Technology

In this Monday’s Weekly Report we initiated a new long/short trade idea that will generate alpha regardless of the pair trade war outcome: long industrials/short tech. If the U.S. and China manage to iron out their differences and strike a deal, industrials should benefit from a greater catch-up phase because they have been depressed over the past two years, while tech stocks are near relative all-time highs. In contrast, a “no deal” scenario, should also re-concentrate investors’ minds and lead to relative selling in tech stocks versus their already beaten-down deep cyclical peers: industrials. Three key macro forces will be driving the rebound in the price ratio. First, were the deal to get struck, growth expectations will pick up pushing rates higher, which are a boon for industrials and a bane for high P/E tech stocks (top panel). Second, we expect the ISM manufacturing survey to outshine the San Francisco Fed’s Tech Pulse Index (middle panel). Finally, relative capital expenditure outlays should also veer in favor of industrials as previously mothballed infrastructure projects will come out of hibernation (bottom panel). On the other hand, should a “no-deal” scenario occur, we doubt that these three macro forces that we identified would sink further (please see the next Insight). ​​​​​​​

Highlights Portfolio Strategy The trade-weighted U.S. dollar’s appreciation along with the still souring manufacturing data are weighing on SPX profit growth, at a time when heightened geopolitical uncertainty and a looming reversal in financial conditions has the potential to wreak havoc on stock prices. Stay cautious on the prospects of the broad equity market on a cyclical 9-12 month time horizon. Firming operating metrics, the resilient U.S. dollar, compelling valuations and depressed technicals, all signal that there is an exploitable tactical trading opportunity in a long S&P industrials/short S&P tech pair trade, irrespective of the trade war outcome. A tentative tick up in EM and China data along with improving relative operating metrics signal that the time is ripe to initiate a long machinery/short semis pair trade. Recent Changes Initiate a long S&P Industrials/short S&P Tech pair trade on a tactical three-to-six month time horizon, today. Initiate a long S&P Machinery/short S&P Semiconductors pair trade on a tactical three-to-six month time horizon, today. Feature The S&P 500 oscillated violently again last week, as the barrage of declining economic data, heightened trade war-related volatility and political upheaval dominated the news flow. While the Fed remains the backstop of last resort, we doubt additional interest rate cuts, which are already aggressively priced in the bond market, will boost lending and entice CEOs to invest in capital expenditure projects. Investors have to stay patient and disciplined, let this economic slowdown play out and allow for the natural healing of the economy. As a reminder, the ISM manufacturing index has been decelerating for twelve months and only been below the boom bust line for two. If history is an accurate guide, an additional three-to-six months of manufacturing pain are in store before a definitive bottom is in place (bottom panel, Chart 1). Such a macro backdrop, still warrants caution on the prospects of the broad equity market. Chart 1Allow Time For Economic Healing Beginning in August, a number of BCA publications became a tad more cautious on risk assets. Following our October editorial view meeting last week, this cautiousness was cemented with a tactical downgrade of global equities to neutral from previously overweight in the BCA House View matrix. While this marks a clear shift toward this publication’s less sanguine view of the U.S. equity market adopted during the summer, BCA's cyclical 12-month House View remains overweight global equities. Worryingly, the majority of the indicators we track continue to emit distress signals and warn that the SPX has further downside (Chart 2), especially absent profit growth. Importantly, we first correctly posited last May that the back half of the year global growth reacceleration was in jeopardy and would go on hiatus courtesy of rising policy uncertainty.1 Such a backdrop would boost the U.S. dollar and simultaneously take a bite out of SPX EPS.2 Chart 2Soft Data Red Flag Last week we highlighted that the U.S. dollar is the most important indicator to monitor