ...Have The Upper Hand... Chart 5...Vs. Defensives ...Vs. Defensives ...Vs. Defensives This week we update our view on a deep cyclical sector and modestly tweak our intra-sector positioning. Industrials And China We lifted the S&P industrials sector to an above benchmark allocation in early October via boosting the S&P construction machinery & heavy truck sub index to overweight.2 Synchronized global growth, a capex upcycle, firming capital goods final demand, and the U.S. dollar's fall coupled with the commodity price rebound all pointed to a bright outlook for U.S. capital goods producers. Currently, all these forces remain in play and continue to bolster industrials stocks' profit prospects. However, the emerging market (EM)/Chinese economic backdrop deserves closer scrutiny. Why? Because the most cyclical parts of the industrials complex are levered to the EM in general and China in particular. These high operating leverage businesses also drive relative profit and stock performance, signaling that China's economic growth might or ails determine the overall fortunes of U.S. capital goods producers. While Chinese economic data are currently a mixed bag and we take them with a big grain of salt, global high-frequency financial market data are emitting an unambiguously positive signal. First, BCA's FX strategist, Mathieu Savary, brought to our attention that the extremely economic-sensitive Canadian TSX Venture Exchange Index is in a V-shaped recovery.3 Highly speculative basic resources issues dominate this Index and help explain the tight positive correlation with Chinese output (top panel, Chart 6). Second, the ultimate economic-sensitive indicator, Dr. Copper, is also in a violent upswing, heralding that China will be, at least, stable in 2018 (middle panel, Chart 6). Third, high-beta Australian materials stocks have been in an upward trajectory since the early 2016 trough both versus the MSCI All-Country World Index and the broad Australian market, sniffing out improving Chinese-related commodity demand (bottom panel, Chart 6). Similarly, upbeat non-Chinese economic data suggest that China's economic prospects are far from faltering. Australia's close economic ties with China signal that taking a pulse of the Australian economic juggernaut reveals the state of China's economic affairs. Down Under employment growth has been brisk of late, with annual job creation running at a 3.3% clip, a rate last hit in the mid-2000s when China's economy was roaring and the commodity super-cycle was in full swing (second panel, Chart 7). Australian CEO confidence as well as consumer confidence are pushing decade highs, and the manufacturing PMI survey recently shot to a 16 year high (third panel, Chart 7). Chart 6China Is##BR##Alright China Is Alright China Is Alright Chart 7Australian Indicators Confirm:##BR## China Is Stable Australian Indicators Confirm: China Is Stable Australian Indicators Confirm: China Is Stable All of this suggests that China will likely remain stable in 2018, barring a policy mistake a la the August 11, 2015 currency devaluation. The upshot is that industrials EPS and equities have more room to run. On that front, both our Cyclical Macro Indicator and our profit growth model corroborate that the path of least resistance for relative share prices is higher (Chart 8). U.S. dollar debasing is synonymous with capital goods producers' top line growth acceleration, as a large part of total revenues are sourced from abroad. The near 20 percentage point fall in the trade-weighted U.S. dollar since 2015 suggests that more global market share gains are in store for U.S. industrials (Chart 9). Global growth is also joined at the hip with the greenback's depreciation. Synchronized global growth along with our derivative coordinated global capex growth 2018 theme, will likely serve as catalysts for a sustained breakout in relative share prices (Chart 10). Chart 8EPS Model And CMI Flash Green EPS Model And CMI Flash Green EPS Model And CMI Flash Green Chart 9Industrials Love A Cheap Greenback Industrials Love A Cheap Greenback Industrials Love A Cheap Greenback Chart 10Levered To Global Growth Levered To Global Growth Levered To Global Growth Adding it up, a stable China is music to the ears of industrials executives. Tack on a depreciating U.S. dollar, rising commodity prices and sustained synchronized global growth and the most cyclical parts of the industrials complex will continue to lead the pack. Bottom Line: Stay overweight the S&P industrials index, but selectivity is warranted. Take Profits In Industrial Machinery We outlined above that the most cyclical parts of the S&P industrials index with high foreign sales content would benefit disproportionately from our stable-to-mildly sanguine EM/China view. While the broad machinery index fits the bill, the industrial machinery sub index less so, and we recommend monetizing gains of 4% since inception and moving to the sidelines. Chart 11 shows the relative performance of the two key drivers of the S&P machinery index: industrial machinery and construction machinery & heavy truck sub-indexes. While these indexes moved hand-in-hand since the mid-1990s, early this decade this tight positive correlation fell apart. One key determinant of the relative move of these indexes is the U.S. dollar. The greenback troughed in 2011 and since then the more "defensive", less globally-exposed S&P industrials machinery index left their brethren in the dust (bottom panel, Chart 11). Now that the U.S. dollar has peaked, the catch up phase in the S&P construction machinery & heavy truck index that is already underway will likely gain momentum (top panel, Chart 11). Beyond the depreciating currency, at the margin, softening S&P industrial machinery operating metrics argue for pruning exposure in this index. Both the Empire and Philly Fed new orders surveys have petered out, suggesting that industry new order growth will likely continue to lose steam (middle panel, Chart 12). In fact, a weak industrial machinery new orders-to-inventories ratio is also warning that sell-side analysts' relative profits forecasts are too optimistic (bottom panel, Chart 12). Chart 11Catch Up Phase Catch Up Phase Catch Up Phase Chart 12Waning End-Demand Waning End-Demand Waning End-Demand Drilling deeper into industry operating metrics is revealing. While shipments have held their own and moved mostly sideways similar to new orders, inventory accumulation is worrying. Industry inventories have risen by over 30% during the past three years (Chart 13). Simultaneously, industrial machinery backlogs have drifted steadily lower. Given the supply build up, any hiccup in demand, even a minor one, could prove very deflationary and heavily weigh on industry profitability. With regard to valuations, Chart 14 shows that both on a relative trailing price-to-sales and relative forward price-to-earnings ratio basis, the index is trading one standard deviation above the historical mean. The moderating industry demand backdrop suggests that relative valuations are expensive. Chart 13Inventory Liquidation Risk Inventory Liquidation Risk Inventory Liquidation Risk Chart 14Why Pay A Premium? Why Pay A Premium? Why Pay A Premium? Adding it all up, deteriorating profit prospects warn that investors should refrain from paying a premium valuation for the S&P industrial machinery index. Bottom Line: Book profits of 4% in the S&P industrial machinery index and downgrade to a benchmark allocation. We also recommend redeploying profits from our downgrade in the S&P industrial machinery index to their more cyclical machinery siblings the S&P construction machinery & heavy truck index, thus sustaining the overall overweight exposure in the broad S&P industrials sector. Housekeeping Last week we instituted a risk management tool for our 2018 high-conviction list: setting a stop once a call has cleared the 10% return mark.4 This past week, the S&P construction machinery & heavy truck index hit the trailing stop at the 10% mark, and thus we are booking gains and removing this index from the high-conviction list. While our confidence is not as high as in late-November given the parabolic move in this index and rising chance of a tactical overall equity market pullback, from a cyclical perspective we continue to recommend a core overweight in this industrials sector powerhouse. Anastasios Avgeriou, Vice President U.S. Equity Strategy anastasios@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "Too Good To Be True?" dated January 22, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "Earnings Take Center Stage," dated October 2, 2017, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see BCA Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, "Health Care Or Not, Risks Remain," dated March 24, 2017, available at fes.bcaresearch.com. 4 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "Too Good To Be True?" dated January 22, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. Current Recommendations Current Trades Size And Style Views Favor value over growth. Stay neutral small over large caps (downgrade alert).

Dear Client, In addition to this abbreviated Weekly Report, I am sending you a Special Report co-authored by Mark McClellan, Managing Editor of the monthly Bank Credit Analyst, and Brian Piccioni of Technology Sector Strategy. Mark and Brian argue that the deflationary impact of robot automation will not prevent inflation from rising as the labor market tightens. I hope you will find their report interesting and informative. Best regards, Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Global Investment Strategy Highlights Our cyclically overweight stance on global equities/underweight stance on bonds is working. Stick with it. U.S. Treasury Secretary Mnuchin's comments about the dollar are unlikely to have any lasting effects. EUR/USD has decoupled from terminal rate expectations since the start of this year. Tactical trade recommendation: Go short EUR/USD while simultaneously going long 30-year U.S. Treasurys/short 30-year German bunds. Feature Global Equities Enter A Blow-Off Phase Valuations do not matter on the way up, but they sure do matter on the way down. Once the market reaches that Wile E. Coyote moment - the one where the poor sap runs off the cliff, pauses in mid-air, looks down, and sees the ground below - all hell will break loose. On every valuation measure, U.S. stocks, and increasingly global stocks, have become very expensive (Chart 1). Chart 1AU.S. Stocks Are Expensive... U.S. Stocks Are Expensive... U.S. Stocks Are Expensive... Chart 1B...While Global Stocks Are Getting There ...While Global Stocks Are Getting There ...While Global Stocks Are Getting There That moment, however, is unlikely to arrive until the global economy and earnings growth begin to stall out. As we have argued in past reports, this probably will not happen until late next year. Historically, it has not paid to get defensive until six months before the start of a recession (Table 1). This suggests that stocks could continue to rally right through 2018. Beep beep. Table 1Too Soon To Get Out The Indefatigable Euro The Indefatigable Euro Granted, the timing of our recession call could turn out to be wrong, which is why we are watching a wide number of leading variables for signs that a slowdown is around the corner (Chart 2). In the U.S., these include credit spreads, the slope of the yield curve, financial conditions, business and consumer confidence, ISM new orders minus inventories, building permits, core capital goods orders, and initial unemployment claims. We have consolidated these variables and dozens of others into our MacroQuant model. The model is still pointing to a reasonably rosy cyclical outlook for stocks (Chart 3). Chart 2Leading Cyclical Data Still Strong Leading Cyclical Data Still Strong Leading Cyclical Data Still Strong Chart 3Cyclical Outlook For Stocks Is Still Rosy The Indefatigable Euro The Indefatigable Euro The Dollar Takes A Pounding While our cyclical bullish view on stocks and bearish view on bonds has paid off this year, our expectation that the dollar would recoup some of last year's losses has not worked out. Time will tell if December 2016 marked the beginning of a secular dollar bear market. The dollar tends to suffer when global growth accelerates. This happened last year. The dollar also tends to weaken when the composition of growth shifts away from the United States. That also happened in 2017. The remainder of this year could be different. We expect global growth to remain solidly above-trend in 2018, but ease from the torrid pace of 2017. This is already being foreshadowed by the decline in our Global LEI diffusion index to below 50%, a slowdown in Korean and Taiwanese exports, a deceleration in the Chinese Li Keqiang Index, and the loss of momentum in EM carry trades (Chart 4). Meanwhile, the composition of global growth should shift back in favor of the U.S. The fact that the U.S. Economic Surprise index has recovered in recent months relative to other economies suggests that this reversal of fortunes is already underway (Chart 5). The end result for asset markets could be slightly reminiscent of the late 1990s, a period when both equities and the dollar rallied. Chart 4Global Growth Will Remain Above-Trend ##br##But Ease From Blistering Pace Global Growth Will Remain Above-Trend But Ease From Blistering Pace Global Growth Will Remain Above-Trend But Ease From Blistering Pace Chart 5Composition Of Global Growth Will Shift ##br##Back In Favor Of The U.S. Composition Of Global Growth Will Shift Back In Favor Of The U.S. Composition Of Global Growth Will Shift Back In Favor Of The U.S. Talk Is Cheap Chart 6Trade-Weighted Dollar No Longer Pricey Trade-Weighted Dollar No Longer Pricey Trade-Weighted Dollar No Longer Pricey We do not put much weight on the remarks concerning the dollar made by Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin at Davos this week. While Mnuchin did say that "obviously a weaker dollar is good for us as it relates to trade and opportunities," he added that "longer term, the strength of the dollar is a reflection of the strength of the U.S. economy and the fact that it is and it continues to be the primary currency in terms of the reserve currency." More importantly, history suggests that verbal interventions in currency markets are only effective beyond the near term when backed by a supporting change in monetary policy. Many people remember the success that then-Treasury Secretary James Baker had in driving down the dollar following the Plaza Accord in 1985, but what is often forgotten is that the Federal Reserve steadily cut rates from 11.8% in July 1984 to 5.8% in October 1986. As a result, the 2-year interest rate differential fell by 454 bps against Japan, 630 bps against the U.K., and 407 bps against Germany over this period. It is also worth noting that the Fed's real broad trade-weighted dollar index is now 27% below its 1985 peak and 3% below its long-term average (Chart 6). This makes any effort to talk down the dollar all the more difficult. ECB Sending Mixed Messages About The Euro Chart 7Market Has Brought Forward ECB Rate Hikes Market Has Brought Forward ECB Rate Hikes Market Has Brought Forward ECB Rate Hikes ECB officials continue to send mixed messages about the resurgent euro. Earlier this month, ECB Vice President Vitor Constâncio and Bank of France Governor François Villeroy both expressed concern about the euro's strength, as did Ewald Nowotny, the fairly hawkish President of Austria's central bank. In contrast, Mario Draghi refused to wade into the debate during yesterday's press conference. The lack of angst in his tone sent the euro higher. Draghi's reluctance to say anything concrete about the euro was partly motivated by the desire to avoid the sort of "beggar thy neighbor" criticism that greeted Mnuchin's remarks. Like other central banks, the ECB gives a lot of weight to financial conditions in setting monetary policy. A stronger currency has tightened euro area financial conditions. This is something that must concern the ECB, at least behind closed doors. Ultimately, any effort by the ECB to knock down the euro will only work if it convinces the market to soften its expectations about the future pace of rate hikes. The likelihood of such an outcome is certainly higher now than it was in 2016. Our "months to hike" measure for the ECB has plummeted from over 60 months in mid-2016 to 19 today (Chart 7). Given that the ECB has made it clear that it intends to delay raising rates for some time after asset purchases end later this year, it is hard to see the central bank hiking rates before the summer of 2019. That is not far from where market pricing now stands. In contrast, if euro area growth were to surprise meaningfully on the downside or if core inflation in the peripheral economies continues to fall - it is already close to zero in Italy - the ECB could be forced to bide its time longer than the market currently expects. A Safer Way To Short EUR/USD Chart 8EUR/USD And Rate Decoupling ##br##Will Not Last Long EUR/USD And Rate Decoupling Will Not Last Long EUR/USD And Rate Decoupling Will Not Last Long Still, the euro has a lot going for it. Unlike the U.S., the euro area is running a current account surplus. This means the region does not need to attract foreign capital for there to be excess demand for euros. All it needs to do is keep net capital outflows roughly below 3% of GDP. The ability of the euro area to retain and attract fresh capital has become easier as political risk has ebbed and the ECB's pledge to do "whatever it takes" to preserve the euro has solidified. The euro's share of global central bank reserves currently stands at 20%, well below the 60% share enjoyed by the U.S. dollar. If capital continues to gravitate towards the region, the euro could strengthen further. All this makes shorting the euro a risky bet. With that in mind, investors should consider hedging short EUR/USD positions by wagering that the terminal rate spread between the euro area and the U.S. will narrow. Chart 8 shows that the spread in expected policy rates ten years out has decoupled from EUR/USD since the start of the year. The same is true for the 30-year spread between Treasurys and bunds - another good proxy for the terminal rate spread. While spreads have widened in favor of the dollar, the greenback has nonetheless plunged. Such decoupling rarely lasts long, which makes this a highly attractive trade. With that in mind, we are going short EUR/USD as a tactical trade while hedging the risk of a stronger euro by going long 30-year Treasurys/short 30-year bunds (a bet on further spread compression). Given that the first leg of the trade is more volatile than the second, we are scaling up the latter by a factor of 1.5. We will aim to close the trade for a gain of 5% (EUR/USD of about 1.18), assuming no change in the current spread of 160 bps. Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Global Investment Strategy peterb@bcaresearch.com Strategy & Market Trends Tactical Trades Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades

Highlights A thorough audit of our trade book highlights that our country and sector allocation recommendations have been quite profitable for investors. Of the 12 active trades in our book, 11 have generated a positive return, including one with a 32% annualized rate of return. A review of the original basis and subsequent performance of our trades suggests that investors should close 6 out of 12 of our active positions, predominantly related to resource & construction and domestic stock market themes. We will be looking for opportunities to add new trades to our book over the coming weeks and months that have broad, "big-picture" relevance. Watch this space. Feature In this week's report we conduct a thorough audit of our trade book, by revisiting the original basis and subsequent performance of all 12 of our active trades. While these trades have been initiated at different points over the past five years, they can be broadly grouped into five different themes: Core Equity Allocation & General Pro-Risk Trades (4 Trades) Reform-Oriented Trades (2 Trades) Resource & Construction Plays (2 Trades) Domestic Stock Market Trades (2 Trades) Trades Linked To Hong Kong (2 Trades) Overall, our trade book performance has been excellent. Of the 12 active trades in our book, 11 have generated a positive return, including one with a 32% annualized rate of return (since December 2015). As a result of our trade book review, we recommend that investors close six trades and maintain six over the coming 6-12 months. The closed trades predominantly fall into the resource & construction and domestic stock market categories, although we also recommend closing our long China H-share / short industrial commodity trade as well as our long Hong Kong REITs / short Hong Kong broad market trade. We present our rationale for retaining or closing each trade below. Over the coming weeks and months we will be looking for opportunities to add new trades to our book. Stay tuned. Core Equity Allocation & General Pro-Risk Trades We have four open core equity allocation and pro-risk trades: Overweight MSCI China Investable stocks versus the emerging markets benchmark, initiated on May 2, 2012 Long China H-shares / short industrial commodities, initiated on March 16, 2016 Short MSCI Taiwan / Long MSCI China Investable, initiated on February 2, 2017 and Long China onshore corporate bonds, initiated on June 22, 2017 We recommend that investors stick with three of these trades, but close the long China H-shares / short industrial commodities position for the following reasons: Chart 1Be Overweight China Vs EM In This Environment Be Overweight China Vs EM In This Environment Be Overweight China Vs EM In This Environment Overweight MSCI China Investable Stocks Versus The EM Benchmark (Maintain) This trade represents one of the most important equity allocation calls for Chinese stocks, and is one of the ways that BCA expresses a view on the Chinese economy in our House View Matrix.1 While it hasn't always been the case, we noted in a recent Special Report that Chinese stocks have become a high-beta equity market versus both the global aggregate and the emerging market benchmark, even when excluding the technology sector.2 China's high-beta nature, the fact that EM equities remain in an uptrend (Chart 1), and our view that China's ongoing slowdown is likely to be benign and controlled all suggest that investors should continue to overweight Chinese stocks vs their emerging market peers. Long China H-Shares / Short Industrial Commodities (Close) We initiated this trade in March 2016, one month after Chinese stock prices bottomed following the significant economic slowdown in 2015. At that time it was not clear to global investors that a mini-cycle upswing in the Chinese economy had begun, and this pair trade was a way of taking a limited pro-risk bet. Given our view of a benign, controlled economic slowdown in China, this hedged trade is no longer needed, especially given the uncertain impact of ongoing supply side constraints in China on global commodity prices. As such, we recommend that investors close the trade, locking in an annualized return of 15.7%. Short MSCI Taiwan / Long MSCI China Investable (Maintain) Chart 2If The TWD Declines Materially, ##br##Upgrade Taiwan (From Short) If The TWD Declines Materially, Upgrade Taiwan (From Short) If The TWD Declines Materially, Upgrade Taiwan (From Short) We initiated our short MSCI Taiwan / long MSCI China investable trade last February, when the risk of protectionist action from the Trump administration loomed large. While there have been no negative trade actions levied against Taiwan this year, macro factors, particularly the strength of the currency, continue to argue for an underweight stance within the greater China bourses (China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan). We reviewed the basis of this trade in a report last month,3 and recommended that investors stick with the call despite significantly oversold conditions (Chart 2). A material easing in pressure on Taiwan's trade-weighted exchange rate appears to be the most likely catalyst to close the trade and to upgrade Taiwan within a portfolio of greater China equities. Long China Onshore Corporate Bonds (Maintain) Chinese corporate bond yields have risen materially since late-2016, largely in response to expectations of tighter monetary policy. These expectations have been validated, with 3-month interbank rates having risen over 200bps since late-2016. We argued last summer that the phase of maximum liquidity tightening was likely over, and that quality spreads and government bond yields would probably drop over the coming three to six months. While this clearly did not occur (yields and spreads rose), the total return from this trade has remained in the black owing to the significant yield advantage of these bonds versus similarly-rated bonds in the developed world. Chart 3 highlights that Chinese 5-year corporate bond spreads are also considerably less correlated with equity prices than their investment-grade peers in the U.S. This underscores that the rise in yields and spreads over the past year has reflected expectations of tighter monetary policy, not rising default risk. Our sense is that barring a significant improvement in China's growth momentum, significant further monetary policy tightening is improbable, meaning that corporate bond yields are not likely to rise much further. As a final point, as of today's report we are changing the benchmark for this trade from a BCA calculation based on a basket of 5-year AAA and AA-rated corporate bonds to the ChinaBond Corporate Credit Bond Total Return Index. Chart 3Chinese Corporate Spreads Aren't A Risk ##br##Barometer Like In The U.S. Chinese Corporate Spreads Aren't A Risk Barometer Like In The U.S. Chinese Corporate Spreads Aren't A Risk Barometer Like In The U.S. Reform-Oriented Trades We have two open trades related to China's rebooted reform initiative, both of which were initiated on November 16, 2017: Long China investable consumer staples / short consumer discretionary stocks and Long China investable environmental and social governance (ESG) leaders / short investable broad market These trades were recently opened, and we continue to recommend that investors maintain both positions: Long China Investable Consumer Staples / Short Consumer Discretionary Stocks (Maintain) The basis for the first trade stems from the current limitations of China's investable consumer discretionary index as a clear-cut play on retail-oriented consumer spending. We argued in our November 16 Weekly Report that Chinese investable consumer staples would be a better play on Chinese consumer spending owing to the material weight of the automobiles & components industry group in the discretionary sector, which may fare poorly over the coming year due to the environmental mandate of President Xi's proposed reforms. We argued in the report that this trade would likely be driven by alpha rather than beta, and indeed Chart 4 illustrates that staples continue to rise relative to discretionary against a backdrop of a rising broad market. Long China Investable ESG leaders / Short Investable Broad Market (Maintain) In the same report we recommended that investors overweight the China investable ESG leaders index, based on the goal of favoring firms that are best positioned to deliver "sustainable" growth in an era of heightened environmental reforms. The index overweights firms with the highest MSCI ESG ratings in each sector (using a proprietary MSCI ranking scheme), and maintains similar sector weights as the investable benchmark, which limits the beta risk of the trade. Chart 5 highlights that the trade is progressing in line with our expectations, suggesting that investors stick with the position over the coming 6-12 months. Chart 4Staples Vs Discretionary Isn't A Low Beta Trade Staples Vs Discretionary Isn't A Low Beta Trade Staples Vs Discretionary Isn't A Low Beta Trade Chart 5Likely To Continue To Outperform Likely To Continue To Outperform Likely To Continue To Outperform Resource & Construction Plays We have two open trades related to the resource sector: Long China investable oil & gas stocks / short global oil & gas stocks, initiated on April 26, 2014 and Long China investable construction materials sector / short investable broad market, initiated on December 9, 2015 We recommend that investors close both of these positions, based on the following rationale: Chart 6Similar Earnings Profile, ##br##But Weaker Dividend Payouts Similar Earnings Profile, But Weaker Dividend Payouts Similar Earnings Profile, But Weaker Dividend Payouts Long China Investable Oil & Gas Stocks / Short Global Oil & Gas Stocks (Close) This trade was initiated based on the view that the valuation gap between Chinese and global oil & gas companies is unjustifiable given that the earnings off both sectors are globally driven. Indeed, Chart 6 shows that the trailing EPS profiles of both sectors in US$ terms have been broadly similar over the past few years, and yet China's oil & gas sector trades at a 40% price-to-book discount relative to its global peers. However, panel 2 of Chart 6 highlights that this discount may represent investor concerns about earnings quality and/or state-owned corporate governance. The chart shows that while the earnings ROE for Chinese oil & gas companies is higher than that of the global average, the dividend ROE (dividends per share as a percent of shareholders equity) is considerably lower. While China's oil & gas dividend ROE has recently been rising, the gap remains wide relative to global oil & gas companies, suggesting that there is no significant re-rating catalyst that is likely to emerge over the coming 6-12 months. Close for an annualized return of 1.4%. Long China Investable Construction Material Stocks / Short China Investable Broad Market (Close) The relative performance of Chinese investable construction material stocks has been positive over the past two years, with the trade having generated an 8.1% annualized return since initiation. There are two factors contributing to our view that it is time for investors to book profits on this trade. The first is that China's investable construction materials are dominated by cement companies, which may suffer in relative terms from China's rebooted reform initiative this year.4 The second is that the relative performance of construction materials stocks is closely correlated with, and led by, the growth in total real estate investment (Chart 7). Residential investment makes up a significant component of total real estate investment, and Chart 8 highlights that a significant gap between floor space sold and completed has narrowed the inventory to sales ratio over the past three years. But the ratio remains somewhat elevated relative to its history which, when coupled with the ongoing growth slowdown in China and the deceleration in total real estate investment growth, implies a poor risk/reward ratio over the coming 6-12 months. Chart 7Cement Producers Trade Off Of Real Estate Investment Cement Producers Trade Off Of Real Estate Investment Cement Producers Trade Off Of Real Estate Investment Chart 8No Clear Construction Boom Is Imminent No Clear Construction Boom Is Imminent No Clear Construction Boom Is Imminent Domestic Stock Market Trades We have two open trades related to China's domestic stock market: Long China domestic utility sector / short domestic broad market, initiated on January 22, 2014 and Long China domestic food & beverage sector / short domestic broad market, initiated on December 9, 2015 Similar to our resource & construction plays, we recommend that investors close both of our recommended domestic stock market trades: Long China Domestic Utility Sector / Short Domestic Broad Market (Close) We initiated this trade in early-2014, following a comprehensive reform plan released in late-2013 by the Chinese government. The plan called for allowing market forces to play a decisive role in allocating resources, which we argued would grant utilities more pricing power, reduce their earnings volatility associated with policy risks, and lead to a structural positive re-rating. Chart 9 illustrates that this trade gained significant ground in 2014 and early-2015, even prior to the significant melt-up in domestic stock prices that began in Q2 2015. However, the trade has underperformed significantly since the middle of last year, which has been driven by a sharp deterioration in ROE. This decline in ROE appears to have been cost-driven, as coal is an important feedstock for Chinese utility companies and has risen substantially in price over the past two years. While domestic utilities are now significantly oversold in relative terms, we recommend that investors close this trade because the original reform-oriented basis has shifted significantly. The priorities that emanated from October's Party Congress were decidedly environmental in nature, meaning that coal prices may very well remain elevated over the coming 6-12 months (due to restricted supply). This means that a recovery in ROE would rest on the need to raise utility prices, which is a low-visibility event that will be difficult to predict. Close for an annualized return of 3%. Long China Domestic Food & Beverage Sector / Short Domestic Broad Market (Close) We initiated this trade in December 2015, based on this sector's superior corporate fundamentals and undemanding valuation levels. We argued that the anti-corruption campaign since late-2012 was likely the cause of prior underperformance, given that the group is dominated by a few high-end alcohol producers. The market overacted to the high-profile crackdown, and ultimately the fundamentals of the sector did not deteriorate materially. Our view has panned out spectacularly, with the trade having earned a 32% annualized return since inception5 (Chart 10 panel 1). While the group's ROE remains significantly above that of the domestic benchmark, valuation measures suggest that investors have more than priced this in (Chart 10 panel 2). The trade has mostly played out and we would not like to overstay our welcome. In addition, panel 3 illustrates that technical conditions are extremely overbought, suggesting that investors are being presented with an excellent opportunity to exit the position. Chart 9Sidelined By A Major Hit To ROE Sidelined By A Major Hit To ROE Sidelined By A Major Hit To ROE Chart 10Time To Book Profits Time To Book Profits Time To Book Profits Trades Linked To Hong Kong We have two open trades related to Hong Kong: Long U.S. / short Hong Kong 10-Year government bonds, initiated on January 15, 2014 and Short Hong Kong property investors / long Hong Kong broad market, initiated on January 21, 2015 We recommend that investors stick with the first and close the second, based on the following perspectives: Long U.S. / Short Hong Kong 10-Year Government Bonds (Maintain) Hong Kong has an open capital account and an exchange rate pegged to the U.S. dollar, meaning that its monetary policy is directly tied to that of the U.S. Yet, Hong Kong's 10-year government bond yield is non-trivially below that of the U.S., which argues for a short stance versus similar maturity U.S. Treasurys. While it is true that the Hong Kong - U.S. 10-year yield spread does vary and can widen over a 6-12 month horizon, Chart 11 highlights that the relative total return profile of the trade (in unhedged terms) trends higher over time due to the carry advantage. Short Hong Kong REITs / Long Hong Kong Broad Market (Close) There are cross-currents facing the outlook for Hong Kong REITs vs the broad market, arguing for a neutral rather than an underweight stance. Close this trade for an annualized return of 3.6%. While the relative performance of global REITs is typically negatively correlated with bond yields, Chart 12 shows that the relationship with Hong Kong property yields has been positive and lagging (i.e. falling yields lead declining relative performance, and vice versa). Under this regime, a rise in U.S. government bond yields, as we expect, would suggest an improvement in the relative performance of Hong Kong REITs. Chart 11A Straightforward Carry Pick Up Trade A Straightforward Carry Pick Up Trade A Straightforward Carry Pick Up Trade Chart 12Rising Bond Yields Implies ##br##Positive HK REIT Performance Rising Bond Yields Implies Positive HK REIT Performance Rising Bond Yields Implies Positive HK REIT Performance Chart 13 highlights that periods of positive yield / REIT performance correlation have tended to occur when Hong Kong property prices are rising significantly relative to income, as they have been for the past several years. One interpretation of this dynamic is that when house prices are overvalued and potentially vulnerable, REIT investors react positively to an improvement in economic fundamentals (which tends to push yields up due to higher interest rate expectations). The risk of an eventual collapse of Hong Kong property prices is clear, but we cannot identify an obvious catalyst for this to occur over the coming 6-12 months. Importantly, the fact that property prices have continued to rise during a period of tighter mainland capital controls suggests that only a significant economic shock will be enough to derail the uptrend in prices, circumstances that we do not expect over the coming year. Finally, Chart 14 highlights that Hong Kong REITs are deeply discounted relative to book value when compared against the broad market. This suggests that at least some of the risks associated with the property market have already been priced in by investors. Chart 13Yields & REITs Positively Correlated ##br##When House Prices Are Overvalued Yields & REITs Positively Correlated When House Prices Are Overvalued Yields & REITs Positively Correlated When House Prices Are Overvalued Chart 14Hong Kong REITs Are Cheap Hong Kong REITs Are Cheap Hong Kong REITs Are Cheap Jonathan LaBerge, CFA, Vice President Special Reports jonathanl@bcaresearch.com Lin Xiang, Research Analyst linx@bcaresearch.com 1 https://www.bcaresearch.com/trades 2 Please see China Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "China: No Longer A Low-Beta Market", dated January 11, 2018, available at cis.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see China Investment Strategy Weekly Report "Taiwan: Awaiting A Re-Rating Catalyst", dated December 14, 2017, available at cis.bcaresearch.com. 4 Please see China Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "Messages From The Market, Post-Party Congress", dated November 16, 2017, available at cis.bcaresearch.com. 5 Please note that the total return from this trade had been erroneously reported for some time due a data processing error on BCA's part. The return since inception now properly sources the China CSI SWS Food & Beverage index from CHOICE. We sincerely regret the error and any confusion it may have caused. Cyclical Investment Stance Equity Sector Recommendations

Highlights While bullish sentiment for copper remains high, concerns that policymakers' attempts at a managed slowdown in China this year goes too far will weigh on the market. Fundamentally, support for copper prices from potential supply shortfalls at both the mining and refining levels will be offset by a stronger USD and slower growth in China this year (Chart of the Week). Despite our expectation a slight physical supply deficit will emerge this year, we remain neutral copper. We do not believe this will be enough to rally prices in a meaningful way. Energy: Overweight. Ministers from Saudi Arabia and Russia confirmed OPEC 2.0 - the oil-producer coalition led by these states - will survive beyond the expiry of their production-management deal at the end of this year. What and how they will manage the production of coalition members, however, remains unknown. Base Metals: Neutral. Positive fundamentals for copper are at risk if the USD rallies on the back of Fed tightening this year or China's managed economic slowdown is too severe (see below). Precious Metals: Neutral. Gold prices remained well bid, despite expectations for three or four Fed rate hikes this year, suggesting the market is pricing in either fewer rate hikes and lower real rates, or geopolitical risk - most prominently in Venezuela or North Korea. We remain long gold as a strategic portfolio hedge. Ags/Softs: Underweight. Soybean has been gaining ground on concerns about yield damage due to droughts in parts of Argentina. Expectations of a bumper year for Brazil will mitigate the impact on global supply. Feature Bullish copper sentiment is at a multi-year high, with four bulls for every bear in the market (Chart 2). The strong global economy, weak USD, and elevated risk of further supply-side disruptions - at mines as well as at the refining level - are feeding into buyers' optimism. Chart of the WeekChina Fears Weighing##BR##On Copper Prices China Fears Weighing On Copper Prices China Fears Weighing On Copper Prices Chart 2Bullish Sentiment Remains##BR##At Multi-Year Highs Bullish Sentiment Remains At Multi-Year Highs Bullish Sentiment Remains At Multi-Year Highs Our outlook for 2018 calls for another, albeit smaller, refined copper deficit (Chart 3). This will come on the back of escalated risks from supply side disruptions at mines in Chile and Peru, and potential constraints on primary and secondary refined output from China, the largest refined copper producer (Table 1). Chart 3A (Smaller) Deficit##BR##In 2018 A (Smaller) Deficit In 2018 A (Smaller) Deficit In 2018 Table 1China Is Significant For##BR##Copper Supply And Demand Stronger USD, Slower China Growth Threaten Copper Stronger USD, Slower China Growth Threaten Copper China also is the world's largest refined-copper consumer, which makes the risk of a more severe downturn in China arising from too much policy-driven restraint in the metal's top consumer acute. In the following sections, we present our expectations for the fundamentals: copper mine output, refined copper production, and refined copper consumption. Industrial Action Will Threaten Mine Output Again In 2018 Copper had an exceptional year in 2017. The synchronized global upturn and weak USD set the stage for a memorable performance. On the supply-side, disruptions at some of the world's largest mines pushed prices up 8% in 1H17. Although the risk of further production shocks had subsided by 2H17, copper gained another 22% on the back of restrictive Chinese scrap import policies and better than expected demand fundamentals. Last year, the copper market registered a physical deficit, mainly on the back of a decline in copper mine supply. A 0.3% yoy fall in copper ores and concentrate output in the first eleven months of the year kept production broadly unchanged compared to the same period last year. In fact, this was the first yoy decline for that period since 2002, and contrasts with an average 5% expansion in ore and concentrate output for that period since 2012 (Chart 4). The most notable supply side disruptions last year were: Chart 4Supply Disruptions Put##BR##Copper In Deficit Last Year Supply Disruptions Put Copper In Deficit Last Year Supply Disruptions Put Copper In Deficit Last Year A 9% yoy decline in output from top producer Chile in 1H17. Chile accounts for more than a quarter of global ore & concentrate supply. The decline is a result of strikes at the Escondida mine as well as lower output from Codelco mines. The Indonesian government's ban on exports of copper ores in the first four months of the year led to a 6% yoy decline in production in the first eleven months. U.S. output, which accounts for~7% of global copper ores & concentrates supply is down 12% yoy in the first eleven months of 2017. In fact, the last time the U.S. recorded a positive yoy growth rate was in October 2016. The decline in U.S. output came mainly on the back of lower grade ores, a fall in mining rates, and poor weather conditions. The majority of these disruptions occurred in 1H17 - the first five months of the year witnessed a 1.6% yoy fall in output, while the Jun-Oct period experienced a 0.7% yoy increase. Nonetheless, the ramp up in second part of the year is significantly slower than the 6% yoy and 5% yoy increases in the same period in 2015 and 2016. Global supply was partially supported by Peruvian and European production. Peruvian output grew 3.6% yoy in the first eleven months of the year. However this rate is dwarfed in comparison to previous years. Output grew almost 40% yoy in 2016 and 23% yoy in 2015. Similarly, European output - which accounts for 8% of global supply - seems to be continuing its uptrend. It expanded by 2.4% in the first eleven months of 2017 to record the highest level of output for that period. In fact, growth in output is above the average 0.8% yoy pace in the same period in 2014-2016. We expect a small rebound in mine production in 2018. According to the International Copper Study Group, temporarily shut down capacity in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) and Zambia will resume operations, supporting mine supply this year. Supply-side disruptions pose a significant risk to mine supply again this year. An estimated more than 30 labor contracts, representing ~5mm MT of mined copper - a quarter of global production - will expire this year.1 While surely not all of these negotiations will result in strikes and supply disruptions, the figure is noteworthy as it is significantly above the average 1.7mm MT worth of annual copper supply at risk from contract renewal between 2011 and 2016. The most significant of these renewals is that which was most damaging last year. The 44-day strike at BHP Billiton's Escondida mine in Chile last year, which resulted in a 7.8% yoy fall at the world's most productive copper mine, ended without agreement. Although the contracts were extended, they are due for renegotiation in June. In fact, one of the unions at Escondida held a day long "warning strike" in November, an indication that they do not intend to back down from their demands. Unless management gives in, this implies a heightened risk of disruptions. Bottom Line: Supply disruptions negatively impacted mine supply in some of the world's top producers in 1H17. Although European and Peruvian supply has been somewhat supportive, global supply stagnated in 2017. Industrial action remains the major risk to mined copper this year. 5mm MT worth of copper ores and concentrates are at risk of supply side disruptions in 2018 - the highest figure since 2010. Environmental Reforms Limit Refined Production From China Chart 5China's Scrap Imports Cushion##BR##Against High Prices China's Scrap Imports Cushion Against High Prices China's Scrap Imports Cushion Against High Prices World refined production grew 1.3% yoy in the first eleven months of 2017, the slowest growth rate for that period since 2009. This reflects significant declines in refined copper production in Chile and the U.S. Supply disruptions at mines in Chile - the world's second-largest producer of refined copper - led to a 182k MT fall in refined output in the first eleven months of 2017, compared to the same period in 2016. Refined output from the U.S. fell by 91.4k MT in that period. However, the downside pressure on refined output from lower ore production was mitigated by increased secondary production from scrap, which accounts for ~20% of global refined copper production. Chinese copper producers took advantage of the oversupply in global scrap and ramped up their production. According to the ICSG global secondary output expanded by almost 10% yoy in the first ten months of last year. China's copper scrap imports increased 9% yoy in the first eleven months of last year, following four years of declines (Chart 5). China makes up less than 10% of global mined copper, but it is the largest producer of refined copper in the world, accounting for 36% of the global production. China is expected to remain the main contributor to world refined production growth (Chart 6). However, Beijing's environmental reforms, and measures to curb the imports of "foreign trash" will limit secondary refined production. Chart 6China Remains Most Significant Factor In Refined Production Growth Stronger USD, Slower China Growth Threaten Copper Stronger USD, Slower China Growth Threaten Copper New policies affecting refined output in China are supportive of copper prices this year: 1. In relation to scrap copper, Beijing recently imposed two policy changes, in line with its environmental reforms. First, since the start of 2018, only copper scrap end-users and processors will be granted import licenses. Second, a proposal to limit the hazardous impurity levels in scrap copper imports to 1% by March. Both these policies will curtail China's scrap copper imports. China imports an estimated 3mm MT of scrap copper annually, accounting for roughly half of its total scrap copper supply. Such limitations would severely dent China's scrap supply. Furthermore, scrap copper imports play a significant role in China. They act as a buffer against high prices, soaring during periods of high prices and dwindling when prices are low - as they were between 2013 and 2016. If China does in fact go through with the tighter regulations on scrap imports, Chinese copper consumers would not be able to fall back on the secondary metal when prices rise - as they have been over the past year - leading to greater demand for imports of primary products, chasing prices higher. However, over the long term, we are likely to see Chinese scrap traders move their businesses offshore, notably in Southeast Asia, where they will process the scrap until it meets the regulations necessary to be imported by China.2 In fact, this has already started to happen in the case of the category 7 scrap - derived from end-of-life electronics, households, cars and industrial products - which is widely believed will be banned by year-end. Nevertheless, these recycling plants do not yet exist. Thus, the transition cannot occur overnight, and we expect the tighter policies on scrap imports to support prices in the interim as China increases its imports of ores and refined copper in order to fill the supply gap. 2. China's environmental reforms also pose a risk on refined supply this year. Smelters and refiners risk being shut down if they do not comply with tighter pollution controls. This could limit copper output this year. Similar to the winter production cuts occurring at steel and aluminum producers, China's second largest copper smelter - Tongling Nonferrous Metals Group - announced plans to reduce its smelter capacity by up to 30% during the winter.3 In addition, late last month, China's largest smelter - Jiangxi Copper Co. - was forced to curb output while local pollution levels were assessed.4 The extent to which these measures are adopted by other producers will interrupt refined output this year. Given the more elevated pollution levels during the winter months, this risk is most notable in the November to March period. Bottom Line: The major risk to refined copper supply is China's environmental reforms which will likely constrain copper scrap imports, and could lead to temporary shutdowns of polluting smelters and refineries. If Beijing tightens these regulations, we are likely to witness disruptions in both primary and secondary refined output, while the copper supply chain readjusts to be able to comply with these policies. Slowdown In China Would Temper Copper World refined copper consumption grew 0.8% yoy in the first eleven months of 2017. Weaker consumption was mainly in the 1H17, during which global consumption fell 1.8% yoy, whereas consumption in the July-to-November period accelerated by 3.9% yoy. Weaker demand in the first half of the year came on the back of weaker demand from China, which accounts for half of global consumption. China recorded a 7.7% yoy fall in consumption of refined copper in the January-to-April period. However, Chinese copper demand subsequently strengthened, accelerating by 7.4% yoy in the May-to-November period. While demand from the rest of the world muted the impact of weaker Chinese consumption in the first half of the year, it weakened in the second half of the year, falling 3.3% yoy in the May-to-October period. This fall in copper demand was driven by a 5.5% yoy fall in the U.S., and to a lesser extent, a 2.0% yoy fall in demand in Japan in the May-to-November period. According to China Customs data, China's refined copper imports fell 5.1% in 2017 after growing 3.7% in 2016 (Chart 7). However, what is noteworthy is that while imports fell 18.3% yoy in H1, they picked up in H2, increasing by 11.3% yoy, mainly on the back of strong demand in Q3. This is in line with strong economic performance in China in 2H17 - an upside surprise which supported copper prices. Going into 2018, we expect a managed deceleration in China - and in China's demand for copper - to be mitigated by stronger demand from the rest of the world. In fact, the IMF revised up its 2018 and 2019 global growth forecasts in the latest WEO Update earlier this week (Table 2). Global growth is now forecast to reach 3.9% in 2018, up from the estimated 3.7% last year. Chart 7China's Q4 Imports Were Strong China's Q4 Imports Were Strong China's Q4 Imports Were Strong Table 2Upward Revisions To IMF Growth Projections Stronger USD, Slower China Growth Threaten Copper Stronger USD, Slower China Growth Threaten Copper Chart 8Speed Bump Ahead For China? Speed Bump Ahead For China? Speed Bump Ahead For China? That said, our China construction Indicator - which includes several variables measuring construction activity in China - shows strong growth in the main end-user for copper (Chart 8). Given that building construction accounts for 43% of copper end-use in China, this indicates demand for copper should remain healthy in the near term. Furthermore, despite concerns of a slowdown, China's manufacturing PMI still points to a healthy economy. Even so, a decline in the Li Keqiang Index, which tracks industrial activity, warrants caution and could be signaling trouble ahead for the Chinese economy. In addition, government spending has decelerated significantly from its mid-2017 peak. Against these risks, the global economy is expected to remain strong. Thus the biggest risk to our assessment is a pronounced deceleration in China which would hit demand for the red metal. Bottom Line: The major risk to refined copper demand this year is a slowdown from China. Downside Risk From A Stronger USD In addition to the fundamental variables highlighted above, U.S. monetary policy - and its effect on the USD - will also be an important driver of the copper market. We expect the Fed to embark on its interest rate normalization process more aggressively this year, hiking its policy rate up to four times. This would see copper prices weaken as the red metal becomes more expensive in USD terms. The USD is significant because a weaker dollar means that dollar-based commodities are cheaper for foreign buyers. Thus, foreigners tend to buy dollar-denominated commodities when the USD is weak, and sell when the USD is strong, in order to also benefit from exchange rate differentials. Continued weakness of the USD has been supportive of copper prices since the beginning of 2017. A risk to our outlook is an unexpectedly dovish Fed, which would keep the dollar muted and be favorable to copper. Bottom Line: We expect the copper market to record a small physical deficit this year. A stronger USD and deceleration in China will prevent a repeat of 2017's performance. However supply side disruptions at the mine and refined levels will provide opportunities for some upside in the market. Synchronized global demand will be a tailwind throughout the year. In the near term, we expect copper to continue gyrating around its current level of $3.10/lb. Absent a marked slowdown in China, we expect a rally into mid-year as contract renegotiations get underway. Roukaya Ibrahim, Associate Editor Commodity & Energy Strategy RoukayaI@bcaresearch.com Hugo Bélanger, Research Analyst HugoB@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see "Copper soars to 4-year high as funds bet on shortages," dated December 28, 2017, available at reuters.com. 2 Please see "As China restricts scrap metal companies look to process copper abroad," dated January 8, 2018, available at reuters.com. 3 Please see "Chinese Copper Smelter Halts Capacity to Ease Winter Pollution," dated December 7, 2017, available at Bloomberg.com. 4 Please see "Copper Rallies to Three-Year High as China Plant Halts Output," dated December 26, 2017, available at Bloomberg.com. Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Stronger USD, Slower China Growth Threaten Copper Stronger USD, Slower China Growth Threaten Copper Trades Closed in 2018 Summary of Trades Closed in 2017 Stronger USD, Slower China Growth Threaten Copper Stronger USD, Slower China Growth Threaten Copper

Highlights Trade #1: Go Short The December 2018 Fed Funds Futures Contract. The trade has gained 64 bps since we initiated it. We are lifting the stop to 60 bps and targeting a profit of 75 bps. Trade #2: Go Long Global Industrial Stocks Versus Utilities. The trade is up 13.1%. We are targeting a profit of 15%, and are tightening the stop further to 12%. Trade #3: Go Short 20-Year JGBs Relative To Their 5-Year Counterparts. The trade is up 0.7%. We see this as a multi-year trade with significant upside potential. The unwinding of heavy short positions could cause the yen to strengthen temporarily. The euro is vulnerable to negative growth surprises. A retracement of some of its recent gains is likely. Feature Looking Back, Thinking Forward I had the pleasure of speaking at BCA's Annual Investment Conference held in New York on September 27th of last year where I offered three "tantalizing" trade ideas. Chart 1 reviews their performance. They were the following: Trade #1: Go Short The December 2018 Fed Funds Futures Contract We argued last summer that U.S. growth was likely to accelerate, taking rate expectations higher. That has indeed happened. Aggregate hours worked rose by 2.5% in Q4 over the previous quarter. Assuming that productivity increased by 1.5% in Q4 - equal to the pace recorded in Q3 - real GDP probably increased by nearly 4%. A variety of leading indicators point to continued above-trend growth in the months ahead (Chart 2). Chart 1Three Tantalizing Trades: ##br##An Update Three Tantalizing Trades: An Update Three Tantalizing Trades: An Update Chart 2Leading Indicators Pointing ##br##To Above-Trend U.S. Growth Leading Indicators Pointing To Above-Trend U.S. Growth Leading Indicators Pointing To Above-Trend U.S. Growth We think the Fed will raise rates four times this year, one more hike than projected by the dots and roughly 35 bps more in tightening than implied by current market expectations. The median Fed dot calls for an unemployment rate of 3.9% by end-2018, only marginally lower than today's rate of 4.1%. We have been saying for a while that above-trend growth will take the unemployment rate down to a 49-year low of 3.5% by the end of this year. If the unemployment rate falls this much, the Fed will probably turn more hawkish. Stronger inflation numbers should also give the Fed confidence to keep raising rates once per quarter. Core inflation surprised on the upside in December. We expect this trend to continue in the coming months, as the ISM manufacturing index, the New York Fed's Inflation Gauge, and our own proprietary pipeline inflation index are already foreshadowing (Chart 3). Chart 3U.S. Inflation ##br##Should Accelerate U.S. Inflation Should Accelerate U.S. Inflation Should Accelerate Chart 4A Pick-Up In Wage Growth ##br##Would Put Upward Pressure On Service Inflation A Pick-Up In Wage Growth Would Put Upward Pressure On Service Inflation A Pick-Up In Wage Growth Would Put Upward Pressure On Service Inflation As we noted two weeks ago,1 service sector inflation should get a lift from faster wage growth this year (Chart 4). Goods inflation should also rise on the back of higher oil prices and the lagged effects of a weaker dollar (Chart 5). In addition, health care inflation is likely to pick up from its current depressed level, especially if the Congressional Budget Office is correct that insurance premiums will rise due to the elimination of the individual mandate (Chart 6). Housing inflation will moderate, but this is unlikely to stymie the Fed's tightening plans since excessively low interest rates could lead to even more overbuilding in the increasingly vulnerable commercial real estate sector. Chart 5Higher Oil Prices And A Weaker Dollar ##br##Are A Tailwind For Inflation Higher Oil Prices And A Weaker Dollar Are A Tailwind For Inflation Higher Oil Prices And A Weaker Dollar Are A Tailwind For Inflation Chart 6Health Care Inflation ##br##Should Move Higher Health Care Inflation Should Move Higher Health Care Inflation Should Move Higher Granted, four rate hikes equal four opportunities to defer raising rates. It is easy to imagine scenarios where the Fed stands pat, but hard to conjure scenarios where the Fed has to raise rates five times or more this year. Thus, the risk to our four-hike view is to the downside. As such, we will be looking to take profits of 75 bps on the trade, and are putting in a stop of 60 bps. Trade #2: Go Long Global Industrial Stocks Versus Utilities Capital spending tends to accelerate in the late innings of business-cycle expansions. We are in such a phase now, as evidenced by capital goods orders, capex intention surveys, and our global capex model (Chart 7). Increased capital spending will benefit industrial companies. Conversely, rising bond yields will hurt rate-sensitive utilities. Valuations in the industrial sector have gotten stretched, but are not at extreme levels (Chart 8). Based on enterprise value-to-EBITDA, industrials are still only slightly more expensive than utilities compared to their post-1990 average. Chart 7Capex Is Shifting Into ##br##Higher Gear Capex Is Shifting Into Higher Gear Capex Is Shifting Into Higher Gear Chart 8Industrial Stocks: Valuations Are Stretched, ##br## But Not Yet Extreme Industrial Stocks: Valuations Are Stretched, But Not Yet Extreme Industrial Stocks: Valuations Are Stretched, But Not Yet Extreme While we do think global growth will slow this year from the heady pace of 2017, it should remain firmly above-trend. A bigger-than-expected slowdown - especially if it is concentrated in China - would undoubtedly hurt industrials. A stronger dollar could also be a headwind. Thus, we are keeping this trade on a short leash, with a target of 15% and a stop of 12%. Trade #3: Go Short 20-Year JGBs Relative To Their 5-Year Counterparts The Japanese economy is on fire. Growth almost reached 2% in 2017 and leading indicators suggest a solid start to 2018 (Chart 9). The unemployment rate has fallen to 2.7%, a full point below 2007 levels. The ratio of job openings-to-applicants has surpassed its bubble peak. The Tankan Employment Conditions Index is pointing to an exceptionally tight labor market. Wages excluding overtime pay are rising at the fastest pace in twenty years (Chart 10). Chart 9Japanese Growth Momentum Is Positive Japanese Growth Momentum Is Positive Japanese Growth Momentum Is Positive Chart 10Signs Of A Tight Labor Market Signs Of A Tight Labor Market Signs Of A Tight Labor Market Inflation is low but is starting to edge up. The most recent release surprised on the upside. Inflation expectations moved higher on the news, benefiting our long Japanese 10-year CPI swap trade recommendation (Chart 11). A simple scatterplot between the unemployment rate and core inflation suggests the Phillips curve remains intact in Japan -- amazingly, it even looks like Japan (Chart 12)! Chart 11Inflation Expectations Have Edged Higher Inflation Expectations Have Edged Higher Inflation Expectations Have Edged Higher Chart 12The Phillips Curve In Japan Looks Like Japan Three Tantalizing Trades - Four Months On Three Tantalizing Trades - Four Months On Still, with core inflation excluding food and energy running at only 0.3%, there is a long way to go before inflation reaches the BoJ's target -- and even longer if the BoJ honours its promise to generate a meaningful overshoot to compensate for the below-target inflation of prior years. This suggests the BoJ will not meaningfully water down its Yield Curve Control regime anytime soon. As such, five-year yields are likely to stay put while yields with maturities in excess of ten years should move higher. Our "tantalizing trade" being short 20-year JGBs versus their 5-year counterparts still has a long way to run. Too Risky To Short The Yen The exceptionally strong correlation between USD/JPY and U.S. Treasury yields has broken down this year (Chart 13). Had the relationship held, the yen would have actually weakened against the dollar. Still, we are reluctant to get too bearish on the yen (Chart 14). The yen real effective exchange rate is close to multi-decade lows. Positioning on the currency is heavily short. The current account surplus has mushroomed from close to zero in 2014 to 4% of GDP at present. And even if the BoJ keeps the Yield Curve Control regime in place, investors may still anticipate its demise, leading to a temporary bout of yen strength. Chart 13Strong Correlation Is Broken Strong Correlation Is Broken Strong Correlation Is Broken Chart 14Too Risky To Short The Yen Too Risky To Short The Yen Too Risky To Short The Yen What's Propping Up The Euro? The euro has been on a tear since last week, egged on by the ECB minutes, which hinted at a faster pace of monetary normalization. Growing confidence that Angela Merkel will be able to form a grand coalition also helped the common currency, along with hopes that the new government will loosen the fiscal purse strings. The euro is often thought of as the "anti-dollar." And sure enough, the euro's strength has been reflected in a broad-based decline in the dollar index in recent days. BCA's Global Investment Strategy service went long the dollar on October 31, 2014. We "doubled up" on this call in the fall of 2016, controversially arguing that "Trump will win and the dollar will rally." Obviously, in retrospect, I should have rung the register and declared victory on our long dollar view when I had the chance. EUR/USD fell to 1.04 on December 2016, within striking distance of our parity target. Bullish dollar sentiment had reached unsustainably lofty levels. That was the time to sell the greenback. But hubris got the best of me. While our other currency trade recommendations have delivered net gains of 11% since the start of 2017, the long DXY trade has stuck out like a sore thumb. Hindsight is 20/20. The key question is what to do today. EUR/USD is still trading below the level it was at when we went long the DXY. Relative to the IMF's Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate of 1.32, the euro is 7% undervalued. That said, PPP exchange rates may not be a reliable benchmark in this case. Given current market expectations, EUR/USD would need to strengthen to 1.41 over the next ten years just to cover the carry cost of being short the dollar. Even assuming lower inflation in the euro area, that would still leave the euro trading above its long-term fair value. It is possible, of course, that rate differentials will narrow further, but the scope for this is more limited than it might appear. The market currently expects policy rates ten years out to be 95 basis points higher in the U.S., down from a spread of nearly 180 basis points in late December (Chart 15). Given that euro area inflation expectations are 40-to-50 bps lower than in the U.S., this implies a real spread of about 50 bps - broadly in line with our estimate of the real neutral rate gap between the two regions. Ultimately, the fate of the euro in 2018 will rest on the same question that drove the currency in 2017: Will euro area growth surprise on the upside, prompting investors to price in a faster pace of monetary normalization? The bar for success is certainly higher at present. Chart 16 shows that euro area consensus growth estimates have risen significantly since the start of last year. The expected lift-off date for policy rates has also shifted in by more than a year to mid-2019. Considering that Jens Weidmann stated earlier this week that he thinks current market pricing is broadly consistent with when the ECB expects to hike rates, there is little scope for the lift-off date to move forward. Chart 15Little Scope For Rate Differentials ##br## To Narrow Further Little Scope For Rate Differentials To Narrow Further Little Scope For Rate Differentials To Narrow Further Chart 16Euro Area Growth Estimates Have Been Revised Up ##br##Since The Start Of 2017 Euro Area Growth Estimates Have Been Revised Up Since The Start Of 2017 Euro Area Growth Estimates Have Been Revised Up Since The Start Of 2017 Meanwhile, financial conditions have tightened significantly in the euro area relative to the U.S., the euro area credit impulse has turned negative, and the U.S. economic surprise index has jumped above that of the euro area (Chart 17). Euro area inflation has also dipped. Especially worrying is that core inflation in Italy has fallen back to a near record-low of 0.4% (Chart 18). How is Italy supposed to navigate its way out of its debt trap if nominal growth stays this weak? On top of all that, long speculative euro positions have soared to record-high levels (Chart 19). Given the choice of betting whether EUR/USD will first hit 1.30 or 1.15, we would go with the latter. If our bet turns out to be correct, we will use that opportunity to shift to neutral on the dollar. Chart 17The Euro Is Vulnerable ##br##To Negative Growth Surprises The Euro Is Vulnerable To Negative Growth Surprises The Euro Is Vulnerable To Negative Growth Surprises Chart 18Euro Area Core Inflation ##br##Has Dipped Euro Area Core Inflation Has Dipped Euro Area Core Inflation Has Dipped Chart 19Euro Positioning: From Deeply Short ##br##To Record Long Euro Positioning: From Deeply Short To Record Long Euro Positioning: From Deeply Short To Record Long Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Global Investment Strategy peterb@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Global Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "Four Key Questions On The 2018 Global Growth Outlook," dated January 5, 2018. Strategy & Market Trends Tactical Trades Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades

Highlights The euro is in a cyclical bull market. It is supported by attractive valuations, improving balance of payments dynamics, declining political risk, potential shifts in reserves preferences, and a re-rating of the European terminal rate. This positive cyclical backdrop hides a more treacherous short-term outlook. EUR/USD is vulnerable because ECB members are increasingly worried, the European periphery is displaying early strains, European inflation will slow versus the U.S., global industrial activity may experience a mini down cycle, and sentiment measures are massively stretched. Short EUR/JPY for now, and use any move in EUR/USD to 1.15 or lower to buy this pair. Feature The euro has undergone a major paradigm shift over the course of the past 16 months. In December 2016, the euro was trading near parity, and expectations were uniform that it would fall well below that threshold. The narrative was simple: Europe was turning Japanese, with inflation forever moribund; also, Europe was succumbing to the siren call of nationalism and populism, which meant the euro was bound to break up within the next five years. Meanwhile, the U.S. was on the rebound. Core consumer price inflation was above 2.2%, and U.S. President Donald Trump was set to massively stimulate the American economy, giving a free hand for the Federal Reserve to hike to its heart's content. Today, the picture could not be more different. Investors expect the European Central Bank's first hike to materialize in the summer of 2019, European growth is stellar, and European inflation is not low enough to warrant emergency-level policy rates. As a result, not only is EUR/USD trading above 1.20, but consensus forecasts increasingly see the euro trading into the 1.25 to 1.30 zone by year end. Is EUR/USD at 1.22 a buying or a selling opportunity? Short-term risks are currently elevated for the euro, but a move toward 1.15 would represent a buying opportunity, as the cyclical bear market in the euro is over. The Long-Term Bull Case A crucial long-term positive factor for the euro is that it is cheap. EUR/USD currently trades at a 10% discount to its purchasing-power-parity equilibrium, even after a nearly 17% rally since its December 2016 low. Encapsulating this concept, the real effective exchange rate for the euro remains well below equilibrium (Chart I-1). Additionally, our fundamental long-term fair value model pegs the euro as being almost 1-sigma undervalued. The euro area's balance of payment is also very favorable. It is well known among the investment community that the euro area sports a surplus of 3.5% of GDP, but significant changes are also materializing in the capital account. Portfolios outflows out of the euro area have begun to decrease, as equity inflows are rising and bond outflows are becoming smaller. Moreover, the euro area basic balance is moving into positive territory, which historically has been a precursor to sustainable euro rallies (Chart I-2). The supply of euro for international markets is therefore decreasing. Additionally, the euro area's net international investment position (NIIP), which was as low as -17% of GDP in 2014, will likely move into positive territory toward the end of the year. The NIIP has historically been a strong driver of long-term exchange rate moves.1 Chart I-1The Euro Is Still Cheap The Euro Is Still Cheap The Euro Is Still Cheap Chart I-2The European Balance Of Payments Has Improved The European Balance Of Payments Has Improved The European Balance Of Payments Has Improved Politics too have been moving in the right direction. Euro skepticism is not taking hold in the euro area: Last year's French election was a vivid demonstration that "more Europe" is not electoral poison. Even the Italian elections this coming March may not land much of a blow to the European project: The Five Star Movement is rapidly softening its anti-euro rhetoric, and support for centrist parties is strengthening (Chart I-3). Moreover, a German move toward a grand coalition means Angela Merkel's CDU is very likely to be governing along with a pro-euro SPD, whose campaign theme was "MEGA": Make Europe Great Again. Already, Germany is lending a listening ear to some of Macron's integrationist proposals, and fiscal stimulus could well be in the pipeline. Long-term reserves diversification is also in the euro's favor. A headline last week suggested that China would unload some of its vast holdings of Treasurys. This leak was soon condemned as "Fake News" by China's State Administration of Foreign Exchange. However, while the news clearly lacked substance, the reality remains that despite the euro area and the U.S. being similarly sized economies, the euro only represents 20% of allocated global reserves, compared to 65% for the greenback. The greater depth and liquidity of U.S. bond markets contributes to this discrepancy, but the ECB's bond buying, by creating a scarcity of euro denominated securities, has exacerbated the disparity. This latter handicap for the euro will end sometime next fall, and if Europe's integrates further, European bond markets will increasingly become alternatives to U.S. ones. A rebalancing of reserves would principally help the euro by hurting the U.S. dollar: It will become more tenuous for the U.S. to achieve a positive international income balance while sporting a NIIP of -40% of GDP if official international demand for dollars falls (Chart I-4). Chart I-3Italian Centrists Are Gaining Ground Italian Centrists Are Gaining Ground Italian Centrists Are Gaining Ground Chart I-4The USD Needs Its Reserve Status The USD Needs Its Reserve Status The USD Needs Its Reserve Status Finally, the terminal rates differential between the U.S. and the euro area remains well above its long-term average of 110 basis points. Thus, there is scope for a normalization of European terminal rates relative to the U.S. on a long-term basis (Chart I-5). However, an average is only a number. What forces could cause the terminal rate spread between the euro area and the U.S. to normalize over the coming years? European policy is currently very loose when compared to the U.S., which will enable the ECB to play catchup over the coming years. To make this judgment, we look at broad money supply in excess of money demand. Because money demand is an unobserved variable, we have to estimate it. Economic theory argues it should be a positive function of economic activity, wealth and uncertainty. Therefore, to get a sense of what money demand may be, we regress the real broad money aggregates of various countries on uncertainty indices and real wealth.2 The difference between real broad money supply numbers and these estimates represent excess money supply. If a country's excess money is being generated today, it ends up stimulating future economic activity and inflation. This increase in expected nominal growth should contribute to lifting expected interest rates at the long end of the yield curve - i.e. expected terminal rates. As Chart I-6 shows, the stock of excess money supply in the U.S. has stopped growing since 2015. However, it is currently exploding in the euro area as European commercial banks are regaining their health and lending again. The money supply dynamics in Europe signal that the easy policy of the ECB is finally bearing fruit. And as the bottom panel of Chart I-6 illustrates, when European excess money supply increases relative to the U.S., as is currently the case, EUR/USD experiences cyclical rallies.3 This counterinituitive result exists because previous ECB easing is bearing fruits, European asset returns are rising, and economic activity is increasing. As a result, the European terminal rate now has more scope to rise vis-à-vis the U.S. The steepening of the German yield curve relative to the Treasury curve only confirms this message (Chart I-7). Chart I-5The U.S. Terminal Rate Has Room To Fall##br## Against That Of Europe The U.S. Terminal Rate Has Room To Fall Against That Of Europe The U.S. Terminal Rate Has Room To Fall Against That Of Europe Chart I-6European Excess##br## Money Is Surging European Excess Money Is Surging European Excess Money Is Surging Chart I-7Listen To Yield ##br##Curves Listen To Yield Curves Listen To Yield Curves The five forces described above imply that the euro's move from 1.03 to 1.21 was the first salvo in what is likely to be a long cyclical bull market that could end up driving the euro above 1.40 over many years. However, these factors provide little insight regarding the euro's path over the next three to six months. Bottom Line: The euro is likely to have embarked on a cyclical bull market at the beginning of 2017. Five factors support this judgment: The euro is cheap, the European balance-of-payment backdrop is favorable, political winds in the euro area remain favorable to further European integration, global foreign exchange reserves are very underweight the euro, and the spread between U.S. and euro area expected terminal rates remains well above its long-term average, and has scope to narrow. Murkier Short-Term Outlook While the long-term outlook is very favorable for the euro, the shorter-term outlook is much more clouded. First, the chorus of complaints against the euro's strength is growing among European central bankers. In recent days, not only have Vitor Constâncio and Francois Villeroy voiced concerns over the euro's recent strength, but so has Ewald Nowotny, the rather hawkish Austrian central banker. Additionally, Bundesbank President Jens Weidmann stated that the market should not anticipate a rate hike before the summer of 2019, suggesting he would not want to see a more aggressive rate pricing than what is currently at play (Chart I-8). Second, the less competitive and more fragile European periphery is already showing early signs that the sharp appreciation in the euro is causing some pain. Peripheral equities have begun to underperform the stocks of core euro area nations, and are also sharply underperforming U.S. equities. This phenomenon tends to be associated with a weakening euro. Moreover, peripheral inflation excluding food and energy has already weakened to 1.3% from a high of 2% in February last year, the consequence of a tightening in financial conditions (Chart I-9). Chart I-8ECB Doesn't Want This To Change ECB Doesn't Want This To Change ECB Doesn't Want This To Change Chart I-9Peripheral Core Inflation In Free Fall Peripheral Core Inflation In Free Fall Peripheral Core Inflation In Free Fall Third, the economic environment points to underperformance of aggregate European inflation relative to the U.S. A fall in the gap between euro area and U.S. inflation tends to be associated with short-term gyrations in EUR/USD (Chart I-10). This is because a fall in relative inflation against the euro area causes investors to temporarily tweak the perceived path of future policy differentials. Over the course of 2018, U.S. inflation is set to increase. A simple model based on U.S. capacity utilization and the velocity of money shows that U.S. core CPI could hit 2.1% (Chart I-11). While this model has done a good job picking the turning points in U.S. core inflation, it has consistently overestimated inflation since 2013. Correcting for this bias, the model still forecasts a significant pick-up in inflation to 1.8% (Chart I-11, bottom panel). Chart I-10Higher European Inflation Equals Higher Euro Higher European Inflation Equals Higher Euro Higher European Inflation Equals Higher Euro Chart I-11A U.S. Inflation Pick Up Is Coming A U.S. Inflation Pick Up Is Coming A U.S. Inflation Pick Up Is Coming The same cannot be said for euro area inflation. Not only is the European periphery already feeling the pain caused by the euro's strength, but also we have entered the window of time where the previous tightening in euro area financial conditions vis-à-vis the U.S. puts a brake on euro area relative inflation.4 Moreover, the diffusion index of the components of the euro area core CPI index has been below 50% for four months in a row now. Historically, this has been associated with a fall in core CPI. Fourth, over the past year or so, EUR/USD has traded in line with risk assets. The euro area has benefited from EM growth improvement, which has lifted all corners of the global economy levered to the global industrial cycle. As a result, as investors become increasingly bullish on industrial metals, EM assets or momentum plays, so they have of the euro.5 However, clouds are slowly forming over the global economy, at the very least pointing to a mini-cycle downturn. For one, Chinese producer prices have rolled over, and Chinese import growth has significantly underperformed expectations in recent months, slowing to a 5% pace from a 20% pace as recently as September 2017. Essentially, industrial activity has slowed in response to a tightening in Chinese monetary conditions. This slowdown is already beginning to impact various corners of the globe: Korean and Taiwanese export growth continues to decelerate; BCA's Global LEIs Diffusion Index is well below the 50% mark, which normally precedes slowdowns in the global LEI itself; Our boom/bust and global growth indicators have slowed further - two precursors to global industrial production decelerations. Our global economic and financial A/D line, which tallies 100 pro-cyclical variables, has also rolled over sharply, another early warning sign for the global economy (Chart I-12). Finally, as we highlighted in December, EM/JPY carry trades, a canary for the global economy, have lost momentum - a signal that has normally preceded a slowdown in global industrial activity.6 All these signals only confirm the "Yellow Flags" we highlighted last October.7 In an environment where complacency is rampant and assets levered to growth are priced for perfection, this is worrisome. The euro's recent elevated correlation to such risk assets, along with the fact that the gap between European and U.S. core inflation is itself led by Chinese PPI, suggests that the euro is tactically vulnerable. Fifth, from a technical perspective speculators have never been this long the euro, which represents a significant danger as the euro is trading at a sharp premium to its short-term interest rate driver (Chart I-13). Moreover, risk-reversals for EUR/USD point to heightened susceptibility of a selloff if the bad omen on global growth and European inflation come to fruition (Chart I-14). Chart I-12Rising Risks For Global Growth Rising Risks For Global Growth Rising Risks For Global Growth Chart I-13The Euro Is Vulnerable The Euro Is Vulnerable The Euro Is Vulnerable Chart I-14Risk Reversals Point To Euro Downside Risk Reversals Point To Euro Downside Risk Reversals Point To Euro Downside This short-term picture suggests that the probability of a move in EUR/USD toward 1.15 is growing over the course of the next three to six months. Bottom Line: While the cyclical picture for the euro is bright, the short-term snapshot is much more dangerous. Not only are an increasing number of ECB officials weighing in on the impact of the euro's recent rally, but the European periphery is showing growing signs that the euro rally has indeed taken a bite. Additionally, European inflation is set to underperform U.S. inflation, and the global economic cycle could enter a short burst of disappointment. Finally, investors are not positioned for such developments, increasing the likelihood of a downward move in the euro. What To Do? Caught between a cyclically propitious backdrop and a tactically dangerous environment, EUR/USD presents a riddle for FX investors right now. The odds of a euro correction over the next three to six months are substantially greater than 50%. But as we highlighted last week, instead of taking a direct bet on EUR/USD, we recommend investors short EUR/JPY. Shorting EUR/JPY is an even cleaner way to take advantage of the cloudy weather building over the global economy.8 Moreover, in recent years, EUR/JPY has fallen when the 52-week rate-of-change of momentum trades began to weaken (Chart I-15). This highly mean-reverting indicator is currently in the 96th percentile of its distribution for the past 25 years, suggesting an imminent rollover. Additionally, EUR/JPY tends to perform well when the LIBOR-OIS spread widens. Today, the three-month FRA-OIS spread has been widening, even as the end-of-year dollar funding shortage has passed (Chart I-16). These kinds of dynamics point to a potential drying out in global liquidity, a phenomenon which historically hurts risk assets, especially when they are as frothy as they are now. This should once again hurt EUR/JPY. Chart I-15EUR/JPY And Momentum Stocks EUR/JPY And Momentum Stocks EUR/JPY And Momentum Stocks Chart I-16Funding Stresses Point To A Fall In EUR/JPY Funding Stresses Point To A Fall In EUR/JPY Funding Stresses Point To A Fall In EUR/JPY Thus, shorting EUR/JPY is our highest conviction trade for the next six months or so. If, as we foresee, EUR/USD weakens during the first half of 2018, we will look to buy this pair. Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Special Report, "Assessing Fair Value In FX Markets" dated February 26, 2016 available at fes.bcaresearch.com 2 We do not include real GDP in the models because since wealth is affected by GDP, they are two co-integrated variables, which creates strong multi-collinearity in the regressions. Of the two variables, real wealth was the stronger explanatory variable. 3 While the focus of this report is on the euro, the relationship between relative excess money supply and currency performances works across many exchange rates. We will develop this theme over the coming weeks. 4 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Special Report, "Assessing Fair Value In FX Markets" dated February 26, 2016 available at fes.bcaresearch.com 5 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, "Euro: Risk On Or Risk Off" dated November 17, 2017 available at fes.bcaresearch.com 6 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, "A Cold Snap Doesn't Make A Winter" dated January 5, 2018 available at fes.bcaresearch.com 7 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, "The Best Of Possible Worlds?" dated October 6, 2017 available at fes.bcaresearch.com 8 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, "Yen: QQE Is Dead! Long Live YCC!" dated January 12, 2018 available at fes.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 USD Technicals 1 USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 USD Technicals 2 USD Technicals 2 Data out of the U.S. was strong this week: Industrial production increased by 0.9% on a monthly pace; Capacity utilization increased to 77.9% from 77.2%; Continuing jobless claims increased to 1.952 million from 1.876 million, beating expectations of 1.9 million; Initial jobless claims however decreased to 220K from 261K, beating expectations of 250K. We continue to expect the Fed to hike more than is priced by the market. A tightening labor market will eventually feed inflationary pressures, causing upward pressure on the dollar. Report Links: A Cold Snap Doesn't Make A Winter - January 5, 2018 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 Canaries In The Coal Mine Alert 2: More On EM Carry Trades And Global Growth - December 15, 2017 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 EUR Technicals 1 EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 EUR Technicals 2 EUR Technicals 2 European data was decent: German CPI came in unchanged and at expectations, at 1.6%; European headline and core CPI also remained unchanged and at consensus, coming in at 1.4% and 1.1% respectively. However, the euro seems to be losing momentum his week. Comments by ECB board members such as Ewald Nowotny, Vitor Constâncio, and Francois Villeroy, all pointed to issues with the euro's sharp rise, and how they "don't reflect changes in fundamentals". Additionally, relapsing inflation data in the peripheries shows that the strength in the euro is beginning to cause strains and may even negatively affect the ECB's mandate. Report Links: The Unstoppable Euro - January 19, 2018 Yen: QQE Is Dead! Long Live YCC! - January 12, 2018 A Cold Snap Doesn't Make A Winter - January 5, 2018 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 JPY Technicals 1 JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 JPY Technicals 2 JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan has been mixed: Domestic corporate goods year on year inflation underperformed expectations, coming in at 3.1%. It also decreased substantially from November. Moreover, the Eco Watchers Survey for current conditions underperformed expectations, coming in at 53.9. It also decreased from the November reading. However, machinery orders yearly growth outperformed expectations substantially, coming in at 4.1%. USD/JPY is relatively flat from last week. Overall we expect upside to the yen to be limited against the U.S. dollar, given that bond yields are set to go up in the U.S. That being said, the yen has upside against the euro, as financial conditions have eased significantly in Japan relatively to the euro area. This should cause rate expectations in Japan to improve relative to those of Europe's, pushing EUR/JPY lower. Report Links: Yen: QQE Is Dead! Long Live YCC! - January 12, 2018 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 Riding The Wave: Momentum Strategies In Foreign Exchange Markets - December 8, 2017 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 GBP Technicals 1 GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 GBP Technicals 2 GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.K. has been mixed: The DCLG House Price Index yearly growth outperformed expectations, coming in at 5.1%. However, core consumer price inflation underperformed expectations, coming in at 2.5%. It also decreased from the 2.7% reading of November. Moreover, headline inflation came in line with expectations at 3%. This also marks the first decrease in inflation in the U.K. since July 2017. Lifted by the USD's weakness, cable has now reached the pre-Brexit low 1.38 hit in February 2016. However, GBP has been experiencing a downtrend versus the euro since last September Overall, we continue to be skeptical of the ability of the BoE to raise interest rates meaningfully. Thus, we would fade any further rally from GBP/USD. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Reverse Alchemy: How To Transform Gold Into Lead - November 3, 2017 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 AUD Technicals 1 AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 AUD Technicals 2 AUD Technicals 2 Australian data was strong this week: Home loans grew at a 2.1% annual pace in November, higher than the expected -0.2%; Employment grew by 34.7K, beating expectations of 9K. The part-time component increased by 19.5K, while the full-time component grew by 15.1K; The participation rate increased to 65.7% from 65.5%; Unemployment rate increased to 5.5% from 5.4%. Foreign exchange traders lifted the AUD further this week. While the headline employment data remains stellar, the heavy concentration part-time job creation means that overall labor utilization measures is staying low. This will cap wage and inflationary pressures, especially as the AUD is once again expensive, further exacerbating deflationary pressures. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Currency Hedging: Dynamic Or Static? - A Practical Guide For Global Investors - September 29, 2017 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 NZD Technicals 1 NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 NZD Technicals 2 NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand has been negative: The month-on-month growth of food prices declined from -0.4% to -0.8%. Moreover, Electronic Card retail sales yearly growth slowed from 4.3% to 3.3%. Finally the ANZ Commodity Price Index year on year growth declined from -0.9% to -2.2%. The New Zealand Dollar has surges by almost 3% year to data against the U.S. dollar. This has been largely due to the depreciation of the greenback itself, as global growth continues to beat forecast. On a short term basis we are positive on the NZD relative to the AUD, as Chinese tightening should weigh more on Australia than New Zealand. However, the new populist government in New Zealand worsens the outlook of the kiwi on a long term basis. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Reverse Alchemy: How To Transform Gold Into Lead - November 3, 2017 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 CAD Technicals 1 CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 CAD Technicals 2 CAD Technicals 2 Movements in the petrocurrency were muted following the 'dovish hike' by the Bank of Canada. Numerous factors were highlighted to justify the rate hike to 1.25%, such as: strong employment growth; higher wages; robust consumption; and exceptional GDP growth in 2017. While the Bank's Business Outlook Survey suggests the labor market is tightening due to labor shortages, the BoC underplayed this factor, pointing to much more muted overall labor utilization metrics. The BoC also noted the expected decline in the contribution of housing and consumption to growth this year due to higher mortgage and borrowing rates. While the economy is firing on all fronts, the spread between the West Canada Select and West Texas Intermediate oil prices continues to widen due to a lack of pipeline capacity to ship the oil out of Canada. According to the Bank, these bottlenecks should be temporary, which means that the CAD could catch up to oil later. Report Links: Yen: QQE Is Dead! Long Live YCC! - January 12, 2018 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 CHF Technicals 1 CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 CHF Technicals 2 CHF Technicals 2 On Tuesday, Thomas Jordan, the president of the SNB once again reiterated that the franc is still "highly valued", and thus interest rates need to stay low so as to prevent the franc from appreciating. Moreover, he emphasized that while expansionary monetary policy was necessary, it was important to not wait too long to normalize rates. Overall, we believe that the SNB will want to see sustained inflation at relatively high levels to justify an exit from their radical monetary policy. In the meantime the Swiss Central bank will stay accommodative, and thus, EUR/CHF is likely to have limited downside. If the mini down cycle takes hold of the global economy, this would temporarily weigh on EUR/CHF. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Updating Our Long-Term Fair Value Models - September 15, 2017 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 NOK Technicals 1 NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 NOK Technicals 2 NOK Technicals 2 The krone continued to appreciate this week, and is now UP 3.3% year-to-date. The krone has been helped mostly by the surge in oil prices and by the fall in the dollar. Overall, we are bullish on this cross against the CAD, as there are 60 basis points of hiked priced in the Canadian curve, even after this week's hike. In the meantime, there are only 21 basis points in the Norwegian curve. We believe this spread is too high, and thus, that the krone should appreciate against the Canadian dollar. Moreover, further downside in EUR/NOK is limited, given that near 70 dollars, there is not much room for oil prices to go up. Thus, we are closing our EUR/NOK trade with a 3.40% gain but keep our long NOK/SEK call in place. Report Links: Yen: QQE Is Dead! Long Live YCC! - January 12, 2018 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 Canaries In The Coal Mine Alert 2: More On EM Carry Trades And Global Growth - December 15, 2017 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 SEK Technicals 1 SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 SEK Technicals 2 SEK Technicals 2 In a recent speech in Uppsala, Sweden, Deputy Governor Henry Ohlsson reminded the audience of his view from the December meeting that it would have reasonable to hike rates in "early 2018". He pointed to Sweden's robust economic performance, highlighting population growth, migration into cities, and higher real wages. Inflation has also been on target since mid-2017. This assessment is in line with our view of the economy, however Governor Ingves consistently supported a strong dovish tone which undermined our view. Now that the ECB has begun tapering, the consensus within the Riksbank seems to also be shifting. Falling house prices need to be monitored closely, especially when one keeps in mind Governor Ingves dovish inclinations. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 Canaries In The Coal Mine Alert 2: More On EM Carry Trades And Global Growth - December 15, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades