Health Care
The S&P health care equipment (HCE) index is our only overweight within the health care universe, and over the past several weeks the index has been ripping higher. One of the likely catalysts behind the recent rally in US health care equipment manufacturers is the dollar. With exports accounting for a large portion of overall sales, a depreciating US dollar boosts international competitiveness of US manufacturers (middle panel). In turn, HCE stocks enjoy top line growth. On the domestic front the news is also welcoming. Our operating margin proxy, which gauges the difference between the industry’s PPI and wage bill, has made a clear U-turn (bottom panel). The upshot is that earnings will get a boost from this looming margin expansion. Bottom Line: We remain overweight the S&P HCE index. The ticker symbols for the stocks in the index are: BLBG: S5HCEP – ABT, MDT, DHR, BDX, SYK, ISRG, BSX, BAX, EW, ZBH, IDXX, RMD, TFX, HOLX, ABMD, VAR, STE, DXCM.
Please note that we will be on our summer holidays next week. Our next report will come out on August 20. Highlights The 30-year bond yield is the puppet master pulling the strings of all other investments. Where 30-year bond yields are still far from the lower bound, they will ultimately get a lot closer. Continue to overweight 30-year bonds in the US and periphery Europe versus 30-year bonds in core Europe. Continue to overweight the US stock market versus the European stock market. An expected near-term setback to stocks versus bonds will briefly pause the European currency rally. The gold rally is also due a pause, given that it is overstretched relative to the decline in the real bond yield. Fractal trade: Long USD/PLN. Feature Chart I-1AThe Collapsed 30-Year Bond Yield Explains The Collapse Of Banks... Chart I-1B...And The Collapsed Earnings Yield (Surging Valuation) Of Tech And Healthcare The abiding mantra of this publication is that investment is complex, but it is not complicated. By complex, we mean that the financial markets are not fully predictable or analysable. By not complicated, we mean that the relative prices of everything are inextricably connected, rather like the movements of a puppet. All you need to do is find the puppet master pulling the strings. Right now, the puppet master is the 30-year bond. The Real Action Is In 30-Year Bonds While most people are focussing on the 10-year bond yield, the real action has been at the ultra-long 30-year maturity. In the US and periphery Europe, 30-year yields are within a whisker of all-time lows. Yet these ultra-long bond yields are still well above those in core Europe which are much closer to the lower bound. The upshot is that while all yields have equal scope to rise, yields have more scope to fall further in the US and periphery Europe than in core Europe (Chart I-2 and Chart I-3). Chart I-230-Year Yields In The US And Periphery Europe... Chart I-3...Are Still Well Above Those In ##br##Core Europe This simple asymmetry has created a winning relative value strategy that will keep on winning. Overweight 30-year bonds in the US and periphery Europe versus 30-year bonds in core Europe. Our preferred expression is to overweight 30-year bonds in the US and Spain versus Germany and France. Bond yields have more scope to fall further in the US and periphery Europe than in core Europe. Remarkably, in the US, the 10-year real yield is also tightly tracking the 30-year nominal yield (minus a constant 2.2 percent) (Chart I-4). Using a little algebra, this means that the market’s 10-year inflation expectation is just a steady-state value of 2.2 percent minus a shortfall equalling the shortfall in the 10-year nominal yield versus the 30-year nominal yield (Chart I-5). Chart I-4The 10-Year Real Yield Is Just ##br##Tracking The 30-Year Nominal ##br##Yield Chart I-5The 10-Year Inflation Expectation Can Be Derived From The 30-Year And 10-Year Nominal Yields 10-year inflation expectation = 2.2 – (30-year nominal yield – 10-year nominal yield) The reason that this is remarkable is we can explain the trend in inflation expectations from just the 30-year and 10-year nominal yields, and nothing more. In turn, gold is tightly tracking the inverted real yield, as it theoretically should. Gold, which generates no yield, becomes relatively more valuable as the real yield on other assets diminishes (Chart I-6). Having said that, the most recent surge in the gold price is stretched relative to its relationship with the real bond yield, suggesting that the strong rally in gold is due a pause (Chart I-7). Chart I-6Gold Is Just Tracking The (Inverted) Real Yield... Chart I-7...But Gold's Most Recent Surge Is ##br##Stretched The 30-Year Bond Is Driving Stock Markets Moving to the stock market, bank relative performance has closely tracked the collapse in the 30-year yield, because the collapsed bond yield signals both weaker bank credit growth and a likely increase in banks’ non-performing loans (Chart of the Week, left panel). Banks and other ‘value cyclicals’ whose cashflows are in terminal decline are highly sensitive to the prospects for near-term cashflows, which are under severe pressure in the pandemic era. At the same time, as the distant cashflows are small, the banks’ share prices are less sensitive to the uplifted net present values of these distant cashflows that come from lower bond yields. In contrast, technology, healthcare and other ‘growth defensives’ generate a growing stream of cashflows. Making their net present values highly sensitive to a change in the bond yield used to discount those large distant cashflows. The profits of the tech and healthcare sectors are proving to be highly resilient in the pandemic era. Through 2018, the 30-year yield went up by 1 percent, so the forward earnings yield of growth defensives went up by 1 percent (their valuations fell). Subsequently, the 30-year yield has collapsed by 2 percent, so unsurprisingly the forward earnings yield of growth defensives has also collapsed by 2 percent (their valuations have surged). To repeat, financial markets are not complicated (Chart of the Week, right panel). Moreover, the profits of the growth defensives are proving to be highly resilient in the pandemic era, holding up well in the worst shock to demand since the Great Depression. The combination of resilient profits with higher valuations explains why the technology and healthcare sectors are reaching new highs, while the rest of the stock market is going nowhere (Chart I-8). Chart I-8Tech And Healthcare At New Highs While The Rest Of The Market Languishes Meanwhile, the relative performance of stock markets is also uncomplicated. It just stems from the relative exposure to the high-flying growth defensive sectors. Compared with Europe, the US has a 20 percent larger exposure to technology and healthcare (Chart I-9). Which is all you need to explain the consistent outperformance of the US versus Europe (Chart I-10). Chart I-9The US Is 20 Percent Over-Exposed To Tech And Healthcare... Chart I-10...Which Explains Its Consistent Outperformance Versus Europe A Quick Comment On European Currencies And The Dollar Turning to the foreign exchange market, the recent rally in European currencies can at least partly be explained as a sell-off in the dollar. Begging the question, what is behind the dollar’s recent weakness? The dollar has moved as a mirror-image of the global stock market. For the broad dollar index, the explanation is quite straightforward. True to its traditional role as a haven currency, the dollar has moved as a mirror-image of the global stock market, measured by the MSCI All Country World Index (in local currencies). Simply put, as the stock market has shaken off its year-to-date losses, the dollar has shaken off its year-to-date gains (Chart I-11). Chart I-11The Dollar Has Just Tracked The (Inverted) Stock Market Looking ahead, we can link the prospects of currencies to the outlook for 30-year bond yields. A further compression in yields will weaken the dollar, and help European currencies, in two ways. First, as already mentioned, yields have more scope to decline in the US than in core Europe, and a fading US yield premium will weigh on the dollar. Second, to the extent that the lower yields can prevent a protracted bear market in stocks and other risk-assets, non-haven currencies can perform well versus the haven dollar. Having said that, an expected near-term setback to stocks versus bonds will briefly pause the European currency rally. Concluding Remarks The charts in this report should leave you in no doubt that the 30-year bond yield – particularly in the US – is the puppet master pulling the strings of all investments: bond market relative performance, real bond yields, gold, banks, growth defensives, equity market relative performance, and major currencies. Which raises the crucial question, can the downtrend in 30-year bond yields continue? Yes, absent an imminent vaccine or treatment for Covid-19, the downtrend in yields can continue. As we explained last week in An Economy Without Mouths And Noses Will Lose 10 Percent Of Jobs, the spectre of mass unemployment is looming large. Specifically, the major threat to the jobs market lies in the coming months when government lifelines to employers – such as state-subsidised furlough schemes – are cut or weakened. Where 30-year bond yields are still far from the lower bound, they will ultimately get a lot closer. Hence, it is inevitable that those central banks that can become more dovish will become more dovish. Given the political difficulties of using fiscal policy bullets, the lessons from Japan and Europe are that the monetary policy bullets get fully expended first. In practical terms, this means that where 30-year bond yields are still far from the lower bound, they will ultimately get a lot closer. The upshot is that core European bonds will continue to underperform US bonds, and that the European stock market will continue to underperform the US stock market. European currencies will trend higher versus the dollar, albeit a setback to stocks versus bonds is a near-term risk to the European currency uptrend. Fractal Trading System* This week’s recommended trade is to play a potential countertrend move in the dollar via long USD/PLN. The profit target and symmetrical stop-loss is set at 4 percent. The rolling 1-year win ratio now stands at 57 percent. Chart I-12USD/PLN When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Dhaval Joshi Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