given its global deflationary/reflationary properties. Were the greenback to maintain its year-to-date gains, it will continue to dent SPX profitability via P&L translation loss effects and likely sustain the profit recession into early 2020 (trade-weighted U.S. dollar shown inverted, bottom panel, Chart 3). Chart 3Greenback Weighing On Profits U.S. Equity Strategy’s S&P 500 four-factor macro EPS growth model remains downbeat (middle panel, Chart 4). Were we to isolate the U.S. dollar as a single variable and re-run the regression it is clear that additional greenback appreciation will further weigh on SPX profit growth (bottom panel, Chart 4). Meanwhile, the easing in financial conditions and drubbing of the 10-year Treasury yield since the Christmas Eve lows is already reflected in the 23% jump in the forward PE multiple, which explains over 90% of the SPX’s rise since the Dec 24, 2018 trough (top & middle panels, Chart 5). In other words, for multiples to expand anew, financial conditions would have to further ease, which in our view is a tall order (bottom panel, Chart 5). Chart 4EPS Model Warrants Caution Chart 5Financial Conditions Are The Forward P/E This week we are initiating two related pair trades to exploit the mispricing of the trade war within the deep cyclical sector universe.  Thus, we would lean against the narrative that easy financial conditions are not fully reflected into stocks. In contrast, our worry is that junk spreads are on the verge of a breakout and such a backdrop would tighten financial conditions and aggravate an SPX drawdown (junk OAS shown inverted, Chart 6). Adding it all up, the trade-weighted U.S. dollar’s appreciation along with the still souring manufacturing data are weighing on SPX profit growth, at a time when heightened geopolitical uncertainty and a looming reversal in financial conditions has the potential to wreak havoc on stock prices. Stay cautious on the prospects of the broad equity market on a cyclical 9-12 month time horizon. This week we are initiating two related pair trades to exploit the mispricing of the trade war within the deep cyclical sector universe. Chart 6Watch Junk Spreads Initiate A Long Industrials/Short Tech Pair Trade… Ever since the Sino-American trade war started in March 2018, the market has punished industrials, but tech has escaped unscathed. While the global growth soft patch preceded the U.S./China trade spat, courtesy of the Fed’s tightening cycle and Chinese policymakers’ slamming on the brakes, the trade war has served as a catalyst to aggressively shed deep cyclical equities except for tech stocks (Chart 7). We think this misalignment presents a playable opportunity to generate alpha by going long industrials/short tech, irrespective of the trade war’s outcome. In other words, this market neutral trade will be in the black either because the trade spat gets resolved or because there will effectively be no “real” deal including intellectual property and the tech sector. If the two sides manage to iron out their differences and strike a deal, industrials stocks should benefit from a greater catch-up phase because they have been depressed over the past two years, while tech stocks are near relative all-time highs. In contrast, a “no deal” scenario, should also re-concentrate investors’ minds and lead to a relative selling in tech stocks versus their already beaten-down deep cyclical peers: industrials. Chart 7Bifurcated Deep Cyclicals Market Chart 8Lots Of Bad Trade War News Reflected In Prices Chart 8 shows the drubbing in relative share prices as three key macro drivers have felt the trade war’s wrath. In more detail, were a deal to get struck, growth expectations will reverse course and a bond market sell-off will almost immediately reflect such an improvement in the global macro backdrop. Rising interest rates on the back of a reflationary/inflationary impulse are a boon for industrials and a bane for high growth tech stocks (top panel, Chart 8). Similarly, the middle panel of Chart 8 highlights that the ISM manufacturing survey should climb above the boom/bust line and outshine the San Francisco Fed’s Tech Pulse Index (that comprises “coincident indicators of activity in the U.S. information technology sector”3) on news of a successful deal. Finally, relative capital expenditure outlays should also veer in favor of industrials as previously mothballed infrastructure projects will come out of hibernation (bottom panel, Chart 8). In contrast, tech capex has been resilient of late with analytics, security and cloud computing being the most defensive capex corner, leaving little room for additional relative capex gains. Taking the opposite side i.e. a “no deal”, we doubt the metrics we depict in Chart 8 would sink that much further. If anything we believe that there is an element of exhaustion and relative share prices would jump on news of a breakdown in trade talks as tech sector fire sales would trump the sell-off in already depressed industrials. Meanwhile, the U.S. dollar and relative share prices have been steeply diverging recently and this gap will likely narrow via a catch-up phase in the latter (top & middle panels, Chart 9). According to Factset’s latest data the S&P industrials sector garners 37% of its sales from abroad, whereas the S&P information technology sector’s foreign exposure stands at 57% of total revenues.4 Therefore, given this 20% delta, a rising greenback should be beneficial to the more domestically geared industrials stocks (bottom panel, Chart 9). On the operating front, industrials also have the upper hand. The relative wage bill is sinking like a stone (shown inverted, middle panel, Chart 10) at a time when relative selling price inflation is holding its own (top panel, Chart 10). The upshot is that a relative profit margin jump is in store in the coming months which should boost the relative share price ratio (bottom panel, Chart 10). Chart 9Unsustainable Divergence Chart 10Industrials Have The Upper Hand U.S. Equity Strategy’s proprietary relative Cyclical Macro Indicators and relative profit growth models capture all these drivers and both signal that an industrials versus tech earnings-led outperformance phase looms into year end (Chart 11). Chart 12 shows that the relative earnings breadth and relative net earnings revisions are both deep in negative territory. In terms of technicals, the relative percentage of groups trading with a positive 52-week rate of change has hit the lowest level in the past two decades (second panel, Chart 12) and our composite relative technical indicator is roughly one standard deviation below the historical mean (bottom panel, Chart 11). Chart 11Profit Models And...  Chart 12...Washed Out Breadth Say Buy Industrials At The Expense Of Tech Finally, relative valuations are also bombed out. Our relative valuation indicator has been in a six-year uninterrupted drop, falling from two standard deviations above the mean to one standard deviation below the mean (fourth panel, Chart 11). Such entrenched bearishness in relative value is unwarranted. Bottom Line:  Firming operating metrics, the resilient U.S. dollar, compelling valuations and depressed technicals, all signal that there is an exploitable tactical trading opportunity in a long S&P industrials/short S&P tech pair trade, irrespective of the trade war outcome. …And A Long Machinery/Short Semis Pair Trade A more speculative and higher octane vehicle to explore this trade war-related mispricing is via a long S&P machinery/short S&P semiconductors pair trade. Most of the drivers mentioned above also hold true in this subsector market-neutral trade. However, in this section we will drill deeper in the China/EM drivers. The Emerging Asia leading economic indicator (EALEI) has plummeted to levels last hit around the 1998 LTCM bailout (top panel, Chart 13). While more pain is likely in the coming months as global trade has ground to a halt, we doubt the carnage in the EALEI can continue indefinitely. In fact, a tentative trough in the Emerging Markets (EM) manufacturing PMI heralds a brighter outlook for relative share prices (bottom panel, Chart 13). Chart 13Same Trade War Theme, Different Vehicles To Play It Chart 14China...  Encouragingly, China’s fiscal and credit impulse also signals that a bottom in relative share prices is likely already in place. If this leading indicator proves accurate in the coming months, then relative share prices can spike 20% near the late-2018 highs (Chart 14).   