Economy

Highlights The current pace in the recovery of China’s domestic demand has not been robust enough to fully offset the impact from the collapse in exports. The level of industrial inventory jumped to a five-year high, but it will likely be transitional. We expect the inventory overhang to subside when the recovery speed in demand catches up with supply in H2.  While the gap is widening between stock prices and economic fundamentals in the US, Chinese equity prices have been more “well behaved” in the past month. We continue to overweight Chinese stocks in the next 6 to 12 months and favor Chinese onshore corporate bonds overall and SOEs in particular. Feature China’s Caixin and official PMIs in April highlighted the knock-on effects on the Chinese economy from a collapse in external demand. Although China’s domestic economy continued its rebound, the pace of the improvement has not been robust enough to offset rapidly weakening exports. This was evident in the widening gap between supply and demand in April. The sharp contraction in the global economy in Q1 will likely deepen in Q2 because the lockdowns in Europe and the US started in the later part of Q1 and have mostly remained in place through end-April. We expect global demand to significantly worsen in April and May, generating strong headwinds to China’s near-term recovery. Chinese authorities have been prompted to step up their stimulus efforts due to a fast deterioration in global growth. The government recently approved an additional 1-trillion yuan in local government special-purpose bond issuance, which is scheduled to be fully dispersed by the end of May. China’s stimulus, strongly focused on boosting investment and economic growth, should fuel Chinese stock and industrial metal prices in the next 6 to 12 months. Tables 1 and 2 below highlight key developments in China’s economic and financial market performance in the past month. Table 1China Macro Data Summary Table 2China Financial Market Performance Summary Chart 1Construction Sector Has Seen The Strongest Rebound China’s domestic demand partially offset a collapse in exports in April. The official manufacturing PMI slipped to 50.8 in April from 52 in the previous month. The Caixin PMI survey, which is skewed towards smaller and more export-oriented firms, returned to contractionary territory in April following a brief rebound in March. The retreat in both PMI readings highlights how a worldwide lockdown of businesses has shaken China’s manufacturing sector (Chart 1, top panel). This exogenous negative impact will likely worsen in Q2. China's domestic economy continued its slow recovery through April. The official PMI’s new orders subcomponent declined by only 2 percentage points, despite a collapse of new export orders to 33.5. Moreover, the new orders subcomponent of the non-manufacturing PMI survey increased from 49.2 to 52.1, with the construction subcomponent reverting to its pre-pandemic level. The construction employment subcomponent also confirms that the industry has shown the strongest rebound among sectors in the Chinese economy (Chart 1, middle and bottom panels). Chart 2Home Sales Are Likely To Accelerate China’s housing market also continued to improve in April. Chart 2 (top panel) shows that the demand for both residential housing and floor space started rebounding in March. The high frequency data indicate the year-over-year growth rate in home sales in China’s 30 large- and medium-sized cities turned positive in April (Chart 2, middle panel). The rapid expansion in home sales in the past weeks may be due to recent discount promotions, but we anticipate housing prices to remain stable this year in line with the Chinese leadership’s policy direction (“houses are for living, not for speculation”). We also expect that the number of home sales will accelerate.  Local governments will significantly ramp up land sales this year to make up for their large revenue shortfalls.  The central government will continue to gradually relax real estate purchase restrictions. The more property market-friendly policies, coupled with extremely accommodative monetary conditions, will encourage a healthy rally in property market investment and housing demand in H2 (Chart 2, bottom panel). So far most improvement in China’s domestic demand seems to be concentrated in the construction sector.  The slow pace of manufacturers’ capacity utilization suggests that China’s industrial output growth is unlikely to return to its pre-pandemic rate in Q2. As of April 25, among the official PMI surveyed enterprises, the resumption rate of large- and medium-sized enterprises was 98.5%. However, only 77.3% of them reported that they were operating at 80% or higher of their usual capacity utilization rates.1 Chart 3Pressure On Inventory Should Start To Ease In H2 The imbalance in the recoveries of China’s supply and demand has led to a pileup in inventory, the highest level in five years (Chart 3).  