• Three macro "policy puts" are in jeopardy of disappearing or, at the very least, being repriced.
• Fed Put: Rising inflation has made the Fed more reluctant to back off from rate hikes at the first hint of slower growth or falling asset prices.
• China Put: Worries about high debt levels, overcapacity, and pollution all mean that the bar for fresh Chinese stimulus is higher than in the past.
• Draghi Put: Bailing out Italy was a no-brainer in 2012 when the country was the victim of contagion from the Greek crisis. But now that Italy is the source of the disease, the rationale for intervention has weakened.
• These factors, along with additional risks such as mounting protectionism, warrant a more cautious 12-month stance towards global equities and other risk assets. The fact that valuations are stretched across most asset classes only adds to our concern.
• A neutral stance does not imply that we expect markets to move sideways. On the contrary, volatility is likely to increase over the balance of the year, with the next big move for global equities probably being to the downside.

Buckle Up

One of BCA's key ongoing themes is that policy and markets are on a collision course. We are starting to see this impending crash play out across the world.

Higher Inflation Is Tying The Fed's Hands

A slowdown in global growth caused the Fed to abort its tightening plans for 12 months starting in December 2015. Global growth is faltering again, but this time around the Fed is less eager to hit the pause button. In contrast to 2015, the U.S. economy has run out of spare capacity. The unemployment rate fell to a 48-year low of 3.75% in May. For the first time in the history of the Bureau of Labor Statistics' Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS), there are more job vacancies than unemployed workers (Chart 1).

Average hourly earnings surprised on the upside in May, while the Employment Cost Index for private-sector workers - the cleanest and most reliable measure of U.S. wage growth - rose at a robust 4% annualized pace in the first quarter. Labor market surveys, which generally lead wage growth by three-to-six months, are pointing to a further acceleration in wages (Chart 2).

Chart 1
There Are Now More
Vacancies Than Jobseekers

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

Chart 2
U.S. Wage Growth Is Set To Accelerate

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

The Dollar Rally Can Keep Going

Rising wages will put more income into workers' pockets, who will then spend it. Stronger demand can be partly satisfied by imports, but it will take a change in relative prices for that to happen. U.S. imports account for only 16% of GDP. Unless the prices of foreign-made goods decline in relation to the prices of domestically-produced goods, the bulk of any additional household income will be spent on goods produced in the U.S. This means that the dollar needs to strengthen.

The Fed's broad trade-weighted dollar index is up 8% since the start of February. While we are not as bullish on the dollar as we were a few months ago, we still believe that the path of least resistance for the greenback is up. Our long DXY trade recommendation has gained 12.1% inclusive of carry since we initiated it. We are raising the target price from 96 to 98.

A stronger dollar can help deflect some additional spending towards imports, but this won't be enough to fully cool the economy. Services, which generally cannot be imported, account for nearly two-thirds of GDP. Since it takes time to shift resources from goods-producing sectors to service sectors, any rising aggregate demand will boost service prices. Outside of housing, service-sector inflation is already running at 2.4%, a number that is likely to rise further over the coming year (Chart 3). This will keep the Fed on edge.

Hard Times For Emerging Markets

The combination of rising U.S. rates and a stronger dollar is bad news for emerging markets. Eighty percent of EM foreign-currency debt is denominated in dollars. Outside of China, EM dollar debt is now back to late-1990s levels both as a share of GDP and exports (Chart 4).

Chart 3
Faster Wage Growth Will Push
Up Service Inflation

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

Chart 4
EM Dollar Debt Back To Late-1990s Levels

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

The wave of EM local-currency debt issued in recent years only complicates matters. If EM central banks raise rates to defend their currencies, this could imperil economic growth and make it difficult for local-currency borrowers to pay back their loans.

Rather than hiking rates, some EM central banks may simply choose to inflate away debt. Consider the case of Brazil. Ninety percent of Brazilian sovereign debt is denominated in reais. The Brazilian government won't default on its debt per se. However, if push comes to shove, Brazil's central bank can always step in to buy government bonds, effectively monetizing the fiscal deficit.

The specter of trade wars only adds to the risks facing emerging markets. A larger U.S. budget deficit will drain national savings, leading to a bigger trade deficit. Rather than blaming his own macroeconomic policies, President Trump will blame America's trading partners. Global trade has already been flatlining for over a decade (Chart 5). Trump's trade agenda will further undermine the global trading system. Emerging markets will bear the brunt of that development.

Chart 5
Global Trade Has Crested

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

Chinese Stimulus To The Rescue?

When emerging markets last succumbed to pressure in 2015, China saved the day by stepping in with massive new stimulus. Fiscal spending and credit growth accelerated to over 15% year-over-year. The government's actions boosted demand for all sorts of industrial commodities.