Neutral – Downgrade Alert There is trouble brewing for the S&P pharmaceuticals index as President Trump recently signed four executive orders geared toward lowering drug pricing for Americans. Trump is not the only one who is ready to fight Big Pharma. In recent research we also highlighted that Biden will be tough on pharma, especially on the industry’s pricing power. The implication is that irrespective of who the next President is, the S&P pharmaceuticals index will come under intense scrutiny. Consequently, we find the relative 4% year-over-year sales growth estimates overly optimistic (third panel). The sell-side community is also forecasting even more impressive relative EPS growth over the next 12 months. This is a tall order as double digit relative profit growth typically marks a peak in relative share price performance (second panel). Nevertheless there is a significant offset to the grim pharma selling price backdrop: compelling valuations. The forward P/E is trading at a nearly 40% discount to the broad market a multi decade low, even piercing through the GFC lows (bottom panel). Bottom Line: We remain neutral the S&P pharmaceuticals index, but it is now on our downgrade watch list.
Highlights For financials and energy to produce a sustained rally, there must be no relapse in global growth during the autumn and winter of 2020/21. However, with the coronavirus still in play and the usual flu and virus season yet to come, a key hurdle to overcome will be the physical reopening of schools and childcare facilities this September. Hence, for the time being, remain overweight healthcare and technology versus financials and energy. This implies underweight European stocks versus US stocks, and overweight Germany, France, Netherlands and Switzerland within Europe. Play good news in Europe by remaining long EUR, CHF, and SEK versus USD, and long US T-bonds and Spanish Bonos versus German Bunds and French OATs. Fractal trade: Short silver. Feature Chart Of The WeekDenmark's OMX Is At An All-Time High, While The FTSE 100 Is Languishing. Why? Once upon a time, the stock market existed as a barometer of the economy. Or at least, a good representation of the size and composition of profits in the host economy. But that time is long gone. Today, a tiny handful of companies are driving the performance of supposedly broad indexes such as the FTSE 100 and the S&P 500. Indeed, we should more accurately call the FTSE 100 the FTSE ‘10’ ignoring the other 90. And we should call the S&P 500 the S&P ‘5’ ignoring the other 495. Meaning that stock markets are no longer stock ‘markets’. Yet many analysts still try and explain the stock market’s performance through traditional top-down macro drivers such as GDP growth, profit margins across the host economy, and so on. The trouble is that when the stock market is dominated by a tiny handful of companies, this 20th century approach is doomed to fail. Today, we must take a more granular approach based on the type of companies that are dominating each stock market. Sector Concentration Is Driving Stock Markets The handful of companies that dominate each stock market tend to be the leaders in their global sector. This means that each stock market is defined by a sector concentration, which has often evolved by chance, based on where companies chose to start up and list. This sector concentration usually has little or no connection with the host economy. For example, Denmark’s OMX index is dominated by Novo Nordisk, a global biotech company. The FTSE 100 is heavily weighted to the oil majors Royal Dutch and BP as well as global bank HSBC, which have only a limited exposure to the UK economy. On the other side of the Atlantic, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Google and Facebook are massively over-represented in the S&P 500 compared with their contribution to the US economy. A crucial defining feature of a stock market turns out to be its exposure to healthcare and technology – whose profits are in major structural uptrends – versus the exposure to financials and energy – whose profits are in major structural downtrends (Charts 2 - 5). Chart I-2Healthcare Profits Are In A Structural Uptrend Chart I-3Technology Profits Are In A Structural Uptrend Chart I-4Financial Profits Are In A Structural Downtrend Chart I-5Energy Profits Are In A Structural Downtrend The stock market capitalisation in healthcare and technology stands at 52 percent for Denmark and 40 percent for the US, compared with just 20 percent for Europe and 12 percent for the UK. The flip side is that the stock market capitalisation in financials and energy stands at just 8 percent for Denmark and 11 percent for the US, compared with 21 percent for Europe and 30 percent for the UK. This explains, for example, why Denmark’s OMX is hitting all-time highs while the FTSE 100 is languishing (Chart of the Week). That said, the price of the growing stream of healthcare and technology profits can still fall if it is at an unjustifiably high level. And the price of the shrinking stream of financial and energy profits can still rise if it is at an unjustifiably low level. Hence, the key question is: what determines the prices of these two groups of sectors, one whose profits are in a major uptrend, the other whose profits are in a major downtrend? Healthcare And Tech Performance Hinges On The Bond Yield The price of a rapidly growing profit stream is weighted to the values of the large distant cashflows, making it highly sensitive to the discount rate applied to those distant cashflows. Whereas the price of a rapidly shrinking profit stream is weighted to the values of the large immediate cashflows, making it much more sensitive to the near-term evolution of the economy (Box I-1). Box I-1Bond Yield Sensitivity Versus Economic Sensitivity The upshot is that for stocks and sectors whose profits are in a major uptrend, the key driver of the price is the direction of the bond yield. Whereas for stocks and sectors whose profits are in a major downtrend, the key driver is the near-term direction of the world economy (Chart I-6 and Chart I-7). Chart I-6Exposure To Healthcare And Technology Determines Bond Yield Sensitivity Chart I-7Exposure To Financials And Energy Determines Economic Sensitivity Pulling all of this together, the rally in healthcare and technology stocks is extremely vulnerable to a sustained rise in the bond yield. But a sustained rise in the bond yield seems highly unlikely without a breakthrough vaccine or treatment for COVID-19. While the coronavirus is still in play, the long-term hollowing out and scarring in the jobs market will only become apparent in the coming months once furlough schemes and temporary relief programs end. This will force all central banks to remain ultra-dovish and where possible, become more dovish. Meanwhile, for financials and energy to produce a sustained rally, there must be no relapse in global growth during the autumn and winter of 2020/21. However, with the coronavirus still in play and the usual flu and virus season yet to come, a key hurdle to overcome will be the physical reopening of schools and childcare facilities this September. Hence, for the time being, remain overweight healthcare and technology versus financials and energy. This translates to underweight Europe versus the US. And overweight Germany, France, Netherlands and Switzerland within Europe. How To Play Good News In Europe Things have been going right in Europe. First, unlike in the US, the COVID-19 outbreak is subsiding, at least for now. New infections have been steadily declining through the warm summer months (Chart I-8). Chart I-8New Infections Declining In Europe, Rising In The US Second, the ECB has injected ample liquidity into the banking system which, combined with ultra-low interest rates, has permitted a strong expansion in bank lending. Though somewhat disappointingly, the bank lending surveys tell us that the loans are being used for emergency working capital requirements rather than investment. Third, the EU has approved a €750 billion Recovery Fund, over half of which will take the form of grants to the sectors and regions most stricken by the coronavirus crisis. Given that the fund will be financed by jointly issued EU bonds, this amounts to a fiscal transfer to the areas that need the most help. Hence, even if the amount of the stimulus may be smaller than in other parts of the word, it comprises a huge symbolic step towards greater unity in the EU and euro area. Still, despite this trifecta of good news, European stock markets have not outperformed (Chart I-9). This just emphasises that stock market relative performance has little connection with domestic economics and politics. To reiterate, stock market relative performance is almost always the result of the sector concentration of a handful of dominant stocks. Chart I-9Despite Good News In Europe, European Equities Are Not Outperforming Begging the question: how to play the continuation of good news in Europe? The answer is through the currency and fixed income markets, which have a much stronger connection with domestic economics and politics (Chart I-10 and Chart I-11). Chart I-10Play Good News In Europe Via European Currencies... Chart I-11...And Sovereign Yield Spread Tightening Remain long a basket of EUR, CHF, and SEK versus the USD. Our favourite cross out of these three is long CHF/USD given the haven character of the CHF in periods of market stress. To play bond yield convergence between the US and Europe and between core and periphery Europe, remain long US 30-year T-bonds and Spanish 30-year Bonos versus German 30-year bunds and French 30-year OATs. Dhaval Joshi Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System* The spectacular rally in silver is fractally fragile, and at a point which has signalled several trend reversals through the past five years. Accordingly, this week’s recommended trade is short silver, with the profit target and symmetrical stop-loss set at 12.5 percent. In other trades, long GBP/RUB achieved its profit target. Against this, short Germany versus UK and long bitcoin cash versus ethereum reached their stop-losses. Long nickel versus copper reached the end of its holding period in partial loss. The rolling 12-month win ratio now stands at 59 percent. When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Fractal Trading System Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and the current pageant suggests the most attractive country in the world is Israel. The basis is valuation and the structural change we are witnessing in global economies. With the advent of COVID-19, “platform”…