The combination of excessive inventory and low demand has weakened China’s factory pricing power and profit growth. However, in our view, the inventory overhang will be temporary, and the factory price contraction is unlikely to turn into a deep deflation such as the one in 2009 or the long-lasting deflationary cycle from 2012-2015. The level of industrial inventory has been much lower than it was during the four years leading to the 2008/2009 global financial crisis (GFC) and the 2015/2016 deep deflationary cycle. The deflation in factory prices also has been relatively mild compared with the two previous phases. Moreover, an extremely tight monetary policy and protracted inventory destocking period that contributed to the collapse in global raw material prices in 2012 are not present. Declines in China’s manufacturing, raw material and mining prices are synchronized, echoing the GFC when global demands nose-dived and pushed international oil and raw material prices into deep contractions. Our baseline scenario of an incremental re-opening of the global economy, a peak in the US dollar, and a recovery in the oil market in H2, all support our view that the deflation in China’s producer prices should not last beyond Q3. Given that exports’ share to China’s GDP is currently half of what it was in 2008, the weakness in global demand will be much less of a drag on China’s domestic manufacturing sector than during the GFC. Chart 4Logistics Bottleneck Still In Place Additionally, the drawdown in April’s raw material inventory and an increase in the official PMI’s supplier delivery subcomponents suggest that some lingering logistical bottlenecks may be at play, preventing China’s domestic business operations from recuperating at full speed (Chart 4). We expect a further relaxation of intra- and inter-provincial travel restrictions following the National People’s Congress (NPC) on May 22 in Beijing. This easing should help to accelerate the normalization in both manufacturing activities and inventory levels. The outperformance of Chinese equity prices versus global stocks has eased significantly in the past month (Table 3 and Chart 5). The moderation suggests that investors may be starting to factor in a slower-than-expected economic recovery in China. Near-term risks are still high for further selloffs in both Chinese and global stocks. Nevertheless, we think the rapid advancement in global stock prices in the past month, particularly the SPX, means that Chinese stocks are not as overbought as in February and March. The widening gap between US equity prices and economic fundamentals makes the SPX more vulnerable to near-term uncertainties surrounding global economic recovery. We maintain our view that a combination of massive Chinese stimulus and the momentum in China’s economic recovery in H2 should support an outperformance in Chinese stocks in the next 6 to 12 months. Table 3Chinese Stocks Advanced Much Less Than SPX In April Chart 5Chinese Stocks Less Overbought Now The bull steepening in the government bond yield curve since March 23 flattened a bit in the last week of April, but it remains heightened with the short end of the yield curve falling much faster than the long end (Chart 6). This suggests that domestic investors expect China’s ultra-easy monetary policy to remain in place in the near term due to uncertainties surrounding the global pandemic and a slow economic upturn. At the same time, investors do not believe the weakness in the Chinese economy will persist long enough to warrant a sustained easy monetary policy regime. In addition, China’s 10-year government bond yield fell by 60bps so far this year, about half of the drop in the 10-year US Treasury bond yield (Chart 6, bottom panel). Even though we think the long end of the government bond yield curve has yet to bottom,2 the relatively stable return and RMB exchange rate make Chinese government bonds a safe bet for global investors seeking less risky assets. Chart 6Chinese 10-Year Government Bond Yield Has Not Capitulated Chart 7Chinese Onshore Corporate Bonds Still Offer Solid Returns Chart 7 highlights that the ChinaBond Corporate Bond total return index remains in a solid uptrend in both local currency and USD terms, despite the incredible strength in the USD since March. We continue to recommend onshore corporate bond positions in the coming 6-12 months.For domestic investors, we favor a diversified portfolio of SOE corporate bonds. Even though bond defaults will likely rise in the next 6-12 months, they will probably remain lower than what the market is  currently pricing in.     Qingyun Xu, CFA Senior Analyst qingyunx@bcaresearch.com   Jing Sima China Strategist jings@bcaresearch.com   Footnotes 1NBS’s interpretation of China April PMI.  http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/sjjd/202004/t20200430_1742576.html  2Please see China Investment Strategy Weekly Report "Three Questions Following The Coronacrisis," dated April 23, 2020, available at cis.bcaresearch.com Cyclical Investment Stance Equity Sector Recommendations

Highlights Portfolio Strategy An easy Fed as far as the eye can see and World War-like fiscal easing packages as the Trump administration prepares to slowly reopen the economy, signal that the path of least resistance remains higher for the S&P 500 in the coming 9-12 months. Relative indebtedness and profit margin improvements, extremely oversold technicals and significant relative undervaluation along with an encouraging message from financial market indicators, all suggest that it no longer pays to have a large cap bias. Book gains and step aside. Recent Changes Our long S&P 500/short S&P 600 position was stopped out last Tuesday for a 37% gain since inception.1 Last Wednesday our rolling stop was also triggered on the overweight in the S&P managed health care index – it is now neutral – for a gain of 26% since inception.2 Table 1 Feature The SPX made a run for the technically important 200-day moving average last week, and managed to climb to fresh recovery highs before giving back those gains as profit taking intensified late in the week. Three key drivers underpinned stocks and dominated the newsflow: First, resurfacing of positive news on remdesivir, a GILD drug, in treating the novel coronavirus. Second, the Fed reiterating its commitment to ZIRP and QE5 (Chart 1). And third, the quintuplet tech titans (MSFT, AAPL, GOOGL, AMZN & FB) reporting solid profits and April guidance, thus alleviating investors’ fears of a complete breakdown in tech revenues and EPS. Chart 1Easy Central Bank Monetary Policy Stance… Tack on the World War-like fiscal easing packages (Chart 2) and the path of least resistance remains higher for the S&P 500 in the coming 9-12 months. Chart 2…And An Easier Fiscal Policy Setting Are A Boon For Stocks Granted all of these monies are finding their way into the markets not only via higher asset prices, but also – and most crucially – the Fed’s massive liquidity injection is suppressing volatility. First, Fed actions have crushed the bond market’s vol, as depicted by Bank Of America’s MOVE index, that has now crumbled to a level last seen prior to the equity market drubbing. Similarly, the Fed has also quashed the VIX index which is now hovering near 35, down from a peak of 85 last month. Importantly, volatility petered out prior to the equity market’s trough, and so did different volatility curves (volatilities and volatility curve shown inverted, Chart 3). Turning over to S&P 500 net earnings revisions (NER), this mean reverting series was first tracked by I/B/E/S in 1985, and two weeks ago collapsed to the nadir of the GFC (Chart 4). Every time the NER ratio has hit such depressed levels, stocks have subsequently staged a powerful comeback. This has occurred five distinct times in the past 35 years and the SPX was 15% higher on average in the following twelve months (Chart 4). Chart 3Vols Lead On The Way Up And Down   Chart 4Extremely Depressed Net Earnings Revisions Have Troughed Drilling deeper beneath the surface is revealing. Analysts have been indiscriminately downgrading profits across all sectors. True, last week’s update revealed a tick up, which is an encouraging sign that the avalanche of downgrades may have already hit a climax (Charts 5 &  6). Chart 5Too Much Pessimism… Chart 6…Across The Board Importantly, our in-house calculated SPX sector EPS breadth is probing all-time lows. But, if the Fed manages to devalue the US dollar then a sharp reversal will ensue. Keep in mind, that the greenback and our EPS breadth indicator are inversely correlated as 40% of SPX sales are sourced internationally (Chart 7). Chart 7As Bad As It Gets Finally, a few words on the character of the equity market’s advance since the March 23 lows are in order. Contrary to popular belief, this has been an extremely broad based rally and the stocks that have done the best are not the large/mega caps. Instead the median stock has far outpaced the top market cap ranked constituents. In other words, the stocks that have rebounded the most are the ones that had fallen the most. Using Bloomberg data on SPX constituents from the March 23 lows until April 28, the first mega cap company that makes it to the top return ranks is CVX at the 22nd spot. UNH is 85th, ABT 90th and XOM 132nd. The tech titans start appearing below the 350th mark with MSFT 353rd, AAPL 362nd, FB 370th, AMZN 394th and GOOGL 439th. In other words, both the Value Line Arithmetic and Geometric indexes have been outperforming the SPX since the March 23 lows (top & middle panels, Chart 8). Similarly, small caps have also been besting the SPX (bottom panel, Chart 8). Notably, all three of these hypersensitive indexes have also led the SPX bottom. This week, we update our size view that was stopped out last Tuesday as the rolling stop was triggered for a gain of 37% since inception, and do some housekeeping. Chart 8Broad Based Rally Lock In Profits In the Size Bias And Move To The Sidelines In the spring of 2018 we initiated a size preference of large caps at the expense of small caps. At the time, we went against the grain as the investment community was arguing that small caps would offer the best protection from President’s Trump trade hawkishness. Their reasoning was that small caps are domestically oriented and would benefit from a rising dollar given low export exposure. While we were slightly offside for a quarter, this size preference recouped all the losses by October 2018, and never looked back since then. Our thesis was predicated upon relative indebtedness, relative profitability and relative profit margin outlook, all of which were in favor of large caps. Earlier this year when markets were convulsing we instituted a risk management metric with a rolling 10% stop on this size preference in order to protect profits for our portfolio.3 This past Tuesday our 10% rolling stop was triggered and we are obeying this stop, monetizing 37% gains since inception and we are moving to the sidelines on the size bias (Chart 9). Chart 9Take Profits And Move To The Sidelines Following a near collapse to two standard deviations below the six year mean, small cap performance has returned to the mean and is primed to