Economy

Highlights The Fed will continue to have investors’ backs in 2021 (and beyond): The Fed will maintain extremely accommodative policy settings to combat low inflation expectations and growth that could still falter in the face of insufficient fiscal support or vaccination snafus. Congress appears to be nearing agreement on another round of fiscal aid: The economic outlook is much rosier than it was when the pandemic arrived but households and businesses in the hardest-hit segments need further assistance to tide them over until COVID-19 is definitively beaten. It appears as if a new wave of fiscal transfers is on the way. You wouldn’t know it to look at the equity market, but we’re not out of the woods yet, … : Stocks keep making new highs against a grim near-term public health backdrop and economic data that point to fading momentum. … and that’s giving rise to a general sense of cognitive dissonance: It is becoming more difficult to reconcile the fundamentals with a spreading tide of euphoria/exuberance. Feature You can always count on Americans to do the right thing – after they’ve tried everything else. Policymakers versus the virus has been the macro story since the pandemic reached the US in the spring and it’s not over yet. The remarkable success of Pfizer/BioNTech’s and Moderna’s vaccines in clinical trials is wonderful news for humanity, but the pandemic will be with us until around 70% of the population is inoculated against COVID-19 or has already contracted it. While it is reasonable to think that the pandemic may end within the next nine months, individuals and businesses that were directly in its path still need some support if the rest of the economy is to avoid the cascading effects of their distress. Just as my spending is your income and your spending is my income, timely debt service is essential for banks, specialty lenders, insurers and the broad range of businesses that allow customers to finance the purchase of goods and services. We have repeatedly made the case that the extraordinary monetary and fiscal support measures launched in the spring have shored up the aggregate positions of households, businesses and the banking system. As restrictions are re-imposed across the country in response to strained hospital capacity (Chart 1), months after the last supplemental unemployment insurance (UI) benefit checks were sent and days before many remaining idled workers lose expanded and/or extended access to UI benefits, some households at the lower end of the income and wealth distributions are becoming increasingly desperate. Since they have the highest marginal propensity to consume, their woes could eventually hem in the prospects for the recovery. Chart 1High Water Everywhere As a result, the economy would welcome some targeted stimulus to extend the bridge over the pandemic crater and ensure that hard-hit households and businesses can make it all the way across. Last week’s talks increased the probability that aid will be provided and sped up the timetable for its delivery. They increased the odds that our base-case scenario, in which the economy receives more aid than is strictly necessary, will come to pass. That scenario is positive for the economy and risk assets and reinforces our view that equities and credit will generate positive excess returns in 2021. The Fed Still Has Investors’ Backs Chart 2Mortgage Rates Are Low Enough Already Last week’s FOMC meeting was largely devoid of suspense. The Fed exhausted its shock-and-awe repertoire in the spring when it implemented nearly all of its emergency GFC measures in the space of a few weeks and topped them off with new facilities positioning it to lend directly to businesses and state and local governments. It played its longer-term trump card in August when it amended its monetary policy strategy statement to allow for deliberate inflation overshoots. Attempting to remediate past inflation shortfalls represents a meaningful shift in the direction of easier monetary policy across the cycle, given that the Fed is now pledging that it will no longer pre-emptively tighten when the labor market heats up. Anything the Fed can do to ease policy from this point forward is likely to amount to tinkering at the margin. Ahead of the meeting, some economists were looking for the Fed to increase the weighted average maturity of its Treasury purchases to hold down long rates. With mortgage applications already straining lenders’ capacity to process them and every component of homebuilder sentiment hovering near record levels (Chart 2), we don’t think Operation Twist-style measures would have a telling impact. Europe’s experience with NIRP does not suggest that venturing below the zero bound would help, either. Additional fiscal aid would be much more potent than any incremental monetary moves. Chair Powell agrees, and he kept up his ongoing lobbying campaign for renewed fiscal support at the post-meeting press conference. From our perspective, the Fed is already providing considerable accommodation and its baseline plans, which include maintaining $120 billion monthly asset purchases “until substantial further progress has been made toward the Committee’s maximum employment and price stability goals,” will be amply accommodative going forward, given that the FOMC’s revised economic projections suggest that it doesn’t currently foresee tapering the purchases until sometime in 2022 at the earliest (Chart 3) or beginning to hike the fed funds rate until 2024 (Chart 4). Though we expect that upward inflation pressures will begin to gain traction sooner than the FOMC currently projects and that its timetable for hiking rates will be accelerated, we expect that monetary policy will remain easier for longer than it needs to, giving financial markets a tailwind for all of 2021. Chart 3 The Fed Will Taper Asset Purchases … Chart 4… Before It Hikes The Fed Funds Rate Better Late Than Never At the time of our publication deadline, Congress appeared to be nearing agreement on a new fiscal support package. Media reports project the bill will provide around $900 billion of aid via direct checks to taxpayers; income support for the unemployed, including a renewed UI benefit supplement; rental assistance; federally-backed loans for hard-hit businesses; aid to hospitals and schools; and dedicated funds for vaccine distribution. Republicans have dropped their demands for virus liability protection for businesses and Democrats have backed off of their insistence on direct aid to struggling state and local governments. A bipartisan group of moderate senators provided the impetus for the apparently successful talks, and it would be tempting to conclude that their ad hoc coalition points the way to a more productive Senate. Unfortunately, our geopolitical strategists expect that political polarization will remain elevated on Capitol Hill. Although Senate Republicans paid no political price for standing in the way of additional fiscal aid ahead of the November election, The New York Times reported that Senate Majority Leader McConnell cited the pending Georgia run-offs in urging