Highlights The economic performance of Sweden, which did not have a lockdown, has been almost as bad as Denmark, which did have a lockdown. This proves that the current recession is not ‘man-made’, it is ‘pandemic-made’. While the pandemic remains in play, investors should maintain a defensive bias to their portfolios: favouring US T-bonds in bond portfolios, and technology and healthcare in equity portfolios. The technology sector has become defensive, largely because it has flipped from hardware dominance to software dominance. A new recommendation is to overweight technology-heavy Netherlands. Fractal trade: short AUD/CHF. Feature Chart I-IASweden: Avoiding A Lockdown Did Not Prevent A Slump In Consumption... Chart I-1B...But Led To Many More ##br##Infections Sweden and Denmark are neighbours. They speak near-identical languages and share a broadly similar culture and demographic. Yet the two countries have followed completely different strategies to halt the coronavirus pandemic. Sweden chose not to impose a lockdown. Instead, it opted for a ‘trust based’ approach, relying on its citizens to act sensibly and appropriately. Whereas Denmark imposed one of Europe’s earliest and most draconian lockdowns. The contrasting approaches of Sweden and neighbouring Denmark provide us with the closest thing to a controlled experiment on pandemic strategies. The Recession Is Not ‘Man-Made’, It Is ‘Pandemic-Made’ The surprising thing is that the economic performance of Sweden, which did not have a lockdown, has been almost as bad as Denmark, which did. This year, the unemployment rates in both economies have surged by 2 percentage points (albeit the latest data is for May in Sweden and April in Denmark). Furthermore, high-frequency measures of consumption show that Sweden suffered almost as severe a contraction as Denmark (Chart of the Week and Chart I-2). Chart I-2Unemployment Has Surged In Both No-Lockdown Sweden And Lockdown Denmark This surprising result challenges the popular view that this global recession is man-made. This view argues that without the government-imposed lockdowns, the global economy would not have entered a tailspin. But if this view is right, then why did consumption crash in Sweden? The simple answer is that in a pandemic, most people will change their behaviour to avoid catching the virus. The cautious behaviour is voluntary, irrespective of whether there is no lockdown, as in Sweden, or there is a lockdown, as in Denmark. People will shun public transport, shopping, and other crowded places, and even think twice about letting their children go to school. In a pandemic, the majority of people will change their behaviour even without a lockdown. But if the cautious behaviour is voluntary, then why impose a lockdown? The answer is that without a lockdown, the majority will behave sensibly to avoid catching the virus, but a minority will take a ‘devil may care’ attitude. In the pandemic, this is critical because less than 10 percent of infected people are responsible for creating 90 percent of all coronavirus infections. If this tiny minority of so-called ‘super-spreaders’ is left unchecked, then the pandemic will let rip. All of which brings us back to Sweden versus Denmark. As a result of not imposing a mandatory lockdown to rein in its super-spreaders, Sweden now has one of the world’s worst coronavirus infection and mortality rates, four times higher than Denmark (Chart I-3, Chart I-4, Chart I-5). Chart I-3No-Lockdown Sweden Has Suffered Many More Deaths Than Lockdown Denmark Chart I-4Avoiding A Lockdown Meant More Infections… Chart I-5…And More ##br##Deaths Put simply, containing the pandemic depends on reining in a minority of super-spreaders. Which explains why no-lockdown Sweden suffered a much worse outbreak of the disease than lockdown Denmark. In contrast, the economy depends on the behaviour of the majority. In a pandemic the majority will voluntarily exercise caution. Which explains why no-lockdown Sweden and lockdown Denmark suffered similar contractions in consumption. Looking ahead, will the widespread adoption of face masks and plexiglass screens change the public’s cautious behaviour? To a certain extent, yes – it will permit essential activities and let people take calculated risks. That said, if you are forced to wear a mask on public transport and in the shops, and you have to spread out in restaurants while being served by a masked waiter, then – rightly or wrongly – you are getting a strong signal: the danger is still out there. Meaning that many people will continue to shun discretionary activities and spending. The upshot is that while the