sustain this reflex rebound. In marked contrast, large caps only corrected to their six year average and are now trading at over one standard deviation above that mean (Chart 10). When the economy was shut down small and medium businesses were clearly the outfits that would hurt the most. Their only rescue came belated in the form of the fiscal package. Thus, investors started pricing in a steep default cycle with SMEs at the forefront of the bankruptcy curve (top panel, Chart 10). In contrast, large caps with access to untapped credit lines, the bond and equity markets as well as their own cash coffers would not suffer as severely (second panel, Chart 10). Chart 10Large Cap Outperformance Reached An Extreme Now that the economy is on the verge of slowly reopening, we do not want to overstay our welcome and refrain from betting on a further jump in the large/small ratio; instead we opt to book profits and move to the sidelines. With regard to profit fundamentals, our relative jobs proxy has peaked and is no longer favoring large caps (second panel, Chart 11). Similarly, profit margins have likely bottomed for small caps while they have maxed out for large caps (third panel, Chart 11). On the relative indebtedness front, small cap net debt-to-EBITDA remains sky high but it has crested which is at the margin positive (bottom panel, Chart 11). Meanwhile, as the Fed has opened up the liquidity spigots, the government is as spendthrift as it can be and committed to slowly reopen the economy, then at some point in the summer the pendulum will swing the opposite way and some semblance of normality will return to the US economy. Therefore, this inflection point will end the threat of deflation and likely serve as a catalyst for a small/large multiple expansion phase (Chart 12). Chart 11Marginal Small Cap Improvements Chart 12When The Economy Turns, So Will Small Caps With regard to the message that financial market variables are sending for the small/large ratio, the collapse of the VIX is a welcome development (VIX shown inverted, Chart 13). Similarly, the yield curve has been in steepening mode again emitting a positive “risk on” signal. Under such a backdrop and given depressed technicals and bombed out valuations it is prudent not to wager against small caps at this juncture (Chart 14). Chart 13Leading Financial Market Indicators Say Do Not Overstay Your Welcome Chart 14Unloved And Undervalued Netting it all out, relative indebtedness and profit margin improvements, the slow reopening of the economy in the coming months, extremely oversold technicals and significant relative undervaluation along with an encouraging message from financial market indicators, all signal that it no longer pays to have a large cap bias. Bottom Line: Move to the sidelines on the size bias and crystalize profits of 37% since inception. Housekeeping Last Wednesday our rolling stop was also triggered on the overweight in the S&P managed health care index – it is now neutral – for a gain of 26% since inception (top panel, Chart 15).4 In addition, we are stepping aside from the COVID-proof basket of stocks we recommended six weeks ago.5 The coronavirus unintended consequences will alter government, business and consumer behaviors and it will most definitely affect consumer tastes, underscoring that the companies that comprise our COVID profit basket will likely be long-term winners. However, this basket has served its purpose and given that the global economy is on the verge of reopening it will be increasingly difficult to outperform the broad market. Thus, we are moving to the sidelines for a modest relative gain of 0.8% (second & third panels, Chart 15). Finally, our freshly minted market-neutral and intra-commodity long S&P oil & gas exploration & production/short global gold miners pair trade has gone parabolic right out of the gate soaring to 20% in a mere week. As a result of this explosive up-move, we are instituting a 10% rolling stop in this pair trade in order to protect profits for our portfolio (bottom panel, Chart 15). Chart 15Housekeeping     Anastasios Avgeriou US Equity Strategist anastasios@bcaresearch.com     Footnotes 1    Please see BCA US Equity Strategy Daily Report, “Book Gains In Preferring Large Caps To Small Caps” dated April 30, 2020, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 2    Please see BCA US Equity Strategy Daily Report, “Take Profits In HMOs And Move To The Sidelines” dated May 1, 2020, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 3    Please see BCA US Equity Strategy Daily Report, “Closing Out All High-Conviction Calls” dated March 20, 2020, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 4    Please see BCA US Equity Strategy Daily Report, “Take Profits In HMOs And Move To The Sidelines” dated May 1, 2020, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 5    Please see BCA US Equity Strategy Daily Report, “Corona Virus Proof Portfolio” dated March 18, 2020, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. Current Recommendations Current Trades Strategic (10-Year) Trade Recommendations Size And Style Views June 3, 2019 Stay neutral cyclicals over defensives (downgrade alert)  January 22, 2018 Favor value over growth April 28, 2020  Stay neutral large over small caps  June 11, 2018 Long the BCA Millennial basket  The ticker symbols are: (AAPL, AMZN, UBER, HD, LEN, MSFT, NFLX, SPOT, TSLA, V).