his caucus to get behind the proposed bill, saying that the Republican incumbents were “getting hammered” on the campaign trail over the lack of new support. That election will be in the rear-view mirror after Inauguration Day and unless the Democrats surprisingly capture both of the Georgia seats, Congress will remain stalled for the foreseeable future. Do We Really Need More Stimulus? Future congressional dysfunction notwithstanding, successful stimulus negotiations arrived just in time. Recent releases suggest that economic momentum is waning. Initial unemployment claims surged to an eleven-week high for the week ended December 4th and a fourteen-week high for the week ended December 11th (Chart 5), suggesting that the initial scattering of lockdowns is already sparking a new wave of layoffs. Retail sales flopped in November and the economic surprise index has been steadily declining since June (Chart 6). At the aggregate level, it looks like we may have been able to get by without more stimulus, but many out-of-work households and travel, entertainment and hospitality businesses are gasping for air. Their problems could become everyone's problems once they spread to their lenders and their lenders' counter-parties. Chart 5New Lockdowns = New Layoffs Chart 6Coming Back To Earth Households are quite well positioned in the aggregate, having socked away a mountain of excess savings while riding the equity rally and the boom in home prices, but the gains have not been equally spread across the entire population. Wealth and income disparities influence consumption patterns in individual households as embodied in their marginal propensity to consume (MPC). Households living paycheck to paycheck at the lower end of the income and wealth distributions are far more likely to spend an incremental dollar than households at the upper end, who are prone to save or invest new inflows. All dressed up and nowhere to go: Increased wealth can't burn a hole in households' pockets until inoculation unlocks their spending options. Disparate marginal propensities to consume get to the crux of why further fiscal stimulus is needed despite the CARES Act’s income windfall, and the excess savings that have piled up in its wake. Although surging household net worth (Chart 7) will eventually translate into consumption gains (Chart 8), the lag may be longer this time if better-heeled households’ pent-up demand will not be slaked until the virus is definitively beaten. The economy is more sensitive in the near term to spending by high-MPC households, which may become increasingly vulnerable as fiscal support dwindles while renewed restrictions on activity loom. Chart 7What Recession? Aggregate Household Wealth Is Surging Chart 8Changes In Household Net Worth Lead Changes In Consumption With A Two-Quarter Lag Chart 9Has The Other Shoe Finally Dropped? Falling support and tighter restrictions also leave the economy vulnerable to a self-reinforcing cycle of defaults and bankruptcies. Monetary and fiscal accommodation have held credit stress at bay so far, with the Fed’s efforts clearing the way for record volumes of corporate bond issuance and income support and forbearance programs making it easy for consumers to keep up with their debt obligations. Monthly delinquency rates on auto loans, credit cards, home mortgages and other unsecured consumer debt remain strikingly low and are not signaling any problems. Apartment rent collections had been reinforcing the message from low consumer delinquencies, but a steep year-over-year falloff over the first six days of December may be a canary in the coalmine for struggling households (Chart 9). Howard Marks Versus The Newbies Equities have staged a breathtaking rally since bottoming in late March. Although 2020 full-year S&P 500 earnings per share (~$138) are projected to miss pre-pandemic expectations (~$176) by more than 20%, and 2021 estimates (~$169) are over 10% shy of the number analysts had penciled in at the end of January (~$196), the S&P 500 has gained 15% year to date. Some of the rebound off the trough has come from a better-than-expected recovery in corporate earnings, but multiple expansion has been the dominant engine driving the advance. The S&P 500’s forward multiple is already two standard deviations above its mean, and the index will trade very close to its December 1999 peak of 24.8 once Tesla is officially included (Chart 10). Chart 10Back To The Future (In A Tesla This Time) Peak equity valuations are a sign of a market-specific battle between exuberance and moderation that is an outgrowth of the policymaker-virus clash. We expect that exuberance, embodied by neophyte males in their twenties and thirties who found playing the market on Robinhood a diverting substitute for sports betting while college and pro leagues were idled, will eventually be put in its place. The full weight of history is arrayed against it, along with the impeccable cyclical analysis of Howard Marks, who is often cast as the voice of reason by overheating markets. We don't like the excesses that are popping up all over the investment landscape, but we think uber-accommodative policy will sustain them over the next twelve months. We are especially mindful of Marks’ Minskyesque admonition that a run of persistently strong fundamentals can presage investment disappointments, as prices get bid higher and higher and optimism crowds out skepticism and caution. Investing is a relative game; a stock or bond issuer’s absolute performance is less important than how it shapes up against expectations. A company growing at a good clip will face a falling multiple or wider bond spreads if markets were discounting very good growth, and the securities of a company with bad growth will appreciate if markets thought its growth would be terrible. We remain constructive because we continue to believe that economic and corporate earnings growth still has scope to surprise to the upside. We continue to believe that the time-release aspects of the initial stimulus efforts, manifest in massive savings and burgeoning household net worth, are underappreciated. We were concerned that the loss of support for lower-income households could deliver a shock to the economy via drop-offs in consumption and credit performance, but our take on the news from Capitol Hill suggests that the economy is going to dodge that shock in the nick of time. We remain vigilant for signs of an inflection point driven by an economic stumble, a dramatically negative turn on the pandemic front or an imminent reversal of investor excesses that can no longer be sustained. We are uneasy about budding signs of excess, but we think the best course for multi-asset investors with 12-month timeframes is to remain overweight equities and credit because we expect that policy tailwinds and the release of pent-up consumer demand will keep the rally going through 2021.   This is our final report of 2020. Our next report will be published on Tuesday, January 5th. We wish you a happy, healthy and prosperous new year.   Doug Peta, CFA Chief US Investment Strategist dougp@bcaresearch.com