pandemic remains in play, investors should maintain a defensive bias to their portfolios. Explaining Why Technology Is Now Defensive A defensive bias to your portfolio now requires an exposure to technology – because in 2020 the tech sector is behaving like a classic defensive. Its relative performance is correlating positively with the bond price, like other classic defensive sectors such as healthcare (Chart I-6 and Chart I-7). Chart I-6In 2020, Tech Is Behaving Like A Defensive... Chart I-7...Like Healthcare The behaviour of the technology sector in the current recession contrasts with its performance in the global financial crisis of 2008. Back then, it behaved like a classic cyclical – its relative performance correlated negatively with the bond price (Chart I-8). Begging the question: why has the tech sector’s behaviour flipped from cyclical to defensive? Chart I-8In 2008, Tech Behaved Like A Cyclical The main reason is that the tech sector’s composition has flipped from hardware dominance to software dominance. In 2008, the sector market cap had a 65:35 tilt to technology hardware. But today, it is the mirror-image: a 65:35 tilt to computer and software services (Chart I-9). Chart I-9Tech Is More Defensive Now Because It Is Dominated By Software Computer and software services have many defensive characteristics suited to the current environment: For many companies, enterprise software is now business critical. It is a must-have rather than a like-to-have. Computer and software services use a subscription-based revenue model, minimising the dependency on discretionary spending. Computer and software services are helping firms to cut costs through automation and back-office efficiencies as well as facilitating the boom in ‘working from home’. The sector is cash rich. Despite these defensive characteristics, there remains a lingering worry: is the tech sector overvalued? The Rally In Growth Defensives Is Not A Mania Some people fear that the recent run-up in stock markets does not make sense, other than as a ‘Robin Hood’ day-trader fuelled mania. After all, the pandemic is still very much in play, and so are other geopolitical risks, so how can some stock prices be near all-time highs? Yet the recent run-up in growth defensives such as tech and healthcare does make sense. Their valuations have moved in near-perfect lockstep with the bond yield, implying that the rally is based on fundamentals (Chart I-10). Chart I-10Tech And Healthcare Valuations Are Tracking The Bond Yield Simply put, if the 10-year T-bond is going to deliver a pitiful 0.7 percent a year over the next decade, then the prospective return from growth defensives must also compress. It would be absurd to expect these stocks to be priced for high single digit returns. Since late 2018, the decline in growth defensives’ forward earnings yield has broadly tracked the 250bps decline in the 10-year T-bond yield. Given that the forward earnings yield correlates well with the 10-year prospective return, the depressed bond yield is depressing the prospective return from growth defensives – as it should. Tech and healthcare valuations have moved in near-perfect lockstep with the bond yield. But with the pandemic and geopolitical risks menacing in the background, shouldn’t the gap between the prospective return on stocks and bonds – the equity risk premium – be larger? This is open to debate. When bond yields approach the lower bound, the appeal of owning bonds also diminishes because bond prices have limited upside. Nevertheless, the gap between the tech and healthcare forward earnings yield and the bond yield has gone up this year and is much larger than in 2018 (Chart I-11). This suggests that valuations are taking some account of the pandemic and other risks. Moreover, in a longer-term perspective the current gap between the tech and healthcare forward earnings yield and the bond yield, at +4 percent, hardly indicates a mania. In the true mania of 2000, the gap stood at -4 percent! (Chart I-12) Chart I-11The Equity Risk Premium Has Risen In 2020 Chart I-12Tech And Health Care Valuations Are Not In A Mania In summary, until the pandemic is conquered, investors should maintain a defensive bias to their portfolios. Bond investors should overweight US T-bonds versus core European bonds. Equity investors should overweight the growth defensives, technology and healthcare, which implies overweighting the technology-heavy US versus Europe. A new recommendation is to overweight technology-heavy Netherlands. Stay overweight healthcare-heavy Switzerland, and bank-light France and Germany (albeit expect a technical 5 percent underperformance of Germany versus the UK in the coming weeks). And stay underweight bank-heavy Austria. Fractal Trading System* The AUD is technically overbought and vulnerable to a tactical reversal. Accordingly, this week’s recommended trade is short AUD/CHF, with a profit target and symmetrical stop-loss set at 4.2 percent. The rolling 1-year win ratio now stands at 63 percent. Chart I-13AUD/CHF When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Dhaval Joshi Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations

