Norway
Highlights The long term direction for the pound is higher... ...but as the EU withdrawal bill passes through the U.K. parliament, expect a very hairy ride. The stock markets in Norway, Sweden and Denmark are driven by energy, industrials, and biotech respectively. Upgrade Sweden to neutral and downgrade Denmark to underweight. Think of semiconductors as twenty-first century commodities. Overweight the semiconductor sector versus broader technology indexes. Chart of the WeekBritish Public Opinion On Brexit Is Shifting Feature The Brexit drama is playing out exactly as scripted (Chart I-2). Chart I-2The Pound Is Following The Brexit Drama In July, we wrote: "The U.K. government's much hyped 'Chequers' proposal for Brexit risks getting a cold shower... the EU27 will almost instantaneously reject the proposed division between goods and services as 'cherry-picking' from its indivisible four freedoms - goods, services, capital, and people... the rejection will be based not just on the EU's founding principles, but also on the practical realities of a modern economy - specifically, the distinction between goods and services has become increasingly blurred." 1 Hence, the Chequers proposal to avoid a hard border between Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic is just wishful thinking: "The Irish border trilemma will remain unsolved, leaving a 'backstop' option of Northern Ireland remaining in the EU single market - an outcome that will be politically unpalatable." 2 What happens next? Understanding Brexit In a sense, Brexit is very simple. The EU27 sees only three options for the long-term political and economic relationship between the U.K. and the EU. Remain in the EU (no Brexit). Plug into an off-the-shelf setup, either the European Economic Area (EEA), European Free Trade Association (EFTA), or a permanent customs union, which already establish the EU relationship with Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein, and Switzerland (soft Brexit). Become a 'third country' to the EU like, for example, Canada (hard Brexit). The first option, to stay in the EU, is politically impossible unless a new U.K. referendum overturned the original referendum's vote to leave. The second option, to join the EEA, EFTA, or permanent customs union is very difficult for Theresa May - because it is strongly opposed by many of the Conservative government's ministers and members of parliament who regard the option as 'Brino' (Brexit in name only). However, in a significant recent development, the opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn has committed the Labour party to a Brexit that keeps the U.K. in a permanent customs union.3 The third option, to become a 'third country', would very likely require some sort of border in Ireland. As already discussed, the only way to avoid a border would be a perfect alignment between the U.K and EU on tariffs and regulations for goods and services. But then, there would be little point in becoming a third country. Here's the crucial issue. The EU27 does not know which option the U.K. will eventually take, yet it must provide an 'all-weather' safeguard for the Good Friday peace agreement, requiring no border between Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic. Therefore, the EU27 will need the withdrawal agreement to commit: either the whole of the U.K. to a potentially permanent customs union with the EU; or Northern Ireland to a potentially permanent customs separation from the rest of the U.K. - in effect, breaking up the U.K by creating a border between Britain and Northern Ireland. Clearly, the hard Brexiters and/or Northern Ireland unionist MPs will vote down a withdrawal bill which contains either of these commitments, thereby wiping out Theresa May's slender majority. The intriguing question is: might Labour MPs - or enough of them - vote for a potentially permanent customs union to get the soft Brexit they want? Labour would be torn between the national interest and the party interest, as it would be missing a golden opportunity to topple the Conservative government. If the withdrawal bill musters a majority, it would remove the prospect of a 'no deal' Brexit and the pound would rally - because it would liberate the Bank of England to hike interest rates more aggressively (Chart I-3 and Chart I-4). If the bill failed, the government and specifically Theresa May would be badly wounded. She might call a general election there and then. Chart I-3Absent Brexit, U.K. Interest Rates Would Be Higher Chart I-4Absent Brexit, U.K. Interest Rates Would Be Higher If May limped on, parliament would nevertheless have the final say on whether to proceed with a no deal Brexit. And the parliamentary arithmetic indicates that a clear majority of MPs would vote against proceeding over the cliff-edge. At this point with the government paralysed, the only way to unlock the paralysis would be to go back to the people. Either in a general election or in a new referendum, the key issue for the public would be a choice between one of the three aforementioned options for the U.K./EU long-term relationship - because by then, it would be clear that those are the only options on offer. Based on a clear recent shift in British public opinion, the preference is more likely to be for a soft (or no) Brexit than to become a third country (Chart of the Week). Bottom Line: The long term direction for the pound is higher but, as the withdrawal bill passes through parliament, expect a very hairy ride. Understanding Scandinavian Stock Markets The Scandinavian countries - Norway, Sweden, and Denmark - have many things in common: their languages, cultures, and lifestyles, to name just a few. However, when it comes to their stock markets, the three countries could not be more different. Looking at the three bourses, each has a defining dominant sector (or sectors) whose market weighting swamps all others. In Norway, oil and gas accounts for over 40 percent of the market; in Sweden, industrials accounts for 30 percent of the market and financials accounts for another 30 percent; and in Denmark, healthcare accounts for 50 percent of the market (Table I-1). Table I-1The Scandinavian Stock Markets Could Not Be More Different! In a sense, the dominant equity market sectors in Norway and Sweden just reflect their economies. Norway has a large energy sector; Sweden specializes in advanced industrial equipment and machinery and it also has very high level of private sector indebtedness, explaining the outsized weighting in banks. However, Denmark's equity market - dominated as it is by Novo Nordisk, which is essentially a biotech company - has little connection with Denmark's economy. The important point is that the four dominant sectors - oil and gas, industrials, financials, and biotech - each outperform or underperform as global (or at least pan-regional) sectors. If oil and gas outperforms, it outperforms everywhere and not just locally. It follows that the relative performance of the four dominant equity sectors drives the relative stock market performances of Norway, Sweden, and Denmark. Norway versus Sweden = Energy versus Industrials (Chart I-5) Chart I-5Norway Vs. Sweden = Energy Vs. Industrials Norway versus Denmark = Energy versus Biotech (Chart I-6) Chart I-6Norway Vs. Denmark = Energy Vs. Biotech Sweden versus Denmark = Industrials and Financials versus Biotech (Chart I-7) Chart I-7Sweden Vs. Denmark = Industrials And Financials Vs. Biotech Last week, we upgraded some of the more classical cyclical sectors to a relative overweight. Our argument was that if an inflationary impulse is dominating, beaten-down cyclicals have more upside than the more richly-valued equity sectors; and if a disinflationary impulse from higher bond yields is dominating, its main casualty will be the more richly-valued equity sectors. On this basis, our ranking of the four sectors is: Industrials, Financials, Energy, Biotech. Which means the ranking of the Scandinavian stock markets is: Sweden, Norway, Denmark. Bottom Line: From a pan-European perspective, upgrade Sweden to neutral and downgrade Denmark to underweight. Understanding Semiconductors The best way to understand semiconductors is to think of them as twenty-first century commodities. In the twentieth century, many everyday goods and products contained a classical commodity such as copper. Today, the ubiquity of electronic gadgets, devices, and screens contains a twenty-first century equivalent: the microchip. Hence, semiconductors are to the tech world what classical commodities are to the non-tech world. They exhibit exactly the same cycle of relative performance. If, as we expect, beaten-down industrial commodities outperform, it follows that the beaten-down semiconductor sector will outperform broader technology indexes (Chart I-8). Chart I-8Semiconductors Follow The Commodity Cycle Bottom Line: Overweight the semiconductor sector versus technology. Dhaval Joshi, Senior Vice President Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com 1 For example, the sale of a car is no longer the sale of just a good. As car companies often structure the financing of the car purchase, a car purchase can be a hybrid of a good - the car itself, and a service - the financing package. Therefore, a single market for cars requires a single market for both goods and services. 2 The Irish border trilemma comprises: 1. the U.K./EU land border between Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic; 2. the Good Friday peace agreement requiring the absence of any physical border within Ireland; 3.the Northern Ireland unionists' refusal to countenance a U.K./EU border at the Irish Sea, which would entail a customs border between Northern Ireland and the rest of the U.K. 3 At the Labour Party's just-held 2018 conference, Jeremy Corbyn made a commitment to joining a permanent U.K./EU customs union. Fractal Trading Model* This week's recommended trade comes from Down Under. The 25% outperformance of Australian telecoms (driven by Telstra) versus insurers (driven by IAG and AMP) over the past 3 months appears technically extended, with a 65-day fractal dimension at a level that has regularly indicated the start of a countertrend move. Therefore, the recommended trade is short Australian telecoms versus insurers, setting a profit target of 7% and a symmetrical stop-loss. In other trades, long CRB Industrial commodities versus MSCI World Index achieved its profit target very quickly, leaving four open trades. For any investment, excessive trend following and groupthink can reach a natural point of instability, at which point the established trend is highly likely to break down with or without an external catalyst. An early warning sign is the investment's fractal dimension approaching its natural lower bound. Encouragingly, this trigger has consistently identified countertrend moves of various magnitudes across all asset classes. Chart I-9 The post-June 9, 2016 fractal trading model rules are: When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. Use the position size multiple to control risk. The position size will be smaller for more risky positions. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report "Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model," dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading Model Recommendations Equities Bond & Interest Rates Currency & Other Positions Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart I-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart I-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
Highlights Global Inflation has upside on a cyclical basis, but this narrative is well known and investors have already placed their bets accordingly, buying inflation protection in a wide swath of markets. However, global growth has not yet found its footing, suggesting a mini-deflation scare, at least relative to expectations, is likely this summer. The U.S. dollar will benefit in such a scenario, and NOK/SEK will depreciate. While GBP/USD has downside, the pound should rally versus the euro. Weakness in EUR/CAD has not yet fully played out; the recent bout of strength was only a countertrend move. Feature Inflation is coming back, and this will obviously have major consequences for both asset and currency markets. However, macro investing is not just about forecasting fundamentals correctly; often, just as importantly, it is about understanding how other investors have priced in these expected economic developments. Therein lies the problem. While we understand why inflation could pick up, so too have most investors, and they have positioned themselves accordingly. With global growth currently looking shaky, we believe a better entry point for long-inflation plays will emerge in the coming months. In the meanwhile, a defensive, pro-U.S. dollar posture still makes sense. Investors Are Long Inflation Bets We have long argued that inflation was likely to make a cyclical comeback, a return that would begin in the U.S. before spreading to the rest of the globe. This story is currently playing out. However, in response these developments, investors have placed their bets accordingly, and the story currently seems well baked in. Prices of assets traditionally levered to inflation have already moved to discount a significant pick-up in inflation. The most evident dynamics can be observed in the U.S. inflation breakevens. Both the 10-year breakevens as well as the 5-year/5-year forward breakevens just experienced some of their sharpest two-year changes of the past 20 years, notwithstanding the pricing out of a post-Lehman, depression-like outcome (Chart I-1). Breakevens are not alone. Other assets have displayed similar behavior. In the U.S., investors have aggressively sold their holdings of utilities stocks, which have been greatly outperformed by industrial stocks. Traditionally, investors lift the price of XLI relative to that of XLU when they anticipate global inflation to pick up (Chart I-2). Chart I-1Markets Are Positioning Themselves##br## For Higher Inflation Chart I-2U.S. Sectoral Performance Suggests Investors ##br##Have Already Bet On Higher Inflation... It is not just intra-equity market dynamics that support this assertion. The behavior of the U.S. stock market relative to Treasurys further buttresses the idea that investors have already aggressively discounted an upturn in global consumer prices (Chart I-3). Potentially, the best illustration of investors' preference for inflation protection is currently visible in EM assets. A seemingly paradoxical phenomenon has been puzzling us: How have EM equities managed to avoid the gravitational pull that has caused EM bonds to nearly flirt with the nadir of early 2016? After all, EM equities, EM currencies and EM bonds are normally closely correlated, driven by investors' wagers on the direction of global growth. A simple variable can explain this strange dichotomy: anticipated inflation. As Chart I-4 illustrates, the performance of a volatility adjusted long EM stocks / short EM bonds portfolio tends to anticipate fluctuations in global inflation. The current price action in this basket indicates that investors have made their bets, and they think inflation is going up. Chart I-3...So Does The Stock-To-Bond Ratio Chart I-4Inflation Bets Explain Why EM Stocks And EM Bond Prices Have Diverged Anecdotal evidence suggests that in recent quarters, pension plans have been aggressive buyers of commodities - a move that normally coincides with these long-term investors putting in place some inflation