Chinese money supply growth is showing some signs of life and capital committed to infrastructure spending is coming out of hibernation. Goldman Sachs’ China current activity indicator is on a similar upward trajectory, underscoring that the path of least resistance is higher for relative share prices (Chart 15). Chart 15...Holds The Key Chart 16Firming Final Demand... On the operating front, relative new orders and relative shipment growth have both ticked higher (top & middle panels, Chart 16). Importantly, our relative demand proxy suggests that the relative end-demand backdrop is also firming. Using Caterpillar’s global sales to dealers data compared with global chip sales reveals that a wide gap has formed between relative share prices and our relative demand gauge (bottom panel, Chart 16). If our thesis pans out in the upcoming three-to-six months then machinery will trounce semis. Finally, relative pricing power corroborates that machinery demand has the upper hand versus semiconductor final demand. The Commodity Research Bureau’s raw industrials index is climbing relative to Asian DRAM prices. The upshot is that the compellingly valued relative share price ratio will gain steam in the months ahead (Chart 17). In sum, a tentative up-tick in EM and China data along with improving relative operating metrics signal that the time is ripe to initiate a long machinery/short semis pair trade. Bottom Line: Initiate a long S&P machinery/short S&P semiconductors pair trade today. The ticker symbols for the stocks in the S&P machinery and S&P semis indexes are: BLBG – S5MACH – CAT, DE, ITW, IR, CMI, PCAR, PH, SWK, FTV, DOV, XYL, IEX, WAB, SNA, PNR, FLS, and BLBG – S5SECO – INTC, TXN, NVDA, AVGO, QCOM, MU, ADI, AMD, XLNX, QRVO, MCHP, MXIM, SWKS, respectively. Chart 17...Is A Boon To Relative Pricing Power Key Risk To Monitor One important risk to both of our newly recommended market-neutral trades is China. We recently touched base with our ex-Chief Geopolitical Strategist and currently Chief Strategist at the Clocktower Group, Marko Papic. He warned us that all bets would be off because: “I think we will look back at the recession of 2020 and it will be known as the “China recession”. Basically, China just decided to stop playing, pick up its toys, and go home”. If Marko’s wise words were to ring true, then such a Chinese policy shift will truly be a game changer with negative global economic growth implications. With regard to our pair trades, they would both be offside.   Anastasios Avgeriou, U.S. Equity Strategist anastasios@bcaresearch.com   Footnotes 1      Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, “Consolidation” dated May 21, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 2      Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, “On Edge” dated May 13, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 3      https://www.frbsf.org/economic-research/indicators-data/tech-pulse/ 4      https://www.factset.com/hubfs/Resources%20Section/Research%20Desk/Earnings%20Insight/EarningsInsight_100419A.pdf Current Recommendations Current Trades Size And Style Views Stay neutral cyclicals over defensives   (downgrade alert) Favor value over growth Favor large over small caps (Stop 10%)

オーバーウェイト (発足以来の相対リターンが27%に達した場合にサイクリカルなトレーリング・ストップを維持) 最新のISMサービス報告は、米国製造業セクターの先行性と極めて高い景気感応度を踏まえて当社が予想していた通り、姉妹版であるISM製造業調査に続いて下落しました。債券市場の反射的な反応は、FRBが事態を救い景気後退を回避してくれるという期待から、10月30日の会合での利下げはほぼ確実、さらに12月11日の会合で追加利下げがある確率を54%とするものでした。その結果、株式は反発し、金利変動に非常に敏感なグロース株（ソフトウェアを含む）が上昇を牽引しました。 当社は2017年後半のサイクリカルな立ち上がり以来、S&Pソフトウェア指数に対してオーバーウェイトを維持していますが、リスク管理の観点からは相対リターンが約27%の地点に近づいた場合には当社のトレーリング・ストップを順守します。 ご参考までに、最近この指数で相対的なタクティカル利得を10%計上し、ハイ・コンヴィクションのオーバーウェイト一覧から除外しました。 ソフトウェアのイエローフラッグ ソフトウェアのイエローフラッグ S&Pソフトウェア指数の長期的なドライバーは維持されているものの、最新のISMサービス調査の下落は、強力なソフトウェア需要でさえ小さな後退を被る可能性があるという警告弾でした（第2パネル）。さらに、IPO上場投資信託（ETF）の最近の損失は、急騰するグロース株が重力によって地に引き戻され得ることを警告しています（下段パネル）。特に今年はIPO供給が大幅に増加している点を踏まえると（第3パネル）、そのリスクは高まります。 結論：当面はS&Pソフトウェアに対してサイクリカルなオーバーウェイトの姿勢を維持しますが、トレーリング・ストップの27%の水準を順守して利益確定の引き金を引く準備をしておいてください。   

特別レポート

2010年晩夏、我々はデフレーション期における米国株式のセクター間相対パフォーマンスを概観するスペシャルレポートを公表しました。それ以降、インフレーション—より具体的にはコアPCEデフレーター—は2018年中頃に連邦準備制度理事会（FRB）の2％目標と短く“戯れ”たに過ぎず、長期のインフレ期待は高い水準へ再定着することはありませんでした。 憂慮すべきことに、インフレが今後数四半期で頭をもたげるのではなく、むしろ弱まる兆候が出始めています。 評論家たち—我々も含めて—は依然としてインフレ圧力が最終的に浸透するのを待っています。憂慮すべきことに、インフレが今後数四半期で頭をもたげるのではなく、むしろ弱まる兆候が出始めています（チャート1）。 2018年後半の金融状況の引き締まりは、若干のラグを伴って前年比CPI成長率を下押しするでしょう（上段、チャート1）。より広く見れば、ISM製造業PMIの急落（およびそのほとんどのサブコンポーネントに見られる動き）が示すように、米国経済の継続的な減速はインフレにとって深刻な逆風です（第2パネル、チャート1）。 世界的な成長の弱さを受け、逆循環通貨である米ドルの上昇も今後のインフレを抑制する要因となるでしょう（図示せず）。さらに、最近の力強いインフレ数値を我々は持続可能とは見なしていません。実際、コア・グッズCPI—コアCPIの25％を占め、最近の主な牽引役になっている—は、今後18か月でピークアウトして縮小する見込みです（第3パネル、チャート1）。 チャート1 まだインフレを探しているのか？ まだインフレを探していますか？ まだインフレを探していますか？ U.S. エクイティ・ストラテジーの企業の価格決定力（プライシング・パワー）代理指標も急落しており、コアインフレの下落が最も抵抗の少ない経路であることを裏付けています（下段、チャート1）。 言い換えれば、もしマーティ・マクフライが再びデロリアンに乗って過去へ戻れるなら、デフレーション／ディスインフレーションがBCAにおける主要な株式テーマであることを確かに支持し、我々に以前の分析をさらに掘り下げるよう頼むでしょう。本レポートはまさにその作業です。 我々は現在のディスインフレ傾向を認め、そのような期間における各株式セクターの歴史的相対パフォーマンスの詳細を示します。我々は単純なトレーディングルールを紹介します。デフレ期を企業部門価格デフレーターの成長が2四半期以上連続でマイナスとなる期間と定義しています（チャート2）。より広いデフレ傾向の中で単発のプラス成長四半期は外れ値として扱い、塗りつぶされた期間内の時折の四半期反発として扱います。 チャート2 デフレーション期 デフレ期 デフレ期 次のページでは、各セクターの歴史的相対パフォーマンスについてさらに詳述します。特筆すべきは、企業部門価格デフレーターの成長が2四半期連続でマイナスとなったシグナルに従うことで得られた年率換算リターンの概要を短く示す点です。1960年以降、そのようなシグナルは27回あり、中央値の継続期間は15か月、最短は6か月でした。したがって、我々は6か月、12か月、24か月の投資期間を用いて、デフレーション期に好成績を示したセクターをロング、インフレ期に好成績を示したセクターをショートすることに自信を持っています。 表1はこの実証的検証の結果を要約したものです。 表1 セクター相対パフォーマンスとデフレーション（1960年〜現時点） デフレ環境下におけるセクターのパフォーマンス：バック・トゥ・ザ・フューチャー？ デフレ環境下におけるセクターのパフォーマンス：バック・トゥ・ザ・フューチャー？ 我々の仮説は、ディスインフレーション期にはディフェンシブがサイクリカルを上回るというものです。GICS11の相対セクターパフォーマンスはこの仮説と一致しています。具体的には、我々のデフレシグナルに続き、ディフェンシブは6か月で1.4％上昇する一方、サイクリカルは2.5％下落します。12か月時点では転換点が見られ、サイクリカルは-2.5％から-0.21％へと損失を回復し始め、ディフェンシブは1.38％から0.76％へと利得を手放します。この結果は前述の中央値である15か月のデフレ期間と整合します。同様に、24か月先を見ると、サイクリカルが0.5％で市場をアウトパフォームしており（主にテクノロジーが牽引）、ディフェンシブは-1.2％で市場に劣後している（通信とユーティリティが足を引っ張る）、すなわち市場が回復していることを示唆しています。 図1 パフォーマンス・タイムライン デフレの世界におけるセクター・パフォーマンス：バック・トゥ・ザ・フューチャー？ デフレの世界におけるセクター・パフォーマンス：バック・トゥ・ザ・フューチャー？ 重要なのは、我々の定義する2四半期シグナルにより2018年中頃に始まったデフレーション環境下に我々は現在いるということであり、U.S. エクイティ・ストラテジーは過去6か月にわたってサイクリカルのエクスポージャーを積極的に削減し、幅広い株式市場の見通しに対して投資家に慎重であるべきことを強調してきました。 再び表1に戻ると、GICS1のセクターパフォーマンスには我々の期待と異なるいくつかの乖離も見られます。ユーティリティーズはディスインフレーション期にアウトパフォームするはずで、理由は2つあります：(1) 安定したキャッシュフロー成長、(2) 低下する金利が高利回りの代替資産の魅力を高めるためです。もう一つの注目すべき外れ値はS&P コンシューマー・ディスクリショナリー指数です。具体的には、我々のデフレシグナル後の6か月で約2％のアンダーパフォームが見られ、これは金利低下が辺際で裁量的支出を押し上げるはずという我々の期待を覆すものでした。 結論として、我々は表1の結果とセクター別コメントを要約したタイムラインも提示します。重要なのは、このタイムラインはデフレーション環境をナビゲートするための「経験則」としてのみ使うべきロードマップであるという点です。中央値が15か月であっても、デフレーション期間は1年足らずから4年以上まで幅があります。常に文脈が重要です。 最後に、今後数か月内に予定している我々の従来の米国株式セクターの利益率見通しレポートの更新にご期待ください。 以下は各セクター別の追加分析の詳細と、セクター別の価格決定力および売上回転率に関するチャートです。     Jeremie Peloso, リサーチアナリスト JeremieP@bcaresearch.com   Arseniy Urazov, リサーチアソシエイト ArseniyU@bcaresearch.com   コンシューマー・ステープルズ（オーバーウェイト） 生活必需品 生活必需品 S&P コンシューマー・ステープルズ指数はデフレーション期に良好なパフォーマンスを示します。この指数の避難先としての性格と、業界の継続的な再編が説明要因と考えられます。 当社のセクター価格決定力代理指標は、ステープルズが2003年以降、価格決定力の収縮を経験していないことを示しています。 相対株価は回復基調にありますが、依然として歴史的トレンドを下回る1標準偏差の位置にあります。デフレシグナル後の6か月、12か月、24か月の驚異的なリターンを考えれば、さらなる上昇が期待されます。 我々はS&P コンシューマー・ステープルズ指数をオーバーウェイトで推奨します。 コンシューマー・ステイプルズ コンシューマー・ステイプルズ エネルギー（オーバーウェイト） エネルギー エネルギー サイクリカル群の中で、S&P エネルギーは2番目に大きなアンダーパフォーマーであり、我々のデフレシグナル後6か月で平均して相対的に3.4％下落します。 このアンダーパフォーマンスは当社の価格決定力（PP）代理指標にも明確に表れています。エネルギー企業のPPは経済がデフレに入ると同時に低下します。これは、原油がほぼ全てのインフレ／デフレ指標において重要な役割を果たすという我々の予想と一致します。 ただし現時点での注意点として、最近の原油価格の急騰は、暴落したエネルギー株に格好の価値機会をもたらす触媒となり得ます。サウジアラビアの生産・精製施設に対するドローン攻撃の結果、地政学的プレミアムが原油価格に持続的に織り込まれることを我々は想定しています。 我々は現時点でS&P エネルギー指数をオーバーウェイトで推奨します。 エネルギー エネルギー ヘルスケア（オーバーウェイト） ヘルスケア ヘルスケア デフレーション期において、S&P ヘルスケア・セクターはS&P コンシューマー・ステープルズと同様に市場をアウトパフォームしています。 ヘルスケア産業の避難先的性格に加え、価格決定力はデータ系列の全期間を通じてゼロラインを下回ったことがありません。この顕著な実績は同セクターの売上成長にも当てはまります。 我々は現時点でS&P ヘルスケア指数をオーバーウェイトで推奨します。 ヘルスケア ヘルスケア インダストリアルズ（オーバーウェイト） インダストリアルズ インダストリアルズ デフレーションの瀬戸際では、インダストリアル株は2つの相反する力に直面します：原材料の値下がりと経済活動の減速です。 最終的には経済の軟化が勝ち、この深いサイクリカル指標は6か月、12か月、24か月でそれぞれ-1.4％、-1.0％、-0.5％と市場に対してアンダーパフォームします。 このセクターの価格決定力はしばしばデフレーション域に入ると鋭く低下し、インダストリアルズの収益見通しと相対パフォーマンスに重しをかけます。 我々は現時点でS&P インダストリアルズ・セクターをオーバーウェイトで推奨します。 インダストリアルズ インダストリアルズ ファイナンシャルズ（オーバーウェイト） 金融 金融 早期に反応するサイクリカルセクターであるため、我々の2四半期デフレシグナル後、S&P ファイナンシャルズ・セクターが6か月、12か月、24か月で市場にアンダーパフォームするのは驚くべきことではありません。 ファイナンシャルズの最大のアンダーパフォーマンスはデフレーション期の後半に現れます。実際、もしユーティリティーズを分析から除外していたなら、S&P ファイナンシャルズは12か月および24か月の両期間で最も成績の悪いセクターになっていたでしょう。 約42％を占めるヘビーウェイトの銀行サブグループがこのアンダーパフォーマンスを説明します。思い出していただきたいのは、銀行はデフレーション／ディスインフレーションによってクレジットの価格が下落する際にアンダーパフォームするという点です。 当社のフィクスト・インカム・ストラテジストは債券市場の売りを予想しているため、我々はS&P ファイナンシャルズ指数をオーバーウェイトで維持します。 金融 金融 テクノロジー（ニュートラル – 格下げ注意） テクノロジー テクノロジー 2010年に我々はテック株がデフレーション期の勝者であると再確認しましたが、これは現在も変わっていません。革新の猛烈なペース自体が、セクターをデフレーションの局面に耐えうるものにしています。 サイクリカル内では、テクノロジーは表1で圧倒的に最良のパフォーマーですが、現在の地政学的および貿易緊張は我々に同セクターをニュートラルとすることを促しています。将来的にソフトウェアのサブグループの格下げを通じた本格的な格下げが到来する可能性があります。 テックの価格決定力はデフレーション期でも頑強です。しかし、サイクルでピークアウトしたように見えるテックの売上成長は激しく振れるため、下振れ局面が近づくと潜在的な乱高下を警告しています。 我々はS&P テクノロジー・セクターをニュートラルとし、格下げ監視リストに載せています。 テクノロジー テクノロジー テレコミュニケーション・サービス（ニュートラル） テレコミュニケーション・サービス テレコミュニケーション・サービス 伝統的にディフェンシブであるテレコム・サービス株は近年苦戦しており、債務の増加に悩まされ、「ダムパイプ（単なる通信路）」にならないよう重要性を維持しようともがいています。 業界の価格決定力代理指標も同様の点を強調しており、テレコム各社は世界金融危機（GFC）以来、地盤を取り戻すことができていません。 もう一つ重要な点は、この指数が我々が検証した全ての期間で市場に対して著しくアンダーパフォームしていることです：-1.5％、-2.0％、-4.4％。我々の仮説では、テレコム事業者は安定したキャッシュフロー生成と高い配当利回りプロファイルのためデフレーション期にアウトパフォームするはずでしたが、実証的事実は逆を示しています。 おそらく、この数十年にわたる持続的なアンダーパフォーマンスは、もはやニッチ化したこの避難先産業のセクター固有のダイナミクスに原因があることを示唆しています。 我々は現時点でS&P テレコミュニケーション・サービス指数をニュートラルとします。 テレコミュニケーション・サービス テレコミュニケーション・サービス マテリアルズ（アンダーウェイト） 資料 資料 ここ数年の中国および一般的に新興市場複合体からのコモディティ需要の大きさにもかかわらず、S&P マテリアルズ・セクターは構造的な下降トレンドから脱却できていません。 このセクターはディスインフレーションの主要な敗者の一つであり、チャートからも明らかです。重要なのは、1970年代中盤以降、マテリアルズが市場をアウトパフォームしたほとんどの期間は塗りつぶされた領域や景気後退の外側で発生している点です。 平均して、グローバル成長が弱まるとマテリアルズの価格決定力は急落する傾向があり、僅かな遅れを伴って同セクターの売上成長も後退する可能性が高く、サイクルの売上成長は既にピークアウトしたことを示唆しています。 我々はS&P マテリアルズ・セクターの最近の格下げを受け、アンダーウェイトを繰り返します。 資料 資料 コンシューマー・ディスクリショナリー（アンダーウェイト – 格上げ注意) コンシューマー・ディスクリショナリー コンシューマー・ディスクリショナリー 我々の仮説に反して、S&P コンシューマー・ディスクリショナリー株は金利を押し下げるディスインフレーション期においてアンダーパフォームします。おそらく、経済活動の減速が金利低下を上回り、消費者はディスクリショナリーな購入からステープルズ系の商品・サービスへと寄り添うためです。 表1は、コンシューマー・ディスクリショナリー株が実際にはデフレーション期の初期に最も打撃を受け（-2.0％）、その後12か月で急速に回復しわずかにプラス（0.1％）に転じることを示しています。 我々は現時点でS&P コンシューマー・ディスクリショナリー指数をアンダーウェイトとしていますが、買い機会の可能性として格上げ注意リストに載せています。 コンシューマー・ディスクリショナリー コンシューマー・ディスクリショナリー ユーティリティーズ（アンダーウェイト） ユーティリティ ユーティリティ 本スペシャルレポートの最後のセクターとして、S&P ユーティリティーズは我々の分析で顕著な外れ値であり、期待通りに振る舞わないことを指摘していました。おそらく業界固有のダイナミクスが働いており、高利回りの避難先であるユーティリティーズ株はデフレーション期に大きくアンダーパフォームしています。 同セクターは6か月、12か月、24か月でそれぞれ市場に対して-3.5％、-4.3％、-4.5％のリターンです。理論的には、相対株価を押し上げるはずの2つの要因がありました：(1) 安定したキャッシュフロー成長、(2) 低下する金利は高利回りの代替資産の魅力を高める、の両方です。 しかし、どちらも長年にわたる構造的な下降トレンドからの脱却には十分ではありませんでした。 我々は現時点でS&P ユーティリティーズ指数をアンダーウェイトとします。 ユーティリティ ユーティリティ   脚注 1    GICS 1の親インデックスであるCommunication Services指数は最近導入されたためデータが不足しており、代わりにGICS 2のテレコミュニケーション・サービス指数を使用しています。

 Remain Cyclically Overweight, But Remove from High-Conviction Overweight List Our 10% stop on the S&P software high-conviction call got triggered and we are obeying it, booking gains and removing this index from the high-conviction overweight list. As a reminder, we are still overweight the S&P software index on a cyclical basis since November 2017, with a trailing stop at a the 27% relative return mark that has yet to get hit (bottom panel). Software stocks have offered bulletproof returns for investors as they are mostly insulated from direct impacts of the U.S./China trade war. In addition, these secular growth stocks are also perceived as immune to a growth slowdown and the drubbing in interest rates since the November 2018 peak in the 10-year Treasury yield has been more than reflected in high-flying multiples. Now that interest rates are trying to bottom, investors have been quick to rein in some of their enthusiasm on the largest tech subsector. We still believe that artificial intelligence, augmented reality, SaaS and the push to the cloud have staying power and are not fads, however from a risk management perspective we are compelled to act and protect profits for our portfolio. Bottom Line: Crystalize 10% gains in S&P software index and remove it from the high-conviction overweight list. We are still cyclically overweight the S&P software index and remain prepared to book profits at the 27% relative return mark and downgrade this key tech subgroup to neutral. Such a downgrade will push the S&P tech sector to an underweight stance and also give our portfolio a defensive over cyclical tilt. Stay tuned.

Neutral Downgrade Alert This Monday we published a summary of our portfolio allocation changes that we made over the past couple of months. They key underlying theme running through most of our recent moves was to reduce our cyclical exposure and pocket in some profits. Today we highlight one of the major moves we are preparing to make: downgrade the S&P technology sector. The downgrade will be executed via the S&P software index. As a reminder, we have a stop at the 27% relative return mark and once it’s triggered, we will go neutral on software pushing the overall tech sector to a below benchmark allocation. Our EPS model for the overall tech sector is on the verge of contraction on the back of sinking capex and a seemingly invincible U.S. dollar (middle panel). The San Francisco Fed’s Tech Pulse Index is also closing in on the expansion/contraction line warning that tech stocks are in for a rough ride (bottom panel). Bottom Line: We reiterate our defensive stance on the U.S. equity market as the risk/reward remains to the downside. For the full summary of our recent moves, please see this Monday’s Weekly Report.  

Highlights Portfolio Strategy Despite the Fed’s supra natural powers, the deep rooted global growth slowdown will likely win the tug of war versus flush liquidity, especially if the trade war spat stays unresolved and the U.S. dollar remains well bid, both of which undermine U.S. corporate sector profitability. Recent Changes There are no changes to the portfolio this week. Table 1 Feature Equities hit all-time highs last week, eagerly anticipating this Wednesday’s Fed decision to commence an easing interest rate cycle and save the day. The looming global liquidity injection is the sole reason that stocks are holding near their all-time highs. While markets are treating the Fed as a deity, empirical evidence suggests that risks are actually lurking beneath the surface. Over the past two decades the correlation between stocks and the fed funds rate has been tight and positive. Given the bond market’s view of four fed cuts in the coming year, equity gains are likely running on fumes (Chart 1). Chart 1Mind The Positive Correlation As we highlighted recently, we remain perplexed that stocks are diverging from earnings.1 Anticipating a flush global liquidity backdrop (i.e. global central banks increasing their reflationary efforts) likely explains this dynamic as the former should ultimately rekindle economic growth, which in turn should boost profit growth. However, the disinflationary fallout from the ongoing manufacturing recession and the petering out in the global credit impulse signal that the liquidity pipes remain clogged. We recently read and re-read the Bank For International Settlements (BIS) Hyun Song Shin’s “What is behind the recent slowdown” speech where he eloquently argues that the global trade deceleration predates last spring’s U.S./China trade dispute.2 Shin has a compelling argument blaming the growth deceleration on the drop in manufactured goods global value chains (GVC) and he depicts this as global trade trailing global GDP (top panel, Chart 2). Interestingly, despite the V-shaped recovery following the Great Recession, global trade never really regained its footing, failing to surpass the 2007 peak. Shin then links this slowdown in global supply chains to financial conditions and the role that banking plays in global trade financing. The middle panel of Chart 2 shows that the GVC move with the ebbs and flows of global banks. In other words, healthy banks tend to boost global trade and vice versa. Finally, given that most trade financing is conducted in U.S. dollars, the greenback’s recent appreciation also explains trade blues. Simply put, decreased availability of U.S. dollar denominated bank credit as a result of a rising greenback is another culprit (U.S. dollar shown inverted, bottom panel, Chart 2). Ergo, there is no miracle cure for the sputtering world economy, especially given the recent re-escalation in global trade tensions and the stubbornly high U.S. dollar, and the gap between buoyant share prices and poor profit performance is likely to narrow via a fall in the former. Two weeks ago we highlighted that foreign sourced profits for U.S. multinationals are under attack as BCA’s global ex-U.S. ZEW survey ticked down anew (top panel, Chart 3). Tack on the global race to ZIRP (and in some cases further into NIRP) and it is crystal clear that the profit recession has yet to run its course. Chart 2Grim Trade Backdrop... Chart 3...Will Continue To Weigh On Foreign Sourced Profits   Meanwhile, China is likely exporting its deflation to the rest of the world and until its business sector regains pricing power, U.S. profits will continue to suffer (bottom panel, Chart 3). Turning over to U.S. shores and domestic corporate pricing power, the news is equally grim. Our pricing power proxy is outright contracting and warns that revenue growth is also under duress for U.S. corporates. Similarly, the ISM manufacturing prices paid subcomponent fell below the 50 boom/bust line and steeply contracting raw industrials commodities are signaling that 6%/annum top line growth for the SPX is unsustainable (Chart 4). On a cyclical 3-12 month time horizon we remain cautious on the broad equity market. Chart 4Sales Pressures... Chart 5...Are Building Rapidly Melting inflation expectations and the NY Fed’s softening Underlying Inflation Gauge (UIG) best encapsulate this softening revenue backdrop and warn that any further letdown in inflation risks sinking S&P 500 sales growth below the zero line (Chart 5).   Netting it all out, despite the Fed’s supra natural powers, the deep rooted global growth slowdown will likely win the tug of war versus flush liquidity, especially if the trade war spat stays unresolved and the U.S. dollar remains well bid, both of which undermine U.S. corporate sector profitability. On a cyclical 3-12 month time horizon we remain cautious on the broad equity market. This is U.S. Equity Strategy’s view, which stands in contrast to the more sanguine equity BCA House View. What follows is a recap of recent (mostly) defensive moves in the health care, consumer staples, materials, tech, consumer discretionary and communication services sectors.   Anastasios Avgeriou, U.S. Equity Strategist anastasios@bcaresearch.com   S&P Health Care (Overweight) Upgraded from Neutral S&P Health Care Equipment (Overweight) Upgraded from Neutral Fear-based sell-off created a buying opportunity in the U.S. health care equipment index as fundamentals remain upbeat. Rising U.S. medical equipment exports are a tailwind for this health care subgroup as 60% of its revenues are generated outside the United States (second panel). The EM demographic shift (not shown) represents yet another boost to the sector as U.S. companies are the technology leaders and often the only source for equipping hospitals/clinics around the globe. Our move to upgrade the S&P health care equipment index also pushed the entire health care sector from neutral to overweight (bottom panel). S&P Health Care S&P Managed Health Care (Overweight) Upgraded from Neutral The Bernie Sanders “Medicare For All” bill reintroduction created a buying opportunity in the S&P managed health care index and we were swift to act on it in mid-April. Contained industry cost factors including wages staying at the 2% mark help preserve industry margins (bottom panel). Melting medical cost inflation signals that HMO profit margins will likely expand (third panel). Overall healthy labor market conditions with unemployment insurance claims probing 60-year lows should underpin managed health care enrollment (top & second panels). S&P Managed Health Care   S&P Hypermarkets (Overweight) Upgraded from Neutral S&P Soft Drinks (Neutral) Upgraded from Underweight A deteriorating macro landscape reflected in the steep fall in U.S. economic data surprises, the drubbing of the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield and melting inflation make a compelling case for an overweight stance in the S&P Hypermarkets index (top & second panels). Similarly, safe haven soft drinks stocks shine when economic conditions are deteriorating (third panel). This defensive pure-play consumer goods sub-sector is also enjoying a rebound in operating metrics, and thus it no longer pays to stay bearish. We lifted exposure to neutral last week, locking in gains of 5.5% since inception. S&P Hypermarkets   S&P Materials (Neutral) Downgraded from Overweight S&P Chemicals (Underweight) Downgraded from Neutral Global macro headwinds continue to weigh on this deep cyclical sub-index as the risks of a full-blown trade war will likely take a bite out of final demand (third panel). Chemical producers garner 60% of their revenues from abroad and falling U.S. chemical exports are troublesome for this index (top & second panels). Given that chemicals have a 74% market cap weight in the S&P materials index, our move to underweight on the sub-index level also pushed the entire S&P materials index to neutral from overweight. S&P Materials   S&P Technology (Neutral) Downgrade Alert S&P Software (Overweight) Lifted trailing stops As a part of our portfolio de-risking measures, we put a 27% profit-taking stop loss on our overweight S&P software index call on June 10. Once triggered, a downgrade to neutral in the S&P software index would also push our S&P tech sector weight to a below benchmark allocation. Meanwhile, our EPS model for the overall tech sector is on the verge of contraction on the back of sinking capex and a firming U.S. dollar (middle panel). The San Francisco Fed’s Tech Pulse Index is also closing in on the expansion/contraction line warning that tech stocks are in for a rough ride (bottom panel). S&P Technology   S&P Technology Hardware, Storage & Peripherals (Neutral) Downgraded from Overweight As nearly 60% of the revenues for the S&P technology hardware, storage & peripherals (THS&P) index are sourced from abroad, deflating EM currencies sap foreign consumer purchasing power and weigh on the industry’s exports (third panel). Global export volumes have sunk into contractionary territory, to a level last seen during the Great Recession (not shown) and underscore that industry exports will remain under pressure. The IFO World Economic Survey confirms this challenging export backdrop as it is still pointing toward sustained global export ails (second panel). As a result, all of this has shaken our confidence in an overweight stance in the S&P THS&P and we were compelled to move to the sidelines in early June for a modest relative loss since inception. S&P Technology Hardware, Storage & Peripherals S&P Consumer Discretionary (Underweight) Upgrade Alert S&P Home Improvement Retail (Neutral) Upgraded from underweight In the July 8 Weekly Report, we put the S&P consumer discretionary sector on an upgrade alert as this early-cyclical sector benefits the most from lower interest rates (bottom panel). The way we will execute this upgrade will be by triggering the upgrade alert on the S&P internet retail index. Melting interest rates and rebounding lumber prices are a boon for home improvement retailers (HIR, second & third panels). Tack on profit-augmenting industry productivity gains and it no longer pays to be bearish HIR. S&P Consumer Discretionary S&P Homebuilders (Neutral) Downgraded from overweight Long S&P Homebuilders / Short S&P Home Improvement Retail Booked Profits Lumber represents an input cost to homebuilders (we booked profits of 10% in our overweight recommendation on May 22 and downgraded to neutral) whereas it is an important selling item in Big Box building & supply retailers that make a set margin on it (third panel). On June 18, as part of our de-risking strategy, we locked in 10% gains in the long S&P homebuilders/short S&P home improvement retail trade that hit our stop loss and we moved to the sidelines. S&P Homebuilders S&P Telecommunication Services (Neutral) Upgraded from Underweight The recent escalation of the trade spat has pushed July’s Markit’s flash U.S. manufacturing PMI reading to 50 - the lowest level since the history of the data. Historically, relative S&P telecom services share price momentum has moved inversely with the manufacturing PMI and the current message is to expect a sustained rebound in the former (bottom panel). Rock bottom profit expectations and firming industry operating metrics signal that most of the grim news is priced in bombed out telecom services valuations (middle panel), and it no longer pays to be underweight. In late-May, we lifted exposure to neutral for 6% relative gains since inception. S&P Telecommunication Services S&P Movies & Entertainment (Overweight) Upgraded from Neutral Structural shifts in the streaming services industry marked a start of a pricing war with incumbents and new entrants fighting for market share, as evidenced by DIS’s pricing of their upcoming Disney+ service. Consumer confidence remains glued to multi-decade highs and there are high odds that the big gulf that has opened up between confidence and relative S&P movies & entertainment share prices will narrow via a rise in the latter (top panel). Moreover, more dollars spent on recreation is synonymous with a margin expansion in the S&P movies & entertainment index (bottom panel). This consumer spending backdrop is also conducive to a rise in relative profitability, the opposite of what the sell-side currently expects. S&P Movies & Entertainment   Arseniy Urazov, Research Associate ArseniyU@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1      Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, “Beware Profit Recession” dated July 8, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 2      https://www.bis.org/speeches/sp190514.pdf   Current Recommendations Current Trades Size And Style Views Favor value over growth Favor large over small caps

Last Thursday we were stopped out from our tactical S&P semi equipment underweight position as it hit our -7% stop loss (bottom panel). We are obeying the stop loss and are returning this index to a neutral weighting as better than expected profits from both ASML and TSMC lifted all chip-related equities. In marked contrast, our long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas exploration & production trade initiated just last week has gone parabolic, spiking to 17% (top panel). While our thesis has not changed in this high beta tactical pair trade, from a risk management perspective, we are moving our stop loss from -10% to +12% in order to protect profits. Bottom Line: Stick with the counter-cyclical long global gold miners/short S&P oil & gas exploration & production trade via the long GDX:US/short XOP:US exchange traded funds. For additional details on the rationale behind this trade, please refer to last Monday’s Weekly Report.