Economy

Highlights Economy – The inevitable deceleration has arrived, but the economy is still growing far faster than trend and will continue to do so through 2022: A wide range of data series shows that US growth has likely peaked but deceleration from way, way above the long-run potential growth rate to way above it is not cause for concern. Markets – Growth worries pulled equities lower for one day last week before investors rushed back in to buy the dip: Stock volatility made a brief return at the beginning of the week before the S&P 500 snapped back to resume taking aim at new highs. Fundamentals supported the reversal as earnings are on a path to blow away expectations for the fifth consecutive quarter. Strategy – Investors should stay the course by overweighting risk assets in multi-asset portfolios: As long as the spread of the Delta variant does not lead to punishing new restrictions, the economy will continue to grow at an extremely rapid clip and the strong-growth, easy-policy backdrop will continue to support equities and credit. Feature The S&P 500 had its worst one-day performance since early April last Monday, shedding 1.6% and sending the VIX above 20 for only the ninth time since it broke into the teens in March (Chart 1). We do not read too much into day-to-day moves in financial markets, but the tumult seems to have resulted from equities’ delayed reaction to investor unease about decelerating growth. It makes intuitive sense that forward-looking markets often assign greater importance to the direction of a key data series than its level. In Wayne Gretzky terms, the level is largely an indication of where conditions have been, while the direction offers more insight into where they are headed. Direction does not always trump level, however, and investors should bear in mind that the current pace of growth is extremely elevated. The Bloomberg consensus of economists is calling for 6.6% real GDP growth in 2021 and 4.2% in 2022. Those figures project a tapering, especially from quarter to quarter (Table 1), but they still represent red-hot growth for an economy with an annual long-term potential growth rate in the range of 1.75% to 2%. They also reflect a gentle tapering, with growth expected to remain comfortably above trend through 2023. Chart 1Lower Highs, Lower Lows Table 12% Is So Last Decade   We are far less concerned about deceleration from high single-digit growth than we would be about sub-trend readings. Falling below trend was the persistent fear in the aftermath of the Global Financial Crisis when economists and investors alike worried that the economy would not be able to stay above stall speed. Growth likely peaked in the second quarter, and supply bottlenecks and wavering confidence in the face of the spread of COVID-19’s Delta variant have brought the economic surprise index back down to earth (Chart 2). To take one example of a series that recently generated a negative surprise, however, we think the month-over-month decline in the ISM non-manufacturing index has less to say about the economy than its fourth straight reading in the 60s, a level it had reached just eight times in the previous 23 years (Chart 3). Chart 2The Economy Is Cooling Off, ... Chart 3... But It's Still Quite Hot   Is The Bond Market Trying To Warn Us? Chart 4Inflation Fears Have Ebbed We did not foresee the steep decline in 10-year Treasury yields that has played out since mid-June and it has led us to ask if underlying economic conditions are weaker than we perceived. Based on the available data, we do not think so. It seems like the rally in long-dated Treasuries can be attributed to an unwinding of inflation fears, concerns about slowing growth and the reversal of a Treasury sell-off that had gone too far too fast. We remain constructive on the economy, assuming vaccine-resistant COVID-19 variants do not emerge, and we still expect the 10-year Treasury yield will end the year north of 1.75%. Inflation fears have cooled considerably, with 10-year TIPS breakevens having retreated to the lower end of the Fed’s desired range, while the 5-year-on-5-year series (the 5-year breakeven five years from now) has dropped out of it (Chart 4). Though we do not expect inflation to become a problem for the economy for another couple of years, we do expect that it will re-emerge as a worry for investors once the primary impediments to labor supply disappear in September, especially if the year-over-year CPI readings continue to come in way above 2%. Our Global Fixed Income Strategy service stresses that investors should watch the mix of components driving inflation. If accelerated wage gains appear to be on their way to becoming entrenched or the rate of growth in rents inflects higher, the transitory inflation narrative might begin to weaken, leading the Fed to dial back accommodation sooner and/or faster than the bond market currently anticipates. Though we are not concerned about a widely anticipated peak in the rate of growth, a revival of COVID-19 after it seemed to have been defanged would throw a spanner into the works. A surge in new infections, even in countries like the UK and the US which have been ahead of the pack in terms of vaccinations, indicates that the Delta variant is especially transmissible. The spike in infections here (Chart 5, top panel) and abroad has apparently dampened economic optimism, helping to push Treasury and other developed world sovereign yields lower. The good news, however, is that the Delta variant does not appear to be particularly lethal (Chart 5, bottom panel) and the leading Pfizer and Moderna vaccines have acquitted themselves well against it. We are watching virus developments carefully, but we do not yet see evidence that suggests new rounds of activity restrictions are in store and we therefore expect virus variants will ultimately have little economic impact. Chart 5The Delta Variant Is More Contagious But Less Serious Aside from the pendulum shifting from too-hot concerns to too-cold concerns, much of the Treasury rally appears to have been a reaction to the speed and extent of the backup in yields. Our Global Fixed Income Strategy colleagues point out that Treasuries became quite oversold in the first quarter. The 10-year yield got as far above its 200-day moving average as it did during the taper tantrum in 2013 (Chart 6, second panel), with both real-money investors (Chart 6, third panel) and speculators (Chart 6, bottom panel) shunning duration. Speculators have trimmed their short positions but the real money has yet to capitulate, suggesting that yields may be able to hang around current levels or edge even lower before returning to a level that better aligns with underlying economic strength, robust inflation readings and the future path of the fed funds rate. Earnings Continue To Crush Expectations Every equity investor is familiar with the earnings season dance. About halfway through the quarter, companies begin to guide analysts’ expectations lower. Analysts duly adjust their estimates down a few percentage points over the ensuing ten weeks before companies begin to report. Company earnings then come in about the level initially expected midway through the quarter and – voila! – three-quarters of S&P 500 constituents beat expectations and the overall index beats by around 3%. The typical pattern looks very much like it did across 2019 (Chart 7, top panel). Chart 6The Treasury Selloff Was Overdone Chart 7Not The Same Old Song-And-Dance Beginning with the second quarter of 2020, when the most stringent lockdown measures meant to stymie the spread of the pandemic were fully in force, the picture has been very different. S&P 500 constituents have barely guided down heading into earnings before proceeding to demolish estimates by close to 20% (Chart 7, bottom panel). The established practice of companies guiding analysts to position the bar at a height they think they can comfortably clear produced a narrow and consistent dispersion of earnings beats across the 32 quarters from 2012 to 2019, with a mean of 3.7% and a standard deviation of 1.4%, all clustered within a narrow 1-to-6% range (Chart 8). Chart 8Blasting Out Of The Old Range Something else entirely has unfolded over the last four quarters, when earnings beat by an average of 19.5%, more than three times above the previous eight years’ peak and five times their mean. Even with the pandemic numbers pushing the mean higher and quadrupling the standard deviation, the four quarters’ beats have been 3.2, 2.2, 1.8 and 3.1 standard deviations above the mean, respectively. With a quarter of the S&P 500 having reported results through last Friday, the second quarter appears to be on a path to extend the blowout streak to five quarters (Chart 7, bottom panel). Investors, conditioned to the S&P 500 unfailingly beating earnings, don’t seem to be cognizant of how unusual the magnitude of the beats has been. Gigantic year-over-year earnings gains, which will peak this quarter, also seem to have obscured how low the bar has been set on a quarter-over-quarter basis. As our US Equity Sector Strategy colleagues have highlighted, year-over-year comparisons that span pandemic-distorted quarters are of limited use. To get a more relevant read, they compare 2021 results to 2019 results. (For the full year, 2021 earnings per share for the S&P 500 are projected to come in 18.2% above 2019, for 8.7% annualized growth). Table 2A Remarkably Low Bar We have been tracking quarter-over-quarter changes and were surprised to see that forward four-quarter earnings were expected to decline 2% from their first-quarter run rate ($196.52, annualized) when the reporting season began, with the second quarter declining by 8% (Table 2). Given manifold signs of economic revival, an 8% sequential contraction strikes us as highly improbable. With real GDP expected to grow by 9% on an annualized quarter-over-quarter basis, or better than 12% in nominal terms, 2% growth seems reasonable, so we see $50 as a more realistic and easily attainable ballpark estimate, which would have earnings beat by 11%. Regardless of where earnings end up, the bar has been set extremely low – the analyst consensus has not forecasted contraction in any forward four-quarter period since 1980 (Chart 9). Our takeaway is that earnings estimates have scope to move higher, taking the S&P 500 with them if multiples don’t contract, or giving valuations a chance to cool if the index moves sideways or turns lower. Chart 9An Odd Time To Call For The First Contraction In 40 Years Investment Implications Our investment strategy recommendations follow from our ongoing analysis of the business cycle, the credit cycle, the monetary policy cycle and (when applicable) the sentiment cycle. Although the consistency of our risk-friendly asset allocation recommendations may have begun to seem boring, nothing in our cycle analysis calls for a change in our views. There is no reason to expect a recession when households are sitting on $2.4 trillion of excess savings, household net worth has advanced at the fastest rate on record, retail inventories have been depleted to record-low levels and payrolls are set to continue expanding at a furious rate over the next year-plus. The credit cycle is set to continue its charmed path, as rising incomes, cash-stuffed households and businesses, and zero interest rate policy suppress borrower distress and keep lenders eager to make loans. Monetary policy may get incrementally less accommodative as asset purchases shrink, but a rate hike is more than a year away. One can make a reasonable argument that the Fed will be unable to lift the fed funds rate to a truly restrictive level in the next policy tightening cycle once it begins to hike rates, even if it’s not our base case. We are certain that monetary policy settings will remain extremely easy well beyond our one-year investment timeframe. Sentiment is generally buoyant, but it is not at extreme levels that would warrant factoring it into our strategy as a contrarian indicator. We will therefore stay the course, while monitoring pandemic developments and keeping a sharp lookout for signs that we’re wrong about inflation or growth. If we are correct that the threat from COVID-19 will remain contained, we expect that earnings revisions will ensure that the next catalyst for equities will be a positive one. The consensus expectation for a decline in the earnings run rate is simply incompatible with observed conditions on the ground. Doug Peta, CFA Chief US Investment Strategist dougp@bcaresearch.com

Dear Client, I will be on vacation next week. In lieu of our regular report, we will be sending you a Special Report written by my colleague Arthur Budaghyan, BCA Research’s Chief Emerging Markets Strategist. Arthur’s report will discuss the long-term outlook for industrial companies. He argues that the US is entering an industrial boom prompted by infrastructure stimulus and onshoring. This will benefit US industrial equities, or ones selling into the US on a multi-year horizon. I trust you will find it insightful. Best regards, Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Highlights Investors keep asking whether the recent increase in US inflation is transitory. However, this is the wrong question to ask. Annualized core CPI inflation reached 10.6% in the second quarter. There is little doubt that inflation will fall from such elevated levels. The key question that investors should be asking is whether inflation will decline more or less than what the market is discounting. The widely watched 5-year/5-year forward TIPS inflation breakeven rate has sunk to 2.11%, below the Fed’s “comfort zone” of 2.3%-to-2.5%. Thus, the market already expects a substantial decline in inflation. Our sense is that US inflation will come down fast enough to allow the Fed to maintain a highly dovish policy stance, but not as fast as market expectations currently imply. As inflation surprises on the upside, long-term bond yields will rise. This should revive bank shares and other reflationary plays. The combination of a weaker US dollar, faster sequential Chinese growth, increased vaccine supplies, and favorable valuations should all help EM stocks later this year. Go long the Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (VWO) versus the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO). The Right Question About Inflation Chart 1After A Spike In Q2, US Inflation Will Decelerate Investors remain focused on whether the recent bout of US inflation is transitory. However, this is not the correct question to be asking at the present juncture. The US core CPI rose by 10.6% at an annualized pace in Q2 relative to the first quarter (Chart 1). It is almost inevitable that inflation will come down from such high levels. The key question investors should be asking is whether inflation will decline more or less than what is already baked into market expectations. As Chart 2 shows, investors expect US inflation to come down rapidly over the next two years. The 5-year/5-year forward TIPS breakeven inflation rate – a good proxy for where investors expect inflation to be over the long haul – has sunk to 2.11% (Chart 3). This is below the Fed’s comfort zone of 2.3%-to-2.5%.1 Globally, long-term inflation expectations remain subdued (Chart 4). Chart 2Inflation Is Expected To Moderate Over The Coming Years Chart 3Inflation Expectations Have Fallen Back Below The Fed's Target Zone Chart 4Long-Term Inflation Expectations Remain Subdued       Inflation Will Fall, But… Our sense is that US inflation will come down fast enough to allow the Fed to maintain a highly dovish policy stance, but not as fast as market expectations currently imply. Broad-based inflationary pressures would make the Fed nervous. However, that is not what we are seeing. Wages have accelerated markedly in only a few relatively low-skilled sectors such as retail trade and leisure and hospitality (Chart 5). For the economy as a whole, wage growth is broadly stable (Chart 6). The expiration of extended unemployment benefits, the reopening of schools, and increased immigration should also boost labor supply in the fall. Chart 5Faster Wage Growth Has Been Confined To A Few Low-Wage Sectors Chart 6No Sign Of A Wage-Price Spiral... For Now     On the price front, more than two-thirds of the increase in the core CPI in June stemmed from pandemic-afflicted sectors (Chart 7). The price of the median item within the CPI index rose by just 2.2% year-over-year in June, somewhat below the pre-pandemic pace of inflation (Chart 8). Chart 7Most Of The Recent Increase In Inflation Is Pandemic-Related Chart 8The Median Price In The CPI Basket Is Up Only 2.2% … Not As Fast As The Market Expects While inflation will fall as pandemic effects recede, investors are overestimating how fast this will happen. US growth has undoubtedly peaked, but at a very high level. Economists surveyed by Bloomberg estimate that US GDP rose by 9.0% in Q2. Growth is expected to slow to 7.1% in Q3 and 5.1% in Q4, while averaging 4.2% in 2022 (Table 1). By any standard, these are very strong, above-trend growth rates. Table 1Growth Is Peaking, But At A Very High Level Chart 9Nearly 90% Of US Seniors Have Had At Least One Shot The current Delta-variant wave is unlikely to slow US growth by very much. Although vaccination rates among younger people are at middling levels, they are quite high for the elderly who are most at risk of serious illness. Close to 89% of Americans above the age of 65 have received at least one shot, and nearly 80% are fully vaccinated (Chart 9). The 65+ age group accounts for four-fifths of all Covid deaths in the United States. Widespread vaccination coverage for older Americans will take pressure off the hospital system, allowing the economy to remain open. Fiscal Support In The US And Abroad As we noted last week, Senate Democrats are likely to use the reconciliation process to both raise the debt ceiling and pass President Biden’s $3.5 trillion American Jobs and Families Plan. They are also likely to move forward on Biden’s proposed $600 billion in infrastructure spending, with or without Republican support. Meanwhile, much of the fiscal stimulus that has already been undertaken has yet to make its way through to the economy. US households are sitting on about $2.5 trillion in excess savings, about half of which stems from increased government transfers (Chart 10). Chart 10A Lot Of Excess Savings Chart 11Inventories Are At Low Levels   Satiating that demand has not been easy for many companies. Retail sector inventories are at record lows (Chart 11). The number of homes that have been authorized for construction but where building has yet to begin has increased by 62% since the start of the pandemic (Chart 12). By limiting production, supply-chain bottlenecks will push some spending towards the future. This will keep growth from decelerating more than it otherwise would. Outside the US, fiscal policy will remain supportive. All 27 EU countries ratified the €750 billion Next Generation fund on May 28th. The allocations from the fund for southern European countries are relatively large (Chart 13). Most of the money will be spent on public investment projects with high fiscal multipliers. Chart 12Growing Backlog Of New Home Construction Projects Chart 13EU Fiscal Policy: Allocations To Southern European Countries Are Relatively Large Chart 14Economic Growth In China Was Slow In H1 The Japanese government is contemplating sending stimulus checks to low-income citizens in advance of the general election due by October 22nd. It is an understandable move. Covid cases are rising again. As a result, the authorities have declared a state of emergency in Tokyo and barred spectators from attending the Olympic games in and around the city. Fortunately, the Japanese vaccination campaign has accelerated after a slow start. A third of the population has now received at least one shot. The government intends to vaccinate all eligible people by November.  Looking at quarter-over-quarter growth rates, Chinese growth averaged just 3.8% on an annualized basis in the first half of 2021 (Chart 14). Growth should pick up in the second half of the year thanks in part to increased fiscal spending. As of June, local governments had used only 28% of their annual bond issuance quotas, compared with 61% over the same period last year and 65% in 2019. Most of the proceeds from local government bond sales will likely flow into infrastructure projects.   Resumption Of The Dollar Bear Market Will Keep Inflation From Falling Too Far As a countercyclical currency, the US dollar usually weakens when global growth is strong (Chart 15). Short-term real interest rate differentials have moved sharply against the dollar, a trend that is unlikely to change anytime soon given the Fed’s dovish bias (Chart 16). While inflation in the US is not as sensitive to currency fluctuations as in most other countries, a weaker dollar will still lift tradeable goods prices (Chart 17). Chart 15The Dollar Is A Countercyclical Currency Chart 16Rate Differentials Are A Headwind For The Dollar Chart 17The Dollar And Inflation Structural Forces Turning More Inflationary Not only are cyclical forces likely to turn out to be less disinflationary than investors believe, but many of the structural factors that have suppressed inflation over the past 40 years are reversing direction: Chart 18Globalization Plateaued More Than A Decade Ago Globalization is in retreat: The ratio of global trade-to-manufacturing output has been flat for over a decade (Chart 18). Looking out, the ratio could even decline as more companies shift production back home in order to gain greater control over supply chains of essential goods. Baby boomers are leaving the labor force en masse. As a group, baby boomers hold more than half of US household wealth (Chart 19). They will continue to run down their wealth once they retire. However, since they will no longer be working, they will no longer contribute to national output. Continued spending against a backdrop of diminished production could be inflationary. Despite a pandemic-induced bounce, underlying productivity growth remains anemic (Chart 20). Slow productivity growth could cause aggregate supply to fall short of aggregate demand. Social stability is in peril, as exemplified by the recent dramatic increase in the US homicide rate. In the past, social instability and higher inflation have gone hand in hand (Chart 21). Perhaps most importantly, policymakers are deliberately aiming to run the economy hot. A tight labor market will eventually lift wage growth to a greater degree than what we have seen so far (Chart 22). Not only could higher wage growth push up inflation through the usual “cost-push” channel, but by boosting labor’s share of income, a tight labor market could spur aggregate demand. Chart 19Baby Boomers Have Accumulated A Lot Of Wealth Chart 20Trend Productivity Growth Has Been Disappointing Chart 21Historically, Social Unrest And Higher Inflation Move In Lock-Step     Chart 22A Tight Labor Market Eventually Bolsters Wages Investment Implications Chart 23Positive Earnings Revisions Are At High Levels The path to higher rates is lined with lower rates. The longer central banks keep interest rates below their neutral level, the more economies will overheat, and the more rates will eventually need to rise to bring inflation back down. For now, we are still in the warm-up phase to higher inflation. With long-term inflation expectations below target, central banks will be able to maintain accommodative monetary policies. This is good news for stocks, at least in the short-to-medium term. The recent wobble in equity markets has occurred despite a strong second quarter earnings season. According to the latest available data from I/B/E/S, 90% of S&P 500 companies have reported earnings above analyst expectations. Earnings have surprised on the upside by an average of 19.2%, compared to a historical average of 3.9%. Positive earnings revisions are at record high levels (Chart 23). Full year 2021 S&P 500 EPS estimates have risen 16% since the start of the year. Analysts have also raised their estimates for 2022 and 2023 (Chart 24). We continue to recommend that asset allocators favor stocks over bonds over a 12-month horizon.   Chart 24Analysts Have Been Revising Up Earnings Estimates This Year Chart 25The Gains Of Recent Winners Have Not Been Fully Mirrored In Relative Earnings Growth Chart 26Bank Shares Thrive In A Rising Yield Environment Tech stocks have outperformed the broader market over the past seven weeks. However, unlike during the pandemic, 12-month forward EPS estimates for tech have not risen in relation to other sectors (Chart 25). As long-term bond yields move back up, tech shares will underperform. In contrast, banks will benefit from higher yields (Chart 26).     Along the same lines, US stocks have outpaced other stock markets by more than one would have expected based on relative EPS trends. Notably, EM earnings have moved sideways versus the US since mid-2019. Yet, US stocks have outperformed EM by 17% over this period. Today, the forward P/E ratio for EM stands at 13.8, compared to 22.1 for the US (Chart 27). The combination of a weaker US dollar, faster sequential Chinese growth, increased vaccine supplies, and favorable valuations should all help EM stocks later this year. Go long the Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (VWO) versus the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO).   Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist pberezin@bcaresearch.com Chart 27Wide Valuation Gap Between US And Non-US Markets Footnotes 1 The Federal Reserve targets an average inflation rate of 2% for the personal consumption expenditures (PCE) index. The TIPS breakeven is based on the CPI index. Due to compositional differences between the two indices, CPI inflation has historically averaged 30-to-50 basis points higher than PCE inflation. This is why the Fed effectively targets a CPI inflation rate of about 2.3%-to-2.5%. Global Investment Strategy View Matrix Special Trade Recommendations Current MacroQuant Model Scores