hedges. Moreover, positioning in the futures markets corroborates these stories: speculators are still very long commodities like copper and oil - commodities traditionally perceived as efficient protectors against inflation spikes (Chart I-5). Finally, despite the potentially deflationary risks created by Italy three weeks ago, speculators remain short U.S. Treasury futures, bond investors are underweight duration, and sentiment toward the bond market remains near its lowest levels of the past eight years (Chart I-6). Again, this behavior is consistent with investors being positioned for an inflationary environment. Chart I-5Money Has Flown Into Resources Chart I-6Bond Market Positioning Is Still Very Short Bottom Line: There is a well-defined case to be made that a global economy that was not so long ago defined by the presence of deflationary risks is now morphing into a world where inflation is on the upswing. However, based on inflation breakevens, sectoral relative performance, equities relative to bonds in both DM and EM as well as on the positioning of investors in commodity and bond markets, this changing state has been quickly discounted by investors. The Decks Are Stacked, But Where Does The Economic Risk Lie? The problem facing investors already long inflation protection every which way they can be is that the global economy is slowing, which normally elicits deflationary fears, not inflationary ones. This seems a recipe for disappointment, albeit one that is likely to help the dollar. Our global economic and financial A/D line, which tallies the proportion of key variables around the world moving in a growth-friendly fashion, has fallen precipitously. This normally heralds a slowdown in global economic activity (Chart I-7). Chart I-7Global Growth Is Losing Traction In similar vein, global leading economic indicators have also begun to roll over - a trend that could gain further vigor if the diffusion index of OECD economies experiencing rising versus contracting LEIs is to be believed (Chart I-8). The global liquidity picture has also deteriorated enough to warrant caution. Currency carry strategies - as approximated by the performance of EM carry trades funded in yen - have sagged violently. This tells us that funds are flowing out of EM economies and moving back to countries already replete with excess savings like Japan or Switzerland (Chart I-9). Historically, these kinds of negative developments for global liquidity have preceded industrial slowdowns, as EM now accounts for the lion's share of global IP growth. Finally, China doesn't yet look set to bail out the world's industrial sector. This month's money and credit numbers were weaker than anticipated, and our leading indicator for the Li-Keqiang index - our preferred gauge of industrial activity in the Middle Kingdom - points to further weakness (Chart I-10). This makes it unlikely that China's imports will rise, lifting global growth. Additionally, China has re-stocked in various commodities, suggesting it is front-running its own domestic demand, highlighting the risk that its commodities intake could become even weaker than what domestic growth implies. Chart I-8More Weakness In LEIs Chart I-9Global Liquidity Tightening Chart I-10China Not Yet Set To Bail Out The World With this kind of backdrop, we expect the current slowdown in global growth to run further before ebbing, probably in response to what will be a policy move out some kind from China to put a floor under growth. As a result, the current infatuation with inflation hedges among investors may wane for a bit as slower growth could shock inflation expectations downward, especially in a global context that has been defined by excess capacity since the late 1990s. An environment where global inflation expectations could be downgraded in response to slower growth is likely to be an environment where the dollar performs well, particularly as U.S. growth continues to outperform global growth (Chart I-11). This also confirms our analysis from two weeks ago that showed that when bonds rally the dollar tends to outperform most currencies, with the exception of the yen.1 Moreover, with the Federal Open Market Committee upgrading its path for interest rates by one additional hike in 2018, this reinforces the message from our previous work noting that once the fed funds rate moves in the vicinity of r-star, the dollar performs well, nearly eradicating the losses it incurred when the fed funds rate rises but is well below the neutral rate (Table I-1). This is especially true if vulnerability to higher rates rests outside - not inside - the U.S., as is currently the case.2 Chart I-11The Dollar Likes Lower Global Inflation Table I-1Fed And The Dollar: Where We Stand Matters As Much As The Direction Beyond the dollar, one particular currency cross has historically been a good correlate to investors betting on higher inflation: NOK/SEK. As Chart I-12 illustrates, when investors buy inflation hedges such as going long EM equities relative to EM bonds, this generates a rally in NOK/SEK. These dynamics played in our favor when we were long this cross earlier this year. However, not only are EM equities extended relative to EM bonds, the current economic environment portends a growing risk of investors curtailing these kinds of bets. The implication is bearish for NOK/SEK, and we recommend investors sell this cross at current levels. Chart I-12NOK/SEK Suffers If Inflation Bets Are Unwound Bottom Line: Investors have quickly and aggressively positioned themselves to protect their portfolios against upside inflation risks. However, the global economy is still slowing - a development that has further to run. As a result, this current anticipation of inflation could easily morph into a temporary fear of deflation, at least relative to lofty expectations. This would undo the dynamics previously seen in the market. This is historically an environment in which the dollar performs well, suggesting the greenback rally is not over. Moreover, NOK/SEK could suffer in this environment. The Bad News Is Baked Into The Pound There is no denying that the data flow out of the U.K. has been poor of late. In fact, despite what was already a low bar for expectations, the U.K. economy has managed to generate large negative surprises (Chart I-13). One of the direct drivers of this poor performance has been the complete meltdown in the British credit impulse (Chart I-14). Additionally, the slowdown in British manufacturing can be easily understood in the context of slowing global growth (Chart I-15). Chart I-13Anarchy In The U.K. Chart I-14The Credit Impulse Has Bitten Chart I-15U.K. Exports Are Slowing Because Of Global Growth But, the bad new seems well priced into the pound, especially when compared to the euro. Not only is the GBP trading at a discount to the EUR on our fundamental and Intermediate-term timing models, speculators have accumulated near-record short bets on the pound versus the euro (Chart I-16). This begs the question: Could any positive factor come in and surprise investors, resulting in a fall in EUR/GBP? We think the answer to this question is yes. First, despite the negatives already priced in, incremental bad news have had little traction in dragging the pound lower versus the euro in recent weeks, suggesting that EUR/GBP buying has become exhausted. Second, a falling EUR/USD tends to weigh on EUR/GBP, as the pound tends to act as a low-beta version of the euro (Chart I-17). Chart I-16Investors Are Well Aware Of Britain's Problems Chart I-17EUR/GBP Sags When EUR/USD Weakens Third, the economic outlook for the U.K. is improving. It is true that in the context of slowing global growth, the manufacturing and export sectors are unlikely to be a source of positive surprises for Great Britain. However, the domestic economy could well be. As Chart I-14 highlights, the credit impulse has collapsed, but the good news is that outside of the Great Financial Crisis it has never fallen much below current levels, suggesting that a reversion to the mean may be in offing. Additionally, U.K. inflation is peaking, which is lifting British real wages (Chart I-18). In response, depressed consumer confidence is picking up. This is crucial as consumer spending, which represents roughly 70% of the U.K.'s GDP, has been the key drag on growth since 2016. Any improvement on this front will lift the whole British economy, even if the manufacturing sector remains soft. Fourth, Brexit is progressing. This week's vote in the House of Commons was confusing, but it is important to note than an amendment that gives Westminster the right to force a renegotiation between the U.K. and the EU if no deal is reached in 2019 has been passed. This also decreases the risk of a completely economically catastrophic Brexit down the road, but increases the risk that PM Theresa May could be ousted over the next 12 months. Our positive view on the pound versus the euro (or negative EUR/GBP bias) is not mimicked in cable itself. Ultimately, despite the GBP/USD's beta to EUR/GBP being below one, it is nonetheless greater than zero. As such, it is unlikely that GBP/USD will be able to rally if the DXY rallies and the EUR/USD weakens (Chart I-19). Therefore, while we recommend selling EUR/GBP, we are not willing buyers of GBP/USD. Chart I-18A Crucial Support To Growth Chart I-19Cable Will Not Avoid The Downward Pull Of A Strong Dollar Bottom Line: The British economy has undergone a period of weakness, which is already reflected in the very negative positioning of investors in the GBP versus the EUR. However, the bad data points are losing their capacity to push EUR/GBP higher, and the British economy may begin to heal as consumer confidence is rebounding thanks to improving real wages. The low beta of GBP/USD to the euro also implies that a falling EUR/USD will weigh on EUR/GBP. However, while the pound has upside against the euro, it will continue to suffer against the dollar if EUR/USD experiences further downside. What To Do With EUR/CAD? One weeks ago, we were stopped out of our short EUR/CAD trade. Has EUR/CAD finished its fall, or was the recent rally a pause within a downward channel? We are inclined to think the latter. Heated rhetoric on trade has hit the CAD harder than the EUR, as exports to the U.S. represent a much larger share of Canada's GDP than of the euro area, forcing the pricing of a risk premium in the loonie. However, even after a rather explosive G7 meeting, we do believe that a compromise is still feasible and that NAFTA is not dead on arrival. A deal is still likely because, as Chart I-20 demonstrates, Canadian tariffs on U.S. imports are not only marginally in excess of U.S. tariffs on Canadian imports, they are also in line with international comparisons. This suggests only a small push is needed to arrive to a deal that salvages NAFTA, which ultimately is much more important to Canada than the dairy industry. Chart I-20Canada And The U.S. Can Find A Compromise Despite this reality, we cannot be too complacent, U.S. President Donald Trump is likely to be playing internal politics ahead of the upcoming mid-term elections. U.S. citizens are distrustful of free trade (Chart I-21), a trend especially pronounced among his base. However, a good result for the GOP in November is contingent on the Republican base showing up at the polls. Firing this base up with inflammatory trade rhetoric is a sure way to do so. This means that risks around NAFTA are still not nil. Chart I-21America Belongs To The Anti-Globalization Bloc However, EUR/CAD continues to trade at a substantial premium to fair-value on an intermediate-term horizon (Chart I-22). Moreover, as the last panel of the chart illustrates, speculators remain massively short the CAD against the EUR. This creates a cushion for the CAD versus the EUR if global growth slows. Moreover, technicals are still favorable of shorting EUR/CAD. Not only is EUR/CAD still overbought on a 52-week rate-of-change basis, it seems to be in the process of forming a five-wave downward pattern, with the fourth one - a countertrend wave - potentially ending (Chart I-23). Chart I-22EUR/CAD Is Still Vulnerable Chart I-23Wave Pattern Not Completed Finally, EUR/CAD tends to perform poorly when the USD strengthens, which fits with our current thematic for the remainder of 2018. Bottom Line: The headline risk surrounding NAFTA has weighed on the loonie against the euro, stopping us out of our short EUR/CAD trade with a small profit. However, the valuation, positioning and technical dynamics suggest the timing is ripe to short this cross once again. Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, titled "Rome Is Burning: Is It The End?", dated June 1, 2018, available at fes.bcaresearch.com 2 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, titled "This Time Is NOT Different", dated May 25, 2018, available at fes.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 U.S. data was stellar: NFIB Business Optimism Index climbed to 107.8, outperforming expectations; the price changes and good times to expand components are also very strong; Headline and core PPI both outperformed expectations, auguring well for future consumer inflation; Headline and core retail sales grew by 0.8% and 0.9% in monthly terms, beating expectations; Both initial and continuing jobless claims also came out below expectations, highlighting that the labor market is still tightening, and wage growth could pick up further. The Fed raised interest rates this week to 2%, and added one additional rate hike to its guidance for 2018. FOMC members once again highlighted the "symmetric" target, suggesting that the Fed expects the economy to overheat slightly. An outperforming U.S. economy relative to the rest of the world is likely to propel the greenback this year. Report Links: This Time Is NOT Different - May 25, 2018 Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Economic data was largely disappointing: Italian industrial output contracted by 1.2% on a monthly basis, and grew only by 1.9% on a yearly basis; The German ZEW Survey declined substantially across all metrics; European industrial production increased by 1.7% annually, less than the expected 2.8% increase; However, Spanish headline inflation spiked up from 1.1% to 2.1%. Yesterday, ECB President Mario Draghi announced the ECB's plan to taper asset purchases to EUR 15 bn a month in September, and phase them out completely by year-end. Moreover, Draghi highlighted that the ECB was not anticipating to implement its first hike until after the summer of 2019. Furthermore, the ECB President highlighted the current slowdown in global growth, as well as the rising protectionist risk from the U.S. potentially negatively impacting the European economy and the ECB's decisions going forward, suggesting that the plans are not set in stone. 2018 is likely to remain a volatile year for the euro. Report Links: Rome Is Burning: Is It The End? - June 1, 2018 This Time Is NOT Different - May 25, 2018 Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Japanese data has been strong this week: Machine orders increased on a 9.6% annual basis, and a 10.1% monthly basis, in April, outperforming expectations by a large margin; The Domestic Corporate Goods Price Index also increased by 2.7% annually, higher than the expected 2.2% increase. As political and economic risks in Europe and South America having subsided for now, the yen has lost some of its glitter. However, with ongoing uncertainty on trade and populism across the globe, we maintain our tactically bullish stance on the yen, especially against commodity currencies and the euro. However, beyond the short-term horizon, the BoJ will remain determined to cap any excess appreciation in the yen, as a strong JPY tightens Japanese financial conditions, weighing on the BoJ's ability to hit its inflation target. This will ultimately limit the yen's upside on a cyclical basis. Report Links: Rome Is Burning: Is It The End? - June 1, 2018 Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Data from the U.K. was somewhat disappointing: Manufacturing and industrial production both increased less than expected, at 1.4% and 1.8%, respectively; The goods trade deficit widened to GBP 14.03bn from GBP 12bn, and the overall trade deficit widened to GBP 5.28bn from GBP 3.22bn; Average earnings grew by 2.8%, less than the expected 2.9%; However, headline inflation came in at 2.4%, less than the expected 2.5%, while retail price inflation also underperformed expectations. This means that the uptrend in real wages continues. Given the limited movement in the pound, it seems that a lot of the bad news was already priced in by last month's depreciation. However, Theresa May's ongoing blunders in parliament represent a continued source of risk for the pound. While the GBP has downside against the EUR, it is unlikely to see much upside against the greenback. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Do Not Get Flat-Footed By Politics - March 30, 2018 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Australian data was weak: NAB Business Confidence and Conditions surveys both declined, also underperforming expectations; Australian employment grew by 12,000, less than expected. Moreover, full-time employment contracted. While the unemployment rate dropped as a result, this was largely due to a fall in the participation rate. RBA's Governor Lowe, in a speech on Wednesday, announced that any increase in interest rates "still looks some time away" as the slack in the labor market does not seem to be diminishing. Annual wage growth has been constant at 2.1% for the past three quarters, and did not pick up despite an improvement in full-time employment earlier this year. We remain bearish on the AUD. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Who Hikes Again? - February 9, 2018 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 The NZD is likely to face significant downside against the greenback along with the other commodity currencies as global growth slows down. However, due to its weaker linkages to Chinese industrial demand, the kiwi is likely to see less downside than the AUD. Nevertheless, it is likely to weaken against the CAD and the NOK as the NZD is expensive against these oil currencies, and oil's is likely to continue to outperform other commodities will support this view. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Who Hikes Again? - February 9, 2018 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 USD/CAD has been on an uptrend given the greenback generally strong performance since February year, a force magnified by the volatile rhetoric surrounding NAFTA negotiations. However, the Canadian economy has been accelerating this year, thanks to robust growth in the U.S., to a strong Quebecer economy, and to a pickup in Alberta. In addition, the Canadian labor market is tightening further and wage growth is above 3%. Furthermore, risks surrounding NAFTA seem already reflected in the CAD's behavior and valuation. There is more clarity on the CAD versus its crosses than on the CAD versus the USD. Outperforming U.S. and Canadian growth relative to the rest of the world mean that the CAD should outperform most other G10 currencies. Report Links: Rome Is Burning: Is It The End? - June 1, 2018 Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data out of Switzerland was decent: Industrial production increased by 9% in annual terms, albeit less than the previous 19.6% growth; Producer and import prices increased by 3.2% year on year, in line with expectations, however the monthly increase underperformed markets anticipations. With global trade tensions rising, and Germany having entered President Trump's line of sight, the CHF could experience additional upside against the euro in the coming months. However, the SNB is unlikely to deviate from its ultra-accommodative stance, which means that any downside in EUR/CHF will proved to be short lived. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 The SNB Doesn't Want Switzerland To Become Japan - March 23, 2018 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Both headline and core inflation underperformed, coming in at 2.3% and 1.2%, respectively. However, the Regional Network Survey hinted at a pickup in capacity utilization as expectations for industrial output remained robust, as well as at an additional strength in employment. This led to a forecast of a resurgence in inflationary pressures. We expect the NOK to outperform the EUR. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Who Hikes Again? - February 9, 2018 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Swedish inflation rose from 1.7% to 1.9%, coming in line with expectations. Additionally, Prospera 1-year inflation expectations survey rose to 1.9% from 1.8% in the March survey. This is likely to provide the Riksbank with reasons to turn gradually more hawkish, which should support the very cheap krona. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Who Hikes Again? - February 9, 2018 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
Highlights Stay tactically long the SEK. Our preferred expression is long SEK/GBP. Stay tactically short the NOK. Our preferred expression is long AUD/NOK. Take profits in the underweight to Poland... ...and open a tactical countertrend position: long Poland's Warsaw General Index, short Italy's MIB. A coalition of populists governing Italy might ruffle some feathers in Brussels, but the main risk appears to be contained. Both The League and 5 Star Movement have dropped calls for a referendum on Italy's membership of the monetary union. Feature Italy And The U.K. Compete For Political Risk The European political lens is once again focussed on Italy as the two anti-establishment parties - The League and 5 Star Movement - negotiate to form a government. A coalition of populists governing Italy might ruffle some feathers in Brussels, but the main risk appears to be contained. Both parties have dropped calls for a referendum on Italy's membership of the monetary union, and have instead turned their fire on the EU's fiscal rules, specifically the 3 per cent limit on budget deficits. Chart of the WeekThe SEK Is Due A Tactical Rebound The populist demand for some fiscal relaxation is actually smart economics. When the private sector is paying down debt - as it is in Italy - private sector demand shrinks. To prevent a recession, the government must step in to borrow and spend the paid-down debt. And what seems to be fiscal largesse does not lead to crowding out, inflation, or surging interest rates. This means that as long as Italian populists correctly push back on the EU's draconian fiscal rules rather than the monetary union per se, the market is right to regard Italian politics as a drama, rather than an existential risk to the euro (Chart I-2). Chart I-2The Market Remains Unconcerned ##br##About Euro Break-Up Risk Maybe the European political lens should be focussed instead on Britain. The Conservative party remains as bitterly divided as ever on its vision for the U.K.'s future trading and customs relationships with the EU and the rest of the world. Paralysed and frightened by this division, Theresa May is delaying the legislative passage of three crucial bills - the EU Withdrawal Bill, the Trade Bill, and the Customs Bill. When these bills eventually reach a vote in the House of Commons later this year, any one of them could result in a humiliating defeat for May - and, quite likely, resignations from the government. Meanwhile, as the government kicks the issue into the long grass, firms are holding fire on long-term spending commitments in the U.K. and rechannelling the investment to elsewhere in Europe. Buy SEKs, Avoid NOKs For all the recent swings in the euro versus the dollar and pound, the trade-weighted euro has remained a paragon of relative stability (Chart I-3). This is because the moves versus the dollar and pound have largely cancelled out (Chart I-4). Earlier this year, euro weakness versus the pound coincided with strength versus the dollar; more recently, euro weakness versus the dollar has coincided with strength versus the pound. Chart I-3The Trade-Weighted Euro Has ##br##Remained Relatively Stable... Chart I-4...Because Moves Versus The Dollar And The ##br##Pound Have Largely Cancelled Out Interestingly, the driver of the trade-weighted euro remains the same as it has been for the past fifteen years - it is simply the euro area's long bond yield shortfall versus the U.K. and U.S. (Chart I-5). With the ECB already at the realistic limit of ultra-loose policy, the path for policy rate expectations cannot go meaningfully lower. This means that the trade-weighted euro has some long-term support given that the BoE and/or the Fed have tightening expectations that could be priced out, while the ECB effectively doesn't. Chart I-5The Trade Weighted Euro Is A Function Of The Euro Area's ##br##Long Bond Yield Shortfall Versus The U.K. And U.S. Put another way, for the trade-weighted euro to drift significantly lower, relative surprises in the economic, financial and political news have to be significantly worse in the euro area than in both the U.K. and the U.S. We think this configuration is unlikely. Nevertheless, the more interesting tactical opportunities lie elsewhere: the Swedish krona and the Norwegian krone. Recent tweaks to monetary policy frameworks in Sweden and Norway are responsible, at least partly, for technically exaggerated moves in their currencies which are likely to reverse. In the case of Sweden, the inflation target is unchanged at 2 per cent but the Riksbank introduced a variation band of 1-3 per cent, because "monetary policy is not able to steer inflation in detail." Given that Sweden's inflation rate is now close to 2 per cent, the market interpreted this tweak as very dovish - because it permits the continuation of ultra-accommodative policy. The upshot was that the SEK sold off. But our tried and tested indicator of excessive groupthink suggests that the currency may have overreacted (Chart of the Week). Hence, the tactical opportunity is to stay long the SEK, and our preferred expression is long SEK/GBP. In the case of Norway, a Royal Decree on Monetary Policy lowered the Norges Bank inflation target from 2.5 to 2.0 per cent. This followed years of failure to achieve the higher target. The market interpreted this change as hawkish, as it created the scope for tighter - or at least, less loose - policy than was previously expected. The upshot was that the NOK rallied. But again, the market reaction shows evidence of a technical overreaction (Chart I-6). Hence, the tactical opportunity is to stay short the NOK, and our preferred expression is long AUD/NOK. Chart I-6Our Preferred Expression Of Short NOK Is Versus The AUD Financial Markets Are Not Complicated, But They Are Complex The words 'complicated' and 'complex' appear to be interchangeable, but their meanings are quite distinct. The distinction is important because financial markets are not complicated, but they are complex. Something that is complicated is the sum of a large number of separate parts or processes. For example, making a car is complicated. But predicting the performance of financial markets over the medium term - say, a year or longer - is uncomplicated. The philosophy of Investment Reductionism teaches us that investment strategy is not made up of many separate parts or processes. It reduces to just three things: Predicting the evolution of the global economy. Predicting central bank reaction functions. Predicting tail-events: political, economic and financial. For example, this week's lesson in Investment Reductionism is to illustrate that the medium term decision to allocate between emerging market equities and the Eurostoxx600 largely reduces to the prospects for global metal prices (Chart I-7). Chart I-7EM Versus Eurostoxx600 = Metal Prices By contrast, something that is complex is not the sum of its parts, because the parts interact in unpredictable ways. Complexity characterizes the behaviour of financial markets over the short term - say, up to around six months. Therefore, the best way to model the behaviour of any investment over the very short term is to think of it as a complex adaptive system. A complex adaptive system is a system with a large number of mutually interacting agents, which can learn from their interactions and thereby adapt their subsequent behaviour. Examples include traffic flows, crowds in stadiums, and of course financial markets. A crucial property of all such systems is they possess an endogenous tipping point of instability, at which the behaviour undergoes a 'phase-shift'. This is the essence of how we identify likely short-term trend reversals in any investment such as the SEK and the NOK. This week's final trade recommendation uses this idea once again. Poland's equity market has underperformed recently in line with the general underperformance of the emerging market basket - and our underweight in the Warsaw General Index versus the Eurostoxx600 is handsomely in profit. However, looking at the market as a complex adaptive system, the extent of Poland's underperformance is overdone (Chart I-8). Chart I-8The Extent Of Poland's Underperformance Is Overdone Hence we are taking profit on our underweight in Poland and putting on a short-term countertrend position: long Poland's Warsaw General Index, short Italy's MIB. Dhaval Joshi, Senior Vice President Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading Model* As discussed in the main body of the report, this week's new trade recommendation is a pair-trade: long Poland's Warsaw General Index, short Italy's MIB. The profit target is 5% with a symmetrical stop loss. Our preferred expression of long SEK is versus the GBP which is already in profit since initiation. For any investment, excessive trend following and groupthink can reach a natural point of instability, at which point the established trend is highly likely to break down with or without an external catalyst. An early warning sign is the investment's fractal dimension approaching its natural lower bound. Encouragingly, this trigger has consistently identified countertrend moves of various magnitudes across all asset classes. Chart I-9 The post-June 9, 2016 fractal trading model rules are: When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. Use the position size multiple to control risk. The position size will be smaller for more risky positions. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report "Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model," dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading Model Recommendations Equities Bond & Interest Rates Currency & Other Positions Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch ##br##- Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations
Highlights The global economic mini-cycle is set to weaken while the euro is set to grind higher. Upgrade Telecoms to overweight. Also overweight Healthcare and Airlines. Underweight Banks, Basic Materials and Energy. Overweight France, Ireland, U.K., Switzerland and Denmark. Underweight Italy, Spain, Sweden and Norway. The Eurostoxx50 will struggle to outperform the S&P500. Feature We are strong believers in Investment Reductionism, a philosophy synthesized from the Pareto Principle and Occam's Razor.1 Investment reductionism offers a liberating thesis - the incessant barrage of investment research, newsfeeds and ten thousand word commentaries is largely superfluous to the investment process. What seems like a complexity of investment choice usually reduces to getting a few over-arching decisions right. Chart of the WeekIn Quadrant 4, Overweight Domestic Defensives And Underweight International Cyclicals For equity sector and country allocation, two over-arching decisions dominate: Whether the global economic mini-cycle is set to strengthen or weaken (Chart I-2). Whether the domestic currency is set to strengthen or weaken. Chart I-2The Empirical Evidence For Credit And Economic Mini-Cycles Is Irrefutable The four permutations of these two decisions create the four quadrants of cyclical investing (Chart of the Week). Right now, European investors find themselves in quadrant four: the global economic mini-cycle is set to weaken while the euro is set to grind higher. This favours an overweight stance to defensives, especially domestic-focused defensives. Therefore today, we are upgrading Telecoms to overweight. We also recommend an underweight stance to the most cyclical sectors, especially international-focused cyclicals such as Basic Materials and Energy. Country allocation then just drops out of this sector allocation. The Global Economic Mini-Cycle Is Set To Weaken We can predict the changes of the seasons and the tides of the sea with utmost precision. How? Not because we have an ingenious leading indicator for the seasons and tides, but because we recognise that these phenomena follow perfectly regular cycles. Regular cycles create predictability. Significantly, global bank credit flows also exhibit remarkably regular cycles with half-cycle lengths averaging around eight months. Recognizing these mini-cycles is immensely powerful because, just as for the seasons and the tides, it creates predictability. Furthermore, if most investors are unaware of these cycles, the next turn will not be discounted in today's price - providing a compelling investment opportunity for those who do recognise the predictability. The empirical evidence for credit mini-cycles is irrefutable. The theoretical foundation is also rock solid, based on an economic model called the Cobweb Theory.2 This states that in any market where supply lags demand, both the quantity supplied and the price must oscillate. Given that credit supply clearly lags credit demand, the quantity of credit supplied and its price (the bond yield) must experience mini-cycles (Chart I-3). And as the quantity of credit supplied is a marginal driver of economic activity, economic activity will also experience the same regular oscillations. Today, the global 6-month credit impulse is turning from mini-upswing to mini-downswing, with all three subcomponents - the euro area, the U.S. and China - now in decline (Chart I-4). This is exactly in line with prediction. Mini half-cycles average eight months, and the latest mini-upswing started eight months ago. Chart I-3The Global Economic Mini-Cycle##br## Is Set To Weaken Chart I-4All Three Subcomponents Of The Global 6-Month ##br##Credit Impulse Are Now Declining More importantly, as we enter a mini-downswing, we can also predict that global growth is likely to experience at least a modest deceleration through the coming two to three quarters. The Euro Is Set To Grind Higher, Except Versus The Yen Chart I-5Lost In Translation Nowadays, mainstream stock markets tend to be eclectic collections of multinational companies which happen to be quoted on bourses in Frankfurt, Paris, New York, and so on. For example, BASF is not really a German chemical company, it is a global chemical company headquartered in Germany. For operational hedging, multinational companies like BASF will intentionally diversify their sales and profits across multiple major currencies, say euros and dollars. But of course, the primary stock market quotation will be in the currency of its home bourse, euros. Therefore, when the euro strengthens, the company's multi-currency profits, translated back into a stronger euro, will necessarily weaken (Chart I-5). Clearly, more domestic-focused companies like telecoms will not experience such a strong currency-translation headwind. We expect the main euro crosses to continue strengthening over the next 8 months, with the exception being the cross versus the Japanese yen. Our central thesis is that the payoff profile for a foreign exchange rate just tracks the bond yield spread. This means that when a central bank has already taken bond yields close to their lower bound, its currency possesses a highly attractive asymmetry called positive skew. In essence, as the ECB is at the realistic limit of ultra-loose policy, long-term expectations for the ECB policy rate possess an asymmetry: they cannot go significantly lower, but they could go significantly higher. Exactly the same applies to long-term expectations for the BoJ policy rate. In contrast, long-term expectations for the Fed policy rate possess full symmetry: they could go either way, lower or higher. This stark asymmetry of central bank 'degrees of freedom' favours the euro and the yen over the dollar. Which Sectors And Countries To Own And Which To Avoid? Pulling together the preceding two sections, the global economic mini-cycle is set to weaken while the euro is set to grind higher. This puts Europe in quadrant four of our four quadrant framework for cyclical investing. Unsurprisingly, the relative performance of the most cyclical sectors - Banks, Basic Materials and Energy - very closely tracks the regular mini-cycles in the global 6-month credit impulse. In a mini-downswing these cyclical sectors always underperform (Chart I-6, Chart I-7 and Chart I-8). Accordingly, underweight these three sectors on a two to three quarter horizon. Chart I-6In A Mini-Downswing, ##br##Banks Always Underperform Chart I-7In A Mini-Downswing,##br## Basic Materials Always Underperform Chart I-8In A Mini-Downswing,##br## Energy Always Underperforms Conversely, overweight the relatively defensive Healthcare sector. Also overweight the Airlines sector. Airlines' performance is a mirror-image of the oil price cycle, given that aviation fuel comprises the sector's main variable cost. Furthermore, as aviation fuel is priced in dollars, it also insulates European Airlines against a strengthening euro. Today, we are also upgrading the Telecoms sector to overweight given its relative non-cyclicality (Chart I-9), its domestic-focus, and the excessively negative groupthink towards it (Chart I-10). Chart I-9In A Mini-Downswing, ##br##Telecoms Always Outperform Chart I-10Telecoms Are Due ##br##A Trend Reversal In summary: Overweight: Healthcare, Telecoms, and Airlines Underweight: Banks, Basic Materials and Energy Then to arrive at a country allocation, just combine the cyclical view on the major sectors with the country sector skews in Box 1. The result is the following unchanged European equity market allocation. Overweight: France, Ireland, U.K., Switzerland and Denmark Neutral: Germany and Netherlands Underweight: Italy, Spain, Sweden and Norway Lastly, what is the prognosis for the Eurostoxx50 relative to the S&P500? Essentially, this reduces to a battle between the multinational cyclicals - especially banks - that dominate euro area bourses and the multinational technology giants that dominate the U.S. stock market. With the global economic mini-cycle set to weaken and the euro set to grind higher, the Eurostoxx50 will struggle to outperform the S&P500. Box 1: The Vital Few Sector Skews That Drive Country Relative Performance For major equity indexes in the euro area, the dominant sector skews that drive relative performance are as follows: Germany (DAX) is overweight Chemicals, underweight Banks. France (CAC) is underweight Banks and Basic Materials. Italy (MIB) is overweight Banks. Spain (IBEX) is overweight Banks. Netherlands (AEX) is overweight Technology, underweight Banks. Ireland (ISEQ) is overweight Airlines (Ryanair) which is, in effect, underweight Energy. And for major equity indexes outside the euro area: The U.K. (FTSE100) is effectively underweight the pound. Switzerland (SMI) is overweight Healthcare, underweight Energy. Sweden (OMX) is overweight Industrials. Denmark (OMX20) is overweight Healthcare and Industrials. Norway (OBX) is overweight Energy. The U.S. (S&P500) is overweight Technology, underweight Banks. Dhaval Joshi, Senior Vice President Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com 1 The Pareto Principle, often known as the 80-20 rule, says that 80% of effects come from just 20% of causes. Occam's Razor says that when there are many competing explanations for the same effect, the simplest explanation is usually the best. 2 Please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report 'The Cobweb Theory And Market Cycles' published on January 11, 2018 and available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Fractal Trading Model* This week's recommended trade is to short the Helsinki OMX versus the Eurostoxx600. Apply a profit target of 3% with a symmetrical stop-loss. In other trades, we are pleased to report that short Japanese Energy versus the market achieved its 8% profit target at which it was closed. This leaves four open positions. For any investment, excessive trend following and groupthink can reach a natural point of instability, at which point the established trend is highly likely to break down with or without an external catalyst. An early warning sign is the investment's fractal dimension approaching its natural lower bound. Encouragingly, this trigger has consistently identified countertrend moves of various magnitudes across all asset classes. Chart 11 The post-June 9, 2016 fractal trading model rules are: When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. Use the position size multiple to control risk. The position size will be smaller for more risky positions. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report "Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model," dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading Model Recommendations Equities Bond & Interest Rates Currency & Other Positions Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations
Highlights The Japanese economy is booming. This is allowing the BoJ to move away from its QQE (Quantitive and Qualitative Easing) program. However, the YCC (Yield Curve Control) program will stay in place for the foreseeable future as inflation remains a direct function of financial conditions. Because yen positioning and valuations are so skewed, this could result in a yen rally, especially against the Euro. Short EUR/JPY. Like the Fed, the BoC will hike rates three times this year. However, the market already discounts more hikes in Canada than the U.S. We remain neutral USD/CAD. However, CAD will experience downside against the NOK. Short CAD/NOK. Feature Chart I-1JPY Vs. Bonds: The Divorce Something fascinating happened to USD/JPY in recent months: it began to decouple from U.S. bond yields (Chart I-1). To a large degree, this break in relationship reflected the dollar's own weakness, as the dollar index fell by 10% in 2017. But as weak as the dollar may have been last year, it has actually been flat since September 7. Another culprit behind the yen's decoupling from bond yields has been that as the European Central Bank announced the end of its own asset purchases program, the Bank of Japan has been seen as the next in line to diminish its purchases. On January 8th, the BoJ began moving in that direction, as it started to curtail its buying of long-dated JGBs. Since that day, not only have global bonds sold off, but the yen has regained vigor as well. We believe the yen bear market is not over, but a playable rally against the euro is likely to emerge. The Sun Is Rising The BoJ is justified in wanting to remove some policy stimulus. The Japanese economy is firing on all cylinders, and the improvement seems broad-based. Consumer confidence, buoyed by rising asset prices and an unemployment rate at 23-year lows, is hitting record highs (Chart I-2). This will continue to support real household spending, which is now growing at a nearly 2% pace after contracting steadily from 2015 to early 2017. Another support for household spending comes from the wage front. Contractual wages are already growing at their fastest pace since 2006, and wages excluding overtime pay are expanding at rates not seen since 1998 (Chart I-3). Moreover, the openings-to-applicant ratio is at its highest level since 1974. This increases the likelihood that Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's arm-wrestling with corporate Japan to increase wages will bear fruit, and that the upcoming spring wage negotiation will generate accelerating gains. Chart I-2Japanese Households Feel Ebullient Chart I-3Wage Growth Has Picked Up Business confidence is also surging. The Japanese manufacturing PMI number is elevated by Japanese standards, currently at 54, and small business confidence points toward an acceleration in industrial production (Chart I-4). Financial markets validate this picture as well. The surge in the Nikkei has grabbed the imagination of investors, but even more impressive has been the strength in small-cap equities, which have outperformed their large-cap counterparts by 17% since 2015 (Chart I-5). This development has coincided with a pick-up in credit growth, and is also normally associated with a robust growth outlook. The GDP model developed by our sister publication, The Bank Credit Analyst, encapsulates these various phenomena, and forecasts that Japanese real GDP growth could hit an annual rate of 3% in the first half of 2018 (Chart I-6). Thus, it would seem that the Japanese economy will continue to gain momentum. Chart I-4Japanese Companies Are Also##br## Feeling The Good Vibes Chart I-5Small Caps Point To##br## A Bright Outlook Chart I-6Japanese Growth ##br##Has Momentum But what underpins these improvements? First, the fiscal thrust in Japan has changed. Fiscal policy was a drag in Japan from 2012 to 2016, creating an average brake on economic activity of 0.6% of GDP per year. However, in 2017, fiscal policy eased to add 0.2% to GDP. Second, Japan has greatly benefited from the rebound in EM growth. According to the IMF, a 1% growth shock in EM affects Japanese growth by 50 basis points - nearly five times more than the effect of the same shock on the U.S. economy. This is because 43% of Japanese exports are shipped to EM economies. Third, the impact of EM activity on Japan is amplified by the countercyclical nature of the JPY. As global and EM growth expands more vigorous, the yen weakens, which eases Japanese financial conditions. This phenomenon was in full display last year, as financial conditions eased by a full standard deviation over the past 16 months. These developments are what have laid the ground for better growth and the change in the BoJ's tone. Bottom Line: Japan is doing very well. Consumers and businesses are upbeat, spending is on the rise and GDP is forecasted to accelerate even further. Easing fiscal belt-tightening, stronger EM economies, and the softening financial conditions are the factors behind these improvements. The BoJ is taking notice. How Far Can The BoJ Go? The BoJ had been itching to move policy for a few months now. In November 2017, BoJ Governor Haruhiko Kuroda was making noise about the concept of the "reversal rate." The reversal rate is the interest rate below which additional interest rate cuts become contractionary for economic activity. This is because below this level, lower rates hurt bank interest margins to such a degree that commercial banks start curtailing their lending to the private sector. The reason why the BoJ was getting more vocal about the reversal rate was because this rate is inversely related to the amount of securities held on commercial banks' balance sheets. If commercial banks hold plenty of government bonds, as interest rates fall to very low levels, the value of these securities increases, offsetting the negative impact of lower interest rate margins. The problem in Japan is that as the BoJ mopped up more JGBs than was issued by the government, and therefore the bond holdings of banks were dwindling at an alarming rate (Chart I-7). This meant that the reversal rate was rising, implying that the BoJ had less control over policy. When inflation surprised to the upside in December, financial markets reacted violently. While Japanese nominal yields did not budge much, Japanese inflation expectations surged, which prompted a collapse in Japanese real rates (Chart I-8). This produced a de facto easing in Japanese monetary conditions, creating the perfect cover for the BoJ to adjust its asset purchases: any negative impact from tweaking bond purchases would be mitigated and the BoJ, according to its view, would not lose control of financial conditions because of a falling reversal rate. Despite this shift in policy action and rhetoric, we do not yet foresee the end of the Yield Curve Control program. Inflation excluding food and energy only stands at a paltry 0.3%, still well below the BoJ's 2% target or even 1% - a level that is likely to result in a more real removal of easing. Additionally, the BoJ is in somewhat of a bind. It is true that the economy is doing much better, but this does not really help explain inflation dynamics. Japanese capacity utilization only explains 3% of the movements in Japanese core inflation; global utilization, only 10%; and inflation leads credit creation in Japan. Instead, the best factor to explain Japanese inflation has been financial conditions (FCIs). In no other country do FCIs explain inflation dynamics as much as they do in Japan. The recent movements in Japanese inflation are fully consistent with how Japanese FCIs have evolved since 2010. Based on this relationship, CPI excluding food and energy should likely peak at 0.7% in June 2018 (Chart I-9). Chart I-7Japanese Reversal Rate##br## Is Falling Because Of QQE Chart I-8Sudden Pick Up In##br## Inflation Expectations Chart I-9Inflation Is Picking Up Because##br## Financial Conditions Eased However, if the BoJ removes accommodation too fast, the yen would rally and financial conditions would tighten sharply. In all likelihood, inflation would weaken substantially, nullifying the very reason to tighten policy in the first place. These very dynamics point to a continuation of YCC for at least the next 12 to 18 months. Bottom Line: Japan will soon fully do away with its QQE program. However, this is not indicative of a removal of yield curve controls. This is not only because Japanese inflation is extremely far off from the BoJ's target, but also because Japan's inflation rate is hyper-sensitive to financial conditions. Therefore, any tightening in financial conditions created by a stronger yen - the likely market response of tighter policy - will cause inflation to collapse, nullifying the very need for tighter policy. Investment Implications USD/JPY is expensive, trading 16% above the fair value implied by purchasing power parity. Additionally, the yen is supported by a generous current account surplus of 4% of GDP. Moreover, global investors have been underweighting duration. This phenomenon tends to be negative for the yen. When investors are as underweight duration as they are currently, the yen becomes more likely to rally (Chart I-10). It is true that in 2014, investors were as negative on bonds as they are today, but USD/JPY sold off. This was because back then, the BoJ announced an increase to its asset purchase program. Today, the BoJ is moving toward ditching its QQE program, which is likely to prompt a short-covering rally. Now, the key question for investors is what currency should be sold against the yen. We posit the euro is an interesting alternative to the USD. EUR/JPY is exceptionally expensive at present. On a long-term basis, EUR/JPY is trading well outside its normal range on a purchasing-power-parity basis (Chart I-11). Moreover, while USD/JPY is mildly expensive according to metrics that incorporate rate differentials and risk appetite, EUR/USD is very dear based on a similar comparison. The implication is that EUR/JPY is trading at an exceptionally demanding level in terms of short-term valuations (Chart I-12). Hence, tactically, the timing is becoming increasingly ripe to short this cross Chart I-10Duration Positioning Points To Upside Risk For The Yen Chart I-11EUR/JPY Is Expensive Chart I-12Tactical Risk For EUR/JPY . Further arguing in favor of shorting EUR/JPY instead of USD/JPY are relative financial conditions. Euro area financial conditions have tightened much more than U.S. financial conditions relative to Japan's (Chart I-13). As a consequence, even when adjusting for sector biases, European stocks are currently underperforming Japanese equities by a greater margin than the underperformance of U.S. equities. This highlights that Japan's relative economic outlook burns brighter when compared to the euro area than when compared to the U.S. This also means that the yen has more room to rally against the euro than the USD. Finally, relative positioning between the euro and the yen is also exceptionally skewed. As Chart I-14 illustrates, when speculators are simultaneously long the euro and short the yen, EUR/JPY tends to experience subsequent corrections. Chart I-13Euro Area FCIs Tightened ##br##More Than U.S. Ones Chart I-14Skewed Positioning##br## In EUR The aforementioned factors point to a potentially large yen rally, but the durability of this rally is likely to be limited. The BoJ will only be dropping a QQE program that it had already only half-implemented in recent months, as bond purchases were well below its JPY80 trillion-yen objective. The BoJ is still committed to its YCC program for the foreseeable future. Only a rejection of this program will create a durable support for the yen. In the meanwhile, as any yen rally will tighten financial conditions and hurt inflation, any yen rally is to be rented rather than owned, as terminal policy rates in Japan still have little scope to rise. Bottom Line: Ditching QQE is likely to result in a yen rally. Such a rally is likely to be most pronounced against the euro as valuations, positioning, and financial conditions are especially exacerbated when compared to the European currency. To be clear, the yen rally is likely to be a countertrend move, as a strong yen will exert serious deflationary pressures on Japan, which means the BoJ's YCC program will remain firmly in place. We are shorting EUR/JPY at 133.79. CAD: Stuck Between The BoC And NAFTA Chart I-15Canada Will Experience Rising Wages Canada:##br## Inflationary Conditions Emerging The Bank of Canada (BoC) is meeting next week and the odds are rising that it will lift policy rates this month. The Canadian economy is very strong too, led by the domestic sector. Real consumer spending is growing at its fastest pace in nearly 10 years, the unemployment rate is at 40-year lows, and capex is recovering after having been decimated by the collapse in oil prices from 2014 to 2016. Thanks to this backdrop, the Canadian economy is hitting its own capacity constraints. The BoC estimates that the Canadian output gap has closed. Moreover, the recent Business Outlook Survey confirms this message: A record proportion of Canadian firms are having difficulty meeting demand because of capacity constraints, and the growing number and intensity of labor shortages points to a tight labor market (Chart I-15). Tight capacity and higher wages will support the already-visible rebound in core inflation, which has already reached 1.8%. As a result, we expect the BoC to tighten rates as much as the Federal Reserve this year. However, the impact of this development on the CAD might be limited. Investors are already pricing in more hikes in Canada than in the U.S. over the next 12 months - 82 basis points versus 60 basis points, respectively. Moreover, speculators are once again very long the loonie, implying an elevated hurdle for strong economic data to actually lift CAD further. Moreover, NAFTA remains a major risk for Canada. As Marko Papic, our Chief Geopolitical Strategist, wrote in a November Special Report, President Trump does have uninhibited power when it comes to abrogating NAFTA (Table I-I).1 If NAFTA were to collapse, Canada would most likely ultimately revert to the still-preferential Canada-U.S. Free Trade Agreement. Thus, the impact on Canada-U.S. trade would likely be temporary. However, the brunt of the pain should be felt in Canadian capex spending. The high degree of uncertainty associated with unwinding NAFTA would cause companies to abandon expansion plans in Canada, and prompt them to expand their North American capacity directly in the U.S., thereby bypassing the regulatory risk created in the supply chain. This would dampen the future growth profile of Canada. Table I-1Trump Faces Few Constraints On Trade Oil is unlikely to fill the void for CAD. At near US$70/bbl, Brent has hit our Commodity and Energy strategists' target. OPEC 2.0 will be unwilling to accommodate much higher prices, as this would incentivize shale producers to expand capacity, recreating the supply glut dynamics that existed prior to the 2014 crash. Additionally, the West Canada Select benchmark, the oil price most relevant for Canada, remains at a substantial discount to WTI and Brent. This is because there is not enough pipeline capacity to ship oil outside of Alberta. Canada is drowning in its own oil. This situation is not about to change. Chart I-16CAD/NOK Is Stretched Based on this combination, we are neutral USD/CAD on a 12-month basis, even if a move back to 1.29 is likely over the coming weeks. However, while Canadian oil is trading at a discount, the CAD has performed better than the NOK, the other petrocurrency in the G10 space. This suggests that shorting CAD/NOK may be a cleaner way to play the risks inherent to the Canadian dollar. First, the Canadian dollar is very expensive relative to the Norwegian krone right now, trading 11% above its purchasing-power-parity rate (Chart I-16). Even when adjusting for other factors like productivity and commodity prices, CAD is trading at its largest premium to the NOK since 1994. This represents a risk for CAD/NOK as the loonie is exposed to trade policy risks, while the nokkie is not. Second, the balance-of-payments picture remains highly favorable for the NOK. Norway runs a current account surplus of 5.5% while Canada runs a deficit of 2.8%. Additionally, Norway sports a Net International Investment position (NIIPs) of 210% of GDP, the largest in the G10. Strong NIIPs are associated with rising real effective exchange rates. Third, while the Canadian economy's momentum is well known by investors - this is the reason why they are so long the CAD and expecting so many hikes from the BoC - the positives in Norway are being ignored. Norway's leading economic indicator is still rising, and Norwegian industrial production and real GDP growth are accelerating. Fourth, the Norges Bank is responding to weakness in the NOK. At its December meeting, it adjusted its tone, as the NOK is easing monetary conditions too much in the eyes of the Norwegian central bank. This suggests the 25-basis-point hike currently expected out of Norway could be too low. It also highlights that the exceptional 60-basis-point gap between Canada and Norway in terms of expected 12-month rate hikes is also likely to normalize. Finally, CAD/NOK is trading toward the top of both its long-term and near-term historical trading ranges. While positioning on the CAD is now quite extended on the long side, speculators are short the NOK, according to Norges Bank data. Thus, with NAFTA in question, a fully priced BoC outlook, and the unlikelihood that the WCS-Brent discount narrows, risks are skewed toward a lower CAD/NOK going forward. Bottom Line: The Canadian economy is booming. This means the BoC will keep pace with the Fed and increase rates at least thrice this year. However, markets are already discounting more hikes in Canada than they are in the U.S. Moreover, oil prices have limited upside from here, and the WCS benchmark will continue to trade at a deep discount to Brent. Thus, while USD/CAD has limited upside, it has limited downside as well. However, CAD/NOK faces plenty of downside risks from current levels. We are shorting this cross this week, with an entry point at 6.398. Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see BCA Global Investment Strategy Special Report, "NAFTA - Populism Vs. Pluto-Populism" dated November 10, 2017, available at gis.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.S. has been mixed: Nonfarm payrolls surprised to the downside, coming in at 148 thousand. Moreover, labor force participation rate surprised to the downside, coming in at 62.7%. ISM non-manufacturing PMI also underperformed expectations, coming in at 55.9. However, consumer credit change outperformed expectations, coming in at 27.95 billion dollars. The dollar began the week on a strong, which ultimately dissipated, on relatively hawkish ECB minutes and policy tweaks in Japan. Overall, we expect the market to continue to price the fed dot plot, putting upward pressure on the dollar. Report Links: A Cold Snap Doesn't Make A Winter - January 5, 2018 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 Canaries In The Coal Mine Alert 2: More On EM Carry Trades And Global Growth - December 15, 2017 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the Euro area has been positive: Core inflation outperformed expectations, coming in at 1.1%. Moreover, the economic sentiment indicator also outperformed expectations, coming in at 116. Retail sale yearly growth also surprised to the upside, coming in at 2.8%. Finally, the unemployment rate declined from 8.8% to 8.7% In spite of the positive data the euro has fallen this weekThe Euro begun the week on the weak side but surged in the wake of the ECB's hawkish minutes. This has happened due to the surge in rate expectations in the U.S., as the market has continued to price in the fed. Overall, we expect to see downside in EUR/JPY as the BoJ has more room to back off its ultra-dovish policy than the ECB. Report Links: A Cold Snap Doesn't Make A Winter - January 5, 2018 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan has been mixed: Labor Cash earnings yearly growth outperformed expectations, coming in at 0.9%. They also increased relative to October. However consumer confidence surprised to the downside, coming in at 44.7 and declining from the previous month. The yen has been surging this week, with USD/JPY falling by 1.7%. This was caused because the BoJ signaled that they would reduce their buying of long dated bonds. The market interpret this as a signal that the BoJ will start exiting from its ultra-dovish monetary policy. These developments should continue to provide upside to the JPY, particularly against the Euro. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 Riding The Wave: Momentum Strategies In Foreign Exchange Markets - December 8, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.K. has been mixed: Industrial Production yearly growth outperformed expectations, coming in at 2.5%. Moreover, manufacturing production yearly growth also surprised to the upside, coming in at 3.5%. However, Halifax House Prices yearly growth underperformed expectations, coming in at 2.7% as the month-on-month growth contracted by 0.6%. The pound has been flat, this week against the dollar, while it has lost about 1% against the euro. Overall, the BoE is limited in the capacity to raise rates meaningfully. Moreover, inflation should start to ease following the rate hike and the rise in the pound. This will put downward pressure on the pound. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Reverse Alchemy: How To Transform Gold Into Lead - November 3, 2017 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia has been mixed: Building permits yearly growth outperformed expectations, coming in at 17.2%. However, the trade balance in November surprised to the downside, coming in at -628 million. It also decreased from -302 million one month earlier. AUD/USD has been flat this week, however AUD/NZD has fallen by roughly 1%. While it is true that global growth continues to be strong, key indicators like Korean and Taiwanese export growth have rolled over. Moreover money supply growth in China continues to decrease. All of this points to a temporary slowdown in Chinese industrial activity, which would lead to weakness in AUD/USD. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Currency Hedging: Dynamic Or Static? - A Practical Guide For Global Investors - September 29, 2017 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 The kiwi has rallied by nearly 5% since the start of the year, as global growth continues to stay robust. Overall, we expect that the NZD will continue to outperform the AUD this year, as New Zealand is less sensitive to a tightening in financial conditions than Australia. However on a longer time horizon, the upside for the Kiwi is limited, as the new populist government has not only vowed to decrease immigration into the country, but also for the RBNZ to have a dual mandate. Both of these policies will depress the neutral rate in New Zealand, and consequently put downward pressure on the kiwi. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Reverse Alchemy: How To Transform Gold Into Lead - November 3, 2017 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada has been mostly positive: The unemployment rate surprised positively, as it declined to 5.7% from 5.9% Moreover, net change in employment also outperformed expectations, coming in at 78.6 thousand. Housing starts yearly growth also outperformed expectations, coming in at 217 thousand. However, the Ivey Purchasing Manager Index underperformed, coming in at 60.4. USD/CAD jumped on Tuesday following reports that Trump will exit the NAFTA accord. Overall we believe that the Canadian dollar will have limited upside from here on out, as the market is now pricing in more hikes in Canada than in the U.S. This weakness could be taken advantage of by shorting CAD/NOK, as this cross is much overvalued according to multiple metrics. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Market Update - October 27, 2017 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland has been positive: Headline inflation came in line with expectations, at 0.8%, meanwhile month on month inflation surprised to the upside, coming in at 0%. The unemployment rate also came in line with expectations, at a very low level, coming in at 3%. Finally, retail sales yearly growth surprised to the upside substantially, coming in at -0.2%, compared to 2.6% last month. EUR/CHF has stayed relatively flat since last week. Overall, we expect limited upside in the franc. As the SNB will stay active in the foreign exchange market. In order for the SNB to change its policy, inflation in Switzerland will have to stay at a high level for a considerable amount of time. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Updating Our Long-Term Fair Value Models - September 15, 2017 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway has been mixed: Headline inflation outperformed expectations, coming in at 1.6%. Moreover core inflation also surprised to the upside, coming in at 1.4% However, manufacturing output growth underperformed expectations, coming in at 0.3% USD/NOK is down by roughly 0.7%, as oil prices continue to approach the 70 dollar mark. Nevertheless, we believe that the upside for USD/NOK is limited from here, as the market will start pricing in more rate hikes from the Fed. That being said, investors willing to bet on more oil strength could short EUR/NOK. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 Canaries In The Coal Mine Alert 2: More On EM Carry Trades And Global Growth - December 15, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 After falling precipitously at the end of 2017, USD/SEK has been relatively flat this year. Overall, while Stefan Ingves continues to be very dovish, he conceded in the latest minutes that a change in monetary policy is getting closer. Meanwhile, Deputy Governor Jansson stated that while he supports to continue with asset purchases, to keep the repo rate unchanged would be "difficult to digest". Investors willing to bet on a slowdown in the Euro area caused by tightening financial conditions could short EUR/SEK. Report Links: 10 Charts To Digest With The Holiday Trimmings - December 22, 2017 Canaries In The Coal Mine Alert 2: More On EM Carry Trades And Global Growth - December 15, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
Highlights The dollar has decoupled from interest rate differentials, being hurt by buoyant global growth. For the dollar to weaken more in 2018, global growth will have to accelerate further from current lofty rates. The tightening in Chinese policy along with the poor performance of EM carry trades point to a slight slowdown, not an acceleration. A pick up in volatility would magnify the underperformance of EM carry trades, and thus, tighten global liquidity conditions. This will help the dollar, but could help the yen even more. Buy NOK/SEK. Feature This past Wednesday, the Federal Reserve increased its growth forecast through 2020. It also cut expectations for the U.S. unemployment rate in 2018 and 2019 to 3.9%, and finally it increased its interest rate forecast to 3.1% by 2020. Yet, the U.S. dollar weakened substantially. Even if we acknowledge that interest rate markets are skeptical that the Fed will be able to fulfill its promises, the U.S. dollar has also decoupled itself from market interest rates. While rate spreads between the U.S. and the rest of the world point to a higher USD, the dollar is in fact gaining no traction (Chart I-1). We think global growth has been the key to this conundrum. Global Growth Steals The Limelight Interest rate differentials are the most common driver of exchange rates, but sometimes, growth dynamics also play a role. Currently, strong global growth stands firmly in the driver's seat, explaining why the dollar is weakening. Generally, when non-U.S. activity improves, the dollar underperforms (Chart I-2). Chart I-1Dollar And Rates Spot The Disconnect Chart I-2The Dollar Doesn't Like Strong Global Growth The reason is straightforward, and has two main elements. First, the U.S. is a low-beta economy. When global growth accelerates, the U.S. does not benefit as much as Europe. The IMF estimates that a 1% gyration in EM activity affects euro area growth three times as much as it impacts the U.S. Not only is EM activity a key source of variance in the global industrial cycle, it has also been the key factor behind this upswing. Second, money tends to flow out of the U.S. when global growth accelerates. Since non-U.S. economies are more levered to the global industrial cycle than the U.S., so is their profit growth. Additionally, an accelerating global economy is associated with a rise in central bank foreign exchange reserves outside of the U.S. as global trade expands. This creates generous liquidity conditions in the rest of the world, which further favors economic growth and asset price expansion. Money flows where higher returns are to be found. In recent quarters, global reserves have indeed expanded, highlighting this easing in global liquidity conditions (Chart I-3). To bet on the U.S. dollar weakening is to bet on this set of conditions continuing. This is the wager market participants are currently making. Investors are very short the U.S. dollar index and very long the euro, the CAD, the AUD, gold and oil (Chart I-4). This suggests that even a mild slowdown in global growth would indeed be a surprise - one that would cause the dollar to move back toward levels implied by interest rate differentials (Chart I-5). Chart I-3Buoyant Growth Equals Reserves Accumulation Equals Strong EM Currencies Chart I-4Investors Are Short The Dollar Long Growth Chart I-5Dollar Is Cheap Relative To Rates Bottom Line: A key factor behind the dollar's weakness in 2017 has been the positive global growth surprise. This helps explain why the dollar has been much weaker than interest rate differentials would otherwise suggest. Since the dollar is trading at such a discount to interest rate differentials, for the greenback to weaken further global growth needs to continue to accelerate. Based on positioning, the surprise for investors would be if global industrial activity decelerates. Risks To Global Growth Chart I-6China Helped Australia The acceleration in global growth needed for the dollar to sell off more is unlikely to emerge. To the contrary, growing evidence indicates that a mild slowdown is likely to hit global industrial activity next year. One of the key pillars for global growth, China, is turning the corner. China has played an essential role in explaining the strong growth of many economies in 2017. The link for EM or commodity producers like Australia to Chinese growth is relatively self-evident. For example, the value of Australian exports received a strong fillip when Chinese industrial activity surged in 2016 and 2017. As such, the recent rollover in the Li Keqiang index - a key gauge of China's secondary sector - points to a reversal in Chinese growth (Chart I-6). Chinese activity also has important implications for the performance of growth in the euro area relative to the U.S. As Chart I-7 highlights, when Chinese monetary conditions ease or when the Chinese marginal propensity to save - as approximated by the gap between the growth rate of M2 and M1 - decreases, the Eurozone's economy accelerates relative to the U.S. Currently, Chinese monetary conditions are tightening and the marginal propensity to save is rising, highlighting that European growth will decelerate relative to the U.S. Chart I-7AChina Also Matters For The Distribution Of Growth Between Europe And The U.S. (I) Chart I-7BChina Also Matters For The Distribution Of Growth Between Europe And The U.S. (II) The outlook for Chinese growth suggests that the recent reversal in industrial activity could run a bit deeper. Arthur Budaghyan, who leads BCA's Emerging Markets Strategy service, has highlighted that Chinese broad money growth is decelerating, and that the Chinese fiscal impulse is slowing. This is normally associated with falling Chinese imports, which is China's direct footprint on the global economic cycle and global trade (Chart I-8). Moreover, Chinese borrowing costs are rising and the real estate sector is already showing signs of slowing. The amount of new floor space sold is now contracting, which often precedes serious decelerations in new house prices (Chart I-9, top panel). Thus, Chinese construction is likely to contribute less to global growth and to demand for commodities in the coming year than in the past two years. Chart I-8Slowing Chinese Money Is A ##br##Headwind For Global Activity Chart I-9Excess Investment Is A Real Problem China Fixed Capital Formation To Slow in 2018 Meanwhile, China has overinvested in its capital stock when compared with other EM economies at similar stages of development (Chart I-9, bottom panel). Therefore, the risk that capex will slow in response to policy tightening is high. This would further weigh on Chinese imports. Various Chinese leading economic indicators have also rolled over sharply. This portends a further fall in the Li Keqiang index (Chart I-10) and also gives more credence to our view that China's industrial activity and imports will slow in 2018. As BCA's Geopolitical Strategy team has argued, the willingness of the Chinese authorities to implement reforms and control credit growth next year will only solidify this negative impulse.1 It is not just Chinese variables that are deteriorating, but other key leading indicators of the global industrial cycle seem to be picking up on this impulse (Chart I-11). The recent deceleration in global money growth also confirms this insight (Chart I-12). Chart I-10Chinese Monetary Conditions ##br##Point To Slowing Industrial Activity Chart I-11Global Growth Gauges Corroborate ##br## Chinese Indicators Chart I-12Where Global Money Growth Goes, ##br##So Does Activity Most importantly, the performance of our EM Carry Canaries - how key EM carry currencies are performing against the quintessential funding currency, the yen, corroborates this picture. EM carry trades' total returns have sharply rolled over, a signal that has always led to a slowdown in global industrial activity for the past 20 years (Chart I-13). We argued two weeks ago that EM carry trades are beginning to weaken because of the negative impulse emanating from China. We also stressed that the relationship between EM carry trades and global industrial activity is strengthened by the role carry trades play in disseminating and enhancing global liquidity.2 Strongly performing EM carry trades are a symptom of liquidity making its way across the globe, leading to supportive conditions for risk assets and growth. On the other hand, an underperformance in EM carry trades is an early signal that liquidity is on the wane, pointing to an upcoming downturn in risk taking and economic activity. Going forward, there is a growing likelihood that policy within developed markets will amplify the weakness in EM carry trades that currently reflects mostly changing growth dynamics in China. Global volatility has been extremely muted in 2017, which normally helps carry trades perform well. However, as Chart I-14 illustrates, volatility tends to experience upside when U.S. inflation picks up. This is because as inflation picks up, not only does the Fed increase rates, which tightens global liquidity conditions and hampers risk taking, but the path for future growth also becomes trickier to discount, requiring higher volatility in the process. BCA expects U.S. inflation to pick up significantly in 2018. The rise in the growth of the velocity of money in the U.S. is one of the clearest indications of that risk (Chart I-15). Chart I-13EM Carry Trades Are Confirming These Trends Chart I-14Global Vol Will Rise With Inflation Chart I-15U.S. Core Inflation Has Upside The tax repatriation included in the U.S. Tax Cuts and Jobs Act represents an additional risk for global aggregate volatility. When U.S. entities repatriate dollars back home, this curtails the supply of USD collateral available in the offshore market. As a result, dollar funding becomes scarcer, creating widening pressures on USD cross-currency basis swap spreads (Chart I-16, top panel).3 The introduction in January of rules by the BIS for banks to hold greater collateral against OTC transactions will further exacerbate this potential dollar squeeze in the swap market, increasing the risk that the U.S. tax bill will result in wider USD basis-swap spreads. Historically, wider swap spreads haven been associated with rising volatility, a logical consequence of more expensive funding (Chart I-16, bottom panel). This rise in volatility is likely to aggravate the weakness in EM carry trades. This will amplify the risks to global liquidity. As this process unfolds, global growth will begin to slow, precisely at the time when investors are not positioned for it. Bottom Line: Global growth is being hit by the beginning of a slowdown in Chinese industrial activity. This slowdown does not constitute a crisis, nor a repeat of the 2015 period of elevated risks for China. However, it does nonetheless create a headwind for global industrial activity that is already being picked up by key reliable gauges of global growth. Moreover, EM carry trades, which have been an extremely reliable leading indicators of global growth, are already corroborating this picture. Since volatility is set to increase in 2018 as U.S. inflation picks up and U.S. tax repatriation dries global dollar funding, the downside in EM carry trades has further to go which will result in tighter global liquidity conditions, in turn increasing the probability that global growth will disappoint. Global Growth, U.S. Policy, And The Dollar We began this report by highlighting that since the dollar is now trading at a substantial discount to interest rate differentials, betting on a weaker dollar is akin to betting on additional strengthening in global growth. However, the factors highlighted above argue against an acceleration in global growth, especially in global industrial activity. Moreover, global growth is set to decelerate while the Fed is hiking rates - a scenario reminiscent of the late 1990s. In fact, the gap between growth indicators and the Fed's policy setting has in the past been a useful tool in pinpointing dollar bull and bear markets (Chart I-17). Chart I-16Tax Repatriation Leads To Wider ##br## Swap Spreads And Greater Volatility Chart I-17A USD-Positive ##br##Dichotomy Thus, we continue to follow the scenario we elaborated on in early September:4 The dollar will end the year having generated positive but uninspiring returns during the fourth quarter. It will only gather steam in Q1 2018, once U.S. inflation picks up significantly. This rebound in U.S. core inflation will help the Fed fulfill its promise to increase rates three times next year. It will also create a non-negligible headwind to global growth by pushing volatility higher, hurting global carry trades and global liquidity conditions in the process. At this point, any move in DXY to 93 should be used to build bullish bets on the dollar. Conversely, moves in EUR/USD to 1.18 should be used to sell the USD. We remain short commodity currencies and our portfolio is especially negative on the AUD. Finally, we have professed a negative view on the JPY on the basis of higher U.S. rates. While higher U.S. rates may continue to lift USD/JPY, the window to be short the JPY is likely closing. If volatility does pick up on the back of the risks highlighted in this report, the yen could buck the dollar's strength and rally. We thus remain short NZD/JPY to protect against this eventuality, and we will look to close our long USD/JPY position around the New Year. Bottom Line: As global growth is set to slow somewhat, the Fed is redoubling on its hawkish rhetoric. Since the dollar is trading at a discount to interest rate differentials and is being sold by speculators, this raises the risk that the USD will experience a significant rally in the first half of 2018. Any move in the DXY to 93 should be used to build significant long positions in the USD, whether through the index or by shorting EUR/USD, or by betting on further AUD weakness. The yen could benefit in this environment. An Uncorrelated Trade: Long NOK/SEK It is always important to find potentially uncorrelated trades within a portfolio, as it increases diversification benefits. The FX space is no exception to this rule. Such an opportunity seems to be emerging in the European currency space: buying Nokkie/Stokkie. NOK/SEK currently trades at a large 8% discount to purchasing power parity. More sophisticated models incorporating productivity differentials and terms-of-trade shocks also show that the krone is cheap relative to its neighbor (Chart I-18). Moreover, the IMF expects the Norwegian current account to stand at 5.5% of GDP for 2017, while Sweden's will be a more modest 3.9% of GDP. This gap is anticipated to be maintained in 2018. In terms of catalysts for a rally in NOK/SEK, Sweden's relative economic outperformance that has been so vital to this cross's weakness is ebbing. Norwegian real GDP and industrial production growth are both accelerating relative to Sweden's. This trend looks set to endure as the Norwegian leading economic indicator is displaying a similar profile (Chart I-19). Confirming this picture, the Norwegian economic surprise index is turning up from exceptionally depressed levels when compared to Sweden's. Historically, this tends to translate into a stronger NOK. Yesterday's comments by Norges Bank Governor Oystein Olsen pointing to a first hike in late 2018 are helping catalyze the pricing of these dynamics in the cross's price. Financial markets are telling a similar story. Norwegian equities have been outperforming their Swedish counterparts since the middle of 2017. Moreover, Norwegian nominal and real yields are rallying relative to Sweden, which normally puts upward pressure on NOK/SEK (Chart I-20). Chart I-18NOK/SEK Is Cheap Chart I-19Growth Momentum Moving In Favor Of Norway Chart I-20Relative Yields Point To Higher NOK/SEK While a slowdown in global growth is a risk when holding a commodity currency like the NOK, NOK/SEK offers a healthy level of cushion against this eventuality. Overwhelmed by domestic fundamentals, NOK/SEK has decoupled from its historical relationship with EM equities, EM spreads, oil and global growth. Thus, this cross is not as levered to the global economic cycle as it normally is. In fact, BCA's view that oil prices have upside, especially relative to EM asset prices, points toward a higher NOK/SEK (Chart I-21). Finally, from a technical perspective, NOK/SEK looks interesting. The pair's 40-week rate-of-change measure is hitting oversold levels. More tellingly, NOK/SEK is forming an inverted head-and-shoulder pattern exactly as its 13-week rate of change loses downward momentum (Chart I-22). Chart I-21Liking Oil Relative To EM Stocks ##br##Is The Same Thing As Being Long NOK/SEK Chart I-22Favorable Technical ##br##Set Up Thus, we are buying NOK/SEK this week, with an entry point at 1.0163, a stop at 0.998, and an initial target at 1.08. Bottom Line: Buying NOK/SEK at current levels makes sense. Not only is it an uncorrelated trade with the dollar, but the pair is also cheap. Moreover, economic momentum, which was overwhelmingly in favor of the SEK, is now rolling in favor of the NOK, a message confirmed by financial market indicators. NOK/SEK is trading at cheap levels relative to global economic and financial variables, suggesting a cushion to negative shocks is in the price. Instead, NOK/SEK should benefit if oil prices outperform EM assets, a view held by BCA. Finally, the trade looks attractive from a technical perspective. Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Geopolitical Strategy Special Reports, titled "How To Read Xi Jinping's Party Congress Speech," dated October 18, 2017, and "China: Party Congress Ends... So What?" dated November 1, 2017, available at gps.bcaresearch.com 2 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, titled "Canaries In The Coal Mine Alert: EM/JPY Carry Trades," dated December 1, 2017, available at fes.bcaresearch.com 3 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Special Report, titled "It's Not My Cross To Bear," dated October 27, 2017, available at fes.bcaresearch.com 4 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, titled "Conflicting Forces For The Dollar," dated September 8, 2017, available at fes.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 U.S. data has been mixed: Core CPI grew by 1.7% annually, lower than the expected 1.8%; Producer prices were strong annually at 3.1%, above the expected 2.9%; while the core measure also produced strong results of 2.4%, above the expected 2.3%; Retail sales were also quite positives, beating expectations by a wide margin. This week, in line with expectations, the Fed hiked rates to 1.25 - 1.5%. The FMOC also upgraded its growth forecasts while still penciling in three rate hikes for next year. However, Treasurys rallied and the DXY dropped 0.6%, showing that markets believe the Fed is potentially making a hawkish error inflation continues to underperform. We do agree with the Fed and we expect inflation be in the process of bottoming. Report Links: Riding The Wave: Momentum Strategies In Foreign Exchange Markets - December 8, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 It's Not My Cross To Bear - October 27, 2017 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 European data was generally positive: German ZEW Current Situation increased to 89.3 while economic sentiment declined to 17.4; European PMIs were very strong, with the manufacturing and services indices coming in at 60.6 and 58, respectively, both increasing and beating expectations. German inflation stayed steady and in line with expectations at 1.8%; French CPI underperformed expectations, growing at 1.2% annually; Italian inflation was in line with consensus at 1.1%; European growth is currently stellar, and markets have priced in this reality. The ECB agrees, and it has upgraded its growth and inflation forecasts up to 2020. Yet, even under the new set of forecasts, inflation fails to hit the ECB's target. With the end of the asset purchases program anticipated for the September 2018, the first hike could materialize in the second quarter of 2019, suggesting EONIA rates possess some genuine but limited upside from current levels. However, most importantly, we think that EONIA pricing will still lag the U.S. OIS going forward, putting downward pressure on EUR/USD. Report Links: The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Temporary Short-Term Rates - November 10, 2017 Market Update - October 27, 2017 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data has been mixed in Japan: Nikkei Manufacturing PMI outperformed expectations, coming in at 53.8. Machinery orders yearly growth also outperformed expectations, coming in at 5%. Moreover, gross domestic product growth also outperformed, coming in at 2.5% in the third quarter. This was a significant improvement from the 1.4% growth number registered in Q2. However labor cash earnings growth underperformed expectations, coming in at 0.6%, suggesting still muted inflation pressures. Finally, housing starts growth surprised to the downside, coming in at -4.8%. After rising throughout the week, USD/JPY collapsed following the FOMC rate decision, as U.S. Treasuries rallied. Overall we continue to be bullish on the yen against risk-on currencies like the NZD and the AUD, as tightening Chinese financial conditions should set the stage for a temporary slowdown in global growth. Report Links: Riding The Wave: Momentum Strategies In Foreign Exchange Markets - December 8, 2017 The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Temporary Short-Term Rates - November 10, 2017 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.K. has been positive: Markit Manufacturing PMI outperformed expectations, coming in at 58.2. This number also increased from the October reading. Construction PMI also outperformed expectations, coming in at 53.1, and also increasing from the previous month's number. Headline inflation also outperformed expectations, with a reading of 3.1%. Nevertheless, core inflation came in according to expectations at 2.7% Finally, the trade balance also outperformed expectations on the month of October, coming in at -1.405 Billion pounds. The BOE's MPC left policy rates unchanged at 0.5%. Overall, we believe that in the short term, the ability of the BoE to continue to hike is limited, given that consumption remains sluggish and leading indicators of house prices still flag some frailty. Furthermore, the uncertainty surrounding Brexit continues to make the BoE more cautious than otherwise. Report Links: The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Reverse Alchemy: How To Transform Gold Into Lead - November 3, 2017 Currency Hedging: Dynamic Or Static? - A Practical Guide For Global Investors - September 29, 2017 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Australian data was mixed: House prices contracted at a quarterly pace by 0.2%, less than the expected 0.5%; NAB Business Confidence went down from 9 to 6; NAB Business Conditions went down from 21 to 12; Westpac consumer confidence went up to 3.6% from -1.7%; However, employment increased by 61,600, beating expectations of 18,000, with full-time employment increasing by 41,900, outperforming part-time employment of 19,700; The AUD rallied on these data releases. Furthermore, faltering U.S. inflation and upbeat Chinese data fed into the AUD's rally. The Australian economy is still mired in substantial slack, and the RBA is likely to stay easy, putting a lid on AUD upside. Report Links: The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Currency Hedging: Dynamic Or Static? - A Practical Guide For Global Investors - September 29, 2017 Updating Our Long-Term Fair Value Models - September 15, 2017 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand has been negative: Seasonally-adjusted building permits contracted by 9.6% in October. Furthermore, the terms of trade index, continued to fall in the third quarters, coming in at 0.7%. This number also surprised to the downside. Manufacturing sales grew by 0.3% in the third quarter, a slowdown from the 1% growth witnessed in Q2. Finally, the ANZ Business Confidence measure fell to -39.3, the lowest level in more than 9 years. The NZD/USD has rallied by roughly 3% in the past week. This mostly reflects weakness on the part of the USD yesterday following the FOMC interest rate decision as NZD is flat against the AUD on the weak. Overall, the long term outlook for NZD/USD, NZD/EUR, and NZD/JPY is negative, as decreased immigration and the addition of an employment mandate for the RBNZ, will structurally lower rates in New Zealand. However, NZD still possesses upside against the AUD. Report Links: The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Reverse Alchemy: How To Transform Gold Into Lead - November 3, 2017 Updating Our Long-Term Fair Value Models - September 15, 2017 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Last week, the BoC left its policy rate unchanged at 1%. The Bank is delaying hiking as inflation and growth have slowed. The BoC also want to appraise the impact of its previous two interest rate hikes as well as the brewing risks surrounding NAFTA negotiations. That being said, inflation still is around 40 bps higher than it was in June. Employment data remains stellar, and the tightening labor market is pointing to a pickup in wages. Additionally, oil could offer additional upside as supply continues to be curtailed by Saudi Arabia and Russia. The CAD is likely to perform well next year, particularly against the SEK and the AUD. However, upside against the U.S. dollar will be limited. Report Links: The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Market Update - October 27, 2017 Currency Hedging: Dynamic Or Static? - A Practical Guide For Global Investors - September 29, 2017 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland has been mixed: Headline inflation surprised to the downside, coming in at 0.8%. However it increased from 0.7% on the previous month. The unemployment rate came in below expectations, at 3%. Additionally, the SNB kept its -0.75% deposit rate unchanged. Furthermore, it continued to signal that it will stay active in the foreign exchange markets. Indeed, the SNB stated that although the overvaluation of the franc has decreased "the franc remains highly valued". On a more positive note, however, the SNB revised its inflation forecast for its coming quarters, suggesting an overshoot may even happen and be tolerated as this inflation upgrade mainly reflected the appreciation of oil and the depreciation of the franc. We continues to believe that the SNB will keep its ultra-dovish monetary policy in place as long as core inflation remains very low and the Swiss franc stays overvalued on a PPP basis. These negatives for the franc could get occasionally interrupted when volatility re-emerges global markets. Report Links: The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Updating Our Long-Term Fair Value Models - September 15, 2017 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - August 4, 2017 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway has been mixed: Core inflation surprised to the downside, coming in at 1.1%. This number also declined from last week's number of 1.2%. Retail Sales growth also underperformed expectations, coming in at -0.2%. However this number improved from last month's 0.8% contraction. However manufacturing output outperformed expectations, coming in at 0.7%. However this number slowed down from last month's 2.8% growth. The Norges Bank kept rates unchanged at 0.5% at its latest monetary policy meeting. Overall, this release was less dovish than markets expected as the Norge Bank brought forward to late 2018 it expectations for a first hike. Essentially, despite a weak batch of data this week, the Norwegian economy is heeling, and is not experiencing the same debilitating deflationary pressures as has been experienced by other countries in Europe. Our favored way to play these improvements in the Norwegian economy, along with the change of tone at the Norges Bank helm is to buy NOK/SEK And short EUR/NOK. Report Links: The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Updating Our Long-Term Fair Value Models - September 15, 2017 10 Charts For A Late-August Day - August 25, 2017 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Swedish data has recently taken a stronger turn: Industrial production increased by 6% annually, higher than the previous 2.7% growth rate; Manufacturing new orders increased by 3.8% annually; Inflation popped up to 1.9%, higher than the previous 1.7%, and outperforming the expected 1.7%. While inflation has picked back up, last quarter's disappointing GDP numbers still raises important question marks. The risks are still skewed toward the current Riksbank leadership maintaining a dovish stance, despite an economy that hardly needs it. This risk will only grow if our EM canaries are correct and global industrial activity turns around, a phenomenon that will impact Swedish growth and inflation negatively. Report Links: The Xs And The Currency Market - November 24, 2017 Updating Our Long-Term Fair Value Models - September 15, 2017 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - August 4, 2017 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
Highlights Idea 1: Long Eurodollar, short Euribor - December 2022 interest rate futures contracts. Alternatively just go outright long the Eurodollar contract. Idea 2: Long EUR/USD Idea 3: Underweight Basic Materials equities versus market. Alternative expressions are to go short the LMEX index, or underweight Norway (OMX) versus Ireland (ISE). Idea 4: Long Norwegian 10-year bonds, short German 10-year bunds. Idea 5: Long U.K. 10-year gilts, short Irish 10-year bonds. Feature Question 1: Where Is The Worrying Imbalance? Last week, in the Quantum Theory Of Finance,1 we pointed out that when bond yields reach ultra-low levels, the payoff profile from bonds becomes highly asymmetric. When yields approach a lower bound, they cannot fall much further but they can rise a lot. Meaning that bond prices have very limited potential for gains, but have great potential for sudden and deep losses. Chart of the WeekThe Norway Versus Euro Area Bond Yield Spread Is Too Wide The unattractive asymmetric payoff profile - known as negative skew - applies to both nominal and real returns. This is because negative skew is concerned about deep nominal losses over a relatively short period. In which case, a deep nominal loss will be a deep real loss too.2 As equity returns always possess negative skew we can say that at ultra-low bond yields, bond risk becomes equity-like. Given this risk equalization, equities no longer justify a risk premium over bonds. And the lower prospective return required from equities means that today's equity valuations and prices become a lot richer. But the new delicate balance of valuations is conditional on bond yields remaining ultra-low. This is because the unattractive negative skew on a 10-year bond's returns disappears when its yield moves up into the 'high 2s' (Chart I-2). At this point, risk is no longer equalized and the equity risk premium must fully re-emerge - requiring today's equity market valuation and price to drop, perhaps substantially. However, the ensuing fight to havens would then once again pull bond yields back down from the 'high 2s'. It follows that the rise in expected interest rates is self-limiting. Any policy interest rate expectation already in the 'high 2s' - such as the Eurodollar December 2022 contract - cannot sustainably rise much further, whereas those that are still some way below - such as the Euribor December 2022 contract - can (Chart I-3). Which leads to our first investment idea. Chart I-2Bonds Become Much More ##br##Risky At Ultra-Low Yields Chart I-3The Euro Area/U.S. Interest Rate Expectation ##br##Spread Is Too Wide Investment idea 1: Long Eurodollar, short Euribor - December 2022 interest rate futures contracts. Alternatively just go outright long the Eurodollar contract. Question 2: Which Is The Safest Currency To Hold? Chart I-4Euro/Dollar Just Tracks ##br##The Bond Yield Spread To reiterate, at ultra-low bond yields, bond returns offer a highly unattractive payoff profile. Put simply, you can quickly lose a lot more money - in both nominal and real terms - than you can make! Now observe that the payoff profile for a foreign exchange rate just tracks the bond yield spread (Chart I-4). This means that when a central bank has already taken bond yields close to their lower bound, its currency possesses a highly attractive payoff profile called positive skew. In essence, as the ECB is at the realistic limit of ultra-loose policy, the direction of policy rate expectations cannot go significantly lower. Conversely, policy rate expectations for the Federal Reserve (for 2022) are not far from our upper bound of the 'high 2s'. So these expectations cannot go significantly higher without threatening a risk-asset selloff. On this basis, EUR/USD has more scope to gap up than to gap down. Investment idea 2: Long EUR/USD But be aware that investment ideas 1 and 2 are highly correlated with each other! Question 3: Where Are We In The Global Growth Mini-Cycle? Global growth experiences remarkably consistent - and therefore predictable - 'mini-cycles', with half-cycle lengths averaging 8 months. As the current mini-upswing started in May we can infer that it is likely to end in early 2018. So one surprise in 2018 could be that global growth slows in the first half rather than in the second half - contrary to what the consensus is expecting. That said, half-cycle lengths do have some degree of variation: the current upswing might be a few months longer or shorter than the average. So how can we avoid positioning too early or too late for the next turn? The answer is to focus on investments that have already fully priced the current upswing, so that timing becomes less of an issue. On this basis, we propose that the rally in industrial metals and Basic Materials equities is already extended. Our technical indicator which captures herding and groupthink correctly identified the trough at the end of 2015, the mini-peak at the end of 2016, and is now signalling that the latest rally is likely to fade (Chart I-5 and Chart I-6). Chart I-5Metals Have Fully Priced ##br##The Mini-Upswing... Chart I-6...And The Metal Rally Is Reaching##br## Its Technical Limit Investment idea 3: Underweight Basic Materials equities versus market. Alternative expressions are to go short the LMEX index, or underweight Norway (OMX) versus Ireland (ISE). Question 4: Will Inflation Lift Off? The ECB's continued indulgence with ultra-loose monetary policy would make you think that the euro area is on the edge of a deflationary abyss. In fact, inflation has been running comfortably within a 0-2% band for almost two years. Will inflation edge closer to the ECB's 2% point target? Given our view on the growth mini-cycle, not immediately. In the first half of 2018, inflation may even edge lower within the 0-2% band, but this global dynamic will affect inflation in all jurisdictions, not just in the euro area. There is nothing wrong with inflation running comfortably within a 0-2% band. Now that we know that nominal interest rates can go slightly negative, a 0-2% inflation band even permits negative real interest rates. The big mistake is to aim for an arbitrary point target, like 2%. This is because inflation is a non-linear phenomenon, and a defining characteristic of a non-linear phenomenon is that it cannot hit an arbitrary point target.3 It is our high conviction expectation that the major central banks will eventually change their point targets for inflation into target bands such as 0-2% or 1-3%. But afraid to lose credibility, they will not change tack abruptly. In the meantime, we notice that the Norges Bank is undershooting its 2.5% inflation target by considerably more than the ECB is undershooting its 2% target (Chart I-7). Yet the yield spread between Norwegian and euro area bonds has not caught up with this reality (Chart of the Week). Chart I-7The Norges Bank Is Undershooting Its Inflation Target By More Than The ECB Investment idea 4: Long Norwegian 10-year bonds, short German 10-year bunds. Question 5: Will Political Risk Re-emerge? Political events have had a hand in three of the sharpest recent moves in financial markets. The vote for Brexit catalysed a 15% decline in the pound; the vote for Trump triggered an 80 bps spike in the 10-year T-bond yield, and the vote for Macron unleashed a 10% rally in the euro. Political change disrupts markets if it dislocates the long-term expectations embedded in economic agents and financial prices. The vote for Brexit changed expectations about the U.K.'s long-term trading relationships; the election of Trump changed expectations about fiscal stimulus, the tax structure, and protectionism (perhaps unrealistically); and the election of Macron exorcised the potential chaos of a Le Pen presidency. Chart I-8The U.K. Versus Ireland Bond ##br##Yield Spread Is Too Wide In contrast, the recent (disputed) vote for independence in Catalonia, and the breakdown of coalition discussions in Germany barely moved the markets - because neither event changed expectations of long-term economic outcomes. As investors, this is the test we should apply to all political events. In 2018, the evolution of Brexit has the potential to move markets. This is because hard Brexiters and the EU27 are on a collision course. Specifically, the issue of the Irish border is insoluble. It is Brexit's Gordian knot. Theresa May has promised the hard Brexiters that the U.K. will leave the EU customs union and single market. She has also promised the Northern Ireland Unionists - who are propping up May's minority government - that there will be no hard border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland or the rest of the U.K. But these promises are irreconcilable. The Republic of Ireland will veto a border that threatens the Good Friday peace agreement; the Northern Ireland Unionists will not tolerate the border moving to the Irish Sea, which would effectively take Northern Ireland into the EU customs union and single market; and the EU27 will block a Hong Kong type 'free port' status for Northern Ireland - as this would remove the integrity of harmonized standards across the EU. Eventually, the impenetrable Irish border problem is likely to be the roadblock to a hard Brexit. But first there needs to be a collision. And the collision could move markets. With the yield spread between U.K. 10-year gilts and Irish 10-year bonds near a 2-year wide (Chart I-8), this leads us to our fifth investment idea. Investment idea 5: Long U.K. 10-year gilts, short Irish 10-year bonds. Dhaval Joshi, Senior Vice President Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report 'The Quantum Theory Of Finance' November 23 2017 available at eis.bcaresearch.com. 2 For example if the nominal return over 3 months was a very painful -10%, and inflation was running at -10% per annum, the real return over 3 months would be a still very painful -7.5%. 3 Please see the European Investment Strategy Weekly Report 'Three Mantras For Investors' August 17 2017 available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Fractal Trading Model* Ahead of the OPEC meeting on November 30, the WTI crude oil price is vulnerable to any disappointment - because its rally is technically very extended. This week's trade recommendation is to expect a retracement of 7.5% with a symmetrical stop-loss. For any investment, excessive trend following and groupthink can reach a natural point of instability, at which point the established trend is highly likely to break down with or without an external catalyst. An early warning sign is the investment's fractal dimension approaching its natural lower bound. Chart I-9 The post-June 9, 2016 fractal trading model rules are: When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. Use the position size multiple to control risk. The position size will be smaller for more risky positions.Encouragingly, this trigger has consistently identified countertrend moves of various magnitudes across all asset classes. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report "Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model," dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading Model Recommendations Equities Bond & Interest Rates Currency & Other Positions Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch##br## - Interest Rate Expectations