Valuations
US Financials is among the best performing US equity sectors over the past three months. We expect these positive relative gains to continue. Financials will benefit from rising US bond yields over the coming year. Not only are higher interest rates positive…
Market moves since the beginning of September have been characterized by a selloff in US Treasurys and a deterioration in US equity returns. The spectacular performance of US stocks thus far during the pandemic has stretched multiples to an extreme. These…
US energy stocks performed poorly earlier this year. They fell 14tween early March and late August. However, the tide seems to be turning in their favor. The energy sector is now leading the benchmark. It is up 12% since August 20 – a period of negligible…
BCA Research’s US Equity Strategy service recommends overweighting the Hotels, Resorts, and Cruise Lines industry. The team summarizes this view as follows: The Delta variant is cresting. Their base case is that herd immunity is not far off. Of course, the…
Highlights Investment Grade: Investment grade corporate bond total returns will be close to zero or negative during the next 12 months. The bonds are also likely to outperform duration-matched Treasuries during that period, but excess returns are probably capped at 85 bps. High-Yield: High-yield total returns will fall between -0.29% and +1.80% during the next 12 months, but with a much higher likelihood of being positive than investment grade corporates. Junk will outperform duration-matched Treasuries by between 0.94% and 1.84%, besting the excess returns earned in investment grade. Inflation & The Fed: The Fed will announce asset purchase tapering before the end of this year, and tapering will proceed at a pace that opens the door to a potential rate hike before the end of 2022. Ultimately, whether the Fed lifts rates in 2022 will depend on trends in core CPI excluding COVID-impacted services and autos, along with wage growth and inflation expectations. Feature Chart 1Valuations Are Stretched There are two broad factors that must be considered when deciding whether to favor corporate bonds over Treasuries in a US bond portfolio: (i) The cyclical macroeconomic environment and (ii) valuation. The problem is that, as it stands today, these two factors are sending contrasting signals. The cyclical macroeconomic environment is consistent with strong positive excess returns for spread product versus Treasuries. However, corporate bond spreads and yields are extremely low relative to history (Chart 1). We view the slope of the yield curve as the single best indicator of the cyclical macro environment and have shown in prior research that corporate bonds tend to deliver positive excess returns versus Treasuries when the 3-year/10-year Treasury slope is above 50 bps, even when corporate spreads are tight.1 At present, the 3-year/10-year slope sits at 90 bps and our bias will be toward an overweight allocation to corporates until the slope breaks below 50 bps. A flatter yield curve is negative for corporate bond performance because it suggests that monetary conditions are less accommodative. It also makes it more likely that an unforeseen shock will lead to yield curve inversion, a highly reliable recession indicator. While the macro environment is consistent with continued corporate bond outperformance versus Treasuries, valuation suggests that we should anticipate lower returns than usual from corporate bonds. Table 1 shows annualized corporate bond excess returns during each of the past six cycles. Additionally, it splits each cycle into three phases based on the slope of the 3-year/10-year Treasury curve. Phase 1 of the cycle lasts from the end of the prior recession until the slope breaks below 50 bps. Phase 2 encompasses the period when the slope is between 0 bps and 50 bps. Phase 3 lasts from when the yield curve inverts until the start of the next recession. Table 1Corporate Bond Excess Returns In Different Phases Of The Cycle The first conclusion to draw from Table 1 is that excess returns tend to be lower in Phase 2 than in Phase 1 and lower in Phase 3 than in Phase 2. Second, we see that investment grade corporates have returned an annualized 7.55% in excess of duration-matched Treasuries so far this cycle and high-yield corporates have delivered 15.15% of outperformance. These figures are well above even those seen in prior Phase 1 periods. Based on this, an expectation for lower – but still positive – excess corporate bond returns seems like a reasonable base case for the next 6-12 months. Table 2 is identical to Table 1 except that it shows total returns instead of excess returns. We observe that, so far this cycle, junk bond total returns have outpaced prior Phase 1 periods. Investment grade total returns have been slightly lower given the greater exposure to interest rate risk of those securities. Table 2Corporate Bond Total Returns In Different Phases Of The Cycle As noted above, our expectation is that corporate bonds will outperform Treasuries during the next 6-12 months, but that both excess returns and total returns will take a step down. The next section of this report presents a scenario analysis that puts some more specific numbers on the sorts of excess and total corporate bond returns investors might expect to earn during the next year. Corporate Bond Returns: Scenario Analysis Methodology To run our scenario analysis for investment grade corporate bond returns we use the following equations: Excess Return = OAS0 – D0 (dOAS) Total Return = OAS0+ TSY0 – D0 (dOAS+dTSY) Where: Excess Return = The expected corporate index excess return versus duration-matched Treasuries during the next 12 months Total Return = The expected corporate index total return during the next 12 months OAS0 = Today’s average index option-adjusted spread D0 = Today’s average index duration TSY0 = Today’s Treasury yield that matches the duration of the corporate index dOAS = The expected change in the index option-adjusted spread during the next 12 months dTSY = The expected change in the duration-matched Treasury yield during the next 12 months These equations are obviously simplifications. For example, the impact of convexity is ignored. However, Chart 2 shows that our proxies track actual index returns very closely over time, assuming the estimated yield and spread changes are accurate. Chart 2Estimating IG Returns We use similar equations for assessing high-yield corporate returns, with the additional complication that we must include an assumption for default losses. Excess