Today, Chinese growth is slowing again. May data on industrial production, retail sales, and fixed asset investment all disappointed. Property prices in tier 1 cities are down year-over-year. Our leading indicator for the Li Keqiang index, a widely followed measure of economic activity, is in a clear downtrend (Chart 6).

So far, the policy response has been fairly muted. Reserve requirements have been cut and some administrative controls loosened, but the combined credit and fiscal impulse has plunged (Chart 7). Onshore and offshore corporate bond yields have increased to multi-year highs. Bank lending rates are rising, while loan approvals are dropping (Chart 8).

Chart 6
Chinese Growth Is Slowing Anew

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

Chart 7
China: Policy Response To Slowdown
Has Been Muted So Far

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

Chart 8
China: Credit Tightening

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

We have no doubt that China will stimulate again if the economy appears to be heading for a deep slowdown. However, the bar for a fresh round of stimulus is higher today than it was in the past. Elevated debt levels, excess capacity in some parts of the industrial sector, and worries about pollution all limit the extent to which the authorities can respond with the usual barrage of infrastructure spending and increased bank lending. The economy needs to feel more pain before policymakers come to its aid.

Draghi's Dilemma

The Italian economy was showing signs of weakness even before bond yields exploded higher. Domestic demand slowed to a mere 0.3% qoq in Q1. The PMIs, consumer confidence, and the Bank of Italy's Ita-Coin cyclical indicator all decelerated (Chart 9).

Italy would benefit from a more competitive cost structure, but the political will to undertake the sort of reforms Germany implemented in the late 1990s, and that Spain implemented after the Great Recession, has been sorely lacking (Chart 10). Unwilling to take tough actions to improve competitiveness, the Five Star-Lega coalition government has proposed loosening fiscal policy to support demand.

Chart 9
Italy's Economy Is Weakening... Again

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

Chart 10
Italy: More Work Needs To Be Done On
The Labor Competitiveness Front

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

Italy's shift towards populism is arriving at the same time that the ECB is looking to wind down its asset purchase program. This means that a key buyer of Italian debt is stepping back just when it may be needed the most.

Getting the ECB to bail out Italy will not be as straightforward this time around. Recall that Mario Draghi and Jean-Claude Trichet penned a letter to the Italian government in 2011 outlining a series of reforms they wanted to see enacted as a condition of ongoing ECB support. The contents of the letter were so explosive that they precipitated the resignation of then-PM Silvio Berlusconi when they were leaked to the public. One of the reforms that Mario Draghi demanded - and the subsequent government led by Mario Monti ultimately undertook - was the extension of the retirement age. Italy's current government has explicitly promised to reverse that decision much to the consternation of the ECB and the European Commission.

It was one thing for Mario Draghi to promise to do "whatever it takes" to protect Italy when the country was the victim of contagion from the Greek crisis. But now that Italy is the source of the disease, the rationale for intervention has weakened.

Investment Conclusions

The outlook for global risk assets is likely to be more challenging over the coming months. With that in mind, we are downgrading our 12-month recommendation on global equities and credit from overweight to neutral.

A neutral stance does not imply that we expect markets to move sideways. On the contrary, volatility is likely to increase again over the balance of the year, with the next big move for global equities probably being to the downside.

Although Treasurys could rally in the near term, higher U.S. inflation will push bond yields up over a 12-month horizon. Given that yields are positively correlated across international bond markets, rising U.S. yields will put upward pressure on yields in the rest of the world. As such, we recommend shifting equity allocations towards cash rather than long-duration bonds. We would also reduce credit exposure. Within the commodity complex, the backdrop for crude remains more favorable than for economically-sensitive metals.

Investors should underweight EM equities, credit, and currencies relative to their developed market peers. The Fed needs to tighten U.S. financial conditions to prevent the economy from overheating. Chart 11 shows that EM equities almost always fall when that is happening.

Chart 11
Tighter U.S. Financial Conditions Do Not Bode Well For EM Stocks

Fullscreen

Interactive Chart

A stronger dollar will hurt the profits of U.S. multinationals. That said, the sector composition of the U.S. stock market is a bit more defensive than it is elsewhere. On balance, we no longer have a strong view that euro area and Japanese equities will outperform the U.S. in local-currency terms, and hence we are closing our trade recommendation to this effect for a loss of 5.4%.

If macro developments evolve as we expect, we will shift to an outright bearish stance on risk assets later this year or in early 2019 in anticipation of a global recession in 2020. That said, we would consider moving our 12-month recommendation temporarily back to overweight if global equities were to sell off by more than 15% over the next few months or the policy environment becomes markedly more market friendly. But at current prices, the risk-reward trade-off no longer justifies a high degree of bullishness.

Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist
Global Investment Strategy
peterb@bcaresearch.com