Developed Countries

Highlights The European barometer that best gauges global growth is euro area growth excluding inventory adjustments. Euro area growth excluding inventory adjustments is now running at a blistering 4.2 percent nominal pace – close to its 10-year upper bound – and is unlikely to accelerate much further. All the evidence shows that we are at the tail-end of a global growth up-oscillation. Irrespective of the evolution of the trade war, our high conviction view is that our global growth barometer will show weaker readings in the second half of the year. We present the correct investment strategy for this environment within the report. Feature Chart of the WeekGrowth Isn’t Going To Get Much Better Europe is an excellent barometer of the world economy. Not only is Europe a big chunk of the global economy in its own right, Europe also has a very open economy with a huge external sector. Gross exports amount to almost a half of GDP in the euro area, compared to little more than a tenth in the United States (Chart I-2). But here’s the key point: the European barometer that best gauges global growth is not euro area growth per se; it is euro area growth excluding inventory adjustments (Chart of the Week and Chart I-3). Chart I-2Europe Has A Very Open Economy Chart I-3Euro Area Growth Ex Inventory Adjustments Has Rebounded Sharply If euro area firms were building inventories, it would clearly boost economic output; and vice versa. However, this inventory building would not represent genuine end demand from abroad. It follows that we must strip out inventory adjustments to yield a truer gauge of external demand.1 The Reading From Our European Barometer What does euro area growth excluding inventory adjustments show? The long-term analysis confirms that global activity suffered its sharpest setbacks this millennium in 2002, 2008, 2012, and again briefly last year. But in the first quarter of this year, euro area real growth excluding inventory adjustments bounced back to a very robust 2.5 percent clip or, in nominal terms, a blistering 4.2 percent clip.2 Indeed, in nominal terms, our barometer was close to its strongest reading since 2010! These impressive numbers leave us with not a shred of doubt: after a sharp setback, global growth commenced a strong rebound at the end of last year. Global growth commenced a strong rebound at the end of last year. For those still in doubt, further compelling evidence comes from the very clear recent outperformance of the economically sensitive global sectors: industrials and financials. Through the past decade, the relative performance of these global cyclicals has closely tracked our European barometer – albeit a brief decoupling did occur in 2012 after Draghi’s “whatever it takes” speech gave all financial assets a big shot in the arm (Chart I-4). Chart I-4Global Cyclicals Are Tracking Our Growth Barometer One problem is that our barometer gives a reading just once a quarter and these readings come out after a long delay. From the mid-point of the quarter to which the GDP data refers to their release date around one month after the quarter end, there is a two and a half month delay. Begging the question, is there a more frequent and timely current activity indicator (CAI) for the euro area? The answer is yes. We have found that the ZEW economic sentiment indicator (not to be confused with the current situation indicator) does the job well in real-time (Chart I-5 and Chart I-6). Chart I-5The ZEW Economic Sentiment Indicator... Chart I-6...Is A Good Current Activity Indicator   How Should Investors Use Our Barometer? However, investors face an even more fundamental problem. The equity market is itself a real-time current activity indicator. To be more precise, the best current activity is not the equity market taken as a whole – because the aggregate equity market can move as a result of drivers other than current economic activity, most notably central bank policy. Rather, as we have just shown, the very best current activity indicator is the performance of economically sensitive sectors – such as industrials and financials – relative to the total market (Chart I-7 and Chart I-8). Chart I-7The Best Current Activity Indicator... Chart I-8...Is The Relative Performance Of Global Cyclicals This means that even if we could measure GDP growth excluding inventory adjustments in real time, it would not help investors. After all, it would be ludicrous to expect one current activity indicator consistently to lead another current activity indicator! What we really need is a future activity indicator (FAI). If we could reliably predict where our barometer’s reading would be three or six months from now we could also reliably allocate our investments ‘ahead of the move’. Still, sometimes the current reading does inform us about the future. If a barometer already reads ‘very dry’ then we know that the weather is not going to get any better in the next few months! To be clear, euro area nominal growth excluding inventories, running at a blistering 4.2 percent pace, is near a 10-year high not just on a quarter-on-quarter basis but also on a six month on six month basis. The chances that it moves significantly higher are close to nil.   We are at the tail-end of a global growth up-oscillation. We should also look at the short-term impulses that drive growth. Crucially, these emanate from the short-term changes – and not the levels – of bond yields, the oil price (inverted), and bank credit flows. These impulses are now losing momentum (Chart I-9). Chart I-9Short-Term Impulses Are Losing Momentum The Correct Investment Strategy   To sum up, all the evidence shows that we are at the tail-end of a global growth up-oscillation. Irrespective of the evolution of the trade war, our high conviction view is that our global growth barometer – euro area growth excluding inventory adjustments – is highly unlikely to accelerate much further from its blistering 4.2 percent nominal clip. Much more likely, it will show weaker readings in the second half of the year. The yen is still an excellent defensive currency. Nevertheless, in the near term, asset allocation is a tough call. This is because, very unusually, all asset classes have performed well in unison, making it hard to rotate into one that offers value (Chart I-10). Hence, from a tactical perspective, we are shorting a 30:60:10 portfolio of equities, long-dated bonds, and crude oil. So far, the position is slightly down but we recommend holding it until it either achieves a 3 percent profit or it hits a 3 percent stop-loss. Chart I-10All Asset-Classes Have Performed Well In Unison For equities versus bonds, our long DAX versus the 30-year bund is now broadly flat since inception in January. But we will hold it for a while longer until we see clearer signs that global growth has flipped into a down-oscillation.   Within bonds, our underweight German 10-year bunds versus U.S 10-year T-bonds is still appropriate given the closer proximity of the bund yield, at -0.2 percent, to the mathematical lower bound. Moreover, this relative position has been working well recently.  Within equities, overweight European equities versus China and the U.S. has also been working well. However, we will be looking for opportunities to switch to underweight Europe versus the less economically sensitive U.S. equity market within the next couple of months. Finally, our stance to the euro – long versus the dollar, short versus the yen – has also been working well. The stance remains appropriate as the yen is still an excellent defensive currency, with the big additional advantage of possessing minimal political risk. Fractal Trading System* Given the synchronized rally of all asset classes this year, the financial services sector has strongly outperformed the market. But according to its 130-day fractal dimension, this strong outperformance is approaching technical exhaustion. Accordingly, this week’s trade recommendation is to short the financial services sector versus the market. The profit target is 2 percent with a symmetrical stop-loss. (One way of executing this is to short the IYG ETF versus the MSCI All Country World Index). In other trades, we are pleased to report that short NZX 50 versus FTSE100 achieved its 2 percent profit target and is now closed, leaving three open positions. For any investment, excessive trend following and groupthink can reach a natural point of instability, at which point the established trend is highly likely to break down with or without an external catalyst. An early warning sign is the investment’s fractal dimension approaching its natural lower bound. Encouragingly, this trigger has consistently identified countertrend moves of various magnitudes across all asset classes. Chart I-11 The post-June 9, 2016 fractal trading model rules are: When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. Use the position size multiple to control risk. The position size will be smaller for more risky positions.   * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com.   Dhaval Joshi, Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 To be precise, it is the change in the change in inventories that contributes to GDP growth. For example, if the change in inventories added 0.5 percent to GDP this quarter, but 1 percent last quarter, then it will have subtracted 0.5% from growth this quarter. 2 Quarter-on-quarter growth at annualised rates. Fractal Trading System Recommendations Asset Allocation Equity Regional and Country Allocation Equity Sector Allocation Bond and Interest Rate Allocation Currency and Other Allocation Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields   Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations  

We are compelled to put the S&P tech sector on our downgrade watch list as President Trump’s hawkish trade talk and actions since May 5 warn that tech revenues (60% export exposure) and profits will likely remain under intense downward pressure. Our tech EPS model is also flashing red on the back of sinking capex and an appreciating U.S. dollar (bottom panel). We will be downgrading the tech sector to underweight via the S&P software index, the tech sector’s largest industry group on a market cap basis. A downgrade to neutral in the S&P software index would push our S&P tech sector weight to a below benchmark allocation. Thus, we are initiating a stop near the 10% relative return mark on the S&P software high-conviction overweight call since the December 3, 2018 inception. We also lift the stop to 27% from 17% relative return on the cyclical overweight we have on the S&P software index since the November 27, 2017 inception. Bottom Line: We are compelled to put the tech sector on our downgrade watch list. We will execute the S&P tech sector downgrade to underweight when the S&P software index’s stops are triggered. This would push the S&P software index to neutral from currently overweight.

As we highlighted in our most recent Weekly Report, the risk/reward tradeoff remains squarely to the downside and we are turning cyclically (3-12 month horizon) cautious on the prospects of the broad equity market. The Presidential cycle, UBER’s IPO, the S&P 500 hitting all-time highs following the initial December 2018 yield curve inversion, and two additional yield curve inversions signal that this time is no different and a recession is likely upon us in the coming 18 months. Using the NY Fed’s yield curve-derived recession probability forecast is revealing. This recession gauge has been an excellent leading indicator of S&P 500 momentum since the S&L crisis induced recession and its current message corroborates U.S. Equity Strategy’s cautious cyclical equity market view (recession gauge shown inverted, see chart). For additional details, please refer to the most recent Weekly Report.