Return= OAS0 – (DR × (1 - RR)) –D0(dOAS) Total Return= OAS0 + TSY0 – (DR × (1 – RR)) –D0 (dOAS + dTSY) In these equations: DR = The expected issuer-weighted default rate for the next 12 months RR = The expected average recovery rate on defaulted debt for the next 12 months Once again, though these equations are relatively simple, they do a good job of capturing actual returns over time (Chart 3). Chart 3Estimating HY Returns Scenarios With the above equations in hand, we can easily make some educated guesses about future yields, spreads and default losses and translate those assumptions into expected return forecasts. Specifically, we test three different scenarios (bullish, neutral and bearish) for corporate spreads, Treasury yields and default losses. For corporate index spreads, both investment grade and high-yield, our bullish scenario assumes that spreads reach the all-time tight levels seen in the mid-1990s. For investment grade bonds this spread level is 58 bps, 27 bps below the current level. For high-yield bonds this spread level is 233 bps, 41 bps below the current level. Our neutral scenario assumes that index spreads remain at their current levels (85 bps for investment grade and 274 bps for junk). Finally, our bearish scenario assumes that spreads widen back to the average levels seen during the 2017-2019 period (112 bps for investment grade and 369 bps for junk), this implies 27 bps of widening for investment grade and 95 bps of widening for junk. Given our view that bond yields will rise as we approach the next Fed tightening cycle, none of our scenarios assume that Treasury yields will fall during the next 12 months. Our bullish Treasury yield scenario assumes that yields stay flat at current levels. Our neutral Treasury yield scenario assumes that yields follow the path implied by current forward rates, and our bearish Treasury yield scenario assumes that yields rise to levels consistent with fair value estimates assuming the market prices-in a December 2022 Fed liftoff followed by 100 bps of rate hikes per year until the fed funds rate levels-off at 2.08%.2 We use the 7-year and 6-year Treasury yields as our inputs for the investment grade and high-yield scenarios, respectively, as those yields most closely match the interest rate component embedded in the corporate indexes. For default losses, our bullish scenario assumes a 1.8% default rate – consistent with the rate at which defaults are tracking so far this year – and a recovery rate of 50%. Our neutral scenario assumes a 3% default rate and a 40% recovery rate. Our bearish scenario assumes a 4% default rate and 30% recovery rate. Investment Grade Results Table 3 shows the results of our scenario analysis for investment grade corporate bond returns. Table 3Investment Grade Corporate Bond Expected Return Scenarios Starting with excess returns, we think it is most likely that spreads remain near current levels, or perhaps widen a bit, during the next 12 months. We think it’s extremely unlikely that spreads will tighten to the levels seen in the mid-1990s because the average duration of the index is much higher today than it was back then. All else equal, it’s generally true that securities with higher duration also have higher OAS. This means we expect investment grade corporate bond excess returns to be between -153 bps and +85 bps during the next 12 months, probably closer to +85 bps. Obviously, this represents a significant step down from the +550 bps earned during the past year. In fact, even the most bullish scenario where spreads tighten back to all-time lows only implies an excess return of +323 bps, well below the recent rate of outperformance. As for total returns, we estimate that a neutral scenario where the index spread holds steady and Treasury yields follow the forward curve will lead to total returns being close to zero during the next 12 months. In fact, our results suggest that it’s highly likely that investment grade corporate bonds will deliver negative total returns during the next 12 months. Yes, the index is expected to deliver a total return of 1.98% if both the index spread and duration-matched Treasury yield remain at their current levels, but an environment where growth is slow enough to keep Treasury yields flat is much more likely to coincide with spread widening than with steady corporate spreads. For some additional historical perspective, the columns labeled “Historical Percentile Rank” show how the returns in each scenario would rank relative to actual returns earned during the past 31 calendar years. For example, even the most bullish total return scenario of 4.36% ranks at the 27th percentile relative to history. This means that it would only be better than 27% of historical 12-month return observations for that index. High-Yield Results Tables 4A, 4B and 4C summarize the results of our high-yield scenario analysis. Table 4A assumes the bullish scenario for default losses, Table 4B assumes the neutral scenario for default losses and Table 4C assumes the bearish scenario for default losses. Table 4AHigh-Yield Corporate Bond Expected Return Scenarios: Bullish Default Loss Scenario* Table 4BHigh-Yield Corporate Bond Expected Return Scenarios: Neutral Default Loss Scenario* Table 4CHigh-Yield Corporate Bond Expected Return Scenarios: Bearish Default Loss Scenario* Looking at excess returns, the first result that jumps out is that even the most bullish scenario leads to an expected 12-month excess return of +3.43%, this would be equivalent to the median return earned during the past 31 calendar years. In our view, it’s more likely that excess returns will be in the +0.94% to +1.84% range during the next 12 months. This is consistent with flat spreads and a range for default losses between our neutral and bullish scenarios. Our sense is that junk bonds are less likely to deliver negative total returns than investment grade bonds. Though even the most bullish scenario puts expected junk total returns at +4.54%, consistent with the 39th percentile relative to history. Investment Implications To summarize, our expectation is that investment grade corporate bond total returns will be close to zero or negative during the next 12 months. The bonds are also likely to outperform duration-matched Treasuries during that period, but excess returns are probably capped at 85 bps. Our best guess places high-yield total returns at between -0.29% and +1.80%, but with a much higher likelihood of earning positive total returns than a position in investment grade. We estimate that excess junk returns will fall between +0.94% and +1.84%, above returns earned in investment grade. In general, the message is that investors should remain overweight corporate bonds versus Treasuries, but should retain a preference for high-yield over investment grade and should expect to earn far lower returns than were earned during the past year. Given low expected returns, investors should also seek out creative ways of adding additional spread to a bond portfolio. We offered some suggestions in a recent report.3 CPI Update And FOMC Preview This week’s FOMC meeting could be significant for bond markets. First off, there is a possibility that the Fed will announce a timeline for tapering its asset purchases. Our sense is that last month’s weak employment report probably delays this announcement, but we still expect it to come before the end of the year. We expect that the actual tapering of purchases will start in January 2022 and that net Fed purchases will reach zero by Q3 of next year. More broadly, we continue to think that the market is already priced for a tapering announcement in 2021. In other words, any information about asset purchases probably won’t move bond yields that much. What will move bond yields is any hint about when the Fed thinks it may want to start lifting rates. Such news could come in the form of revisions to the Fed’s interest rate forecasts, or in any information that the Fed provides about the pace of asset purchase tapering. Because the Fed has indicated a strong preference for having net purchases at zero prior to liftoff, any pace of tapering that gets net purchases to zero by the middle of next year opens the door to a possible rate hike before the end of 2022. Of course, the economic data between now and the end of 2022 will have a lot to say about whether the Fed actually starts to hike. In particular, last week’s report made the case that next year’s inflation data will determine when rate hikes begin.4 With that in mind, last week’s CPI release showed a significant deceleration in core inflation, driven by the COVID-impacted service and auto sectors that had previously caused inflation to spike (Chart 4). Interestingly, core inflation excluding COVID-impacted services and autos jumped on the month (Chart 4, bottom panel). From the Fed’s perspective, it ignored the transitory rise of COVID-impacted service and auto inflation on the way up, it will also be inclined to ignore its descent. What will ultimately matter for monetary policy is whether underlying inflationary pressures start to build throughout 2022. It is therefore much more important for us to focus on trends in core inflation excluding the COVID-impacted services and autos, along with wage growth and inflation expectations. Our view is that underlying inflationary pressures will be strong enough for the Fed to lift rates before the end of 2022. This will, in large part, be due to an acceleration of shelter inflation (Chart 5). Owner’s Equivalent Rent and Rent of Primary Residence inflation have already jumped, and leading indicators of shelter inflation like the unemployment rate (Chart 5, panel 3) and the Apartment Market Tightness Index (Chart 5, bottom panel) are consistent with further acceleration. Chart 4Looking For Underlying Inflation Chart 5Shelter Inflation Will Keep Rising Bottom Line: The Fed will announce asset purchase tapering before the end of this year, and tapering will proceed at a pace that opens the door to a potential rate hike before the end of 2022. Ultimately, whether the Fed lifts rates in 2022 will depend on trends in core CPI excluding COVID-impacted services and autos, along with wage growth and inflation expectations. Ryan Swift US Bond Strategist rswift@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “The Post-FOMC Credit Environment”, dated June 29, 2021. 2 Last week’s report provides more detail on this fair value analysis. Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “2022 Will Be All About Inflation”, dated September 14, 2021. 3 Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “The Collapsing Credit Risk Premium”, dated July 20, 2021. 4 Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “2022 Will Be All About Inflation”, dated September 14, 2021. Recommended Portfolio Specification Other Recommendations Treasury Index Returns Spread Product Returns
The Evergrade debacle (see Country Focus) underscores the risks facing the global housing market. Ultra-low interest rates are fueling a surge in house prices across the world (see The Numbers). The rapid price increase is making housing increasingly…
Highlights Stocks tend to perform worse when unemployment is low. Since 1950, the S&P 500 has risen at an annualized pace of 12% when the unemployment rate was above its historic average compared to 6% when the unemployment rate was below its average. Three reasons help explain this relationship: 1) The unemployment rate has historically been mean-reverting; 2) Low unemployment often leads to monetary tightening; and 3) Valuations are usually more stretched when unemployment is low. In the spring of 2020, stocks benefited from what turned out to be a very auspicious environment: A steady decline in the unemployment rate from very high levels, assisted by a massive dose of monetary and fiscal stimulus. Today, the situation is less clear-cut. The labor market has improved dramatically, while both monetary and fiscal policy are turning less accommodative. Nevertheless, the Fed is unlikely to hike rates for at least 12 months, and it will take much longer than that for monetary policy to turn restrictive. This suggests that we are still in the middle-to-late stages of a business cycle expansion that began following the Great Recession (and was only briefly interrupted by the pandemic). Historically, cyclical stocks have done well during this phase of the business cycle. To the extent that cyclicals are overrepresented in overseas indices, investors should favor non-US stock markets. Non-US stocks also trade at a substantial valuation discount to their US peers. A Surprising Relationship One of the best pieces of advice I received when I was starting my research career was to get to the punchline as soon as possible. As a strategist, you are not writing a detective novel where the answers are shrouded in mystery until the very end. You are providing conclusions to readers with supporting evidence. Chart 1Stocks Do Best When Unemployment Is High With that in mind, let me answer the question posed in the title of this report: Is low unemployment good or bad for stocks? As Chart 1 shows, the answer is bad. The interesting issues are why it is bad and what this may mean for investors today. There are three key reasons why low unemployment has typically corresponded with paltry equity returns: The unemployment rate has historically been mean-reverting: Low unemployment is often followed by high unemployment. And, when the unemployment rate starts rising, it keeps rising. There has never been a case in the post-war era where the unemployment rate has risen by more than one-third of a percentage point without a recession occurring (Chart 2). Chart 2When Unemployment Starts Rising, It Usually Keeps Rising Low unemployment often leads to monetary tightening: An economy can only grow at an above-trend pace if there is labor market slack. Once the slack runs out, growth is liable to weaken as supply-side constraints kick in. Worse yet, labor market overheating has historically prompted central banks to raise rates (Chart 3). Higher rates in the context of slowing growth is toxic for stocks. Valuations are usually more stretched when unemployment is low: During the post-war period, the S&P 500 has traded at an average Shiller P/E ratio of 22.5 when the unemployment rate was below its historic average compared to 16.3 when the unemployment rate was above its average. Implications For The Present Day Stocks fare best when unemployment is high but falling. In contrast, stocks fare the worst when unemployment is low and rising (Chart 4). My colleague Doug Peta, BCA’s Chief US Investment Strategist, reached a similar conclusion in his August report entitled Level Or Direction? Chart 3Low Unemployment Often Leads To Monetary Tightening Chart 4Stocks Do Best When Unemployment Is Falling From High Levels In the spring of 2020, stocks benefited from what turned out to be a very auspicious environment: A steady decline in the unemployment rate from very high levels, assisted by a massive dose of monetary and fiscal stimulus. Controversially at the time, this led us to argue that the pandemic could lead to much higher stock prices. Chart 5There Is Still Slack Today, the situation is less clear-cut. On the one hand, the unemployment rate has fallen dramatically, while monetary and fiscal policy are turning less accommodative. This week, the ECB reduced the pace of net asset purchases under the PEPP. The Fed will start paring back asset purchases by the end of this year. Governments are also withdrawing fiscal policy support. In the US, emergency federal unemployment benefits expired, somewhat ironically, on Labor Day. On the other hand, the unemployment rate in most economies is still above pre-pandemic levels. In the US, the unemployment rate for prime-age workers is 1.7 percentage points higher than in February 2020, while the employment-to-population ratio is 2.4 points lower (Chart 5). The presence of labor market slack ensures that policy support will be withdrawn only gradually. Granted, core CPI inflation in the US is running above 4%. Standard Taylor Rule equations suggest that the Fed funds rate should be well above zero (Chart 6). That said, these equations use realized inflation, which may be misleading given that both market participants and Fed officials expect inflation to fall rapidly (Chart 7). Indeed, the widely followed 5-year/5-year forward TIPS breakeven rate is below the Fed’s comfort zone (Chart 8).1 With long-term inflation expectations still subdued, there is no urgency for the Fed to sound more hawkish. Chart 6What Rate Does The Taylor Rule Prescribe? Chart 7Investors Expect Inflation To Fall Rapidly From Current Levels Chart 8Long-Term Inflation Expectations Are Muted Cyclical Stocks Usually Do Best In The Latter Innings Of The Business Cycle Expansion Monetary policy is unlikely to become restrictive in any major economy during the next 18 months, which should allow global growth to remain at an above-trend pace. Hence, it is too early to turn bearish on stocks. Nevertheless, given that the unemployment rate in most countries is closer to a trough than to a peak, it is reasonable to conclude that we are somewhere in the middle-to-late stages of a business cycle expansion that began following the Great Recession (and was only briefly interrupted by the pandemic). As Chart 9 shows, cyclical equity sectors, such as industrials, energy, and materials, typically do best in the latter innings of business cycle expansions. Such was the environment that prevailed in 2005-08, and such will be the environment that prevails over the coming quarters as the unemployment rate falls further, capital spending increases, and commodity prices rise further. Chart 9The Business Cycle And Equity Sectors Increased government infrastructure spending should help cyclical sectors. The US Congress is set to pass a 10-year $500 billion package. The EU’s €750 billion Next Generation fund is finally up and running. Chinese local government infrastructure spending is poised to accelerate over the remainder of the year. Chart 10The Dollar Is A Countercyclical Currency Chart 11Past Another Covid Wave A weaker US dollar should also buoy cyclical stocks (Chart 10). As a countercyclical currency, the greenback usually weakens when global growth is strong. A cresting in the Delta variant wave should help jumpstart global growth over the coming months (Chart 11). Meanwhile, interest rate differentials have moved sharply against the US dollar, while the US trade deficit has widened noticeably (Charts 12A & B). Chart 12AInterest Rate Differentials Have Moved Against The Dollar Chart 12BThe US Trade Deficit Has Widened Noticeably Cyclical sectors are overrepresented outside the US (Table 1). Although not a classically cyclical sector, financials are also overrepresented in overseas indices. BCA’s global fixed-income strategists recommend a moderately underweight duration stance. As bond yields rise, bank shares should outperform (Chart 13). In contrast, tech stocks often lag in a rising yield environment. Table 1Cyclicals Are Overrepresented Outside The US Chart 13Higher Rates: A Boon For Banks And A Bane For Tech How Expensive Are Stocks? A high Shiller P/E predicts low future returns (Chart 14). Today, the Shiller P/E stands at 37 in the US. This is consistent with an expected 10-year total real return of close to zero for the S&P 500. Thus, the long-term outlook for US stocks is poor. We stress the words “long term.” As the bottom panel of Chart 14 shows, no matter what the starting point of valuations is, the average return over short-term horizons is very low relative to realized volatility. This is another way of saying that valuations provide a great deal of information about the long-term outlook for stocks, but little information about their near-term direction. Over horizons of about 12 months, the business cycle drives the stock market, as a simple comparison between purchasing manager indices and stock returns illustrates (Chart 15). Chart 14Valuation Is The Single Best Predictor Of Long-Term Equity Returns Chart 15AThe Business Cycle Drives Cyclical Swings In Stocks Chart 15BThe Business Cycle Drives Cyclical Swings In Stocks Outside the US, the Shiller P/E stands at 20. In emerging markets, it is only 16 (Chart 16). This is significantly below US levels, implying that the long-term prospect for equities is much more attractive abroad. Thus, both medium-term cyclical factors and long-term valuation considerations favor non-US stocks. Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist pberezin@bcaresearch.com Chart 16US Stocks Are Pricey Footnotes 1 The Federal Reserve targets an average inflation rate of 2% for the personal consumption expenditures (PCE) index. The TIPS breakeven is based on the CPI index. Due to compositional differences between the two indices, CPI inflation has historically averaged 30-to-50 basis points higher than PCE inflation. This is why the Fed effectively targets a CPI inflation rate of about 2.3%-to-2.5%. Global Investment Strategy View Matrix Special Trade Recommendations Current MacroQuant Model Scores
9 September 2021 at 10:00 EDT Emerging Markets Strategy/Webcast EM/China: See The Forest For The Trees 9 September 2021 at 21:00 EDT Emerging Markets Strategy/Webcast Emerging Asia: See The Forest For The Trees Highlights Structural inflation in India has abated noticeably since the mid-2010s. The cyclical inflation outlook is also benign (Chart 1). As such, the specter of inflation does not pose a material threat to this stock market. Indian stocks’ high valuation is a risk; yet this bourse’s structurally high premium relative to EM will likely continue as India’s earnings growth will stay strong and its volatility low. Investors should stay overweight Indian stocks in an EM equity portfolio, and local currency bonds in an EM domestic bond portfolio. Feature Chart 1India's Cyclical Inflation Outlook Is Benign In a recent Emerging Markets Strategy report we showed that India stands out as the only country in Asia with rather high inflation. Indeed, core CPI in India, at about 6%, is higher than all other major EM and DM countries, save Turkey and Russia. The question is, with the economy re-opening, will Indian inflation rise further and thus derail the rally in Indian equities? Our research indicates that both the structural and cyclical inflation outlook for India remains benign. Our models for headline and core CPI both point to lower inflation in the coming months (Chart 1). As such, inflation is unlikely to pose any major threat to Indian assets in the foreseeable future. Investors should remain overweight Indian stocks in an EM equity portfolio. Fixed-income investors should also continue to overweight Indian local bonds in an EM domestic bond portfolio. Currency traders should favor the rupee versus its EM peers. Inflation Outlook: Structural … The first of the two principal drivers of India’s structural inflation trend is the country’s productivity. The stronger the productivity gains, the more contained has been its structural inflation. The second major driver is broad money supply. The higher the money growth, the steeper have been inflationary pressures – especially during those periods when productivity gains were timid. Top panel of Chart 2 shows that up until the early-2000s, India’s average productivity gains used to be rather low: of the order of 3% annually. That period was also marked by very strong broad money growth: at times, the latter would rise to 20% annually (Chart 2, bottom panel). This growth was due to chronically high fiscal deficits that were monetized, coupled with intermittent surges in bank credit. Chart 2Slower Money Supply Amid Decent Productivity Led To A Structural Decline In Inflation The consequence of persistently low productivity gains amid strong money supply was structurally high inflation, with occasional flare-ups well into double digits (Chart 2). Chart 3Steady Fall In Budget Deficits In Post-GFC Era From the early 2000s, however, that dynamic began to change. A surge in capital spending in infrastructure and other productive capacity propelled India’s productivity trend up by several notches. In the past 15 years, the productivity growth rate has averaged around 6% a year; even though more recently that rate has slowed. In the post-GFC period, both major sources of money creation were stymied. First, successive Indian governments, regardless of political affiliation, adopted a rather tight fiscal policy. They reined in fiscal outlays substantially. Non-interest expenditures of the central government fell from 14% of GDP in 2010 down to 9% by 2019, just before the pandemic (Chart 3, top panel). As a result, during that period, fiscal and primary deficits narrowed significantly: from almost 7% of GDP to 3%, and from almost 4% of GDP to nearly zero, respectively (Chart 3, bottom panel). In addition, a myriad of reasons1 caused commercial bank credit to decelerate materially – from as high as 30% before the GFC to a mere 6% by 2019. The upshot of all this was a secular decline in broad money growth. That eventually led India’s inflationary pressures to decline structurally since the mid-2010s (Chart 2, bottom panel, above). Going forward, those major drivers (both productivity and money growth) will warrant a benign inflation outlook. The country has been continuing its high capital spending for over a decade now (around 30% to 35% of GDP, a rate second only to China). This year, India’s capital spending has already revived. Other corroborating indicators such as imports of capital goods have also recovered robustly. This indicates a new capex cycle is unfolding. Therefore, odds are that the productivity growth rate will stay decent. Prudent fiscal policy, on the other hand, will keep the money growth in check. Chart 4Low Wages Will Help Keep Inflation Subdued Finally, wage pressures in India will also stay muted. In rural areas, both farm and non-farm nominal wages have been growing at a very slow pace; and are now flirting with outright contraction (Chart 4, top panel). Industrial wage expectations have also been tepid over the past several years (Chart 4, bottom panel). The broader picture is unlikely to change in the future as tens of millions of young people continue to join the work force every year. Taken together, these factors point to subdued structural inflation ahead. … And Cyclical The chance that inflation in India will flare up over a cyclical horizon (12 months) is also low: First, one of the major cyclical drivers of inflation in India, the government’s food procurement prices (called Minimum Support Price or MSP) have stayed low for the past several years. The announced MSPs for some of the crops for the 2021-22 agriculture season (July-June) have also shown no marked increase. This will surely help keep the wholesale prices for food in check, which, in turn, will keep a lid on consumer inflation expectations and ultimately on both headline and core consumer inflation (Chart 5). Second, the country’s money growth is also unlikely to witness an immediate, major boom. While the budget deficit has swelled over the past year or so, odds are that the government will revert to the tighter fiscal stance that prevailed over the past decade – as soon as the pandemic is brought under control. Chart 6 shows that government non-interest spending leads core CPI. Reduced expenditure growth will cap inflation. Chart 5Low Food Prices Will Keep A Lid On Inflation Expectations Chart 6Slowing Fiscal Spending Will Cap Core Inflation Chart 7Fuel Price Inflation Is Set To Decelerate The other contributor to money growth, bank credit, is expected to accelerate; but its expansion will not be rapid as banks are still suffering from elevated NPLs. Third, fuel price inflation has likely peaked in India. Last year authorities imposed substantial new taxes on local gasoline and diesel prices, which artificially raised consumer inflation (Chart 7). Since there is little chance of new fuel levies this year and given that crude prices are unlikely to rise much from the current levels (which is EMS’s view), fuel inflation will subside materially next year. And as fuel costs often eventually spill into core inflation, this deceleration will help check the latter as well. Finally, given the massive negative output gap that opened up in the economy during the pandemic-related lockdowns, it will take a while before the economy overheats again. Odds are therefore low that India’s inflation will accelerate much in the coming months. Notably, our cyclical inflation models for both headline and core CPI – built using the drivers discussed above – also vouch for a modest decline in inflation (Chart 1, on page 1). Does Inflation Hurt Stocks? Currently, the Indian economy is not plagued by any major excesses and therefore has no major macro vulnerability. The only potential vulnerability that the economy and stock markets face stem from any possible rise in inflation. Notably, the primary driver of Indian stocks is economic growth and corporate profits. Historically, inflation (CPI) in low- and mid-single digits did not hurt Indian stocks. However, once inflation approached a high-single digit mark (usually 8%), a sell-off in stocks typically occurred. Chart 8 shows that, during India’s high-inflation era (from 1994 to 2013), every time CPI breached the 8% mark (the dotted line in the chart), stocks fell in absolute USD terms, or at the minimum, were weak. Chart 8Indian Stocks Faced Major Headwinds When Headline CPI Approached 8% Chart 9In Recent Years Inflation Has Ceased To Be A Headwind For Indian Stocks Interestingly, the above correlations have changed dramatically since 2014. The top panel of Chart 9 shows that core CPI does not have any steady correlation with stock prices anymore. And core PPI, in fact, has developed a strong positive correlation with stocks (Chart 9, bottom panel) – in complete reversal of the dynamics that prevailed in the previous two decades. The adverse impact of inflation on stock prices is via multiple compression, as rising interest rates lead to equity de-rating. What’s notable is that the multiple compressions do not begin as soon as a rate hike cycle commences. Rather, it takes a meaningful rise in interest rates before it starts to hurt multiples (Chart 10). Given the above, one can expect a material multiple compression only if inflation rises a few notches above the central bank’s target (Chart 11). The odds of that happening now are low. Therefore, policy rates will remain lower for longer, and stock valuations will remain at a higher level than usual. Chart 10Interest Rates Usually Needed To Rise Several Points Before Stock Multiple Compression Began Chart 11India's Inflation Remains Within RBI Target Bands Incidentally, thanks to material rate cuts, real interest rates paid by Indian firms – deflated by both core producer and core consumer prices – have plummeted. Lower real rates benefit the borrowers (i.e., non-financial listed companies) (Chart 12). The bottom line is that, with India’s inflation now being both structurally low (by Indian history) and cyclically tame, it is unlikely to be a cause of any major equity sell-off. Are Indian Equity Valuations Justified? With a trailing P/E of 31, and P/Book of 3.9, there is no doubt that Indian stocks are expensive. Yet, part of the multiple expansion in India, like most other DM countries, has been a direct outcome of a sharply lower policy rate, as discussed above. Incidentally, if one were to look at the cyclically adjusted valuation measures (CAPE), Indian markets appear to be only moderately expensive (Chart 13, top panel). Chart 12Lower Real Rates Boost Firms' Profits And Warrant Higher Stock Prices Chart 13Cyclically-Adjuted P/E Ratio Chart 14Relative Equity Multiples: India vs. EM In terms of relative valuation vis-à-vis the rest of the EM, Indian stocks continue to command a high premium: around 90% in the case of P/E and P/Book multiples. (Chart 14). In terms of cyclically adjusted valuation (CAPE) relative to the EM, India also appears to be quite pricey (Chart 13, bottom panel). The bottom line is that Indian stocks are expensive; and that is a risk to this bourse. A pertinent question here is whether India still merits the structurally high premium that it has enjoyed over the years relative to its peers. Our answer is in the affirmative. One reason this bourse has continued to enjoy a high premium, especially since the mid-2000s, is because the growth of Indian corporate earnings has been superior to those of most other EM countries. But more importantly, the volatility of those earnings has been much lower than its peers. These strong, yet less volatile earnings are what investors have been willing to pay a premium for. Going forward, we see both traits remaining intact. Long-term growth in India will likely stay as one of the highest in the EM world. Earnings volatility is also unlikely to change anytime soon. The reason is, first, lower inflation going forward will entail relatively lower interest rate volatility, and therefore, lower business cycle / earnings volatility. Second, India’s currency volatility will also likely stay lower. Part of the reason is the near absence of foreign investors on government bonds in India. This has precluded India from suffering a major currency sell-off during global risk-off episodes – as few bond investors head for the exit. We discussed this and several other issues related to Indian bond markets and the rupee in much greater detail in our last report on India. Taken together, lower volatility in both local currency earnings and the exchange rate entails lower overall volatility for US dollar-denominated earnings. That will help Indian stocks’ premium to stay elevated beyond any short-term fluctuations. Inflation And The Rupee Chart 15The Rupee Strengthens When Relative Inflation In India Versus US Decelerates The impact of inflation on the rupee is nuanced. It’s not the absolute level of India’s CPI or PPI that affects the rupee-dollar exchange rate; it’s the relative inflation between these two economies that does so. Chart 15 shows that the rupee usually strengthens versus the dollar when inflation in India falls relative to that of US (shown in inverted scale in the chart). These relative inflation dynamics could also provide insight into the exchange rate outlook. Chart 16 shows that the rupee is currently 10% cheaper when measured against what would be its “fair value” (Chart 16, bottom panel). The fair value has been derived from a regression analysis of the exchange rate on the manufacturers’ relative producer prices of the two countries. Investment Recommendations Indian stocks have decisively broken out both in absolute terms and relative to their EM counterparts (Chart 17). Notably, the outperformance is not just due to a sell-off in Chinese TMT stocks. It is even more impressive relative to the ‘mainstream EM’ bourses (i.e., EM excluding China, Taiwan and Korea). Given India’s relatively superior structural and cyclical backdrops, this outperformance should continue for a while (Chart 17, bottom two panels). Investors should stay overweight this bourse in an EM equity portfolio. Chart 16The Indian Rupee Is Now About 10% Below Its Fair Value Versus The US Dollar Chart 17Indian Stocks' Breakout Is Decisive And The Relative Outperformance Is Broad-based Chart 18Higher Carry And A Better Currency Outlook Will Lead To Indian Domestic Bonds' Outperformance The medium-term outlook for the rupee is also positive. The currency is cheap and competitive –an added incentive for both foreign direct investors and portfolio investors. Finally, Indian domestic bonds offer value – both relative to their EM peers and the US treasuries. 10-year government bonds yields, at 6.2%, offer an enticing 480 basis points over similar duration US Treasuries. Given the sanguine rupee and inflation outlooks, Indian bonds will likely continue to outperform EM local bonds (Chart 18). Investors should stay on with our recommendation of overweighting India in an EM local currency bond portfolio. Rajeeb Pramanik Senior EM Strategist rajeeb.pramanik@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 The reasons include a surge in bank NPLs, lack of bankable projects, a kind of policy paralysis resulting in delay in various regulatory clearances for capital projects etc.
Highlights The equity risk premium has turned negative for the first time since 2002. It follows that any significant rise in bond yields will cause risk-asset prices to collapse, quickly flipping any incipient inflationary shock into a deflationary shock. Shorting bonds yielding 2 percent is a ‘widow maker’ trade, as anybody who has tried this with a long list of government bonds has learned to their cost, the most recent being UK gilts. Hence, the next on the list for the ‘widow maker’ is shorting the US 30-year T-bond which is now yielding 2 percent. In fact, the US 30-year T-bond is a must-own structural investment. Fractal analysis: Medical equipment versus healthcare services. Feature Chart of the WeekThe Equity Risk Premium Turns Negative For The First Time Since 2002 Mainstream investments are now priced to deliver negative, zero, or at best, feeble long-term investment returns. Mainstream investments are now priced to deliver negative, zero, or at best, feeble long-term investment returns. For example, the US 10-year Treasury Inflation Protected Security (TIPS) and the UK 10-year index linked gilt are yielding -1.3 percent and -2.8 percent respectively. Meaning that anybody who buys and holds these bonds to redemption is guaranteed a deeply negative 10-year real return. Meanwhile, in nominal yield space, 10-year government bonds yield -0.35 percent in Germany and Switzerland, 0.7 percent in the UK, and 1.3 percent in the US. What about equities? Unlike a bond’s redemption yield, equities do not offer a guaranteed long-term return for buy-and-hold investors. So, some analysts assume that the equity market’s earnings yield is the proxy for this long-term return. According to these analysts, the US equity market’s earnings yield of 4.4 percent means that it will deliver a prospective long-term real return of 4.4 percent per annum. Compared to the 10-year TIPS real yield of -1.3 percent, they argue that this offers an excess return or ‘equity risk premium’ of a comfortable +5.7 percent. Therefore, claim these analysts, equities are reasonably valued, relative to bonds, and in absolute terms. But as we will now demonstrate, this analysis is deeply flawed. The Equity Risk Premium Has Turned Negative The equity market’s earnings yield is a valuation metric, so clearly there is some connection between it and the prospective return delivered by the equity market. Nevertheless, the crucial point to grasp is that: The equity market’s earnings yield does not equal its prospective return. Charts I-2 - I-3 should make this point crystal clear. As you can see, the earnings yield rarely equals the delivered prospective 10-year return, either real or nominal. When the earnings yield is elevated, the prospective return turns out higher. Conversely, when the earnings yield is depressed, as now, the prospective return turns out to be much lower. Chart I-2The Equity Market's Earnings Yield Does NOT Equal Its Prospective Return, Either In Real Terms... Chart I-3...Or In Nominal ##br##Terms Therefore, to take the current earnings yield of 4.4 percent and subtract the real bond yield of -1.3 percent to derive an equity risk premium of +5.7 percent is analytically flawed, just as it is analytically flawed to subtract apples from oranges. To derive the equity risk premium, the correct approach is first to translate the earnings yield into a prospective 10-year return based on the established mathematical relationship between these variables. Chart I-4 does this and shows that, based on a very tight mathematical relationship through the past thirty five years, an earnings yield of 4.4 percent translates into a prospective 10-year nominal return of just 1 percent. Chart I-4We Must Mathematically Map The Earnings Yield Into A Prospective Return... Having translated the earnings yield into a prospective 10-year nominal return of 1 percent, we can now make an apples-for-apples comparison with the 10-year T-bond yield of 1.3 percent (Chart I-5). Chart I-5...And Only Then Subtract The Bond Yield Derived correctly therefore, the equity risk premium has turned negative for the first time since 2002 (Chart of the Week). We deduce that the equity market is very richly valued both in absolute terms and relative to bonds. And crucially, that this rich valuation is contingent on bond yields remaining ultra-low, or going even lower. Shorting Bonds Yielding 2 Percent Is A ‘Widow Maker’ All of which brings us to one of the most pressing questions we get from clients. When a bond is offering a feeble yield, what is the point in owning it? Maybe the best people to answer are the casualties of the now infamous ‘widow maker’ trades. The original widow maker trade was the idea that the yield on the Japanese Government Bond (JGB), at 2 percent, was so feeble that there was no point in owning it. Furthermore, with massive Japanese fiscal stimulus coming down the pike, the ‘no-brainer’ investment strategy was not just to disown the JGBs, but to take an outright short position, as it seemed that the only direction that JGB yields could go was up. In fact, JGB yields did not go up, they continued to trend down. As feeble yields became even feebler, the owners of the short positions got carried out of their careers, feet first. Meanwhile, those investors who owned 30-year JGBs yielding a ‘feeble’ 2 percent in 2013 reaped returns of 75 percent, and even now, are sitting on handsome profits of 55 percent. Some people protest that Japan is an exceptional and isolated case, rather than a template for economies which will not repeat their putative policy-errors. Such protests have always struck us as factually wrong, blinkered, and even prejudiced. Nevertheless, let’s indulge these prejudices with a simple rejoinder – forget Japan, what about Switzerland, or the UK? (Chart I-6) Chart I-6Shorting Bonds Yielding 2 Percent Is A 'Widow Maker' Just like the JGB widow maker, anybody who shorted UK gilts yielding 2 percent is nursing heavy losses. Meanwhile, those investors who owned 30-year UK gilts yielding a ‘feeble’ 2 percent in 2018 reaped returns of 40 percent, and even now are sitting on tidy profits of 30 percent. Just like the JGB widow maker, anybody who shorted UK gilts yielding 2 percent is nursing heavy losses. Bear in mind that a 30-year bond yielding a feeble 2 percent will deliver a cumulative return of more than 80 percent to redemption. And that if the feeble yield becomes even feebler, this return will get front-end loaded, creating widow makers for the short positions and spectacular gains for the long positions, as witnessed in JGBs and UK gilts. The 30-Year T-Bond Is A Must-Own Structural Investment The next candidate for the widow maker is shorting the US 30-year T-bond, which is yielding, you guessed it, 2 percent. Remember that while Japan may not be a great template for the US, the UK certainly is – because the US and UK have very similar economic, financial, political, social, and cultural structures. Until recently therefore, bond yields in the US and UK were moving in near-perfect lockstep (Chart I-7). Chart I-7The Difference Between US And UK Bond Yields Is Just That The UK Has Had One More Deflationary Shock So, what happened? The one word answer is: Brexit. The recent difference between US and UK bond yields is simply that the UK has had one more deflationary shock than the US. Put the other way around, the US is just one deflationary shock away from a UK level of bond yields – meaning the 30-year yield not at 2 percent, but at 1 percent. But why can’t the next shock be an inflationary shock resulting in much higher yields? The simple answer is that the equity risk premium has turned negative for the first time since 2002. Moreover, as we pointed out in The Road To Inflation Ends At Deflation the extremely rich valuation of $300 trillion of global real estate is also highly contingent on ultra-low bond yields. It follows that any significant rise in bond yields will collapse the value of $500 trillion of risk-assets. In a $90 trillion global economy, this will quickly flip any incipient inflationary shock into a deflationary shock. Any significant rise in bond yields will collapse the value of $500 trillion of risk-assets. We conclude that the US 30-year T-bond is a must-own structural investment. Fractal Analysis Update As hospitals have rushed to clear their backlog of non-pandemic treatments and procedures, medical equipment stock prices have surged. This is particularly true for US medical equipment (ticker IHI) which, since June, is up by 25 percent versus US healthcare services (Iqvia, Veeva, or loosely proxied by ticker XHS). Given that the backlog of treatments will eventually clear, and that the intense rally is now extremely fragile on its 65-day fractal structure (Chart I-8), a recommended countertrend trade is to short US medical equipment versus healthcare services. Set the profit target and symmetrical stop-loss at 8.5 percent. Chart I-8The Intense Rally In Medical Equipment Stocks Has Become Fragile Dhaval Joshi Chief Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System Fractal Trades 6-Month Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Equity Market Performance Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields ##br##- Euro Area Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields ##br##- Europe Ex Euro Area Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields ##br##- Asia Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields ##br##- Other Developed Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations

